Culture
Oscar nominee: People hate Israelis for a reason
Avner Hofstein
Published: 02.03.06, 19:33
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
240 Talkbacks for this article
121. Humiliation justifies Killing?
Deanna ,   Austin, USA   (03.03.06)
Although I found almost all of this article ofensive propaganda, what was truly reprehensible was the idea that his being "humilitated" by a security guard justifies killing innocent people. Apparently "evil" acts like being harrassed are now considered terror? And a valid reason for "counter terrorist attacks"? Give me a break.
122. If the Arabs want life they could have it
Jim ,   USA   (03.03.06)
The Arabs could work on economic development and improvement of their own lives but instead spend precious blood and capital on destroying Israel. I have been in both Palestine and Israel many times and the Arabs could but won't
123. The Jews and Arabs
Boris ,   Philadelphia   (03.03.06)
The cycle of violence is shameful. the palestinians who kill innocent jews and themselves are wrong. no one should kill an innocent. ever. The arabs, if they approched Israel with a decent attitude instead of bombs strapped to them, would be able to get more done in a week of friendship than 50 years of war. it will not change unless attitudes change. and the violence will never change anything. the definition of insanity is repeating and action expecting different results. and it should be quite clear to the arabs that the violence doesn't work. If the came up to a few Israeli soldiers with a few sandwiches and conversation.. .bridges would be built.
124. To the Israeli people
T. A. Adams ,   Oklahoma City, USA   (03.03.06)
Whatever you do, please do not judge Americans by the trash that comes out of Hollywood. The entire community collectively sold its soul to Satan long ago and this jackasses contribution to the “Arab/palestinian political propaganda” and the Hollywood pat on the back he’s getting for rewriting history… again.. is just more evidence. Perhaps this guy should stay in Gaza and help them make more convincing fairytales about dying Arabs. On second thought, I find what comes out of there pretty entertaining already. After all, I’d rather pay to get to see a dead guy fall to the ground twice on his way to getting buried and jump back up to continue the charade than to pay to see something like this lying moron’s flick.
125. re: He is raising valid points
2speed ,   Oceanside, CA   (03.03.06)
Ryan from Chicago..................Ryan, maybe you should move to Palestine. With your mentality on this issue, you would fit right in. What size is your waist?
126. Violence begets violence
Anthony ,   Houston, USA   (03.03.06)
127. ABU-STUPID
GIBOW ,   ALEXANDRIA, USA   (03.03.06)
In one sentence, the poor bastard's whole argument is destroyed. I'm certain that Hitler's success would have eliminated all Jews within about 10 years. I also think the "Palestinians" could be eliminated in about 10 days, if that were the object of the exercise.
128. Eternal Reward
pacumis ,   pacuville, usa   (03.03.06)
How does one make 72 virgins last in eternity? If you spend 5000 years wearing out each one, they only last 360,000 years. That's a blink of an eye in eternity. Is there a Mohammadan handbook with ammoritization tables to help with this issue?
129. Such Hypocrisy
Jeremy ,   Albany, NY   (03.03.06)
He's a pacifist, but he suppoprts suicide bombing. He opposes the Jewish state, does he oppose all the fascist Muslim states, like the one's his fellow savages are trying to form? He is skum!
130. Blind Spots
Mario Rojas ,   Ca, U.S.A   (03.03.06)
Tradition for the Philistines ingrained from birth is to hate Jews, Tradition for Jews from birth is to reject Jesus as the Messiah, yet the same prophets that point out the true owners of the land also point out the true Messiah in Isaaiah 53, Zec 12:10, 13:6, Ps 22, and on and on....And it's when the Joshua the Messiah is seated on the throne that there will be peace....Let's get past our traditions and look to the "truth that can make us free"...
131. Abu & Nick#17
J.C. ,   TN,USA   (03.03.06)
abu-assad and nick#17. It used to break my heart to hear the activists,we called them protesters back then,screaming at our vets, calling them babykillers.Now those same activists are supporting you. When you can strap a bomb to yourself and step onto a bus load of young ,innocent children for the purpose of murdering them so you can spend eternity with a bunch of virgins I just don't know what else to call you. Hollywood had awards planned for their demented mountain movie before it was filmed and I"m sure they will do the same for any body that might help them make those children believe that our President is a terrorist! Our educator' s are supporting you to. Sad news for you is that you're on the agenda right beside sexual deviency with our activists which, by the way, have become cowards and terrorists to. Our animal lovers wouldn't hurt a worm for fishing but think nothing of taking an unborn babys life. I guess I can see how you justify murdering a dozen innocent women and children at a busstop because I.D.F. soldiers killed a terrorist leader.
132. To #33 (observer)
Joan ,   Haifa   (03.03.06)
You are totally out of touch with reality. This "one man's terrorist is another man's freedom-fighter" thing is, to quote my 9-year old son, megacrap. I'm curious, though, what are your sources for saying Lehi supported the Nazis during the Shoah?
133. Israel's fault
Elye ,   NY, USA   (03.03.06)
Israel has been capitulating to terror - justifying it as a proper means of protest - since 1993. Why is everyone suddenly offended when an Arab says the same thing the Israeli left (you sometimes wonder whether there is such a thing as an Israeli right...) has been saying all along?
134. Arabs Have 22 States
Ben ,   USA   (03.03.06)
Anne shows this in context. Beautiful! How can anybody even give these murderers a forum?
135. Hey Alan in Frisco.....
Cindy ,   Milwaukee   (03.03.06)
If someone is rendered 'impotent', it does not necessairly mean sexually. One can be an impotent thinker also.
136. PARADISE NOW VS HOLOCAUST MOVIE
DEBRA ,   USA   (03.03.06)
A HOLOCAUST MOVIE, TITLED "SOPHIE SCHULL" IS ALSO NOMINATED FOR BEST FOREIGN FILM. IT IS THE STORY OF THE WHITE ROSE SOCIETY, A GROUP OF BRAVE SOULS WHO STRUGGLED AGAINST HITLER INSIDE NAZI GERMANY. NO ONE HAS HEARD MUCH ABOUT IT BECAUSE OF THE SUICIDE BOMBER'S MOVIE CREATED SUCH A DEBATE, BUT IT WOULD BE TERRIFIC IF THE HOLOCAUST FILM WON. LET'S HOPE HOLLYWOOD HAS THEIR HEART AND CONSCIENCE IN THE RIGHT PLACE.
137. PLO LEADER SAYS: "THE PALESTINIAN PEOPLE DOES NOT EXIST"
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (03.03.06)
Re-take Jewish Gaza! It's been transformed into terrorist training camps and a GLOBAL BASE FOR TERROR! Global jihad is greatly empowered as the U.S. EU and UN support an Islamic terror state in Israel that will threaten the world. There NEVER was an Arab country of Palestine. Jerusalem was NEVER the capital of any Arab or Muslim entity. JERUSALEM IS MENTIONED OVER 800 TIMES IN THE BIBLE, not once in the Koran. Arabs FIRST took the name “Palestinians” in 1967. Arafat was the FIRST leader of this NEW PEOPLE. Before 1948, Jews were known as the Palestinians! The Jewish newspaper, the Jerusalem Post was called the Palestine Post. http://palestinepostings.blogspot.com/2005/06/historical-palestinians-very-simple.html Human Rights Destroyers want Jews barred from living in Judea and Samaria, the Biblical heartland which includes Hebron, the first Jewish city, and second in Jewish holiness, BECAUSE JEWS are NOT MUSLIM! Respect is always given to Muslims! No one is trying to force Muslims out of Mecca and Medina! After the Jews miraculously transformed desert and swamps into rich, agricultural land (for which Jews are world famous!) Arabs came in large numbers from Arab countries for jobs from the Jews. The fact that the overwhelming majority of Arabs resided only briefly in Palestine is attested to by the special UN decree: that any Arab who had resided in Palestine FOR ONLY TWO YEARS BEFORE 1948, and then left, would be considered a refugee and so would his descendants!!! On March 31, 1977, Dutch newspaper Trouw published an interview with PLO executive committee member Zahir Muhsein: “The Palestinian people does not exist. The creation of a Palestinian state is only a means for continuing our struggle against the state of Israel for our Arab unity. In reality today there is no difference between Jordanians, Palestinians, Syrians and Lebanese. Only for political and tactical reasons do we speak today about the existence of a Palestinian people, since Arab national interests demand that we posit the existence of a distinct “Palestinian people” to oppose Zionism. For tactical reasons, Jordan, which is a sovereign state with defined borders, cannot raise claims to Haifa and Jaffa, while as a Palestinian, I can undoubtedly demand Haifa, Jaffa, Beer-Sheva and Jerusalem. However, the moment we reclaim our right to all of Palestine, we will not wait even a minute to unite Palestine and Jordan.
138. Prepare yourself for disappointment.
NS ,   Long Island, NY   (03.03.06)
This scumbag director just might win the Academy Award on Sunday night. Not only that but Spielberg might take one or two awards for his false film "Munich". Most members of the Academy will vote for one of these two films because they look upon it as a protest vote against the present American administration. It will not be because these films are any good just convenient for their protest. We have survived worse troubles. Courage!
139. Natives ?
steve hicks ,   USA   (03.03.06)
If Jews are natives of Israel, then how far back do we go to determine who the rightful inhabitants are of a particulare area is? The argument is that since the early 1900's Jews have decided to come back and they do it with the intention of ousting the Arabs (jews Are Arabs too if you want go back in history) from their homes, their farm lands, building walls right through farms that cut off water and trade routes. Over stepping the green line, buldozing homes of innocent people, confiscating homes and not issueing building permits, seperate laws for Arabs and Jews and the list goes on. Jews ultimatly bring it on themselves. Call me anti Semite andti Jew or whatever I don't give a shit, I just know the difference between right and wrong. Steve Hicks
140. To #67
Joan ,   Haifa   (03.03.06)
You are so right. I've often wondered if anyone ever referred to "the Jordanian-Occupied West Bank" between 1948 and'67. Just to add to what you said: Remember September 1970, called "Black September" by the Palestinians back then? Palestinian extremists were creating havoc in Jordan and King Hussein came down on them so hard that -- I never heard another peep. Of course, Israel can't just go in guns blazing and kill a couple of thousand people like that.
141. To #69
Joan ,   Haifa   (03.03.06)
LOL! But seriously, it makes about as much sense to blame Israel for terrorism in the world as it did for a Syrian government-owned newspaper to claim that Israeli scientists invented the avian flu virus as a biological weapon to wipe out the Palestinians. Or the Palestinian Environment Minister (I forget his exact title) to claim that Israel had buried 85,000 infected birds near Nablus in an attempt to ...well, you get the idea. [Yes, these are *real* accusations.]
142. MUNICH
kv ,   Canada   (03.03.06)
When the movie munich first appeared on the scene I know a lot of people who were offended by the glorification of the assassins, spending the first half of the movie showing their families and their difficulties with dealing what they were supposed to do.... And then Paradise Now comes on the scene and my JAW DROPPED! i could NOT believe the opposition to it...for the exact same reason! it "glorifies" them also by showing that they were struggling with what they thought they had to do etc etc --- ITS BASICALLY THE SAME MOVIE! I just cannot get over how people that are "outraged" about this film have not felt really hypocritical....i feel embarassingly hypocritical FOR them! and second of all as a plain old canadian (read: not arab, not jew) A lot of things link to this site, and everytime i accidently come to it, i waste so much time reading through all of these because...it's like watching a car accident, it's awful and i want to look away, but i can't! I can't believe the racism on here....I feel the same way i felt the time i stumbled on a white supremecist webpage and there were people's comments - it's the top of hillarity that when i clicked "talk back" to write, it says "Responses including incitement, slander and inappropriate language deemed to violate our terms of use won't be published."....what? yes it is so published! Go back and replace the word jew every time it says arab and arab when it says jew....and then read it.....it's disheartening and scary
143. Lisa - SEAD IT BETTER?
KP ,   DALLAS   (03.03.06)
I guess you could not have said it better, and do not worry since we do not expect much from you anyway... moron
144. Brainwashed
Rodrigo ,   Boston , MA   (03.03.06)
Guess who sounds more brainwashed than anyone else...you've got it. This lunatic is the biggest racist. In the article he suggested that Palestinians can eduate themselves. Palestenians have access to all the education of the world....if they wanted it.
145. #72: It Is Not About Religion
emanon ,   USA   (03.03.06)
The strife is over wanting everything handed to you. The Arabs living on the land over a century ago (after the cliphate and others forced the Jews off the land) did not want it. They all sold out their worthless parcels of land to the crazy Jews that were living there and those that came in the late 19th Century CE. They did not want the land because it was either arid desert or miserable swamp land. Once the Jews drained the swamps and built irrigation systems to turn this poor land into a land capable of producing crops and supporting herds, the Arabs decided they wanted the land back. They did not want to toil for it, they wanted it handed to them. Then along comes ome sunbaked Egyptian and starts yelling they have a right to the land, and he names their group Palestinians after the name the Romans gave the land after they occupied it ansd stole the land from the Jews living there. Finally, i 1967, enough people swollowed this lie that we have the current state of chaos. Sadly, even today, these people are unworthy of the land they covet. Look at what happened when Israel displaved its own people to give the Arabs land complete with the infrstructure for starting a viable economy. They destroyed the greenhouses and irrigation equipment becayuse it was formerly owned by Jews. Then they have the guts to say that this is a good start, now they want it all. No, it is not about religion, it is about land, envy and greed. Always has been. By claiming it is religious persecution, these terrorists seek to soften their image. This too is part of the big lie.
146. Why does no one remind Arabs
Andrew ,   USA   (03.03.06)
One, Palestinians don't exist, they are displaced Jordinians/Egyptians/Lebanese. Yassar Arafat, who was the leader of the Palestinians, was Egyptian, how could he claim a right to Israel? Furthermore, there are over a million Arabs who are citizens of Israel, including Hani. There would be no need for bombings if the Arabs had not started the fighting in the first place. Originally the jews wanted to live in peace with the Arabs. This article simply shows this mans ignorance, and his film should be banned. He obviously did not make this film to show an unbiased view of suicide bombers at all. How could he ask a hypothetical question if WW2 had lasted 30 years; obviously if he knew anything, he would know hundreds of millions of people would have died if that were the case. It would be interesting, after all thats happened in Europe lately, if the Dutch deported him from Holland. Being Dutch myself, I am heartbroken that my homeland would allow a man like this to live there.
147. "an act of let me die.....with"
Surrey ,   Chatanooga, Tn   (03.03.06)
I wonder if say, a christian film maker had made this comment if he would even be allowed to attend the academy awards...oh, wait, I forgot in Hollywood their is no greater crime than being considered "politically incorrect"...that is unless you are fat or wrinkled.So, this guy has already been given a golden globe, so that usually is pretty much a shew in for the big O. Hopefully he won't take this opportunity to live out his "fantasy revenge" on the "phillistines". What a waste of plastic surgery....Uh I mean talent, that would be. Is silicone flammable? The "O's" this year will be a Hollywood wet dream. Suicide bombers, gay cowboys, Capote, rasicm, transsexual, hip hop, evil capatilists, George Clooney, evil Republicans, George Cloony, and who did I leave out? Oh, yea Walk the Line? Do you think it has a chance? The anticipation is unbearable.
148. Suicide Samsons vs Israeli Philistines
patrick ,   NY, USA   (03.03.06)
I realized, Abu-Assad explains, that when a man systematically goes through such humiliation, he chooses to kill his own impotency by carrying out an act of "let me die with the philistines." Interesting comparison. It would be a challenge for any man to accept the many humiliations of the Israeli occupation without anger turning to hatred.
149. 72 Virginians
E ,   US of freakin' A   (03.03.06)
150. DON'T HATE JEWS?
L. HYAK ,   SUISUN CITY, CA.   (03.03.06)
ASAD IS BEING LESS THAN TRUTHFUL IN HIS HATRED OF THE JEWS. THE JEWS ARE OUT NUMBERED AT LEAST 20 TO 1 BY ALL OTHER ARABS AND WHAT I SEE HERE IS A JEALOUSY OF THE FACT THAT ISRAEL HAS DONE FAR MORE WITH THEIR RESOURCES THAN ANY OF THE ARAB COUNTRIES. IF IT WERE NOT FOR OIL THE ARABS WOULD HAVE LITTLE OF NOTHING TO SHOW FOR THEIR TIME ON EARTH. I TOO AM OF ARAB DECENT AND TRUTHFULLY , I WONDER JUST WHY THE ARAB COUNTRIES HAVE NOT ALLOWED PALESTINE TO EXIST AT HEIR BEHEST AND NOT THE EXPENSE OF SUCH A SMALL COUNTRY SUCH AS ISRAEL? WHAT THIS GUY SAYS IS A CROCK.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article