Opinion  Soapbox
‘Never again’ or ‘Here we go again’?
Jonathan Pearl
Published: 18.08.06, 23:22
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
79 Talkbacks for this article
31. Check this out for some background
Adam ,   San Francisco   (08.19.06)
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=9071731896689197790&hl=en
32. Jonathan Pearl serves up more ziocrap
American Jihadist ,   Dearborn,MI. USA   (08.19.06)
"The Middle East 'conflict' boils down to this guiding principle: Jewish/Israeli lives are simply worth less than Muslim/Arab lives" writes Pearl. This statement is profound because it summarizes U.S. public opinion. If antisemitism is a sickness,Rabbi pearl is the disease. His essay is more Jew good/Arab bad bullshit. The Rabbi blasts out more of the same old zionist tripe. If he were as smart as he thinks he is, he would shut up. Israel is considered to be a major liability here. Further funding and military support is very unpopular,contrary to what the zionist controlled U.S. media says. It is election time here and the insane Israel firsters are running for cover. As Americans reflect on Israels double standards, false flag mass murders, Spy scandals,and the billions in aid, you are way out of favor. So Rabbi Johnny ,SHUT UP.
33. Very Good Artical
Jewish American ,   USA   (08.19.06)
I don't think anyone could even attempt to rebuke this artical.
34. Jonathan Pearl
Michael ,   USA   (08.19.06)
In the west and the Israeli public, Palestinians Muslims and Christians lives are worth less than Israeli lives. If the Israelis stop conducting massacres in Palestine, the Muslim and Christian world will learn to accept Israelis as people too. Michael
35. Practicing Rabbi?
M.Murad ,   London, UK   (08.19.06)
"Because some Muslim/Arab civilians might inadvertently be killed." Such a callous disregard for human life, from a man of religion no less? If thats a rabbis view on human life then what is a Jewish soldiers? Mr Pearl wonders why the world asks for restrain from Israel? Try looking at a balance sheet of Arab to Israeli lives lost in the last decade or 2 or even 3. The world knows that even when asked for restraint Israel has complete disregard for human life. And when not restrained, as we recently found out, it looks for and targets innocent children.
36. The problem is you don't milk the deaths for propaganda
Adamush   (08.18.06)
Keep some dead children ready in the local morgue and every time a rocket hits, scatter the bodies amongst the rubble and pay some old women to over-act her grief in front of the cameras.
37. THE COUNTRY WHICH ALLOWS SUCH PEOPLE TO WRITE IN MEDIA WILL
Lebanese ,   Lebanon   (08.19.06)
BE DEFEATED. jonathan pearl is a DUMB when he compares the killing of 1250 civilians in Lebanon to killing of 40 civilians in israel,at the time when Hizbollah captured 2 IDF solriers to exchange them for Lebanese prisoners ,IAF started bombing civilians in Lebanon & only after that Hizbollah started to bomb israel towns trying its best not to hurt civilians ,you have to do smth. with your memory or with your brain which is more difficult
38. One israeli live = 1000/37 = 27 lebaneses lives. Cheap ? End
Alex Jacob ,   France   (08.19.06)
39. Spot on Rabbi
Stephen Duke ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (08.19.06)
This article might seem a little simplistic but at root the point made is accurate. European hypocrites purporting to speak in the name of justice and fairness continue with their centuries old practice of deeming Jewish lives to be at best worthless. Israel has the disadvantage of being much stronger than its enemies which means that any time we are attacked there is much less chance of Israelis being killed than there is of Arabs being killed when Israel acts in self defence. Ironically this gives the impressionn that we care less for human life than our Arab attackers. check out my blog at http://dirtyzionist.blogspot.com
40. ‘Never again’ or ‘Here we go again’
DANIEL ,   Lod, Israel   (08.19.06)
The world should understand, if Jewish state is not aggressive, Muslims all around it will crush the state like crushing a bed bug.
41. Over-retaliation hurts Israel
Jacob ,   Maryland, USA   (08.19.06)
#40 says "The world should understand, if Jewish state is not aggressive, Muslims all around it will crush the state like crushing a bed bug." This misunderstanding of Arabs - and Pearl's own innaccurate view of the world - are very dangerous for Israel. Your belief that everyone will always hate you is a self-fulfilling prophecy. It leads you to violence that begets violence How do you expect to ever have peace when your doctrine of self-defense is deterrence through massive over-retaliation? Diplomacy takes years but it's the only way. Arabs can't negotiate? Believe that and it's true. I told my senators to stop abetting Israel's folly until it wises up.
42. Olmert better read this
Richard ,   Los Angeles, USA   (08.19.06)
The entire Israeli diplomatic and military community better read this and take it to heart, otherwise it will soon be too late
43. Complete Opposite
Chris ,   LA   (08.19.06)
Everyone knows that Israelis, westerners in general, and especially Americsans whether consciously or unconsciously think that Israeli lives are worth more. Because Israelis look 'white', they look western and secular, they speak better English than the Arabs and because Israel is a democracy. These are the stereotypes that prevail in their minds...
44. #17
yisrael eretz ahuvah   (08.19.06)
straight up brother, lebanese gotta realise that its the hizballah who have caused the problem, they are the ones who israel targeted with all the justification there could ever be, then they cry over the fact that they use human shields, disgusting cowards!
45. Same Jew mind, different day.
atmawi ,   Historic Palestine   (08.19.06)
46. Just another point of view
Pontus ,   Malmö, Sweden   (08.19.06)
Isn't Israel a democratic state? In my mind that constitutes a great people to look up to, worth keeping safe. Now I haven't seen any terrorists that aren't insane psychopats or having been brainwashed by an insane psychopat. So isn't it natural that when other democratic states asks Israel to find restraint in their actions so as not to hurt inoscents, that this is because Israel is civilized? What's the point of telling a terrorist to show restraint, when he/she shouldn't be blowing up in the first place? My heart goes out to all of Israel, keep up the good spirit
47. STRONGLY DISAGREE !!!!
Victor ,   Zurich, Switzerland   (08.19.06)
The article and this way of thought could not further away from the real situation on the ground. Nobody disputes the right of israel to self-defence, and eliminate people targeting it, the question is why to blow away to pieces everything around them. The answer is that IDF no more has guts it used to have 10-20 years ago and prefer to fight ground war from the air. Biased to Israel CNN estimation of lebanese civilian casualties was 10 much higher then israeli civilian casualties. So it seems like it is arab lives are worth ten times less the jewish.
48. Dave #23
Mustafa ,   Egypt   (08.19.06)
Well said, thank you.
49. no.32: I c u'r here as well...
FBY ,   FL   (08.19.06)
The little racist showed up here too? to be continued bastard! :-x
50. jewish lives worthless than arabs/muslems
alli ,   london   (08.19.06)
i think u need to get ur facts right, killing brings more killing in bothsides, if u beleive in what u said why always for each israeli person 10-20 muslems die, does that mean in ur terms israeli lives more valuable than arabs, so israel has to kill more arabs because their lives worthless, this what is ur standards means to me, . thanks
51. Thank you Ynet for this article!
D ,   Israel   (08.19.06)
Very good article and most true! Only when Israel started defending itself there was an outcry for a cease fire. The U.N. has to be the biggest failure in human history. Where are the cease fires in all those African countries, where people are being slaughtered by the MILLIONS! Where was the call for cease fire during Vietnam War, Iran/Iraq War, the Afgan War, The Balkans War, The Gulf War I & II and so on and so on... Only when Israel defends itself we have 'cease fire calls'
52. Emet emet
zvi ,   los angeles USA   (08.19.06)
Medinat Yisrael must defend and protect Jewish life. That is why the State exists. Zeev Herzl wrote that in the Jewish State we would die peacefully in our own beds. This is not so today and will not be so if we pursue cease fires with barbaric enemies who seek our annihilation.
53. Israel's problem is....
Sir Pilpel ,   Paris, france   (08.19.06)
that it's facing a world that is becoming increasingly sceptical and with less and less reserve of the good foundation of Israel's existence. It was maybe not such a good idea to have let this happen, after all, what we did was force a wedge in between the Arab's teeth, he can no longer afford to smile... But people forget that the whole Middle-East was for a very large part totally made up, carved up one should say on the drawing- tables of the french and the english strategists who didnt really do anything that went against their own interests and didnt give two hoots about the Arabs, this is the Arab's real problem, over the last 100 yrs, actually since the downfall and desintegration of the Ottoman Empire they havent managed to decide anything. Israel in that sense represents the ultimate wedge between their teeth. What is the real problem for a palestinian today in the Middle-East? wherever he goes he is treated like a pariah! So the Arabs are unlikely in the near future to accept Israel and Israel is condemned to keep a very highly trained army, needs to be the top of the top, it is going to have defend itself against an increasingly more and more efficient enemy, with better weapons and technology. Israel cannot afford to let down now, or anytimein the foreseeable future.
54. #8-what a stupid dumb idiot you are...shud up
Anti-Islam-o-facist ,   USA   (08.19.06)
55. The War of two winners ?
Pierre ,   Paris, France   (08.19.06)
Hezbollah was damaged but the reputation of IDF suffered. This is a fact. In spite of the destruction inflicted to Hezbollah, the Israeli operations were mitigated: logistics, operational orders, tactic or strategy, everything was carried out half-done, amateurish. One of the things which is over is this concept of "surgical war" as a solution for everything. Sometimes, the army must carry out a REAL WAR, as it happens in reality in other countries, not just for the Hezbollah's TV show. The conflict between Israel and Arabs lasts for 60 years, and it's been rather "symbolic" in numbers. If we compare it with other regional or ethnic conflicts, we'll even find it moderated. It would be much more effective to strike stronger and make some 300 victims in three days than go on war softly and make 1300 victimes in 30 days. Perhaps the Israel and Arabs need such a REAL war to finish with their conflict?
56. Values
wilbur ,   canton usa   (08.19.06)
Israel cannot rely on a media presentation to achieve security....The UN is a conduit for Arab hatred and anti-israel resolution. Less Israeli "Talkback" regarding its ongoing defense is a better way. Better dialogue with the Us & Great Britain wouldnt hurt!!!
57. To 9. Some People Sympathize With Jews
MENDOZA ,   MONTREAL, CANADA   (08.19.06)
"Perhaps Israel should withdraw from the UN for awhile? I quite agree, Israel should withdraw from the UN, not "Perhaps", but Certainly, and not "for awhile", but forever.
58. wake up
khalid ,   switzerland   (08.19.06)
I am amazed at this article and the mentality behind such thaughts..how can you claim that you are careful about innocent civilians'collateral damage' has been phrased by arrogant superpower like yourself...remember more than 1000 civilians died in Lebannon to your 180 losses with more than 50% soldiers...your would use the nuclear bomp where you not afraid that radiation may affect you...wake up and understand you are fighting people who have rights of land and they will continue to fight till you loose your arrogance and make a respectable peace deal like you did with Jordan and Egypt
59. #5
Dan ,   TLV   (08.19.06)
Great that you are here to tell us what to do! If compromise was the solution, we would live in peace since long time. Oslo was compromise. Gaza is compromise. Most of israeli people are ready for compromise. But for some others compromise means defeat and more violence to come.
60. #8 Egal
zov ,   rosenberg, tx   (08.20.06)
Although you are probably not an arab you are lying as the real mohammedian. Israel suffered 3079 injuries, 750 of them heavy physical damages for life. Israel lost 162 people killed, 118 of them are soldiers and the rest are civilians. There is no such thing as arab land, never was and never will, as of course there is no such thing as rissian, french or jewish lands. There are 360 million arabs and 1,2 billions mohammedians. All these 1,2 billions passively or actively support extermination of 6 million Israeli jews. The HB is only the front line bandits in service to the pathological islamofascist tribe. Thus, to avoid getting "F" in your arithmetic class you should see that to be "balanced" in olimpic game spirit your kind of sleeze is so passionate about, Israel should kill more than 6, 000 mohammedians soldiers and 3 000 civilians, but Israel lost this time, that is why it did not happen.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article