News
15 reservists killed in Lebanon battles
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 10.08.06, 22:03
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
218 Talkbacks for this article
31. Merkava tank weakness
Nikos ,   Athens, Greece   (08.10.06)
Hesbollah has russian-made rockets that pierce Merkava tank armour and expode inside. IDF should not use Merkavas as they are now. They need to do something to their armor or abandon them altogether. Regarding military casualities from Hezbollah rockes, it appears that they have much higher success rate targeting IDF military groups than vililian ones in Haifa. News of 15 troops killed is a greater hit to Israel morale than 100 rockets landing on empty field near Haifa. Plus, killing military personnel is not a war crime. I suggest Hesbollah switch to IDF reservists and abandond civilian targets altogether.
32. trap
neny ,   frankfurt/germany   (08.10.06)
I can't believe that the Israeli Government is so stupid to enter the Hizbullah trap. The IDF is now exactly where Nasrallah wants them to be- deep inside Lebanon. When the Americans cannot win in Iraq ( flat desert country ) how should the Israelis win in the mountains and forests of Lebanon?? The guerillas are behind every bush, behind every rock and deep in the forest. Fresh weapons are supplied over the Syrian border even on donkeys and the first volunteers from other muslim countries have arrived as well. This will turn into an Israeli Vietnam. I think the IDF should fight just from the air, the lives of the young IDF soldiers shouldn't be thrown away in this mess. I pray for them.
33. NO PAIN.. NO GAIN..ITS A WAR
ken ,   california   (08.10.06)
no pain- no gain, no scarifices no achievments, but nazi-allah and hiz bo-ass are going doing for real
34. Let Olmert and Peretz go with their families to fight
Bob   (08.10.06)
This time they went too far they are thinking of elections not for the people and the families of the soldiers my opinion the Lebanese gvt points will be a win to both countries and the beginning of a new peace process which we all hope for.... Let Olmert and Peretz send their families to the south of Lebanon Nasrallah already sent his son and he died u see now the difference of it 1 guy is fighting for as a defense now 2 others are fighting for elections or maybe to please the most idiot president in the world BUSH. Hope peace will come soon coz it is really sad all these killings
35. Baruch Dayan Emet
AJ ,   Tel Aviv   (08.10.06)
Z"L May Hashem watch over all soldiers of TZAHA"L and our security forces, on the land, at sea and in the air. May Hashem give our leaders wisdom, vision and fortitude to guide us through this time. May Israel be blessed with peace, prosperity and strength.
36. Peace of the equals...or more of the same.
Tunisian   (08.10.06)
37. biased media
lex ,   Oslo   (08.10.06)
The Truth is the first casualty of any war. we see it again now during the lebanon campaign where international (and national) media in our (peaceloving?) western countries continue to bring the sensational stories portraying the blood of individuals (kids if they can) instead of discussing the real issue; why didn't we all take part in stopping terror to spread in south lebanon? is israel to blame after having pulled out years ago, but still being able to enjoy a single day of peace as long as iran is allowed to run its proxy war through lebanon? its about time- actually long over-due, that we all take responsibility and make lebanon able to control its own territory. if oslo were hit by swedish missiles we'd be all over stockholm with our jets too..
38. To Arabs: Hezb lost 40+ today, so dont be too happy
RA   (08.10.06)
Plus some Iranians
39. #27-I Agree 100% Trophy should be installed on Merkavas now!
RA   (08.10.06)
And I really hope the government is taking the Northrop laser system seriously. If that and Trophy had been implemented, the majority of the deaths among soldiers and civilians would have been avoided.
40. Sharon
Libneniyye ,   Lebanon   (08.10.06)
You mean where is ayrak sharon? He's burning in hell, waiting for Olmert.
41. easy solution
Fares ,   Cleveland   (08.10.06)
the lebaneese army should go in the south armed with a deterrent power ..ie ..apache helicopter and F-16s and night vision gogles ...etc .. it is all in the equipements those days . ya ..the lebaneese army is weak because he is not allowed to be armed and equipped properly .
42. What a tragedy
Patricia ,   Hawaii, USA   (08.10.06)
This happens in a war, young men lose their lives and it is a very sad thing. This has happened to us too. But the Israeli spirit will persist and I know the israeli's are strong and have a deep survival instinct. This just tells you that you need to be strong, support one another and don't give into defeatism. It is a loss, not the final outcome. I am disappointed, though, that the gloves are still on. War is bad stuff, bad things happen and Israel is there alone fighting for us, I hope the US is sending the needed military equipment. That seems to be all our govt will do at this time. I really regret the Iraq involvement, we should be able to support you with marines. I would respond to the muslim jerks making their usual propaganda and baiting statements, but they do not deserve the time spent on them. I personally think they should be not be permitted to spread their hate and name calling when you confront them in a Israeli newspaper. Those people who offer a different point of view, that Israel should get out of this war are different and a lot of them, because their opinions are not offensive just a little frustrating are a different story. That is what a democracy is about. Keep up the good work Israeli's the outcome is known to all of us. Your brave soldiers will prevail.
43. To Proud Grandpa
Olmert   (08.10.06)
Shut-Up you old fool. This is my war for glory. If "He" made King, I will be Emperor
44. God Bless the Fallen Heroes
Gus ,   Atlanta, GA   (08.10.06)
I am sorry for the death and suffering, but that is part of war. I cannot believe Israel is not raining hell on Syria and Iran who have been the conduit to Hezbollah for these Russian anti-tank missiles--which have claimed a majority of the IDF deaths in this war to date. When all is said and done, IDF Armor units will have to develop new tactics to counter this threat. In the meantime, hang tough and wipe out the bad guys.
45. WAR AGAINST HEZZBOLAH
meir ,   new york   (08.10.06)
THE ONLY WAY TO ACHEIVE PEACE IS WITH THE ABSOLUTE REMOVAL OF TERROR
46. Add 2 - no, 10 - no, 15 more to the price of Olmert's Folly
Jay ,   Los Angeles   (08.10.06)
This is my most-repeated subject. What does that tell you?
47. Let the French rave
Avraham   (08.10.06)
I'd love to see the frenchies under daily missile fire from Germany or Spain. I bet they'd invade wherever they have to to eliminate the missile threat. It was nice to see Olmert tell them and the Europeans to shut up and then give the Yugoslovia example.
48. Eye for Eye
Hassan   (08.10.06)
This is for Qana.
49. 15 dead in one day!!!!!!!
ex proud of IDF ,   NY , USA   (08.10.06)
I cannot believe what's going on in south of Lebanon...the elite troops are crushed by few dozens of terrorists!!??omg I can immagine the IDF heros crying like women while fleeing from the battlefield...lol this is pathetic.
50. Israelis time to emigrate thanks to Olmert
Lemar ,   UK   (08.10.06)
Israel will be destroyed because the Muslims now know that an attack on Tel Aviv will bring the capitulation of Israel. Olmert has shown them we are inefective. Remember the Muslims dont think like us, any sign of victory brings them to do reckless things. EMIGRATE NOW
51. Pressure
Fabrizio ,   Italy   (08.10.06)
it seems IDF is sending brainless soldiers to fight (themself) in lebanon, if not who will accept to go there? you better go home.
52. Re#2
Ron   (08.10.06)
Hey baby,your guys will fly like cowards from there ,I hope U still remember 2000 withdrawal. Your physical strength will never ever beats the belief strength of these guys.U guys fight for lie s while they fight for true cause. Have fun...
53. IDF Soldiers
Josh ,   Detroit, Michigan   (08.10.06)
How many soldiers must die before Israel replace their poltical leadership with those that know how to fight a war?
54. Did you hear the latest
Truth hurts   (08.10.06)
Your loosing, but I nor any intelligent, realistic and honest person needs to tell you that!!! TRUTH HURTS
55. maybe now olmert/peretz/halutz will WAKE UP
aaron ,   ra'anana   (08.10.06)
lebanese civilian casualties and bad press headlines are unpleasant but collateral damage will occur. if you want to win the war you have to want to win the war and then take steps to win the war. firing on all moving vehicles south of litani is a start. the next step would be completely terminating all electricity in lebanon and cellular communications - this will hamper the enemies ability to communicate and fight. a further step would be the destruction of all buildings near where the enemy is located in an effort to deny him shelter and cover. A third step would be the destruction of the enemy's capital city, thus removing the command and control elements. does olmert have the will to win? somehow i doubt it.
56. i fail to understand hezbollah supporters
eugene ,   israel   (08.10.06)
hezbollah is the reason why lebanon is crumbling right now..it could be stopped if seniora accepted the us-french draft but he was either too scared or too dumb. hezbollah will be destroyed or at least heavily crippled this month ..what have you gained from your support ?
57. Get the hell out Guy from Nablus!!!
katy ,   l.r. ark   (08.10.06)
You don't sound American, so get the hell out of our country you ##### Terrorist A hole!
58. To Hannah
Libneniyyeh ,   Lebanon   (08.10.06)
Oh Hannah Im so touched your heart has been broken. Never knew you had one. It's admirable how "honest" the Israelis really are. Al-Jazeerah posted this news HOURS ago.
59. Remember Iraq is a flat country
Kazimi ,   TO, Canada   (08.10.06)
To all those who are screaming through their typed words to flatten S. Lebanon by carpet bombing, remember that Iraq is a marren flat country and still the Americans are unable to finish-off the resistance there - for the last 3 years! Also remember that the Americans bombed out Vietnam jungles and when they sent their ground troops there they went straight to their deaths. You can't win like this.
60. # 2 LIRAL THE COWARD
SHAI ,   TA   (08.10.06)
ITS EASY FOR YOU, COWARD "AMERICAN JEW" TO SAY THAT WHILE HIDING IN NYC. WE ARE THE ONES PAYING - WITH LIFE - IN THIS WAR WHILE THE LIKES OF YOU JEWS IN AMERICA THINK THAT BY DONATING SOME MONEY YOU PERFORMED THE ULTIMATE SERVICE TO ISRAEL. SHUT THE FUCK UP AND WE NEED NO ADVICE FROM YOU.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article