News
Halutz: Abducted soldier alive
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 25.06.06, 16:18
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
162 Talkbacks for this article
91. To mr. Khalil from #86
Rambo ,   Israel   (06.25.06)
You must have forgotten how israelis have beat your arab friends at 1948 ,1956 , 1967 , 1973 , 1981 and in smaller conflicts in between. But ok , i forgive you for your stupidity. If you still not convinced, you can sit in your house and watch in CNN how "coward" israeli soldiers take over your "brave" martyrs. Hmm... you hear them knocking at your house's door? , i guess it's not good.... for you....
92. Sometimes I miss the days
Darren   (06.25.06)
When Israeli politicians didn't engage in bumper stickers statements of who is to blame, who condemns and who didn't, who is gonna say what, or when we do things. You know, the days when the cabinet was holding a meeting and the only statement afterwards was something along the lines of "Israel will retaliate in a time and place where it sees fit" and nothing more. And then, whenever it happens, terrorist and their supporters take a blow. Just like that. Simple, no? Enough of that sleazy-style politicians. It's time get to work, not for talks. Now, get our soldier back!
93. 7 WAEL : Posting BS doesn't show brains
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (06.25.06)
94. 10 rushdi: Brains is not your strong point
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (06.25.06)
95. This is what we're dealing with
Ronnie ,   Israel   (06.25.06)
"The mother of one of the two Palestinians killed in the incident near Kerem Shalom handed out sweets to passerbys in her neighborhood in response to the killing of IDF soldiers. The mother expressed her support of her son's actions and said that she is ready to sacrifice her entire family in the war against the enemy". Above quote is from today's newspaper. Nothing more needs to said. This is the kind of primitive thinking we are up against. Can you imagine an Israeli mother saying this?
96. Blame the American Jews
David ,   USA / ISRAEL   (06.25.06)
It seems to me from the video that the enemy fire was comming from the hot houses the American Jews bought and gave to the Palestinians. I wonder if those same good doers are sleeping at night now. You are the ones responsible for the death of our people. Shame on you. Save your money and mind your owne business
97. 26 Fake Palestinian: actually Russia is a perfect place for
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (06.25.06)
Fake Palis to move to - they teach you obbeyance or it is the Goulags
98. When we will live ?
Max Payne ,   Gaza City   (06.25.06)
I wanna reply to all who say this is a terorrist attack where they have been when 15 childs killed last 2 weeks ago ? Go away from our strip and make us live freely, and you will live freely. We wanna live in peace thats enough, we killed in this life every minute,we wanna live like humans
99. Shake the Earth!
Paula ,   Maaleh Adumim, Israe   (06.25.06)
Shake the Earth By Paula R. Stern Israel has, for the most part over the last year, appeared weak and inefficient in its dealings with the Palestinians. We have emphasized our desire for peace and our willingness to make painful concessions and the Palestinians hear only that we are willing to take pain, and willingly oblige. We have made unilateral concessions and for the most part the Palestinians laugh at our having given up much of our bargaining position before the bargaining has even begun. Imagine, they think to themselves, how much more the Israelis will be forced to give up when we actually do sit down to negotiate. And even more, they tease us with promises of peace…and then explain they only mean a temporary peace, perhaps 10 years, perhaps more, but only if we weaken ourselves enough that they too will be able to follow in the path of their great Mohammed. They remember that Mohammed made a peace agreement, only to break it two years later when the enemy was weakened enough that Mohammed’s victory was assured. But all our past mistakes will be as nothing if we do not make the ground shake today, if we do not act without mercy, as they have done. This morning just after dawn, 8 Palestinians attacked an army base in Keren Shalom. As military strategy goes, it was a successful operation in which 2 of the enemy were killed, 6 others wounded, and best of all, the infiltrators were able to steal back across the border after kidnapping an Israeli soldier. This was not a terrorist attack against innocents. We cannot bemoan the lack of decency or mercy that is so common in most terror attacks. This was a military incursion and must be answered in kind. That they will likely choose to hide their prize among Palestinian civilians is not our problem and we must show the same lack of mercy that was shown to us. The fact that they were able to infiltrate and attack is the fault of the Defense Minister and the upper echelons of the army who have failed to allow our soldiers to adequately defend themselves, but the reasons no longer matter. If Israel does not shake the ground to get our soldier back, if the very earth does not vibrate with our anger and our determination to return the soldier and the body parts these ghoulish gunmen claim they took, we may as well surrender all that we have left. The reason we live in Israel, the purpose for its existence is so that we Jews can live in our land, be protected by our army, and take our place among the nations of the world. If Olmert and Peretz are to be worthy of the positions they hold, they will hold back no mercy, until our boys are home.
100. 32 Guy from Nablus: this is Nablus LEARN
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (06.25.06)
Shechem (Nablus) Nablus, known as the site of biblical Shechem. The area of Biblical Shechem can be found in Balata, which is in the eastern section of the city. Historically, Abraham traveled through Shechem on his way to Canaan and offered his first sacrifice to G-d. After the conquest of Canaan, Joshua assembled the Israelites here Inside the area known as Biblical Shechem are the remains of a defensive wall, a 3,600-year-old Hyksos temple and Joseph’s Tomb. The first reference to Shechem in Scripture occurs in Genesis 12:6-8. This passage records how Abram travelled southwards through Canaan until he reached the great tree of Moreh at Shechem in the centre of the land. There the Lord appeared to him and in response he build an altar and offered sacrifices to the Lord. The oak or terebinth of Moreh was to feature significantly later in the Old Testament, During an outbreak of violence in October 2000, Palestinian rioters destroyed Joseph’s Tomb and were reportedly building a mosque on the site to try once more to demolish anything from Jewish history.
101. 39 Kamal: Move to Gaza: Haifa is Israel dumbed down fool
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (06.25.06)
102. 42 You need to stop smoking Camel crap it shows in your Post
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (06.25.06)
Your brains suffer
103. 45 Observer: You need new goggles yours are blinded + Foggy
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (06.25.06)
104. 49 Nick You make a serious Fool of yourself AGAIN
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (06.25.06)
you need to grow up - or go out and play with your buddies in the street
105. Thank the chamberlain/petain team-AGAIN
Arie   (06.25.06)
106. Will someone PLEASE
Columbus ,   7 Seas   (06.25.06)
show me where Palestine is on the world map. I cannot find it!!!!
107. To #10
Arie   (06.25.06)
"jailing us in Gaza strip, do'nt give us minimum human rights to survive, " You wanted us out, so we left. The "jailing" and "minimum human rights" is the responsibility of YOUR PA not of ours. Complain to them. We WILL remove the chamberlain/petain team of olmert/peretz and vengeance will be achieved!
108. It's time to take a platoon of D9s and push Gaza to the sea!
(06.25.06)
109. Millions for Terror, Not One Cent for the People
Jeremy S. Slavin ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (06.25.06)
It is funny; whoever this Khalil is, he 1) forgets not all Israeli soldiers are males and 2) forgets to mention that Islamic terrorists PRIMARILY target civilians. It seems, from observation, to be the height of jihad when a "martyr" kills as many Jewish or Christian (or depending on the sec, Sunni or Shiite) civilian men, women and children as is possible. Islamic terrorists are apparently only MEN or, for that matter, WOMEN when they attack innocent people on buses or Passover dinners in Israel, or hotels in Amman, Jordan for that matter. It is a mistake to say that people like Khalil should just be ignored when they are the pot calling the kettle black. Their hypocrisy is EXACTLY the kind of thing wrong with those whom artists like Roger Waters admonish Israelis to make peace with. They should be called out upon their hypocrisy - if there is any sort of society living in the Holy Land that celebrates and feels empowered when civilians are murdered, it is unfortunately Palestinian society. Those who remember Palestinians dancing in the streets and passing out candies live on CNN on September 11, 2001 know exactly what I'm talking about. Those who remember that the Palestinians voted in Hamas KNOWING that Hamas has a policy of destruction and murder know what I'm talking about. And yet, there are those like Khalil. People like this likely cannot bring themselves to even believe that Arabs carried out 9/11, even as Osama bin Laden has admitted to that act of war, proudly taking credit for that crime against humanity and civilization. If Islamic suicide bombers struck Palestinians with the frequency they now strike Iraqis, would PalestinianJew and Khalil still be so blind to their own hatred? Maybe. But to expect Palestinians to truly sympathize with those of their Arab brethren in Iraq who have, as a result of Islamic terrorism, suffered many more deaths than those in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, would be for the Palestinians to relinquish the "eternal victim" status they grabbed for themselves, ironically by shooting themselves in the foot time and again to get it. If the Palestinians are so poor and powerless, how is it the terrorists who speak for their desires get the money, supplies and arms to carry out attacks like the one they carried out today? Seems they have "millions for terrorism, not one cent for their people". For those who say that democratic societies do not go to war with one another, look again - Hamas in conjunction with other groups committed yet another act of war among many today against Israel, and Hamas was the democratic choice of a majority of the Palestinian people.
110. WHY
Carlos Murphy ,   Aus.   (06.25.06)
Whilst Olmert was prancing around the world stage being patted on the shoulders by the world leaders. Hamas was pulling the rug from under his feet. Who will tell these mothers that thier sons died,because thier leaders were asleep at the wheel.
111. Jews are to blame
David ,   Sydney, Australia   (06.25.06)
I am ashamed to be jewish. I am part of a cowardly group of appeasers who blame themselves for acts of terrorism. When will they ever learn?
112. Hishtadlut
Ramat Beit Shemesh   (06.25.06)
For those who would like to do something concrete to help Gideon Shalit, the 4 soldiers who were wounded and support our soldiers, there will be prayers at the Wall at 18:00. If you can't make it then anyplace prayers are appropriate
113.  GG POSTINGS SHOWS SHE IS LOOSING HER BRAINS IN LAKE GENEVA
THE JEBUSITE ,   JEBUSTINE   (06.25.06)
HAHAHA GG IT IS TIME FOR YOU TO SHUT UPAND GET A LIFE OLD LADY.
114. #46
Talula Belle ,   Israel   (06.25.06)
At least Mongolia is on the map. Someone in his forum asked where Palestine is on the world map - HELL! I can't find it either!!!!! I found Mongolia though.
115. 112 Ramat Beit Shemesh : We are with YOU no matter where we
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (06.25.06)
116. at the Wall at 18:00: For those NOT in Israel join the Wall
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (06.25.06)
over the Internet - at Israeli time 18'00 hours Here the LINK For the Western Wall Cam http://www.aish.com/wallcam/
117. STUPID,STUPID JEWS
Marcel ,   Florida   (06.25.06)
You retreat and surrender for the lie of Road Map peace. You show restraint to the enemy and reward him at every opportunity while you criminalize your settler citizens .Your leaders are not just stupid but evil because they fail to defeat the Palestinians and allow them to become more and more of a threat. You allow the goyim sanke Bush to restrain you and pressure you while you and he strengthen and help the Palestinain enemy. Stupid, stupid Jews !
118. to talula and g,g
lulu ,   balata nablus   (06.25.06)
yes there is israil on the map please go to the map and plant your selfe on the wall on a map ...,,iam lulu dweekat oin the tomb here in balata is one of my grandfather YUSEF DWEEKAT I HEARED THIS FROM MY LAST GRAND FATHER AHMAD DWEEKAT
119. #111 Yes
(06.25.06)
We Jews are to blame, as we think like Jews and behave as Jews should. We need to behave like the scum we are dealing with but we find it difficult. And yes, we are also ashamed that you're jewish david. I wish you weren't. Ya sound like a wounded wallaby to me, mate.
120. 111# david
eric ,   Israel   (06.25.06)
Then you can always become a Arab,your a coward..You no nothing about the Israeli conflict,,,,,,,
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article