Opinion  Ray Hanania
Palestinian film evokes excitement, anger
Ray Hanania
Published: 19.01.06, 08:19
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
92 Talkbacks for this article
61. Had Rays buddy blown up half the Golden Globe Audience
Steven Wilson ,   Anchorage, Alaska   (01.20.06)
like they blow up Jews----I can just believe, that the wonderful Palestinian love, would vanish. As pieces of fingers, legs, and arms land up into the crowd above----the warmth and love ----would most certainly vanish from the American Audience. Just as it did after the World Trade Center Blasts. As far as Israeli's and Palestinian's calling each other names---he left out the blown up corpse paragraph. The part where 20 or 30 Israeli's live with brain injuries---lost body parts. And then there is the dead---funerals--wailing cries from family members of innocent children who are dead. Ray's so proud of it all, that he forgot to mention----that he forgot to mention it! Maybe Ray should promote a film for American Indians such as myself. At least I'm not blowing up Ray's family---even though he is sitting on my land. Maybe he should show some disgust for his Terrorist brothers---rather than proudly support them---while they commit terrorism to get back a tiny speck of land. Can you imagine Ray inviting me over to blow the crap out of his house, because it's my land. And then proudly writing about how wonderful it was, that I was finally recognized for being an American Indian. And Ray would proudly hand over the deed to his house to me. And give me a flag to wave at his neighbors. Or was it my house to begin with? Rays just happy I blew his house up---to get my land back in the first place. If I kill some innocent people along the way. Ray just won't tell anyone. But he'll still be proud!
62. 57# you really believed we liked all you terrorists?
Steven Wilson ,   Anchorage, Alaska   (01.20.06)
Surprise---We pretty much hate all of you. Why? Because you murder innocent people for no other purpose than your misguided religious terrorism. What did you think? We were gonna want to come over to your house for a group hug? Do you want us to bring the body parts of our dead relatives also? Maybe they want to get into a group hug also? I'm sure Allah wouldn't mind. He pretty much doesn't have any rules. As long as it is a Non Muslim that you are killing. Your cause has done catastrophic harm. None of us will trust or like you for several generations because of this terrorism. We despise your religion now!
64. To Ann nr 31 Should we be grateful for the Holocaust??
Daniel ,   Amsterdam   (01.20.06)
Ann, Those that suggest that the State of Israel is a result of the Holocaust are indeed suggesting this. But no, obviously we should not be since Israel is but the logical consequence of Jewish power: When Jews can they will attempt to be independant in the one place it matters. This was the case before the Holocaust as well. If you look at the 20th century and Jewish life what is more importand, the Holocaust or the recreation Jewish state? I would go for Israel for the simple fact that I care about living Jews not dead ones. Also, as much as I hate Islamic fundamentalists for the suicide bombings, they are not the same as Auschwitz. I know they would if they could, but thanks to the State of Israel they are not able to. Listen, the land of Israel is importand. But what's more importand is the continued existance of the State of Israel in the Land of Israel. It's not worth risking the Jewish state just to own more of Erets Israel. We caused the Palestinian nation into existance. Withouth us the place would be Egyptian, Jordanian or Syrian. Now after 50 years or 80 or whenever you start counting Palestinians are a fact. It's silly to say they don't exist now in 2006 just as silly as it is to claim they did exist 100 years ago. Palestinians should realise that if not for us they would not be. They should be grateful we came and 'occupied' their land. Otherwise they would be living in an Islamic or Ba'thist 'paradise' with nobody caring what happends to them. Just ask the Kurds. Ray, from acros the devide the Zionist monster grins at you. I know you are grinning back.
65. Paradise now
dana ,   israel   (01.20.06)
Can somebody doubt that if it was the worst movie in the world - it would still won the reward?
66. Fool's Paradise
CZ   (01.20.06)
Something tells me Ray resides in one.
67. Peace.......
James K. ,   Leesville, U.S.A.   (01.20.06)
Can't we all just get along?
68. Palestinians are
Isac ,   Florida   (01.20.06)
a violent society. No culture, no love, no mercy, just violence. Being a violent society for what reason ever, how could they ever have a responsible society without gangs, street thugs and mafia?! And that's not a queastion!~
69. kate as usual
(01.20.06)
still you don't write your opinion about the report... just collecting your hate like you did allways and attacking any Arab or any who defend the Arabs who write here ... you are nothing .... you have no opinon about any thing ... empty brain ... with heart full of hate ..... hatress
70. to 68
(01.20.06)
the Palistinians have no culture .... but they speake the same language , they have the traditions , same habits and they are from the same place .... let's see the Israelians .... came from allover the world .... not the same language , not the culture , not the tradtions .... next point ... no love .... if they don't have love .. they would not stand beside eachother till now fighiting together against the occupiers , they don't hate anything which is not moslem or not Palistinian .... the Israelians ... they hate and have no respect to anything which is not Jew .. , and we have to speake about gangs .... the Palistians didn't steal any land from anybody the gangs are the thiefs .... violence ???? let's count together the massacers the Jews did against the Palistians or you can count by your self ... or you didn't hear about it before ? .... lol ... the Palistinians didn't kill their PM because he wanted to make peace but the Israelian did Mr. Rabin (God bless him) ... i will not speake about Sharon ... just to respect his situation now and still i pray for him to stay alife ... do you see the real love? ... .... we say who his hous from glase made ... not to throw the others with stoned ... you got it ? ... now you and kate and and and ... can shout back ... as usual ... but the fact is ... that the Palistinian film got the Golden glob .... even the strong Jewish loby could not stop it this time ... it's a slap on the face of the zionists .
71. To # 70
(01.20.06)
Your post was very incoherent and hard to understand but I got the jist of the last part. You should understand this was the vote of the "foreign press," NOT Hollywood so this "Jewish loby" of Hollywood you speak of is wrong. It was the vote of, as I said, a foreign group of journalists. Hence your point makes no sense.
72. to 71
(01.20.06)
yes sure you understand what suits you and you leave the reast ... no problem ... no matter who voted , the Jewish loby is not only in America , they are allover the world , but they are not any more that strong like before because the world is fed up ... but take it like you want ... the film got the golden glob whatever you think .
73. Where are jewish authors in arab media?
Ignacio ,   Zaragoza, Spain   (01.21.06)
I'm surprised reading not only this article (quite stupid, sincerely, he only praises himself and his myths, without addressing main topics at the film) but to discover he has written more on this outlet. So if an israeli newspaper does not have one of these hate-mongers, its because israeil are thugs, BUT if Arab media is like it is (and I visit MEMRI quite often) then is ok. This guy harasses Xtians, attacks Israelis, shows racism ganist Jews and praises suicide bombers. Out with this guy. And I'm Spani from Zaragoza, a city without Synagoge since 1492 at least, so no Jewish thug here. Why prosecuting Irving while airing such a hate-rubbish?
74. Right On #61
Steve ,   NZ   (01.21.06)
You have succinctly put the point forward..from the reverse...lets see if anyone can actually counter what youre saying
75. Jewish hypocrites
(01.21.06)
You blow people up everyday and don't even wince because they are Christians and Muslims and Palestinian. You only cry and throw the violence you created at us because you are deep down ashamed of your viciousness. You are the murderers. You murder people and, worse, pretend it doesn't happen. You kill an alleged terrorist and kill 5 innocent passersby and that means nothing to you. So, when you talk about pieces of flesh, fingers, and body parts exploding in death, I see the murders you commit and the warcrimes you are all guilty of. I am just so happy to see all of your anger here. That measn we will one day win this war.
76. Slander
Simon ,   San Diego, CA USA   (01.21.06)
Why do you say that the JDL is a terrorist organization? Post the proof or email it to me. I don't want to hear what the ADL says, that's a private organization. Show me where the US Government designates it a terrorist organization. You can't. It's not. Your so-called Palestinian government is a huge terrorist organization. Research your facts there Hollywood.
77. #72 You have a lot of terrorist awards
Roger ,   USA   (01.21.06)
so, what? You represent an ugly, rotten, violent society now and it is not going to be any different in the future. Look at the map of the Arab world. It sreams with corruption, murder and misery.
78. How about arresting them number 75#
(01.21.06)
Arrest your terrorist buddies, and keep them in prison. Then The IDF won't feel the need to push a missile up their behind to get rid of them. As far as being hypocrites. You are sending the terrorists across into Israel to blow up civilians. You don't arrest the bomb makers. You let them hang out in public with your children. They are targeting these people since you are to chicken sh*t to take care of the problem yourself. Since you feel the need to send bombers into Israel whenever feasable, Israel considers itself at war with your terrorist buddies. Therefore your children are going to be fodder, if they hang around terrorists. And that isn't being hypocritical---its called protecting yourself from terrorists. The day that you Palestinians learn to play in a sandbox without blowing up the Jewish children, will be the day, that your children will not have to worry about a missile killing your terrorist neighbor. Your real problem is, that you are a rascist, you hate Jews, you feel that it is okay to kill and maim them, and when the same Jews shoot back at your terrorist buddies killing them, and passers by----you scream and whine ---like spoiled little children---that some of your children were killed in a retalitory air strike. You are like children playing with matches. You set a house on fire, it burns and falls over, crushing twenty school children watching the spectacle. Then you blame the twenty deaths on the house------for falling on the children. Not a one of you----that set the fire in the first place----has enough balls to admit-----that you are responsible for the childrens deaths! Because you!!!!!! Started the fire!!!! In the first place!!!!!! You are the real hypocrites. Stop sponsoring suicide bombers. Arson Boy!
79. about 51
Dana ,   Israel   (01.21.06)
You wrote "Abu-Assad should have also strongly denounced suicide bombing. But not doing so, he left the impression that he supports it which plays into the criticism of his film." It seems to me that he left just the right impression, otherwise what stopped him from expressing his negative view of suicide bombers? And I didn't saw the movie, but nobody refers to this movie mentioning the fate of the victims, so I suppose it's not there. About palestinian being against suicide bombers - you positive impression is not suiting palestinian sources talking about 50% and more support for terror against civilians between palestinians. Of cource it can be that students are the part of population where positive change is starting, I would be glad to believe it, but somehow - I doubt that this is the case here...
80. #6 Try to convience me
Mohammad ,   Gaza in Palestine   (01.21.06)
You all jews (most of you) trying to convience yourself that we do not exist. You guys have a big problem. They call it "The Palestinean Issue" NOT the "Israeli Issue". If we dodnot exist then you are in deep problem fighting ghosts.
81. #4 Donot you have other subject
Mohammad ,   Gaza in Palestine   (01.21.06)
You realy make me board. Can you say other things Mr.Rain Man
82. to 77
(01.21.06)
look at which society you live first .. count and make statistic for the amount of crimes in the US and in any arab countries .... the US is one of countries which no body feel safty in it and in a lot of cities allmost no one can go out in the street as soon as it dark .... in the USA can any child buy a gun or pistol by post ... how many times massacers have been done by children having guns in their hands ... coruption ... it's known the in the USA the corruption is everywhere in the government , in the police everywhere , why no one till now could brig out a low in the USA to forbid selling weapons to the people because of corruption , the weapons dealers buy any one try do it .... your history is black built on deid bodies , starting by killing the indians to steal their land passinf by Hiroshima and Nagazaki ending in Irak ... you are people without idintity , no culture , no history , no pricinples .. all the bad habbits starts in the USA then you export it to the rest of the world .... come on guy ... look at the mirror before you look to the others .
83. to Kate #31
n/a ,   Tel Aviv   (01.21.06)
I quote u: "Should we also be grateful to millions of Dutch gentiles for collaborating with the Nazis to murder over 100,000 Jews, ..." Kate, there are always people in a war who will side with the enemy....unfortunately....but there were no millions of Dutch collaborators....silly girl...get ur facts straight...Holland was invaded by the Nazis and our Jewish population were killed by the Nazis...my mothers father and 3 brothers were taken to Dachau by the Nazis, please Kate don't underestimate my intelligence...my mother and her sister survived because Dutch people hide them while endagering their own lives...
84. Arabs come on YNET to annoy Jews
Mike   (01.22.06)
Don't you see? They don't have their own outlet, b/c their government is watching everything they do. The only thing they are actually allowed and encouraged to do is kill Jews, and if they can't do that, they like to annoy them. This is why they come to YNET, an Israeli-Jewish site. We fall into their trap. If you ignore them, they will go away. Who cares what they have to say. Posters #80-82 cannot even speak English. They probably attempted to learn English just so they can come on to YNEt and annoy American Jews. It's not enough they harrass Israeli Jews on a daily basis.
85. What a lame comparison number 82#
Steven Wilson ,   Anchorage, Alaska   (01.22.06)
While you corrupt idiots shoot guns into the night every chance you get. If you aren't kidnapping someone, cutting their head off with a dull knife, or strapping plastic explosive bomb belts to your children, you are bemoaning the terrible United States. How often do kids in America shoot up a school----compared to all the terrorist attacks that you muslims commit. Guns aren't an argument anyways. The Hutu's killed 800,000 thousand Tutsi's with Machetes. So any country that has large knifes is corrupt also number 82#? It's your behaviour that makes you corrupt. And the Muslims in the Mid East are having a real corrupt time. Killing innocent people, for some fantasy dream vacation with 72 sluts, and a group of stinking, dirty, Camels. Boy oh boy, the thought of that makes me hot too. Not! It's hard to get all emotional with a woman, when the scent of Camel dung gags you during the moment. With 72 cows to mate with, you would need a bottle of viagra every night. You would have to give up on riding the Camel also. Mr. Woody would never go down ever again. Besides, Americans don't want to take over the world like yourselves. Allah needs to ditch the camels---they smell. Americans don't like to live in a barn with stinky camels.
87. to Steve # 85
who cares ,   TA   (01.22.06)
Those muslims still believe that 72 virgins are waiting for them at the gate....what a bummer when there is one 72 year old virgin waiting for them....LOL
88. to 85
(01.22.06)
you speake now about political situation in a certin area ... but i spoke genarly about the daily life in the rest of the arab countries and in the USA , where there is wars .. there is bombs ... but without wars ... which people feels more safty .... corupt idiots shots another people are part from your society , made by your laws which you can not change till now ... with all the democracy you have ... no one could change such law ... ask Mr. Moor about it .... and you speake about the middle east like we are all moslems ... this shows how ignorant you are about what you speake about .... i am not Moslem for example ... coruption has no relegion or nationality .... the hero of Water Gate was not Moslem ... the american society has a lot of Moslems why you speake only about the Moslems of the Middle East ... how many Moslems and arabs you met in your life ?? we are not Engels but you too not ... repare your hous first before you look to the others . the way you ended your post ... showed how hater and ignorant you are .... not polite ... not civilised .... not educated ... just hater ... when the camels are stinky no problem they are animals ... but when people like you are stinky ... this the problem ... smell your self first ... if you can
89. to 84
(01.22.06)
lol ... you want to hear only your voice ... you can not hear the oppostion voices .... what a democracy .... lol
90. Ray Hanania
Morton Rabin ,   Bahamas   (01.22.06)
I am trying to understand the benefits of printing Ray Hanania's columns - They are neigher humorous, nor anything that sounds like encouraging co-existence and harmony between Jews and Arabs - There are enough Israel bashers around without giving him a platform -
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article