News
Report: Obama wants timetable for pullout from West Bank
Ynet
Published: 04.03.13, 10:57
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
82 Talkbacks for this article
31. Let him pull out of the White House
David ,   Shiloh Israel   (03.04.13)
32. Good thing he will not becoming after Bibi fails to form gov
Eric ,   Tel Aviv & NY   (03.04.13)
33. # 23 Birdi,
BUILD BABY BUILD ,   United States   (03.04.13)
I hear obama is leaving 'gorilla my dreams' at home to eat @ McDonalds...
34. Pure Political Spin
David S   (03.04.13)
This is a completely false story that is being thrown out in the media by "Anonymous" sources just to influence the coalition talks either by getting Shelly to believe that peace talks are on the table, or to scare Bayit that they will be left out of the discussion. We can see likud spin a mile away. Obama has no such plan.
35. Israel is not the 51st state
Bill Stein ,   USA   (03.04.13)
Israel is not the 51st state if the PM had any guts he should tell Obama to well you get the idea. No more Appeasement No more Pease Talks make our own borders. Annex Area C and low populated areas of B publish the names also if the congressman who are also saying these things. If Bibi cant fight back put Bennett in charge.
36. 30.
Birdi ,   Israel is ours.   (03.04.13)
try surfing the net. read other news websites. you are in for a surprise. and a happy day to you too!
37. 29.
Birdi ,   Israel is ours.   (03.04.13)
Devorah, his world will eventually come crashing down. It's only a matter of time. wait & watch.
38. Bibi Sources
Bill Stein ,   USA   (03.04.13)
I suspect this is a leak from Bibi not the left for once Bibi did something right and leaked this info in my opinion to deflect the pressure. Sometimes exposing someone is the best defense. Israel is not the 51st state and not a colony of the US
39. Say what?
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.04.13)
“The implication is that if Israel won’t give him something he can work with, then he’ll act on his own." What's Obama going to do? Invade Israel? Remember Somalia? A handful of barefoot warlords with World War II vintage Garand rifles and a handful of rusty RPG launchers made the full faith and credit of the United States Armed Forces turn tail and run. Israel is not Somalia. Do keep that in mind. Neither is Israel Grenada or Panama. Nor is it Iraq -- where the United States REALLY screwed the pooch -- or Afghanistan, where the United States is floundering. Obama has absolutely no clue. Well, if need be, he'll just have to learn the hard way. Ehud Barak hinted at annexation. Is that why Obama has his boxers all in a twist? Why isn't he out raising funds for his brother's election campaign in Kenya? That's really the only thing at which Obama seems to excel.
40. This is getting to be interesting......
Mike Carmel ,   Rishon le Zion   (03.04.13)
The ex-King Bibi is absorbing one political blow after another with Obama's relection, the Israeli elections, Liberman's fall from grace, Lapid & Bennett and now Obama again. How is he going to squirm his way out of this one eh? Watch that space.
41. Here's the timetable
David Samson ,   Toronto, Canada   (03.04.13)
When the Palestinians fully accept Israel as the homeland for the Jews. When the Palestinian terrorists are disarmed and no longer present a threat. When the pull out from Gaza proves to have been beneficial to Israeli security and a democratic leadership there commits itself to peace. When all those who wish to cause harm to Israel have pulled out from the area. That's the timetable.
42. # 3
Mike Carmel ,   Rishon le Zion   (03.04.13)
What a load of IRRELEVANT claptrap.
43. Mark my words: Lapid/Bennett will do as Obama asks.
Mo ,   London   (03.04.13)
44. #6
Rhonda ,   Chicago, USA   (03.04.13)
Hey! I'm an American Jew and I didn't vote for him! And, that's the first time this lifelong Democrat voted Republican. And I was against Hegel and Kerry! Don't throw me in your basket with everyone else. Thank you.
45. Nice how you wanna...
Feras   (03.04.13)
suck the 3 Billion $ aid each year, when it comes to this, all of you are saying Israel is an independent state, is not a US state, it's on its own...let's see you manage that without the US aid then :)
46. Stop whining, right wingers
Isaac Galili ,   Israel   (03.04.13)
The settlements have been built because US foreign aid, very generous over the years, has made it possible. And, it is this foreign aid (about $4 billion/year) that gives the US the leverage to pressure us into doing what should have been done along time ago: end the damned occupation of another people. If you don't like it, then tell Obama to cut all foreign aid to us, and end all political support at the UN, and end all military aid to us, and we will happily go our own way. Then we will see how long we last without any US support. If we are not willing to do that, then we ought to realize that we went as far as we could with the settlements in Judea and Samaria, we will get major settlement blocs as a final deal with the Palestinians, but the rest is beyond us. If the Palestinians have internationally recognized borders and a state, the pressure will be on them to keep the peace. That is why Hamas hates the 2-state solution, for them it is a trap.
47. Israel must stand strong
Rabbi Yakov Lazaros ,   USA   (03.04.13)
Tell Obama to go fly a kite. Better yet withdraw the invitation. Obama is president but not the boss The American people and the Congress are strong supporters of Israel. Congress will continue to support Israel with or without Obama
48. Sanctimonious WESTERN interests! True peace via TRUE BALANCE
Jerry ,   The Netherlands   (03.04.13)
49. Israel will do what's in its national interest
Sam ,   Canada   (03.04.13)
The Israeli people will not allow an Israeli Prime-Minister to be such a pushover. America is a friend not Israel's boss. Netanyahu better get that straight.
50. Bennet has NOW the opportunity...
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (03.04.13)
to prove that keeping the Westbank is more important to him than his political agenda.Therefor he needs to join the coalition,with or without Lapid.
51. #2
Harold ,   USA   (03.04.13)
Because it is not Israeli lands and supposed to be part of the Palestinian State. Wise-up
52. #4
Harold ,   USA   (03.04.13)
Why are you changing the subject. US borders including Texas are recognized by the world but Israeli borders including the occupied are not. Wise-up
53. #9
Harold ,   USA   (03.04.13)
You missed a very import sentence. It is not only stopping the yearly aid money but also the vito that kept Israel free from condemnation at the UN. Morever he will will do what his allies wants him to do - RECOGNIZING A PALESTINIAN STATE WITH 1967 BORDERS. How about that buddy. President Obama was granted the Nobel Peace Prize and he has to do something to solve this 45 years problem.
54. #50
Harold ,   USA   (03.04.13)
What can Bennet and others do when the whole world including the US Republican Congress want peace and the creation of a Palestinian States that includes the West Bank and East Jerusalem.
55. Consider the "source" of this story
Maurice Harris ,   Eugene, USA   (03.04.13)
From the Times of Israel piece today: The World Tribune is a conservative American news website that was founded in 1998 by Robert Morton, a former editor at the Washington Times. The New Yorker has called it ”something between a newspaper and a rumor-mongering blog.” The source is a shady outfit that seeks to get people to be anti-Obama. I'm very suspicious that this is just an anti-Obama smear attempt. "Anonymous Israeli sources?" Who - far right annexationists hoping to wreck Obama's visit? I ask those who have posted anti-Obama comments here, will you take it all back if/when this story turns out to be nothing but a rumor-mill's baloney? Or is your groundless hatred of the man so deep that all you can do is throw stones? Favoring a two-state solution has been the position of GWBush (who made it US policy) and Obama. Obama has pushed for that while simultaneously upping US-Israeli intel sharing, providing the means for the Iron Dome, and maintaining major US economic support to Israel. The demonizing of him comes from those who reject a two-state future, and for many of us in the American Jewish community, that "one-state/Greater Israel" view is not something we'll support. Hate on us if you wish, but that's where things stand.
56. False story. Obama will impose '67 borders, Jews will stay.
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (03.04.13)
57. 45
(03.04.13)
do you realize that the 3 billion annually is only 1-2% of israeli gdp???? do you really think israel can't stand on its own? this 3 billion is not economic aid, moron. 75% has to be spent by israel buying american military equipment like fighter jets ,etc... and the rest of the 25% must be spent by israel in join military projects with the usa. nothing is ever given free to israel. israel pays everything compared to all arab nation that are given billions and they PAY ZERO BACK. the 1-2% of israeli gdp is miniscule and isrel can easily forgo it in a second. how do you think israel won all its wars against you arab morons???? america has not started giving israel any aid money, economic or military until AFTER 1973. AND YET, WE WON ALL THE WARS YOU IDIOTS STARTED AGAINST THE JEWISH HOMELAND IN THE REGION. swallow your idiotic pride and crawl back into your islamic 7th century cave where you came from and where you still exists.
58. 46
(03.04.13)
you are not from israel because israelis are not as dumb as you or as misinformed. number one, israel gets, not 4 billions, but 3 billions per year.
59. 52
(03.04.13)
texas was STOLEN by the usa from mexico, as was california during a war in which the usa attacked mexico and confiscated its lands, the state of texas and the state of california. read your history!!!! there was no un then to recognize these new conquered usa borders. usa just declared them her own. period! and threw out the mixican population further away from the new border. they did the same things to indians; confiscating their god given land (yes, there were people living on american soil before the white man invaded, killed and stole their lands) and declared them the united states of america. the fact that these actions by the usa occured before the advent of the un doesn't make it legal or moral. it was still an invasion, an ethnic cleansing of the native population, etc.... take turkey invasion of cyprus.....invaded north cyprus in 1974, displaced the cyprian population and flooded north cyprus with muslim turks. no one in the world recognizes turkey's ownership of north cyprus. not a single nation....yet, i do not hear you complaining about this illegal invasion, flagrant abysmal illegal international law behavior by the turks. you, wise up.
60. 53
(03.04.13)
granted the peace prize??? for what, pray tell. do you really think obama, your messiah, will be able to solve an arab travesty in the middle east that many much more brilliant and effective usa presidents were not able to? do not discount israel. the usa needs israel in the middle east much more than israel needs the usa. this relationship is a two way road, unlike what you think. also, the 3 billions annul "aid" is not economic air, you fool. it is military where 75% must be spent by israel buying military hardware from the usa, thus increasing pentagon and military jobs in the usa and the rest of the 25% is spent on joint venture r and d military research that benefits both countries, both the usa and israel. this 3 billion is only 1-2% of the total israeli gdp. do you really think israel cannot do without it??? it is not economic aid, you fool. israel is the 17th best economy in the world today and while bigger and more prosperous countries are falling behnd economically and are on the precipe of economic disaster, israel is economically extremely stable (the jewish mind, mind you) where the economy improved markedly while europe and the usa are going down. israel's new relationship with the far east, china and india, will surely counteract anything obama plans for it. israel is not afraid. militarily it is one of the strongest military in the world and above all, the jewish brain, intellect and genius of israeli people is the envy of the world today. israel's acceptance into the oecd in just 63 years of existence rings a bell for you???? this is the israeli genius that not obama, not anyone in the world can destroy. israel will go from strength to strength and you and your dooms day scenarios will be the dust bin of history. mark my words.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article