Opinion
A word to Roger Waters
Lilac Sigan
Published: 21.04.13, 10:52
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
92 Talkbacks for this article
61. to 8
nadin ,   old city   (04.22.13)
you need more than -scratch- to be a good thinking person ..hehehe
62. ridicoulous indeed!
arie ,   israel   (04.22.13)
why would the czech republic depart from the slovaks if not because of the differences of culture and behavior! i understand that czech people doesn't se their own hump!!
63. i think you should read the article again!
arie ,   israel   (04.22.13)
no one said anything about racism/anti-semitism beside you!!!
64. the only dispute is on the small pieces of land
(04.22.13)
called Judea, Samaria and Gaza BOOM! stopped reading there.
65. # 30 title deed
Rau   (04.22.13)
The land was given 6000 years ago.did your G-d specifically mention the boundary and that non jews are not allowed to live in this land.
66. Split...do that!
Koose E Mack ,   NY NY   (04.22.13)
Once again, it's so refreshing to hear your tripe and BS.
67. Love your music but.....
Koose E Mack ,   NY NY   (04.22.13)
as they say in Jolly Old England, "Piss off you bloddy wanker"
68. Waters-to 18
linda ,   Paris   (04.23.13)
Have you read something in this article about Waters's antisemitism? No, you have read only very good arguments.
69. waters
dahnyc ,   nyc   (04.23.13)
the british are hopeless
70. Peer Group Pressure
Zircon   (04.23.13)
Walters is influenced by Peer Group Pressure the Utopian dystopians There is no way after the Holocaust losses the Jews can take in masses of Palestinians already from the sea to the River there are six million Jews and six million Arabs.If the Islamic world had offered mass refugee to the Jews of Nazi Europe even fought the Nazis who mocked the prophets for example Turkey many Jews would have been saved we would not be in this dangerous situation .
71. RM from Amsterdam (#18)
David Gilmour ,   Crumbling Land   (04.23.13)
On the contrary... Please take a moment to re-read the article above. Have you read it in the first place? The main argument is not "either with us or against us" (which hints that you haven't read). Rather it is: "Simply take the time to educate yourself of this issue's complexity". Then you are free to choose your stand. Sure, simplifying stuff is cool and easy, but it is not necessarily correct.
72. # 65 Rau As a matter of fact,
BUILD BABY BUILD ,   United States   (04.23.13)
He did. You should read the original boundary's that the G-d of Israel gifted the twelve tribes of Israel. Quite specific, as a matter of fact, you should read beginning there and read what truth looks like, for once. Those madras's are laughable, except for teaching that terror is somehow justified until it comes back to bite you on the unwashed butt.
73. # 60 Harvey Quite right
BUILD BABY BUILD ,   United States   (04.23.13)
Poor publicity starved Has Been Waters should be ignored and relegated to the pile of useless two chord rockers who are "has beens."
74. # 51....
Edithann ,   USA   (04.23.13)
The only difference of the Israeli aganda today as opposed to the myth of 3000 years ago is your 'Higher Authority' didn't show up to make your crimes legitimate!. TATA
75. # 65 Rau As a matter of fact,
BUILD BABY BUILD ,   United States   (04.23.13)
He did. You should read the original boundary's that the G-d of Israel gifted the twelve tribes of Israel. Quite specific, as a matter of fact, you should read beginning there and read what truth looks like, for once. Those madras's are laughable, except for teaching that terror is somehow justified until it comes back to bite you on the unwashed butt.
76. That's MUSIC?
BUILD BABY BUILD ,   United States   (04.23.13)
I don't think so, noise maybe, music NO!
77. Holy Water or stakes in the heart?
BUILD BABY BUILD ,   United States   (04.23.13)
For pete's sake keep the script accurate. Holy water is for Catholics not muslims.....
78. # 57 BUTseriously you answered your own question
BUILD BABY BUILD ,   United States   (04.23.13)
Britainistan??? Look for a new 'Queen" if you call long gowned bearded ladies "Queens'.
79. He pretends he dosnt know about 57 Moslem Aparthied States!
(04.24.13)
80. Roger Waters is a racist
Andy Gill ,   London, UK   (04.27.13)
Waters attempts to discredit Israel are typical of the covert anti-semitic racism we see on the British left. He completely ignores the bloodthirsty violence of Palestinian terrorists and their hate-preaching clerics.
81. behind the closed doors
(04.27.13)
What I don't understand is why US defends Israel so much, and always all the presidents emphasize on protecting IS in their speech, what is the benefit of this little country for US?
82. 81 Because it is the Right Thing to Do!!!
Dina ,   USA   (05.09.13)
Do you support murdering innocent civilians? I would hope not. Take your head out of the sand long enough to see that most of the technology is created by Israelis. You should thank the US and Israel for all the good that they do and support. know you are smarter than this...
83. Roger Waters
Yvette ,   BA, Argentina   (05.13.13)
The Arabs living at the time were there working for the Jews who had been buying swamps and developing the land from scratch. They came from neighboring countries. They didn't come from Palestine in the first place. That's why Israel belonged to the Jewish people! And has always belonged to them
84. Rogers great Musician with awful ideas
Hilik ,   Barkan ISRAEL   (05.31.13)
Mr. Rogers, You are taking aside with no any knowledge. Israel? Apartheid? so worng? We all evidance what happend in Europe, one day Mr. Rogers will awake up and find out that his Home never the same, and he will be a foriegner at his Home and the muslims will claim London Belong to us. Let me tel you a secrete you may don't know, Family that own houses in the city doesn't mean the city belong to them.
85. Roger Waters Distorted Mind
The Doktor ,   America   (07.25.13)
Perhaps Mr. Waters has been exposed to the Left's Ideology for too long a period. FEELING instead of THINKING is the Left's SOP. Lilac Sigan's Op-ed is clearly a reasoned, educated reply to the blind hatred of an illogical attack upon Israel from Waters.
86. GOOD FOR WATERS!
Lacy ,   Boston, MA   (07.25.13)
Good for Waters! Israel has TAKEN OVER the U.S. federal government using its jack-booted "police state" tactics and using its Zionists in Congress to write legislation ABOLISHING our Constitution and Bill of Rights. WE HAVE "ALL" BECOME ANTI-SEMITIC!
87. That's not the real dispute
CuriousDave ,   L.A., USA   (07.26.13)
Does anyone realistically believe that there will be peace if Israel relinquishes only the settlements on the West Bank (Gaza was de-occupied long ago)? How about Jerusalem? How about the fact that foreigners seized lands occupied by Palestinians in 1948? As for your reference to Samarea and Judea, that is based on religious belief, not logic and fairness, and will never win an argument with the world at large.
88. The Real Reason
CuriousDave ,   L.A., USA   (07.26.13)
From the point of view of most of the Palestinians, their lands were seized from them not in 1967 but in 1948. Thousands of men, women and children were massacred in places likee Deir Yassin. How can anyone expect any of those people - or their descendants - to recognize a state called Israel?
89. No, Lacy, it's YOU who became antisemitic
CuriousDave ,   L.A., USA   (07.26.13)
How log ago was it that YOU became antisemitic (definition of antisemites: those who hate Jews more than they should)? Please tell us how Israel has "taken over the U.S. Federal Government" and please give us a few examples of the "jack-booted "police state" tactics that Zionists have used to "ABOLISH our Constitution... (etc.)?"
90. That's not the real dispute
CuriousDave ,   L.A., USA   (07.26.13)
Does anyone realistically believe that there will be peace if Israel relinquishes only the settlements on the West Bank (Gaza was de-occupied long ago)? How about Jerusalem? How about the fact that foreigners seized lands occupied by Palestinians in 1948? As for your reference to Samarea and Judea, that is based on religious belief, not logic and fairness, and will never win an argument with the world at large.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article