News
Peretz: No pilot ordered to fire at civilians
Ilan Marciano
Published: 31.07.06, 12:10
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
63 Talkbacks for this article
31. #20
Rickmd ,   Baltimore, USA   (07.31.06)
The pictures were terrible. But I have to agree with you. I am not a medical examiner but there are physical processes that are impossible to stop. It appeared that the bodies were from earlier time. Did they empty a cemetary?
32. Qana Massacre a Lie - but a great Photo Op
Nannette ,   London, UK   (07.31.06)
These photos show the cynical manipulation of Hizbollah. Recycling the same bodies for hours... http://eureferendum.blogspot.com/2006/07/milking-it.html Of course there was loss of life at Qana, but mainly due to Hizbollah munitions blowing up! A very curious photo at NY Times http://graphics8.nytimes.com/images/2006/07/30/world/30qana6_650.jpg Notice that the ceiling is completely intact. Doesn't seem to fit with the rubble below it, nor with the body. BTW - is the body in a state of rigor mortis? I refer specifically to the hands.
33. Peretz said:
Schulz ,   Berlin   (07.31.06)
But terror does not rest for a moment. This is a war forced on us after we did everything to prevent it. We can't continue a policy of shutting our eyes and a double standard differentiating between sovereignty and responsibility," the defense minister declared. It is easy to understand!
34. killing children and blaming others
lebanon   (07.31.06)
killing children and blaming others wow???? u blame everyone for being anti zionist but what are u anti-world??? racism and hatered this is what Israel is good 4. what u did in qana 96 and qana 2006 is not better than Auchwiss u consider non jewish lives unworthy to live I am Christian a believer in God's justice...Only HE knows what u deserve.
35. #17 White from ex-Afula
Rustum ,   London, UK   (07.31.06)
Your rabid comments, that Arabs "have no right to sit in the knesset" is the worst form of racist crapola . You would wish to change the laws of the state at a whim, because of your intense dislike of hearing the truth from opposition members of the Knesset. You will end up with a Knesset with one party which speaks only the words which you and other freak racist war mongers want to hear. As it is you are cut off from world opinion - as your media lie to you day in day out and the feeble "hasbara" attempt to explain away the Qana massacre has cut no ice with anyone outisde Israel, and the small Bush/Blair coterie. With your intense dislike of Arabs, expressed so many times in your fetid posts here, I'm surprised that you made "aliya" to the country before it was 100% ethnically cleansed. On a positive note, perhaps Afula will be in need of new architects soon.
36. #10 Hungary. Jó napot, asszony/ úr ...(?)! - Szabad a nevét?
gerd schulz ,   germany   (07.31.06)
(What's your name?) Legyen szives megmondani...: Magyar Hirlap? Something trustworthy like that? Nem! Köszönöm szépen! Minden jót!
37. Talula's double standards
Rustum ,   London, UK   (07.31.06)
how you sleep at night is a question I cannot answer. Your constant and rabid diatribes of joy at Arab deaths really does show that you celebrate the deaths of Arabs much more than you celebrate the life of Israeli children. Not a word out of you about the horrendous carnage and massacre at Qana - just a pathetic blip along the lines "but Hezbullah shoot at civilians". Your great and wonderful air force, in a great show of cowardice, pushed the button which killed 60 innocent people - and you cannot even utter a word of regret about it. I doubt if the "2 million" residents of northern Israel will ever be able to sleep easy in their beds after this.
38. heartless
(07.31.06)
how can u c children dying and still talk like that... nothing surpasses children lives Those who support or find excuses for what happened in Qana are just as guilty as those who shot and gave order to shoot May God help you cause u will really need His Mercy
39. #32 Nannette what do u want 2 prove
lebanese lady ,   Lebanon   (07.31.06)
This is filthy... How can u undermean children lives? Qana a lie? Ok...The children in the photos are dead aren't they? May i remind you that we have 800 civilians dead 450 of them children. U should be ashamed of yourself hope your children are in a safe place watching TV not waiting for the merci of Israeli Air Force to stop bombarding them and stop bombarding ambulances rescuing them or their cars. This is just filthy unhuman what has the world turned to? people supporting that are the real terrorists.
40. Video tape from FOXnews, Hizbollah fires rockets from
Pavel ,   Jerusalem,Israel   (07.31.06)
the building in Kfar-Qana. This is the proof that Hizbollah doesn't care of Lebanese people. A question to Y-net, why this kind of videos are not posted in ynet hebrew and english site, and we, Israel citizens shall read the news from foreign news sites ? http://www.foxnews.com/video2/player05.html?073006/073006_world_wilson&Weekend_Live&Video%20of%20Hezbollah%20Attack%3F&acc&World&-1&new - watch this.
41. another trap in edaiseh _kfar kila
burg ,   ta/israel   (07.31.06)
1-more 5 tanks were destroyed 2-2 humee were damaged completly 3-2 d_nine 4-dozens of idf were killed after this results , what have we said to idf more than a weak army , just killing children and civilians
42. 34 lebanon : Your own lies are starting to smell
Gabrielle Goldwater ,   Geneva Switzerland   (07.31.06)
http://www.news.com.au/heraldsun/story/0,,19955774-5007220,00.html <<< Go to Link to see the moving photo line up Photos that damn Hezbollah HEZBOLLAH IS RESPONSIBLE FOR THE MASSACRE WORLD COUNCIL OF THE CEDARS REVOLUTION www.cedarsrevolution.org July 30: Incident in Qana - IDF Spokesman video of Hizbullah firing rockets from behind buildings http://www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Pages/MediaPlayer.aspx?MediaUrl=/NR/rdonlyres/B883D7F6-FF7B-4E46-A639-643ED03F477E/0/FiringBehindBuilding.wmv&LANGUAGE_NAME=En Lebanon Myth and Facts http://www.aish.com/jewishissues/middleeast/Lebanon_Myths_and_Facts.asp Zak Anani was on Fox News last week and if any one missed it here it is http://www.terrorfreeoil.org/videos/ZA071506.php FACTS: Open letter to Olmert from the Lebanese Foundation for Peace. http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Support_Israel/message/16217;_ylc=X3oDMTJydXNmNnUwBF9TAzk3MzU5NzE1BGdycElkAzI1ODEyMzUEZ3Jwc3BJZAMxNjAxMTQ0Nzc3BG1zZ0lkAzE2MjE3BHNlYwNkbXNnBHNsawN2bXNnBHN0aW1lAzExNTI5MzgzODE- More facts: http://www.free-lebanon.com/ More facts from Brigitte Gabriel A Lebanese http://www.americancongressfortruth.com/ Arabs for Israel http://www.arabsforisrael.com/ UN and Hezbollah are working together - Photo of Kofi Annan in Beirut June 2000 thanking Nasrallah, http://www.israel-wat.com/kofi.jpg Who undermined Lebanon's Sovereignty? Here is another reason to love the UN and Kofi Annan! WORTH A LOOK!........ Who undermined Lebanon's Sovereignty? You got it ! United Nations Secretary-General Kofi Annan In the picture (in above link) taken in Beirut in 2000, Kofi Annan is thanking Nasrallah, head of the terror group Hezbollah for Maintaining law and order in the south of Lebanon. So, in 2000 Kofi Annan acknowledged that the terror group Hezbollah was responsible for Maintaining law and order in southern Lebanon, but it is now ISRAEL which is undermining the country's sovereignty? Source: Al-Ahram, Weekly On-line, Issue 487, 22-18 June 2000 Is Islam going to Kill Her too http://switch5.castup.net/frames/20041020_MemriTV_Popup/video_480x360.asp?ai=214&ar=1050wmv&ak=null
43. Israel and civilian
Wise Man ,   USA   (07.31.06)
For the last 60 years and in every war with Israel one thing was always the same. Target and masacre incocent civilian. It is part of the Israeli stratgy and the Israeli way of doing things. You always did and enjoy killing kids and women and that is the truth.
44. #13
matan ,   netanya   (07.31.06)
do you think thay god loves killing of the children....you are killer too...israel kills children and god hates it...
45. israel is a barbaric state
NANCY ,   AFULA   (07.31.06)
yes , killing children , women is a kind of barbaric action...olmert is cheap killer get his income from USA HE IS STUPID PM, MURDERER , WAR CRIME , TRIAL HIM
46. 37 - no double standards, I just care about my own more
Talula ,   Israel   (07.31.06)
Your attempt at a chilling talkback does nothing for me. 9 soldiers were killed here last week, my heart is with their families and not with the Lebanese. Those people from Qana were told to get out, they paid the price for not doing so. War is ugly, no-one said it's a picnic. By the way, maybe you are interested in this: http://www.newsoftheworld.co.uk/ makes a good read.
47. How long will we harbor traitors?
The Raccoon   (07.31.06)
Why do we have terrorist supporters in the Knesset? This is not democracy - this is suicide! Deport the traitors NOW!
48. THE WHOLE WORLD DONT LIKE JEWS !
JERRY ,   BROOKLYN NY USA   (07.31.06)
WHEN THE PALESTINIAN BLOWS THEM SELF IN ISRAEL AND KILLS INOCENTS PEOPLE THE WHOLE WORLD DONT REACT......OR WHEN THE HIZBOLLAH KILLS CIVILIANS IN ISRAEL THE WHOLE WORLD LOOKS ONLY TO ISRAEL MASSACRE INSIDE LEBANON ! THE LEBANIESE GOVERNEMENT SHOULD OFF WATCH THE HIZBOLLAH TO PROTECT THE POOR LEBANESE CIVILIANS THAT SUFFERS NOW.....INSTEAD TO LETTING THE HIZBOLLAH BUILD A MONSTER MACHINE AGAINST THERE OWN CIVILIANS ! MR PRIME MINISTER OR LEBANON STOP ! THE TERRORIST AND THE DRUG TRAFICKING FROM YOUR COUNTRY AND PROTECT YOUR PEOPLE RATHER ! YOU ARE NOT A MAN .....TELLING THE HIZBOLLAH ON TOP OF THIS THANK YOU ! WHAT KIND OF PRIME MINISTER ARE YOU ?????? DRUG KINGLORD ????OR STUPID ????? LOOK AT YOUR NATION ...NEVER STRONG ??? WHY ??????
49. running against terror organisation!!!????
Lebanon ,   Lebanon   (07.31.06)
Hey Peretz do you really consider yourself that you are running against terror organisation. Are you kidding your people. Give the whole world a break, do you consider yourself that you were forced to the war by the lebanese organisation or by the USA. please explain yourself to your people. Do not let them behave as blind and stupid when they start talking about what it's happenning in their country. By the way, every body knows now, who is the most terrorist organisation in this world.It is 200% YOU israelis, CHILD KILLERS. There is only one explanation for your way of fighting in Lebanon: your are going crasy and bombing every thing because you did not reach what exactly you want from Lebanon, you are really loosers, and even you are not talking any more about your prisonners, loosers. You are trying to explain that you hit Qana and you killed women and children because you think that the lebanese organisation hits israel from there. Do you still have a doubt after 20 days of fighting and you are still not sure if the lebanese organisation has positions between civilians. You are really a good army, loosers. Be realistic, it is Ok every one knows that you are loosing the war and you will, every one knows now who is the terrorist, every israeli knows now that they are sending theirs sons to the land of death, do a favour for your people and send your sons and daughters to this north. Stop going like crasy, in life there is winners and loosers. So it is Ok you have to be realistic and stop having more killed SOLDIERS between YOU.
50. #39 lebanese lady
Nannette ,   London, UK   (07.31.06)
Yes, the truth is filthy, like Hizbollah who are cynically exploiting the dead children for photo ops.
51. #5, denying reality gets you nowhere...
DR ,   Florida, USA   (07.31.06)
There is video proof , which we have seen on tv here in the states that shows Katuyushas being launched from Qana. Hezballah knows there are civilians there and still uses their village to fire rockets into Israel. This is what we call "Human Shields". Get iot now???
52. Enough is enough with the Arab MKs
Rafi ,   Ra'anana   (07.31.06)
The Israeli Arab MKs have been expressing their loyalty and support for the Palestinians and for the Arab countries during whatever conflict Israel had with them. Their voices and condemnation have never ever been heard when Jewish people were the victims (of terrorist attacks etc.). Enough is enough, the Arab MKs should be deported either to the Palestinian territory or to Lebanon and the sooner the better. We are sick and tired of them.
53. #37 Rustum and #43 wise man...
DR ,   Florida, USA   (07.31.06)
You two always try to take the high moral ground in these posts, but you fail to state facts. You only repeat the same line over and over, even though we all know it's not true. Why don't you mention the fact that Hezballah launches rockets from Qana before ISrael bombed it??? Why don't you condemn them for starting this whole conflict.??? They put Lebanon in this position, not Israel. You need to get real and stop regurgitating the same bullshit we always see from you. You show nothing but ignorance with your posts and it makes you look stupid, not wise.
54. to #43
Pavel ,   Jerusalem,Israel   (07.31.06)
Fortunatelly this is mostly YOURS DISTORTED TRUTH, no more than this...
55. #32 nanette's hateful insinuation
Rustum ,   London, UK   (07.31.06)
It seems that you live in a world of cynical paranoia. Every news station in the world reports the results of an Israeli bomb on a civilian building and the ensuing almost 60 deaths of mainly women and children. You, on the other hand, express not one white of regret and insinuate that this is some example of what the foul racists call "Palywood". You should be ashamed of yourself for having lost your humanity completely and become a very good Zionist - not only do you not care about the deaths of non-Jews in the Middle East, you do not believe they happen. Alice in Wonderland revisited, methinks.
56. #46 Talula and the News of the World
Rustum ,   London, UK   (07.31.06)
So what? What has the News of the World article about that guy got to do with anything? Are you trying to imply that the IDF should press more buttons and send more "smart" bombs to kill more Lebanese woman and children because an idiot religious Moslem in Britain has child porn on his computer. I would suggest that you go and examine the PCs of the members of your Haredi community and put your own house in order. Directing me to the News of the World tells me two things: the quality of newspapers that you read leaves much to be desired; the quality of your brain functioning leaves much to be desired. How does it feel to have lost your humanity?
57. #52 Rafi's idiocy
Rustum ,   London, UK   (07.31.06)
So you want to deport the Arab MKs to the Palestinian territories or to Lebanon. I presume you believe that you live in a country run along the rule of law - but you are advocating either an anarchic country where the racist morons on the street (viz. you) can state what the police should and can do - as opposed to being government by the rule of law or a country which is a pure dictatorship where people are deported according to the criterion of whom Rafi of Ra'anana likes at any given moment. The type of country you are advocating has very strong resemblences to the 1930s fascist states of Europe - and the 1950s Stalinist states - but perhaps you have never read Kafka - perhaps you have read nothing about South Africa - perhaps one day the state will decide that you are genetically Arab and deport you with no right of appeal - and I wonder who would be screaming then. The way you racist Israelis respond to the Arab MKs is atrocious. You simply cannot bear to have in your "parliament" an opposition that voices the opinions of the oppressed minority within your country. So you want to chuck them out. Then you will say that any opposing international opinion is based on anti-Semitism and you won't listen to it. In the end, you'll end up as isolated as North Korea with Zionism being some perverted version of Jung-che or whateveer the north Koreans call their ideology. This racist sickness within Israel must come to an end. It is short sighted and bears the seeds of your own destruction since you refuse to learn from history.
58. Hizbullah recruites - 7 year old children
(07.31.06)
Yes, they scream about the children dying yesterday. Makes you wonder why when they recruite 7 year old children, strap a bomb around them and parade them in the streets. No wonder no-one feels that sorry for them.
59. 56 Dunno, I didn't loose it.
Talula ,   Israel   (07.31.06)
It's still in tact. What would the mighty Allah say to child porn? tze tze tze. Talking of putting YOUR OWN HOUSE IN ORDER.... You are such a sad person, you really are.
60. #59 Talula's sadness
Rustum ,   London, UK   (07.31.06)
Sad? Why should I be sad? Because of the deaths of hundreds of Lebanese civilians and the destruction of the infrastructure of that utterly beautiful country with its complex traditions, fantastic food, wonderful musical traditions and literary and artistic heritage - which you and your latter-day horde of Mongols are turning into dust? Should that make me sad? It certainly doesn't make you sad - since you have stated that you can only feel for your own ethnic group - something which has been obvious from your string of recent posts. The big mistake you make from your rat hole in Emeq ha-satan or somewhere similar, if that you think one moron Moslem in the UK who had child porn on his pc represents the worldwide Umma. I don't think you would for one second imagine that the Haredi moron who shook his child to death in Jerusalem represents Judaism or that he shook his child to death with the sanction of the Beth Din. But it's okay for you to make grotesque generalisations about Moslems because you hate and despise them. Your very words drip with contempt "what would the mighty Allah say" - as do the words of many of the posters here. If people wrote about Judaism the same way as many of you referred to Islam - the computer screens would melt from the heat of your accusation of anti-Semitism. It is quite obvious that many, many of the settlers in Palestine - you being one of them, since no indigenous Israeli has such a low level of culture to read the News of the World and think it is a newspaper - many of the settlers seeth with contempt and hatred for the people whose land they have stolen. It's so sad - and there's really no solution to your pent-up contempt and hatred for the non-Jewish world except for you to shelter many years longer in your bunkers. You could of course become a society based on equality and the rule of law and respect for property rights.. in which case it might all be different. However, I suspect "auntie Talula" is going to be baking lekach for her cannon-fodder "brave soldiers" until the end of her sad racist days.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article