News
Olmert: We need 10 more days of military operations
Ronny Sofer
Published: 30.07.06, 16:57
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
73 Talkbacks for this article
31. 10 days more
marianne van geuns ,   ramat hasharon   (07.30.06)
Who start the war??!!Olmert go on Kill the Hizballa
32. IDF Video Shows Rockets Fired From Behind Building
RA   (07.30.06)
Great job IDF. The "civilians" deserve what they got.
33. TIME IS IRRELEVANT TO HEZBOLLAH WHO WILL FIGHT UNTIL DEATH
DAVID P. ,   SANTA CRUZ, USA   (07.30.06)
ISRAEL SHOULDN'T BE THE ONE'S GIVING TIME TABLES, IT'S UP TO THE TERRORISTS TO SURRENDER
34. how could any one talk about dead kids like that ?
rahbar ,   u.s.a   (07.30.06)
i dont give a 2cents about the political objective of a govermint when kids are dieing that is just inhumain, come on now what happend to compasion?,no wonder they turnd in to terorist,the jewish state dosent care about nothing i hope my country push's u in the water .(proud iranian)and u guys are fighting the wrong person! if u have ball's go to iran!try it cant say persain's hide behinde woman and childern , u guy's are just pushing up the oil price till we get our nuke's and then what ? u going to give palistine back?lol.sure! all it take's is 2 missiles and every one knows that so come to grip's with the fact that whats not your's u have to give back u all will feel better about it . go pick on some one your own size! cant your not as strong as u say u are the 70's was a long ass time ago!
35. to #25
Jo ,   USA   (07.30.06)
YOu want to meet Hizbollah head on be my guest. Join IDF and meet them face to face and stop dropping bombs on civilians. This will not get rid of Hizbollah. The last group of troops that entered Bint Jbeil is out of commission and those who surviced are receiving counseling now. When are going to understand that peace will not be forged this way. From the Arab point of view Israel is the initial aggressor (the creation of Israel itself is a big example) and unless you do something about that Arab feels it quite acceptable for them to fight you
36. Olmert
Phil ,   US   (07.30.06)
Unlike the liar who calls himself "proud Jew", I am a proud Jew who loves Israel but I am also appalled at the way Olmert's government is conducting this war. He is incompetent as a commander-in- chief as are the other members of his so-called security cabinet. They refused to accept the advice of the IDF leaders and instead are pursuing a war with no apparent tactical or strategic purpose. Everybody with an ounce of brains and a knowledge of military history and tactics know that a well-armed enemy that has had six years to build underground bunkers and to booby-trap and lay mines is going to be a tough enemy to defeat without being willing to accept casualties and to be willing to commit a large enough force to get the job done. Americans learned this all too well during the battles in the Pacific against the Japanese. Iwo Jima, a small, volcanic island was a horrific battle for the Americans because they were facing an enemy that was fanatical and well dug-in. Massive air and battleship bombardment did little to dislodge the Japanese and the Americans finally won the battle with overwhelming force and the bravery of American soldiers and marines. In this war, the Israeli soldiers are well-trained and brave but the moronic Olmert refuses to give them the force needed to finish the job. Instead, for whatever the reason, he warns the enemy of where the attacks are to occur and almost wrote the script for the killing in Lebanon. New elections are needed in Israel.
37. Too Far
honest one ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (07.30.06)
I understand Israel's concern with Hezbollah; they are terrorists and their objective is to harm Israel at any cost. This is fact. I understand why Israel felt that it needs to take this opportunity (the kidnapped soldiers) and show the Hezbollah once and for all that they can't manipulate us or get away with harming us in order to suit their agenda. Yes, Hezbollah should be destroyed, if it is possible. But not at any and all costs; not at the cost of civilian Lebanese lives or through Lebanese destruction. Israel should have thought this through more, and not just said we will go in there and bomb them all. It is a disporportionate response and it is irresponsible. Israel you are not a terrorist, you should care the most about lives of innocent people, yours or others'. You should do whatever it takes in order to protect innocent lives, even if it means that your plan has to be reconsidered. Think ahead Israel: just because you drop leaflettes does not mean that all civilians can or will escape. You do not have a right to kill those that remain behind. Israel, your reasons are justified but your means are not. I am sad, extrememly disappointed, and embaressed about the recent events in Qana.
38. Help Israel - Sign the Petition
gerd schulz ,   germany   (07.30.06)
The State of Israel is in crisis now and needs your support more than ever before. Help Israel - Sign the Petition  http://newsletters.jpost.com/ct.jsp?uz400190Biz1969042
39. What about the Nukes?
Dave Levi ,   Burbank. USA   (07.30.06)
Hezbollah hides behind the skirts of their womanfolk, and children. So, when Israel hits back, and some so-called innocents are killed (collateral damage), everyone blames it for atrocities. During WW2, we bombed Japanese and German cities back to the stone age. Millions of innocent and not so innocent civilians were killed. (Remember, every child is a potential Jihadists). Israel could have ended this thing in 1 day using just one of it's 200 plus nukes. Sharon could have ended the 2nd intifada in one day by sending in 100 tanks...he didn't. So now, Iran is close to an atomic bomb of it's own...which it will immediately use over Tel Aviv. Then what will we Jews to retaliate, go on the Internet and post misgivings?
40. when wiil the terrorists learn
antiterroist ,   telaviv Israel   (07.30.06)
an eye for an eye a tooth for a tooth
41. Listen up and listen good
John ,   NZ   (07.30.06)
The kids and women were deliberately and forcefully made to stay in that building by Hizbulla. Now that they are dead, there are no witness. Everybody knows Hizbulla do not value human life and they are sub-human. They'll play the dirtiest trick in the book. So stop whining about kids being killed. It's all a Hizbulla's set up and you stupid ppl believe it.
42. 10,000 more days !!!
aaron ,   ra'anana   (07.30.06)
43. 10 more day
(07.30.06)
what do you propose ????
44. Try a different approach
Someone ,   Tel Aviv Israel   (07.30.06)
Israel must realize that there is a better way to deal with the terrorists. If Israel met the demands of the world: withdraw from all occuppied territories and only act in RESPONSE to actions not before, go back to 1967 borders, establish a two state solution, allow Jerusalem to be the holyland for both religions (because it is)... if Israel does this and the terrorists are STILL fighting and do not halt terrorist actions against Israel, then at least Israel has done it's part, to the end, and then won't get criticized by the rest of the world. This will work in Israel's favor because then the terrorists, should they continue their actions against Israel under these conditions, would have to answer to the rest of the world and it would make their job much more difficult and their cause unjustifiable in the eyes of most of the world. This is the only way to get anywhere; this fighting causes nothing but more fighting, it does not work, it gets no one no where, everyone suffers for it. Just because the terrorists do not do their part does not mean Israel must not either. Israel should, and only then can we really deal with the terrorists like they are meant to be dealt with. Playing hardball is not the answer.
45. Israel's survival
Isac ,   Florida   (07.30.06)
why don't we hear the outcry of the Arab street about the the "courageous" Hizbollah fighters who hide between women and children and the elderly. Let them come out of their holes and fight like real men against the IDF. Israel: keep on doing the job RIGHT!!!
46. arabs
joe ,   houston,tx   (07.30.06)
keep up operations. If civilians get in the way to bad .
47. Whenever the curtain falls on Olmert's Folly,
Jay ,   Los Angeles   (07.30.06)
it will be remembered as when Israel lost any moral claim to existence.
48. Who started this
Angry Jack ,   France   (07.30.06)
I was reading all the talkbacks and some of the comments are really childish. This war was not started 19 days ago because of 2 kidnapped soldiers. Thhis war started a long time ago when Israel violated lebanese sovereinety. Israel is not fighting the reason of its instability nowadays, it is fighting the consequences. And doing so Israel are buying itslef another war for the coming years. If you want some peace just be less arrogant in the future... if you keep it this way maybe god (if he really exists) will take the promessed land from you... don't try to find a tent to stay in in Lebanon, you'r not welcome...anymore.
49. Eye-witness: heard TWO explosions
SECONDARY EXPLOSION ,   OF KATYUSHAS   (07.30.06)
The eye witness to the bombing in Qana said in the report transmitted by SKY News this evening that he "HEARD TWO EXPLOSIONS". That means there was a SECONDARY EXPLOSION of Hizbullah MUNITIONS stored at this house after the initial air strike.
50. This is Existential, TAKE what you need
Paqid 16, Netzarim ,   Ra'anana, Israel   (07.30.06)
The soldiers in the IDF are giving everything and they are getting the job done. PM Olmert, it's on you now; you and your generals and cabinet may give NO less! Don't let the soldiers, and Israel, down. You asked for the job. So do it. Paqid Yirmeyahu Israeli Orthodox Jew Advancing Logic as Halakhic Authority Welcoming non-Jews www.netzarim.co.il
51. to #36
antiterrorist ,   tel aviv Israel   (07.30.06)
I get so annoyed with fellow Jewish people who feel they have a right to judge Israels actions. Come and live here and see what fear we have each day. Oh its easier to sit from a far in your nicwe big homes isnt it! Has the world forgotten just over a week ago there was a female suicide bomber and 2 friends caught in the port of Tel Aviv where there are many resturants and cafes, usually full of tourists. As most of us "oleh hadishim" to not have the means to splurge because of the situation here! by the way will you come here before the elections or on the day to vote!!!!!
52. When they learn
Moshe ,   Boston, Mass   (07.30.06)
The unfortunate truth is in inability of Arabs to understand language of peace. They flooded Eretz Yisroel to rip the fruit of Zionist labour and next thing you know they start killing the Jews in Hevron etc. They submitted to the Nazis, the Soviets, had tried and keep trying on and on to wipe Israel from the face of the earth. I dare say they will not learn. And what one does with the enemy who does not want peace but want to have you murdered? Give him peace??? Actually...yes. A quiet one.
53. #35 ISRAEL WON'T DECONSTRUCT ITSELF TO APPEASE ARAB GRIPES
DAVID P. ,   SANTA CRUZ, USA   (07.30.06)
YOU TALK AS IF ISRAELI'S SHOULDN'T FIGHT BACK, THAT THEY SHOULD ACCEPT THE TERMS OF THE MAJORITY IN THE MIDDLE EAST WHICH WOULD ASSUME ISRAEL BE WIPED OFF THE MAP, SOLUTIONS AREN'T ALWAYS IMMEDIATELY FORGED, SOMETIMES THEY'RE FOUGHT OUT, LET THEM FIGHT
54. To 48
Shai ,   Israel   (07.30.06)
Angry Jack, you are proof that ignorance has no limits. The Unitied Nations certified that Israel pulled out of Lebanon. It does not, and has not for 6 years, occupy any part of Lebanon. In return for that pull out, the UN issued a quid pro quo - the UNSCR 1559 calling for Lebanon's army to take positions in South Lebanon, displace and disarm all non Lebanese Army militias, including Hizbollah. From that day when Israel pulled out, the clock began ticking again. What happened before is no more relevant to our conflict than the Pearl Harbor Invasion is to the US's relationship with Japan. If there are consequences from not fulfilling the terms of 1559, and these include bombings and kidnappings acrossed the border with Lebanon into Israel, which was one invasion two many about 3 weeks ago, it is caused by Lebanon and its cowardly refusal to bring peace to south Lebanon by disarming HIzbollah and kicking Syria and Iran out of their country. You have nothing to advise Jews about arrogance, Frenchman, nor about promised Land, nor about what G-d says to us. You are best advised to blame your treasonous country for coddling these Shiite terrorists rather than nipping them in the bud.
55. To 47
Shai ,   Israel   (07.30.06)
Sorry we couldn't be your baby Jesus for the day, Jay, but we don't need your moral claim for existence. We exist. Deal with it.
56. will it end?
misagian ,   beirut   (07.30.06)
i'm armenian lebanese and i like to see hezbollah disarmed.but is this the way. can anybody answer me please how long will this go on???this hatred and killing and never ending wars.it looks like it's eternal.hezbollah are playing it dirty and this is expected from them because they are militias.believe me more than half of the lebanese people don't back them.this war won't lead to anything but kill the innocence on both ends.
57. SVAGAE, BARBARIC STATE...ISRAEL
KOHEN ,   ASHKELO   (07.30.06)
I'M SO SURPRISED OF SAVAGE ISRAEL WHICH DESTROY ALL HUMANTIRIAN MEANS....IT IS BARBARIC STATE.
58. To #54--Shai
Joe ,   Canada   (07.30.06)
Israel pulled out of Southern Lebanon in 2000 but was conducting almost daily flyovers, violating sovereign Lebanese airspace. Are these not "declarations of war"?
59. oh boo hoo
Ari ,   ny   (07.30.06)
go ahead arabs whine and complain. Hide with the children and in the mosques. you will still lose despite your cheap tricks. Israel will not be deterred by you or your europeean sympathizers. And the US and more importantly G-d will be with the Jews
60. Hezbollah uses civilians as human shields.
Roberto Gutierrez ,   Madrid, Spain   (07.30.06)
This is the truth. Israel cannot stop defending itself, although Lebanese civilians are used as human shields by Hezbollah. The same thing happens in Gaza, with Palestinian civilians used by Hamas as human shields. All those islamofascists know well the old trick. All my solidarity and support for Israel from Spain: your democracy is my democracy, your freedom is my freedom.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article