News
Report: US misjudged Iran threat
Ynet and Reuters
Published: 24.08.06, 14:18
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
42 Talkbacks for this article
1. Let's help them arm
Rick Cohen ,   NJ, United States   (08.24.06)
Why not just throw our hands up and help them build their nuclear arsenal. This way the intellegence community won't guess. Sarcasm sometimes isn't funny.
2. INTELLIGENCE
MAHMOOD ,   LONDON-UK   (08.24.06)
It is difficult to understand the fact that the Intelligent Department in USA did not gather proper information.After a lapse of 27 years if this is the conclusion drawn I find it difficult to understand how they are going to rectify it.My strong feeling is that the US Intelligence took it for granted that the clergy in Iran had no clue to the running of the Governemt and underestimated their knowledge and vision.All they thought was that a clergy was more versed with religious matters and had no knowledge of politics.This is where the USA Intelligence has faltered.
3. Arab Terrorisim
Steve Case ,   new york ,new york   (08.24.06)
Its time for all of us to understand, that either were gonna kill or be killed. Those are the only 2 options. lets destroy Iran and Syria just like we hit Norashima. That endede the war. The only solution is to Nuke Iran now, destroy Syria to the ground. Then there will be peace for the next 100 years
4. Intelligence in the American Spy Agencies?
stude ham ,   outremont, canada   (08.24.06)
The articel should have stated categorically "a complete LACK of intelligence in the American spy agencies". Or else, how can anyone explain such things as 911???
5. intelligence
yonatan ,   Beit Shemesh Israel   (08.24.06)
Intelligence is no match for Islamic fanaticism. Nuke Iran now.
6. Missiles....for war? you are kidding
Ivri   (08.24.06)
They are for peacefull purpuses. Islamofascists are holding this bizarre world hostage.
7. HEY MOUTH OF THE NORTH SHUT UP!!
KEITH ,   NY,USA   (08.24.06)
At least we have an agency that is working on the problem. Yes there have been mistakes in the past, but this is a different world we live in. I never even heard of a Canadian Intelligence Agency. Do you even have Intelligence, eh?
8. The administration makes many mistakes
Mark ,   USA   (08.24.06)
I wonder if it is intentional. I can not keep up with all these failures and mistakes. This administration seems to take great pride in their incompetence. They still have Donald Rumsfeld in charge. They want to fail and weaken America.
9. TO THE WORLD...
KEITH ,   NY,USA   (08.24.06)
All of you sit in your quarterback armchairs and redicule MY MIGHT US OF A. How dare you!? What have YOU done for the world? Probebly what your'e doing now...nothing. We in America are hard working, God fearing people,well...most of us, and try ever so hard each day to make this place a better and safer world to live in. So take your comments and thoughts about MY country and shove them up your ASS. Unless you have somthing productive and with some intelligence (no pune intended) keep it to yourself...RIGHT IRONCANDLE?
10. #6 Isri: Of course
Yogi Behrah ,   Forest City, OK   (08.24.06)
the missles are not for war! They are for delivering "humanitarian aid." ; )
11. Intentionally making mistakes.
Mark ,   USA   (08.24.06)
Normally after so many mistakes, one begins to learn. Not this administration. It digs itself deeper and deeper into the hole. It goes from bad to worse.
12. we are not arab
abtin ,   iran   (08.24.06)
we are not arab we are persicus .however we are muslim but we are not arab. at first you should define to us what israel ocupier army and residents do in occupied palestine.a country has been occupied and you want peace this is a crazy request.get out from the occupied lands to have a peace . you are like person who came to a home with no permission and pease for israel is meaningless. l hope hell for you
13. ANSWER TO #7
MAHMOOD ,   LONDON-UK   (08.24.06)
Keith, you have to understand the fact that millions of dollars of American tax money is being spent on CIA.And when taking into the acoount that 27 years of concerted efforts by the CIA and the USA Government to topple the Iranian regime,one finds it difficult to understand what more these 'intelligent' personnel need to know in that span of time...........read my previous talk-back and ponder over it rather than worrying about what Canada has or not.
14. Wake Up America!
CCC ,   GA (United States)   (08.24.06)
WE MUST WAKE UP TO THE REALITY OF THE THREATS PRESENTED BY THE IRANIAN REGIME WHOHAVE BEEN AND WILL LIKELY BE ASSISTED BY "FRIENDS",RUSSIA AND CHINA, AND PERHAPS OTHER COUNTRIES HUNGRY FOR THE FALL OF AMERICA. WHILE WE ARE BUSY DEBATING POLITICS AND FOLLOWING THE DEVELOPEMENTS WITH JOHN KARR, OUR ENEMIES ARE GETTING READY TO BLOW US OFF THE FACE OF THE EARTH! HELLO? WE NEED TO GET OUR PRIORITIES STRAIGHT RIGHT NOW!AMERICANS NEED UNITY! EVENIF WE CAN MUSTER THE UNITY AND RESOLVE OF THE AMERICAN PUBLIC COLLECTIVELY, THIS IS AND WILL BE A TOUGH WAR TO SAY THE LEAST. IF WE DON'T WAKE UP NOW AND TAKE ACTION, IT WILL LIKELY BE TOO LATE. YOU CAN BET THAT OUR ENEMIES ARE FOCUSED AND RESOLVED! LOVE FREEDOM? LOVE AMERICA? LOVE BEING ALIVE? WAKE UP MY FRIENDS AND SEE THAT NO MATTER HOW MUCH WE WANT TO PRETEND THAT ALL OF THE THREATS WE FACE WILL JUST GO AWAY, THEY WILL NOT! IF WE DON'T "SEIZE THE DAY" NOW, IT WILL BE TOO LATE! WE CANNOT AFFORD TO BE DIVIDED AS A NATION AND/OR FELLOW HUMAN BEINGS ANY LONGER. "UNITED WE STAND,DIVIDED WE FALL!",LEST WE FORGET THESE WORDS OF WISDOM. AMERICA, LET'S GET OUR ACT TOGETHER!
15. Limited Case
Theo Verseer ,   Washington DC   (08.24.06)
Right Caseboy, let's nuke them bc we don't want them to have nukes. That makes sense.
16. Outremount Canada let the terrorists into
(08.24.06)
Canada, and let them cross the border into the United States. He even fed them.
17. MAHMOOD, Iwasn't talking to you, sorry for misunderstanding
KEITH ,   NY,USA   (08.24.06)
18. Its going to happen
67cj5 ,   USA   (08.24.06)
The coming war is inevitable. It could have been prevented, but now it is too late. Because the US and our alies do not want the carnage of WWII we have tried to fight a kinder and gentler war. Our enemies however are brutal beyond anything we have seen since WWII. It is too bad our enemies are too stupid understand that all people are capable of unimaginable brutality if pushed hard enough. They push and push and we just take it. We still do not want to do what we must, but one day they will push hard enough to kill themselves. These islamic nuts think we will continue to sit on our hands, they think we are weak. We are not weak, we have the capibility to destroy them, we just don't have the will yet. When they piss us off too bad, and they will, it is coming and we all know it. They will be destroyed. It is going to happen, there is no stoping it now. #12 you wish hell on us? We will rain hell down on you in return. It will happen.
19. #3 Steve
Mick ,   Australia   (08.24.06)
another stupid US citizen like president like citizen. stop watching Hollywood movies and wake up to reality. no wonder you have the lowest IQ in the US.
20. #4 & #7
Ryan ,   Calgary, Canada   (08.24.06)
9/11 happened because of hate, and the desire to keep countries under oppression by Islamic rulers. Can be pretty much summed up as fear of change or of creating a population capable of thinking on it's own. American policy is bringing freedom and choice to people worldwide and some people in control don't want this to happen. Don't be so stupid, your embarrassing to my country. Go Home!!!. Keith, it's called CSIS. They are actually pretty good, they just foiled an attempt to blow up a half dozen buildings in the Greater Toronto area from "peace loving" muslims, and they work hand in hand with US border patrol and have stopped countless "jihadist" from entering the US, as well as provide intel to the FBI. Although an attack on Canadian soil is imminent, they do however do a good job. Like the US though, a major front in the war on Islam will be fought in the homeland of North America, as there are countless sleeper cells in both countries. A north American Union might be needed to eliminate bureacracy with cross border tracking, and to improve security. Although I agree with everything you post, I think one day we will have it out, concerning Northern sovereignty over the artic, thats my only concern with the US, that and there tendancy to fight with one hand behind there back to please human rights groups. They and Israel have more power then they use, which should be used to spare North American lives.
21. To #3 Arab Terrorism
Sal ,   Florida, US   (08.24.06)
You are quite right. I agree 10000% to all you spell out and hope the intelligent will open their eyes. no need to waiste soldiers life, de do not understand anyways. are we so hard headed. let nuke them, easy and will have peace for 100 years,.
22. we are not arab ?
jerry miller ,   liberty nc   (08.24.06)
Maybe you are not arab. You are illiterate. You do not spell peace - pease. Maybe you don't know what it is, since you can't even spell it ? Isreal is in gaza and other territories because muslims in countrys around them started wars and lost ! They lost because the greatest Rabbi that ever lived will soon judge you, me and everyone. This is JESUS. You want hell for me but I say to you, watch out !! What you wish for one may be in YOUR future.
23. ANSWER TO #17
MAHMOOD ,   LONDON-UK   (08.24.06)
Sorry Keith.In the talk-back it is imperative that we jointly discuss the subject.I know that your talk-back was from someone in Canada, we share each other views or agree to disagree.Mine was a general observation and I am indeed surprised that after a lapse of 27 years with the clergy dominated Government in Iran,contacts of the regime of Shah and his numerous stooges who are presently residing in USA,the Intelligent unit concludes with this kind of despair........it's pity isn't it?
24. Killing People would not produce Peace
Ibrahim ,   US   (08.24.06)
To all who have globalized the conflict and would like to see all muslims nuked. Stop calling Muslims fascists when everytime anyone deviates slightly from your wishful thinking is called names . Also calling for the disctrcution of the whole planet so Israel can live in peace is a pethitec statement. If I recall correctly More Jews where killed in Europe in one day that Jews killed in the Arab Isralei conflict in 60 years. So go ahead with your preimptive mentality and see where it will take you. Father Ibrahim
25. To the world (according to KEITH)
Dr. Olson ,   FL, USA   (08.25.06)
KEITH As an "intelligent" and a "productive" officer in the US military I feel well qualified to tell you to "shut up"...but I won't...just like you shouldn't tell others. In our country we have the right to freedom of speech, which I have personally defended for 18 years. From your written perspective I doubt you have ever served YOUR country otherwise you would know that true American's value people's opinions (i.e. "Democracy) and only those who are too scared and closed-minded engage in rhetoric likes yours. I imagine you were also a bully in school...
26. we are not arab
JIM ,   USA   (08.25.06)
We will see who ends up in hell. Your people, civilization and religion have provided nothing positive to the world for thousands of years. Get over the fact that the world has left you in the dust. If not for western technology you would not have the ability to make any money. The people of this nation are growing very tired of your whining about how evil the west is. If you want evil, we will give it to you like you have never seen. Remember what the Japanese said during WWII about waking the giant.
27. time for change
C ,   Seattle   (08.25.06)
We've had so much time in our comfortable lives, here in the West, to do something about the arab/muslim problem, as well as the oil problems, yet in optimistic hopefulness, we keep plugging along, pretending nothing's wrong, not caring about the future, assuming we'll be gone long before any problems arise...our only thought was that it could "possibly" run out in our lifetimes, rather than it go to $10 per gallon, or switching our entire infrastructure of vehicles and fuel stations to alternatives as well as our homes (solar, methane, etc.) and our places of employment...just leave it for the next generation to deal with...this is so selfish and destructive, I hope we will get the ball rolling ASAP, collectively as a nation, so we don't hit a brick wall, so to speak, in terms of islam and oil...they have their ball rolling in terms of goals and destiny, unfortunately it is diametrically opposed to the interests of the rest of the world.
28. Use spellchecker, Father Ibrahim
Abu Fadiha ,   Kafr Fadiha   (08.25.06)
Dear Ibrahim: It would greatly increase your credibility if you used this infidel innovation called SPELLCHECKER. While what you said about Jewish victims in the Holocaust may or may not be true, no one would want to kill any Muslims at all if you guys left the Jews alone. After all, it is not Israelis who murdered Arab sports teams in Munich Olympics in 1972, hijacked Israeli and Western air liners, threw Arab children from school windows in Ma'alot, or blew up buses or cafes in Ramallah, Hebron and Shchem ("Nablus" = Neapolis, a good Arab name ;-) Israelis did not kidnap Hamas and Hezbollah terrorists across the borders or ceasefire lines, and did not fire Katyusha and Kassam rockets indiscriminately against Arab towns.
29. Right on, #14
Steven ,   Biloxi, MS, USA   (08.25.06)
Iranians are taught from birth to hate the American, "Infidels", and will do anything to bring us and our support of Israeal down. This problem should have been fixed in the 70's or 80's. Most of the Islamic, Arabic world views the US as weak and the politically correct soft military action will not win. They only understand violent superiority.
30. Just like Iraq
Brad Arnold ,   St Louis Park, MN   (08.25.06)
Did you know that the "report" was written by a Republican staffer? The same people who misled us into the preventative invasion of Iraq, now want to misled us into a war with Iran. First, they blame Iran for our failure in Iraq, then they imagine Iran as the root of all evil in the Middle East. Finally, they conclude that we don't have a choice, we have to preventatively attack Iran, and they paint a rosey picture of the outcome of the conflict. Beware war monger chicken hawks, and people who profit from the military/industrial complex.
Next talkbacks
Back to article