Opinion
Americans don’t get it
Yair Lapid
Published: 09.09.11, 10:04
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
74 Talkbacks for this article
31. #28: It is a stupid article, but not because of the BS
Veto ,   USA   (09.09.11)
cited in your moronic rant. It's annoying to think that there are people out there who actually believe the lies and propaganda they read on the internet and then have the nerve to pass it along. Shame on you.
32. AND....I was waiting for some insight. Guess not
EZRA THE PROUD JEW ,   USA-ISRAEL   (09.09.11)
What? It's just that "not everyone wants a nice car and a house? G-D is more than Sunday traditions? It's not a millennia old cultural influence on a contrived Theocratic life philosophy? It's not that Islam includes various commands to murder the Kufar? R we all supposed to sit down and study Islam for years to "understand"? (I actually did so I DO "get it") u know, it's one thing to keep an article short for an online blog, it's another to throw out scraps without a logical conclusion as this article does. Additionally, this guy, whoever he is, comes off as one of the most arrogant people I've ever read about. 9-11 happens and he describes, in his own words, how he seems to just go through the day as if nothing happened, visiting a bar, concerned he wasn't charged for his nachos. I question this man's humanity, not to mention his intelligence. But if he is actually in real life as he comes off in this article, I suppose he thinks everyone lives in his little world (I guess he thinks he's some kind of world renowned personality and everyone is aware of his every move?). A bizarre piece if I've ever read one. Not even a blip of comprehendible expression.
33. We don't get it-
Mark Griffin ,   United States   (09.10.11)
I agree that the majority of people in the US just don't get it. If I was a Muslim looking into the US I could only agree we look like the devil. We portray our women as whores on TV which they see , our men come across as ignorant and uneducated and we accept homosexuality as being no problem. Oh and if you get pregnant just abort it. So sad that we can't even see this!
34. WC #28: What scholars have you read?
Steve   (09.09.11)
What scholars and historians have you read on Islam, its texts and teachings, post 9/11? Any reputable scholars? Or have you been reading apologists for Islam and conspiracy theories pervasive throughout the Mideast? Did it occur to you, Muslims attacked the U.S. because Allah and his messenger command devout Muslims to kill unbelievers? Or maybe you are a devout Muslim and you know all that.
35. #28 you are a friggin idiot now crawl back into your hole
Al   (09.09.11)
37. Incredibly self-defeating article
esnuff ,   USA   (09.09.11)
We're not the ones who in September will become the most hated and isolated nation since apartheid-era South Africa. Keep sneering at Americans (your only ally) if it makes you feel better. What I'll do is send this article (and the comments that agree with it) to as many Americans as possible (as well as many American media outlets.) They, too, need to learn what some in our so-called 'ally' think about us. Maybe then they will 'get it' about how ungrateful many Israelis are for American support.
38. Islamic Globalization.
John Prophet   (09.10.11)
It should be obvious to all who want to look,  the Middle East Caliphate is morphing into shape all around Israel. The bricks of this new structure is Islam and the mortar will be Shira law, mix in radicalization and the new entity will be a deadly blow to peace in the twenty first century. Israel will be the first to feel its fury followed by Europe. Complacency and appeasement by the West has only enforced the perception by radical Islam that God has prepared the landscape for global domination. 
39. What an offensive, poorly reasoned argument.
Abe Froman ,   NY, NY   (09.10.11)
Shame. As a New Yorker who watched people die on 9/11 at close range, this article is offensive. I think Americans got the point. Whether they were there or not. Mr. Lapid, that article was despicable.
40. I get it.....
Steven Wilson ,   Anchorage, Alaska   (09.10.11)
Every person out there has a different agenda.....and every one of them....is a potential enemy....in need of a bullet in their head. None of them has the same values....just like a Tiger doesn't have the same values when I step into its cage. We are just meat...or Khaffers as the Muslims call us. No better than a cow....easily led to the slaughter. I totally get it!
41. Americans quickly forget
Adrienne ,   Philadelphia, US   (09.10.11)
As I read this opinion, I hear your voice in the background on Ulpan Shishi. Strange I pulled this up now. Forget about Americans feeling superior, not a fair statement. However, yes the average American up until 9/11 felt as though we were covered in Teflon, ignoring the first signal in 1993. The real sad story, while Americans will use this Sunday as a sad day, they will once again, quickly forget the plague of terrorism. Many Americans will join the voices around the world castigating Israel for protecting her borders. They will forget what it feels like to be frightened, to be bewildered, to want to call all of their loved ones right away. Unfortunately, many Americans didn't learn the lesson, as hard as it was. I am afraid they will never learn the lesson.
42. What America's Liberals Don't Get
Dan ,   USA   (09.10.11)
America's liberal establishment fails to understand that Muslims are at war with America. They continue to say it is only a minority of radical Muslims and will not admit that moderate Muslims never speak out against acts of terror. These same liberals, especially the college professor types, want to eastablish a moral equivalency by saying "one man's terrorist is another man's patriot". This was written by a college professor in The Philadelphia Inquirer.
43. IS LAPID VAPID?
Frank-el ,   Seattle USA   (09.10.11)
I think so as demonstrated by this thoughtless article that pretends to illuminate the ignorant American masses. One thing he doesn't get, or at least admit, is that the US's support for Israel was a major motive for 9/11. Thanks Yair for the pat (I mean knife) on the back. And can somebody please explain the nonsensical statement at the end about God, Sunday meetings and BBQs? A sad swipe at Christianity? Why not God, Saturday and lox? I think he answered me in his next phrase which said, "It's so illogical..." ...and so are you, Yair.
44. #3 John
Habi Seliman ,   New York, USA   (09.10.11)
One more thing many of us do not understand is why some people like you do not understand is that for thousands of years our (60% + of Jewish Israelis families) homes were in Iraq, Syria, the Magreb. and similar places. We were displaced. Where you like us to go. Back to Damascus or Bagdad? You first. The other thing you may have forgotten or just don't get is that way before Baltimore was Baltimore, it rightfully belonged to the Native Americans. And with the help of African slaves your ancestors built upon it.
45. Nice Article - but Al-Qaeda is not dead yet.
Elias   (09.10.11)
What most Americans don't understand is that their supposed war on terror is perceived by the Islamic world as an attack on their faith. The war against Iraq on false intelligence of wmd reinforced that belief, and with the use of drone diplomacy against innocent civilians in Pakistan and Afghanistan, then Jihad against the Americans is a forgone conclusion. The war against Al-Qaeda hasn't ended, it's only just begun.
46. Jon, #3
Max, American Jew ,   New York, NY   (09.10.11)
The partition that created an Israeli state and a Palestinian state was the handiwork of the U.N., Jon, not God. As for "most of the world doesn't get it," how much of the world do you see there in Baltimore?
47. Go for the roots........
Ben Zion   (09.10.11)
.......anything else is useless. 1) Today it looks pretty obious that the whole thing was organised by US government/ secret sevices ( e.g. how should a flight student fly an airliner with 300mph in a relativly small building ? Its just impossible! ) 2) American citizens are very much manipulated by the local economical / political elite : Keep the public school system in a bad shape ( but maintain a small number of top institions for the ''elite'' ). Then withhold social security from the citizens ( NO haelthinsurance, hire and fire, etc) and this will keep everybody quiet and down to earth which again is perfect for the industry and the government...... I think the american citizens DO get it - but they are living in a dictatorship and not in a democracy ! The root of americas bad situation is americas political and economical / financial ''elite''.
48. Stay away from New York City, especially the tunnels on 9/11
Rivkah   (09.10.11)
The ELS Scripture code matrix on 9/11/11 indicates there could be an Arabic attack on a tunnel in New York City. If you are in NYC, get out for the weekend. Do not visit there. There are two possible outcomes in the matrix: of an attack or it is averted. Stay away from the tunnels.
49. 3 Jon, Baltimore US: The fool says in his heart there is no
Rivkah   (09.10.11)
God. The things of God are foolishness to those who do not believe in the Holy Scriptures. But for those who do, the Jews have a sacred God given right to the land God gave to Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob and their descendants forever. How sad for you not to know God or about HIm or His Holy Scriptures. What a hollow person you are without the Ruach HaKodesh in your heart.
50. Sad
Lulu anlaz ,   Brooklyn ny usa   (09.10.11)
It is truly sad you believe this. Being a proud American Jew I can truly say that the opportunities and freedoms that us Americans are offered are incredible compared to every other country.
51. very degrading... we americans get it. and living in israel
shauna ,   US & Israel   (09.10.11)
very degrading... we americans get it. and living in israel now, #21 says it all...
52. someones sent me some "Americans did it: 9/11"... pathetic!
mary of Bethanyr ,   singapore   (09.10.11)
10 years down the road, people are still harping on "AMERICANS DID IT", second to some "JEWS DID IT" conspiracies. just like these same conspiracies theory people are sending 2 planes and crashed into World Trade all over again, killing the same people all over again, and the families are experiencing their loved ones died a 2nd times! burying empty coffins a 2nd times! be merciful! be kind! be human!
53. Yair has the capacity to become a normal person
Ruru   (09.10.11)
Keep working on it...
54. #18, 49 - Rivkah - as dawn's light banishes
seadog1946 ,   Arthur Kill, NJ   (09.10.11)
the night's darkness and cold, the mere suggestion of the secret desires nestled deep within you stokes a curiously responsive warmth deep within me.
55. #3
Benjamin ,   Tel Aviv   (09.10.11)
Your question answers itself. I've never heard the case for Zionism put so clearly. Nothing is more justified than someone taking back what was stolen from them.
56. The time of reckoning has arrived.
John Prophet   (09.10.11)
Israel, as you have ignored Obama so have the Islamics encircling you. The whole of the Middle East sees him as ineffective and feckless. Obama is a one and done, and what ever Republican comes after him will most decidedly be pro Israel, as will be both houses of Congress. Therefore, your greatest time of vulnerability visa vie the Islamic hoard surrounding you screaming death to Israel is between now and November 2012. When they do come for you,you must hit back extremely hard or your grandchildren's grandchildren will be fighting the same fight for existence.
57. 54 seadog1946, Arthur Kill, NJ: The only desire in my heart
Rivkah   (09.10.11)
is for YHWH, secret or otherwise. Since YHWH is concerned for His people on the earth, I am too, but for different reasons. His concern is from His love for them. My concern is from my love for YHWH since people have disappointed me to the marrow my bones to the point that I have no concern for them except what the martyr's song under the altar of YHWH has lyrics for: "How long O Lord faithful and true before you avenge us on the inhabitants of the earth?" My hope is for vengeance, but that is tempered by my love for YHWH. Since He loves His people even though they have not shown themselves worthy of my love, I will be concerned for them enough to warn them on YNET of impending dangers. But not because I am capable of loving people who do not love me but because YHWH is capable of loving them through my cold cold heart that gave up on people a long time ago. People fill my being with revulsion except for a rare few. It is only through the lens of YHWH's eyes that I can have any concern at all for people. Through my own eyes, I see the starving orphans of Africa as a good thing since if they are allowed to grow up they will become seducers and rapists and/or whores or widows or rape victims or horrible mothers and fathers since that is what most humans are unless YHWH is in their hearts conforming them to Himself. People. Ycch. I have been rewarded evil for good and hatred for my love and concern all my life, so I just want to see vengeance on the inhabitants of the earth except through YHWH's eyes which have compassion for them.
58. to 50
(09.10.11)
he told it from his heart not from his proud . //it is all it was my openion before 10 years sure i was sad becouse of the victims but sadness did not blind my eyes .. i think the author was sad also and he is not blind he is proud to tell it for nothing but to say that he see
59. No, Yair Americans don't get it.
noa ,   israel   (09.10.11)
It's because of their lovely naivety, there is the "Peace Corps". It is because of their lovely naivety they give millions of dollars in aid to countries who wouldn't lift a finger to help them if America was in trouble. Americans don't get it? No, you don't get it. Americans were generous and giving to a fault. The whole world stood on America's back thinking it the strongest country in the world and a land of opportunity. The whole world has no problem taking aid and hating America in the process. Did it ever occur to you that Obama and others like him thought that maybe if totalitarian regimes that spew anti-Israel hate, once toppled, would no longer be able to use Israel as a scapegoat? Did it ever occur to you that maybe America isn't able to stem the alarmingly growing tide of anti-semitism? But that America is the only country that will try? Americans don't get it. Get lost.
60. #44
Jarda ,   Czech Republic   (09.10.11)
You can stay in New York. No one force you to go to Palestine.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article