News
IDF: Settlers acting irresponsibly
Efrat Weiss
Published: 16.06.06, 00:42
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
33 Talkbacks for this article
1. Irresponsible, yes! gvm must also better public transportat.
gabriela ben ari   (06.16.06)
2. Yes blame the Jews and not the Arab terrorists
(06.16.06)
Until you rid yourself of your self hate and mad guilt, this will continue. Are you so cowards and defeatists that you cant even recognize who the enemy is? Who makes you nervous wallking around at night? Who makes you scared to hitchhike? Who makes you nervous when your on a bus? Who makes you nervous to let your kids out? The arabs who have made this country into another ghetto when we as Jews have to be scared in our own land. PITIFUL
3. Are you going to increase public transportation?
(06.16.06)
Man, such cowards we have in our government. Such loosers
4. Your weakness to do what is right - to show no mercy!!!!!!!!
(06.16.06)
SHOW NO MERCY TO OUR ENEMIES Goodness gratious, why oh why are you people still in galut exile ghetto mode? Why does Olmert have to parade around the world pleading for acceptance of his suicide plan and to comfort them when instead he should go to the Jewish people in Yesha and explain it, even though its national suicide you would think they would do something. This is a national disgrace and will lead to your doom and civil war.
5. how come the kidnappers were not beaten up
Moshe ,   Beit Shemesh   (06.16.06)
by the police like the kids at Amona ?????
6. irresponsible government
sk ,   USA   (06.16.06)
A responsible government would have made sure that there would be no terror groups around, or that any terror elements would be far too fearful of Israeli might to attack Jews. Israel's government retreats in fear.
7. Crazy settlers obviously think rules are for other people
Karen R ,   Maryland   (06.16.06)
The settlers think they are above the law - the result may be that IDF personnel lose their lives trying to rescue lunatics who think that defying IDF recommendations and common sense is somehow a confirmation of their faith. These kids (and grownups too) are putting their lives at risk assuming that the IDF will bail them out if they get into trouble. Maybe what is needed is a regulation which bans hitchhiking - at least for minors - and is enforced. Why should soldiers and police have to risk their lives for the sake of such idiots? BTW - where are the parents? If parents let their kids in the West Bank hitchhike they should be prosecuted for neglect and endangerment, and the kids should be removed to foster families who will protect them properly.
8. You think that is irresponsible, you should see
Steve ,   USA   (06.16.06)
B"H You think that is irresponsible, you should see ... how irresponsible you blame those already relocated under the previous program, not providing jobs, education, or an environment for raising children. Now responsiblity would be taking care of the Gaza situation. Perhaps that would raise an eyebrow or two. http://english.katif.net/index.php?id=2145&sub=1 And speaking of responsible, do not blame the Arab attackers, but blame the victims ... again. Eventually this would catch up if the victims get tired of playing their roll and decide to clean up the mess that the IDF has abandoned to chaos in the entire territory, including Gaza.
9. #5 good point. and BARUCH HASHEM THEY ARE SAFE
gabriela ben ari   (06.16.06)
10. ISC; Politicians have betrayed the nation
Marcel ,   Florida   (06.16.06)
The corrupt leadership shipwrecks the nation and betrays the Jewish soul. This leadership bows to the foreign agenda of a nation which endangers Isxrael's survival.. These traitors,con-men and saboteurs, starting with Ehud the foreign agen,t follow a failed agenda and must be arrested ,tried and sent to prison. Israel Sanity Commission
11. IDF sterotyping irresponsible!
yehuda ,   new york usa   (06.16.06)
If the IDF wants to sterotype settlers, as a group, as "irresponsible" Why don't they at least use statistics and other mathematical techniques! Why don't they declare "shabbos motorists" as irresponsible, since so many more Israelis, died on the roads, friday night and Saturday, than any "irresponsible settlers". What about those who died from diseases related to irresponsible (and traditionally regarded as immoral) "private behavior" from celebritiesys such as "Ofrah Haza" to so many more than settlers, "others" How about the seekers of hedonism, in Thailand? I am not advocating blaming the victim. The IDF is! So my point is, that if the IDF wants to blame victims, they should at least be mathematical and scientific about it, and not just show their hatred of settlers!
12. The girls have no right to be there in the first place
Ellen Prescott ,   Southsea, Hampshire   (06.16.06)
The 49th article of the 4th Geneva convention states that no country may transfer its citizens into an occupied territory. GET OUT OF PALESTINE NOW!!!!
13. The Mercy of Fools Who Cannot Do What Is Right
(06.16.06)
And Whipe Our This Enemy in Our Mist
14. Why do we as Jews have to be scared in our own land?!
(06.16.06)
Its a nightmare that our leaders press more for Arab rights and Jewish eviction than to save our land from death and destruction
15. why weren't the kidnappers shot on sight to send a message
use real deterents ,   not arrests   (06.16.06)
16. No buses so what are the options?
Ilan ,   Ariel   (06.16.06)
Who in the city would wait 3 hours for the next bus? There are almost no options except tramping.
17. Everyday I pick up trampists
Ilan ,   Ariel   (06.16.06)
I commute to Jerusalem and every day I take 3 or 4 trampists en route. Most trampists wait at bus stops in safe locations by entrances to a yishuv (those trampists were "isolated" less than 5 minutes from the Ariel police station). It is absurd for the army to claim that it can not patrol route 60. Stupid incompentence is the best we can expect from our army?
18. Arabs are the real settlers.
Daisy ,   USA   (06.16.06)
20. get free pub.transport.
banglassie ,   utrecht   (06.16.06)
Ellen P. "get out of Scotland and Irland first +Shut the F*** up!"
21. #12 is now in the shomron too
(06.16.06)
leav 'em waiting for a tremp at a lonely spot pleeeese. Their mates will do the work for us...
22. award
Michael ,   Haifa   (06.16.06)
There is little doubt that the little bunny rabbit from Santa Monica gets the award for being the foulest mouth here in talkback. Even though I often have to disagree with Ms. Prescott, she maintains the decency of civilized speech as opposed to the fishwife style of the Meyer woman.
23. YNET GETS THEIR JOLLYS
marya ,   sacramento USA   (06.16.06)
From their critical headlines..ooh, ooh settlers baaaad -- IDF says so.. Get BENT YNET!
24. Hey you with the thick ankles
marya ,   sacramento USA   (06.16.06)
Yeah, I'm talking to you ellen, you piece of terrorist loving human offal..
25. Ask the army why
marya ,   sacramento usa   (06.16.06)
they hell they hitchhike all the time...
26. ellen allah akhbar part 2
josh ,   jerusalem   (06.16.06)
i believe that england was originally a french territory?
27. Ellen: so UK needs to get out of Ireland
howard ,   pacific coast, usa   (06.16.06)
and it's okay for Catholics to try to kidnap and/or rape you if the UK doesn't (not that I believe it, but obviously you do).
28. ellen or whatever
me ,   earth   (06.16.06)
Oh please ,what ever you call yourself,just shut up,your comments are so nausiating;if they were at least objective,ok,but you are so Racist,and anti-semetic,just the sight of your "name"is enough to want to put on a BELT,and do what your Friends ,are doing to innocent civiliens worldwide.So for once and for all,Go play ball on the tel-aviv,highway....
29. ellen allah akhbar
josh ,   jerusalem   (06.16.06)
tell me, are you jewish? if you are i think that neturei karta is looking for a loud mouth like you as a spokesman. check up if its against the law to preform acts of terror. but please don't tell me that kidnapping citzens whether they are there legally or not, is self defense or what not. please prove that you have a little common sense!
30. YOU STILL BARKING eLLEN pRESCOTT !
AVINU   (06.16.06)
YOU STILL BARKING PRESCOTT, TAKE CARE THIS HATRED FOR JEWS MAY WILL LET YOU TO HAVE RABIES !
Next talkbacks
Back to article