News
IDF leaves Bin Jbeil area
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 29.07.06, 17:08
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
73 Talkbacks for this article
1. kKOL HAKAVOD IDF
(07.29.06)
TO OUR HEROIC AND COURAGEOUS IDF, ON THE HOLY MISSION OF PROTECTING OUR HOMELAND, KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK!
2. one head of the hydra gone
(07.29.06)
3. Hilarious Excuses.
(07.29.06)
Who believes this B"S. Losers!!
4. VERY GOOD! I wish no more IDF soldiers killed on this war!
Proud Grandpa ,   www.KingArik.net   (07.29.06)
Please read the history of the first Lebanon War: http://www.israel-chronicles.org/lebanon1982.htm and learn why Lebanon is one place you should never send troops to!
5. Stop Lying on your People
Ahmed ,   Lebanon   (07.29.06)
Hey, why dont you show up some videos? or pictures? Come one! is that difficult?
6. Keep up the good fight IDF
daniel   (07.29.06)
7. GO IDF
catharine   (07.29.06)
Go IDF, good job!!!! We are proud of you! Finish wih the rest of those terorrists too!!!
8. New weapons
muhammad shurafa ,   detroit, michigan   (07.29.06)
this is tactical withdrawal to avoid collateral losses. Why would the Israeli's withdraw after a successful campaign. Mass destruction and killing is likely to occur now similar to what was used in Iraq.
9. Cleaning Bin Jbeil
Samy ,   France   (07.29.06)
The only way to clean Bin Jbeil is to burn all those bls hezbollah who take the poor Libanese people as hostages.........Kol hakavod le Tsahal.... We are proud of our soldiers, we are proud of our Israeli State, we are proud to be Jewish
10. Give 'em hell IDF!!!
Ron ,   USA   (07.29.06)
11. Go to this Website and ENJOY Video
Mary ,   USA   (07.29.06)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9WxQcWNHmAo
12. tsahal = VICTORY
ARIK ,   PARIS   (07.29.06)
go IDF and kick their asses, we gonna win, as we usually do. God bless our soldiers, you always do a good job. in memory of our soldiers who falled this week, French jews pray for you and for our holly land.
13. Any one have a link to the leaflets?
(07.29.06)
Just wanna see what they say Kol Hakavod IDF
14. The source of Israel aggression is the Torah
Mr Palestine ,   Palestine   (07.29.06)
Just to quote some verses (and there are many many more): Deuteronomy 2 2:33 And the LORD our God delivered him before us; and we smote him, and his sons, and all his people. 2:34 And we took all his cities at that time, and utterly destroyed the men, and the women, and the little ones, of every city, we left none to remain No wonder that jewish children grow up kill arabs (even the little ones). Torah must be banded and declared a terror manual by the UN. and jewish children should be taught the Geneva declaration of Human rights instead In the same context, similar actions should be taken against the Koran and the new testament
15. Congrats to IDF!
RA   (07.29.06)
16. Cheat
sushi ,   israel   (07.29.06)
How to believe because everytime the jews like to lie and shut up the real fact
17. NEWS FLASH
(07.29.06)
this just in: 2 fajr-5 rockets were launched toward afula friday morning. No one was hurt, but 2 cows were killed and a goat sustained moderate injuries. the idf fired on the rocket launcher, destroying it. then they had steak for dinner. hizbollah is getting desperate firing their big munitions into open fields--nice shooting you losers!! GO IDF!!!!
18. READ WHAT THE END PLAN IS FOR LEBANON
MOSHE ,   USA   (07.29.06)
WHEN THE AREA SOUTH OF THE LITANI IS CAPTURED, DROP LEAFLETS TELLING ALL RESIDENTS TO EXIT THE AREA. THEN BOMB ALL STRUCTURES. TELL LEBANESE THAT UNTIL A PEACE AGREEMENT IS MADE BETWEEN BOTH NATIONS, ISRAEL WILL DESTROY ALL ENTRANTS INTO AREA. ANY PEACE AGREEMENT WITH LEBANON SHOULD NEVER ALLOW THE LEBANESE MILITARY AND ITS ARMAMENTS SOUTH OF THE LITANI.
19. "lebanon" being returned to the desert
Arie   (07.29.06)
All the "lebanese" can say "thank you" to hezbullah!
20. To those proclaiming Israeli loss
Da dude   (07.29.06)
The real proof is quite simple. Attacks on Haifa, have literally stopped. Yes we still do get sirens, but guess what, it's more important that no missiles fall on Haifa, than 20 sirens. So the IDF is obviously telling the truth. The affects are being felt. So continue to look at the doctored images of Hizb'allah. Continue to listen to his lies and believe your lies, because as a warring party has to lie to more and more and continuely talk about how it will be victorious instead of doing that on the field, the greater the sign of defeat. So please ramble on, it just shows that Israel's victory drawing nearer.
21. Israeli Refugees demand achievement of goals!
Gal   (07.29.06)
we can not go back to the current situation where hundred of thousands of Israelies flee the northern part of ISrael. For some strange reasons, the foreign media does not cover Israel refugees, only Lebanese. Both people should demand Hizballah disarmed and removed from its occupation of Lebanon.
22. Victory is for Lebanon
T ,   ottawa   (07.29.06)
Isreal watch your forces defeated and turn their backs to where they came from in utmost disgrace. When will you understand that this lebanon is nothing like what you were against before? It will never be defeated and will never kneel!!!
23. The Lone Ranger succeeds
Shoshana ,   Nokem   (07.29.06)
Dear Israel, you are the only nation of nations brave enough to take your mighty broom and clean out the hornet's nest in the swamps. Bravo....Go Israel!
24. Congratulations!!!
Jack ,   France   (07.29.06)
Nasrallah shoud be respected by Israelis. At least he never lies and he do his promesses. This war made Hizbollah stronger and Israel ennemies increased after the massacres. Like usual Israel with its short term strategy is putting itself in a weak position. Lot of civilians paid the price of this foolish war and peace in the mid east is once again a dream. If Israel considers that killing 20 Hizbollah soldiers was a victory, do not forget that more than 600 civilians perished, and Lebanon infrastructure was destroyed instead of nutralizing Hizbollah....Congratulations....Long live Lebanon.
25. to #18 Moshe
Jack ,   France   (07.29.06)
Moshe grew up. War is not Like your "Counter Strike" video game.
26. IDF victory...
HBendor ,   New York USA   (07.29.06)
IDF victory could be total if the Israel Air Force uses NAPALM in the Hizballah concentrations and rat holes they have dug for themselves. The rest could be complemented with the paratroopers' 'FLAME THROWERS'... I also wonder why the ‘Bunker Busters’ are less effective than the 'NAPALM'?
27. Strategic objectives?
Phil ,   US   (07.29.06)
I would like to ask Prime Minister Olmet what he believed were Israel's strategic objectives in launching this attack on Hezbollah. If his strategic objectives were in killing a few hundred fighters and pounding Lebanese targets, I guess that his objectives were met. However, if his objectives were to seriously damage Hezbollah's capacity to threaten Israel with rockets and to deter other terrorists by an overwhelming show of Israeli military prowess, this campaign has been an abject failure. This politician and his inept security cabinet has allowed Hezbollah, with about 1000 fighters to stare down the mighty IDF because he and his cohorts refused to follow the recommendations of his military leaders. The rockets are still hitting Israeli cities, the kidnapped soldiers have not been returned, the tourist and other industries have suffered a grievous blow, and Israel has lost its deterrence.
28. Pyrrhic Victories and Past Mistakes
Jeremy S. Slavin ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (07.29.06)
If it turns out that Ehud Olmert did not fight this war as it should have been fought - to an actual victory, not a Pyrrhic victory (if even that is possible) - because he wanted to avoid dinner-time fights with his far left-wing wife, will it be the scandal that it should? Nasrallah said not long ago that part of the reason the world is searching for a political solution is because of the group's perseverance. He's not dumb...or wrong. If the government in Jerusalem had the political will to match the military will of the IDF to do the job right, Nasrallah wouldn't be able to say that - he'd be dead, or broken and discredited as a leader. For how much longer will we who reside in Israel be force-fed the BS that the destruction of Lebanon has truly been worthwhile, that it’s made a difference, while people still sleep in shelters in northern Israel over two weeks after all this began? Will the troops be released, or will there have to be an exchange? As an American Jew, with my citizenship here usually an afterthought, I'm ashamed to have voted for such weaklings represented by Kadima and Olmert in the last elections. If I get a chance to vote here again before returning to the States, I'll not vote so idiotically again. What we’ve seen, as Hizballah manages to still launch rockets into Israel despite “40-50% of their capabilities being hit”, as we erroneously heard earlier in the war, is the IDF – the finest military force in the Middle East – being forced to fight with one hand tied behind its back, and the other further restricted by Olmert and Peretz. God-willing, before too long, either Olmert/Peretz will fight this war as it should be fought, or the government will fall (when this is all over) and those of us who saw the error of our ways will get the chance to correct past mistakes via the ballot box. And then we’ll vote with our feet – and go back home.
29. such successful battle after which IDF left Bnt Jbeil
lebanese ,   lebanon   (07.29.06)
before we lebanese & arabs looked at previous Israel goverments with respect even we are enemies because they didn't cheat on their own people like some Arab governors... this was during Begin's, Rabin's Barak's , Sharon's cabinets who did everything war & peace both in different times for the best of their people & country (inspite of that lebanon suffered much during periods of Begin & Sharon specially)but after these 18 days analysing & seeing how Olmert,Peretz & others go on lying all these days on own citizens i would to write this maybe some Israel people who can objective look to this :most soldiers hurted by friendly fire ,3 helicopters fell down by technical problems ,F-15 in Safed burned too because of that & now they are saying that it was such a successful battle to retreat back tactically.Israel people wake up & look at this american puppet Olmert who changes his words every day 2-3 times at least , 1stly talked about 24-30kms from boarder to move Hizbollah ,after said 6km,after reduced to 2km & after stopped at all ground operations.pls in future choose better leaders whom you can believe your sons'lifes & not such PM whose both sons ran away from army & in his hands life of thousands of soldiers & citizens
30. A question!!
Ahmad Abouali ,   Nablus   (07.29.06)
if the Zionists wanted to establish a buffer Zone in South Lebanon, and after the huge "success" they had managed in Bent Jbail-Maroun El Ras-Aitaroon, why did they withdrew then?? Could it be that them who lost big time and could NOT hold one inch of Southern Lebanon? It is not the so called IDF who dish lies and fabricates truth, it is the Zionist yellow Journalism, such as Ynet, who is part of this facade called "Success"
Next talkbacks
Back to article