News
9 IDF troops killed in day of fighting
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 26.07.06, 23:23
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
178 Talkbacks for this article
31. Fools
Yisrael ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (07.26.06)
What is wrong with us ? 8 of our fathers, brothers, sons, friends, comrades die and for what ? So we can be careful about the lives of 'civilian' inhabitants who were warned away ? Send in the bombers, let no trace of this village remain. Let it be an example of our determination and let them be afraid; let them be very afraid !
32. The LIST WILL GO ON..... and ON
John ,   Greece   (07.26.06)
let me briefly state some facts: 1- Isreal can not win this war 2- This is a man to man fight, and isreali forces are not ready for that. 3- Airforce can not, totally destroy Hizbulla, therefore its usless now! 4- Hizbulla are 100% ready for these fights, and are ready to die for their land!!!! 5- Olmert, u r sacrifiying ur soldiers!!! 6- ISREALI pple wake up!!! u r loosing this war.... 7- Go into Negotiations .. this is the BEST .. since War wont solve anything... 8- PS: i know lots of pple will say i am an ANTI-JEW and blablabla.. but what i am stating is the truth... So dont use that debate ;)
33. change at the top
eltee ,   NY, USA   (07.26.06)
It is way past the time when the IDF should have mobilized sufficient soldiers to do the job right and not played this game of drip by drip warfare. Also time for that defeatist hack-jobnik Halutz to either stand down or be replaced. It seems from his statements that he is positioning himself for a position in the Meretz party when his term is done. Israel does not need a George McClellan at the helm of it's fighters. It needs a Grant, or better yet a Sherman.
34. Whoever gave the order for ground troops. RESIGN
Lemar ,   uk   (07.26.06)
Someone sitting safely in his office is responsible for the deaths of Israel soldiers. STUPID IDIOTS bomb the place. The whole world hates Jews so why worry.
35. IAF
Bulldozer ,   Hospital, Jerusalem   (07.26.06)
Attention to all those of you calling for an air war only. It does not work. A bomb, much like the katyushas landing in Israel can only damage a certain area. Furthermore, since Olmert and Co. have decided to fight a just and moral war (like such a thing ever existed) the IAF is not carpet bombing S. Lebanon back to the time of our father Abraham, the IDF must go into these decrepid villages and make sure not too shoot and the wives and children of the Hezbollah fighters and their supporters and only shoot at the scum. The problem with most of the non-religious Israelis is that they think that the IDF is a most powerful force. Wake up. It is not. The past, present and future IDF victories are open miracles and acts of the Almighty, and until the Jews of Israel realize that and put the fate of their lives and country in His hands instead of computers, airplanes and promises by US presidents, we shall unfortunately see more loss of Jewish blood. Good Luck.
36. #18 -- response to Ali
br   (07.26.06)
Everyone in Israel goes to the Army, so yes, everyone in the gov't has a son, daughter, grandchild, neice, nephew fighting in the army. so you know that we dont take this lightly.
37. why we don't use airforce
ineke ,   israel   (07.26.06)
Because the army (governement?, Peretz?) puts more value on the lives of Lebanese citizens than on the lives of our soldiers. We are afraid of what "the world" will say. Whatever we do they blame us. We might as well do what we have to do.
38. agree with bombing
meni   (07.26.06)
fire bombing, napalm etc. israel must use its advantags
39. IDF failed
ramallah ,   ramallah   (07.26.06)
they IDF used all kind of weapons , but the detemination of HDF much bigeer than the IDF . AIRFORCE GROUND FORCE NAVEFORCE ALL OF THEM = DEFEAT
40. So, are you still enjoying Olmert's Folly?
Jay ,   Los Angeles   (07.26.06)
How many lives have to be lost before Israel wakes up and ends this nonsensical war which it won't even admit is a war?
41. flatten town to the ground
Zionist ,   israel   (07.26.06)
Who cares if there are civillians living there? If they live there, they support Hizbullah, and they are terrorists themselves. Israel by now should realize that no matter what she does there will be world condemnation. If we sit back and watch as terrorists blow up buses and schools, we will be condemned for not doing enough to appease them. Go into Lebanon and do what any other nation would do - retaliate for the unjust killing of civilians. If this was the US, would America allow herself to be condemned? US dropped nuclear bombs on Japan in 1945 - world was shocked but US didnt care. Israel should not hold back and do whats necessary to protect her people.
42. Mr. Kofi Annan: Satisfied now? (I "DISLIKE" YOU!!!)
Gerd Schulz ,   Germany   (07.26.06)
43. Hezbollah are Gladiators (it's the Irony of the war)
Hani ,   Bahrain   (07.26.06)
Hezbollah fighters have lost their wives and children and land. What do you expect other than Gladiators fighting to meet their beloved ones in Heaven, after they lost everything? They will fight with the highest focus to inflect pain and if they die, they will be smiling and calling their children names. Can't beat believers in God and heaven. On the other hand you have alot to lose and you are not ready to die. The Difference is the irony.
44. No civilians?? #36
Sattouf ,   USA   (07.26.06)
SO there are no civilians in Israel!! So every target in Israel is legitimate for the resistance groups like Hamas and Hizballah!! That's great news thanks!
45. israel go ahead
africa   (07.26.06)
the war is yet beginning, i'm confident israel will win
46. IOF LOSES
Jerusalemite ,   Jerusalem   (07.26.06)
It has been proven by a very samll fighting force like HizbAllah fighters that the IOF is a very very weak army when it comes to face to face compat and the only way they can show off is through using there airforce...what an army??? full of losers...I think the time has come for Jews to leave Holly Palestine.
47. Stop being so nice
One Tough Jew   (07.26.06)
To the leaders of Israel...please, please, please; stop being so nice to worry about "civilians" who live among the terrorists and support their actions...don't sacrifice our Jewish blood in the name of world opinion. Doesn't anyone realize that us Jews are right now in the thick of a Shoah; perhaps not in the exact same ways as the last Shoah but in the thick of a Shoah nonetheless....politically and economically, and in many other ways? Most of the world wants Israel to either allow our Jewish state to be over-run by those who want to kill us or that we should disappear off the map altogether. If you use restraint and you don't cut off the head of this evil insidious terrorist organization Hezbollah and others like it in ONE FELL SWOOP it will fester and mutate and we will never enjoy true peace and freedom. I know that the IDF is the best Armed Forces in the world (in fact all countries know this) and if you have the best; be the best so that you can insure the future of Israel and the Jewish people. You can't be nice and win a war at the same time. Innocents die (although how many Lebanese are really innocent?) But, as in any common streetfight it is either you or me; and it ain't gonna be me. So it ain't gonna be Israel either...So pull out all the stops; screw world opinion; screw the UN; Kofi Annan should go to hell along with his terrorist associations; world leaders that don't want Israel to use its might because it is secretly intimidated by Jewish boldness can also go to hell. Who cares about them? Fight hard; don't hold back; and don't sacrifice Jewish blood in the name of political correctness. G-d Bless the IDF and the State of Israel.
48. Politically Correct
Barry ,   Canada   (07.26.06)
They are going to lose more brave IDF soldiers until they stop being "politically correct",and stop worrying about the media and world opinion. The civilians are obviously supporting Hezbollah,thus they are combatants.Bomb them hard,then send in the ground troops.
49. GET YOUR TERMINOLOGY IN ORDER
FAWZI ,   HOMS   (07.26.06)
your in their land ,they have the right to resist you . calling 40 % of lebaneese as terrorists shows your ignorance ,and twisted idiology . only one person can go for that ,his name is W ...historians will judge him as the worst US president for America ,the world ,and ironically for israel as well . for me peace never been further away than now . the worst part is after those live pictures we are seeing from lebanon ....you will be lucky to get even a truce .
50. A disgrace! I second the other commenters:
The Raccoon   (07.26.06)
Whoemever stayed in Bint Jbal should have been given two hours to step out in their underwear and with their hands raised. After two hours the town should have been pulverized. This is the only correct way to wage this war - we're not going to win by sacrificing our children in an attempt to appease the Israel-hating bigots in the world.
51. 43 when the shia take over arabia you'll be crying 4 saddam
(07.26.06)
52. #44
Zach ,   NYC, USA   (07.26.06)
Satouf, Lebanon likewise has universal consciption -- there are no male civilians in Lebanon by your reasoning, and they are all legitimate targets. If you are going to argue moral equivalence, at least do it properly
53. stop toying with suicidal muslims
Lirail ,   NYC, USA   (07.26.06)
IDF! Use the mighty D-9 buldozers! Enough toying with muslim terrorists! hit them hard ! let the buldozers roam South Lebanon!
54. Olmert, IDF needs to stop with the politically correct war
Dan Livni   (07.26.06)
Israelis will be killed, cause the IDF is not firing when Hizbollah uses civilians as human shields. 90 percent of the Shiites in South Lebanon support Hizbollah. Just level these buildings for goodness sake. www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?apage=2&cid=1153291993055&pagename=JPost%2FJPArticle%2FShowFull 7/26/06 The IDF was still encountering Hizbullah gunmen who were shooting from inside mosques, hospitals, and schools. "They take advantage of the population," Assulin said. "But the IDF has high moral values and does its best to avoid harming anyone uninvolved."
55. Why are the lights still on??!!!
Reality Check ,   USA   (07.26.06)
Many don't understand why Israel is fighting a WAR of survival with warnings, wasting young Israelis lives as ground troops, bombing empty buildings, and the lights still on in Beruit. If you want to win against an enemy that hides behind babies and uses children as bombs you will need to turn them into salt. NOTHING left. How many have to die first? The thousands of arab caskets will not look good on the TV, but the rockets will stop for a long time. Your enemies will hate you more for your weakness/restraint. Such a waste
56. Use de AirForce!
Esteban ,   Argentina   (07.26.06)
No more soldiers killed!
57. I am an injured soldier in hospital
Injured soldier   (07.26.06)
i ask myself and all of you, why we are doing this, the land is not ours, and will not win this war. Thankfully i was injured to get out of hell and... alive
60. IDF -- on to victory.
Stefano   (07.26.06)
Folks, don't let this news get you down. We are unaccustomed to war, so it is hard to accept such losses, but the enemies' casaulties are much greater, despite their being entrenched. IDF is doing a great job. This is not a limited operation, it is war. IDF will win. But, also true that ground units should be calling in for air support more vigorously. And that we need prayer, instead of cockiness. As for you foolish people indicating that Olmert should stop and negotiate: no, Israel must win, survival depends on it, since if not, the next time there will be 10,000 missiles that can reach TA instead of just Haifa. This enemy has shown that negotiation is seen as weakness, and peace an opportunity to arm for offense and destruction.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article