Jewish Scene
Ashkenazi Jews rank smartest in world
Nelly Lalany
Published: 23.07.11, 09:01
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
84 Talkbacks for this article
31. #5 Absolutely right, Charles...
Mark ,   Lodz, Poland   (07.23.11)
..it's beyond your IQ
32. Where's graczekele?
Mark ,   Lodz, Poland   (07.23.11)
OD'd on his Tums
33. Poor Sephardic Jews have no
(07.23.11)
German roots: no EU passports, no extra 20 IQ points.
34. to Charles #5
Arn ,   Yehud, Israel   (07.23.11)
Evidently you're not very partial toward the Jews (no problem - you won't feel lonely in this club) But falling back on a tired cliche when you have nothing original or meaningful of your own to contribute suggests that the authors of this study perhaps knew what they were talking about.
35. Hans Eyesenck
Arn ,   Yehud, Israel   (07.23.11)
Anyone remember what happened to the eminent British psychologist Hans Eyesenck who was behind a study that showed blacks of African and American heritage having a mean IQ that fell short of Caucasians? Political correctness was alive and pulsing more than 50 years ago when the sky fell on his head. It seems information of this order (like this article) should not be discussed in polite society.
36. From my limited experience, Chinese are the smartest.
Michael ,   California, USA   (07.23.11)
Based primarily on working with many of them, but also with Ashkenazim. The statistics in this article surprises me.
37. # 2 you don't sound very smart either.
J.K. ,   Brookllyn USA   (07.23.11)
38. # 17 Ode
J.K. ,   Brooklyn USA   (07.23.11)
I don't know what you are,a viking or hispanic,1 thing for sure,you are dumb and vulgar.
39. Y-Net's IQ
Ron ,   New York, USA   (07.23.11)
As a decendant of Ashenazim I feel I now have the intelligence to question the journalistic stupidity of some of the low points posted on Y-Net. Now look at DNA studies of Askenazim and they will say there is a huge amount of Sephardic ancestry!! Who ever wrote this nonsense has been looking in the mirror and admiring himself too much!!!
40. Deceit
Frank ,   USA   (07.23.11)
The article compares the median Ashkenazi IQ with the average IQ's of other groups.
41. Slight corrections:-)
Ariel ,   USA   (07.23.11)
This book has nothing to do with Cambridge University: none of the authors work there and the only connection is that the book was published by the Cambridge University Press. This is not a study: no original research was done to substantiate the argument of high IQ of Ashkenazi Jews. This book is not about Ashkenazi Jews or IQ: this is a general discussion of eugenics, in terms of its biological, ethical and legal . The Jews/IQ point is only a snippet of the authors' discussion. On top of everything: this book was published quite some time ago. Wasn't your correspondent intelligent enough to notice it earlier?
42. smartest
J.K. ,   Brooklyn USA   (07.23.11)
How about Iraqi Jews ?.the descendants of the sages in Babylonia who composed the Talmud,Iraqi Jews are just as smart as Galitsianer Jews,but more ambitious.
43. Ashkenazim
J.K. ,   Brooklyn USA   (07.23.11)
Now, Ashkenazim have a document proving that they are smart,with the exception of the first Ashkenazi governer of the state of Israel,who was smart and courageous,those who followed him were of a mixed bag,its time to appoint as leader of Israel a Iraqi Jew,the Iraqi Jews are really smart,and what's even more important,he will be able to curse the arabs in their own language,with no translation needed.
44. Individual IQ doesn't mean anything - we, Jews, are very
Matthew ,   West Coast, USA   (07.23.11)
stupid when it comes to politics. Indeed, as a collective, we're morons! Had we played it smart 2K years ago, we would not have been exiled by the Romans.
45. 25
Birdi ,   Israel   (07.23.11)
Right !! you forgot ''chutzpa'' we have a load of it !! tg. YAY for us!
46. 32
Birdi ,   Israel   (07.23.11)
ROFL. Graci's been eating to much popcorn whilst watching the news about the Norway bombing. (belch)
47. 33
Birdi ,   Israel   (07.23.11)
But they sure have yummy food & are as hot as &^%(##
48. 34
Birdi ,   Israel   (07.23.11)
Oh, oh, dont mind our Charles, he is a true patriot of the last century & so abundantly loving towards mankind. YAY for Charles!
49. ADD TO THAT
Mark from Georgia ,   USA   (07.23.11)
This should make all the antisemitic people of the world real happy! As we see Charles in Canada, is so pleased about it. Just bring up the fact that the Nobel Prize winners have a tremendous amount of Jewish winners, while Arabs/Muslims virtually have almost no representation at all. Muslim people make up 1 person out of every five on the planet. While Jewish people make up what, less than 1 out of 1000. Yet with that dramatic difference Muslims have about 5-6 Nobel prizes, none in Math, Science or Medicine. While the Jewish people have won 162 out of 750 awarded between 1901-2007.
50. The fact that 78% of American Jews
Geezee ,   Bayside, USA   (07.23.11)
(vast majority -- Ashkenazim) voted for Hussein Obama proves that they are anything but smart. The same goes for Israelis half of whom voted for Kadima Labor and Meretz. Stop talking about the IQ and Nobel prize winners! In some very important respect we are the stupidest people on earth.
51. nation of God
kevin ,   ireland   (07.23.11)
Jews is a nation chosen by God , what they expected
52. #41 let me simplify
Berel ,   Yehud Israel   (07.23.11)
Maybe knowing how to extrapolate a compliment from a book about other things, and noticing that Oxford gave it's stamp of approval, is the intellience refered to. Nit picking over a few years or actually wasting your time to find all the flaws and then post them on some chat back is probably indicative of those who score lower on IQ tests bob:)
53. Spatial ability is useless nonsense
I ,   Reykjavík, Iceland   (07.23.11)
Spatial ability isn´t a question of real intelligence, as it is mostly conducive to very non cerebral activity and mostly a learned thing. It is useless in most professions, mecnaics and such need it though. It was included later on for the sake of political correctness so that the iq´s of certain minorities might appear to be higher. Also clashing spatial and visual together is based on a misconception. A great engineer can be devoid of any real appreciation of beauty or originality, and a genius of an artist can have very limited spatial ability none the less. So, if the tests where fair, the results would be much greater for the jews. Perhaps there are even hidden benefits in less spatial ability.
54. #46 Shalom Birdi,
Mark ,   Lodz, Poland   (07.23.11)
I'm 3/4 vuzvuz ala Vilna and 1/4 Dutch Sephardi, I got an IQ of 20/20 and can count to 20 with my shoes off. Shevuach tov to you, hamuda!
55. # 50 The fact
J.K. ,   Brooklyn USA   (07.23.11)
Geezee ! Unfortunately many American Jews still carry the socialist bacteria in their genes,as descendants of tailors and shoemakers who left Russia more than a century ago,the Jewish intelligentsia stayed in Russia,and was exterminated by the soviets and the Germans,tailors and shoemakers are respectable people,but have a very narrow world view.
56. 53
Birdi-huh ,   Israel   (07.23.11)
very nice, now would you kindly write in English please so that us plebs can understand what you are trying to convey to us. Pretty please!!
57. 54
Birdi ,   Israel   (07.23.11)
Motek, believe it or not, I did'nt even go near the bottle today! Lo & behold, you & I have the exact same percentage-incredible! Shavua tov to you chamud.
58. 39 Ron DNA is not the cause of...
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (07.23.11)
the high IQ of Ashkenazim, but the outstanding Polish and Russian Yeshivot where the Ashkenazi s ancesters brains were trained intensively.
59. A mixture of Sefardi and Ashkenazi
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (07.23.11)
is the surest receipe of magnificent Israelis
60. #50;Geezee, THAT IS HISTORY
Mark from Georgia ,   USA   (07.23.11)
That is history according to the National Review July 12, 2011: "Secure America Now has just released a new poll showing that only 43 percent of Jews plan to vote to reelect Obama in 2012" Quick learners, though.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article