News
Journalists blame Israel for war coverage
Yaakov Lappin
Published: 29.08.06, 21:46
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
86 Talkbacks for this article
61. Farrell and Erlanger and the NYT
Jonathan and Mollie ,   USA   (08.30.06)
Don't these jounalistic prostitutes realize how stupid and immoral their remarks are? To Mr. Farrell, there are obviously no ethical guidelines in journalism. Hey, pictures are faked .......big deal, everybody is doing it. Stories are inaccurate....hey, it's commercial pressure. Can you imagine the head of surgery excusing a collegue who was drunk during an operation by proclaiming that it's OK, a lot of surgeons are doing the same thing. Or the head of the American Bar Association excusing a lawyer attempting to bribe a juror by saying it's OK, a lot of lawyers do it. After all, there is commercial pressure. It's not surprising that the NYT employs Erlanger because he shares their historic philosophy and agenda. As another responder reported, the NYT deliberately withheld or minimized information about the Holocaust. The self-hating Jewish owners of the Times, the infamous Sulzbergers, didn't want their paper to be known as a Jewish paper so they closed their hearts to the millions of European Jews who were being slaughtered by the nazis. They were and remain creatures without a soul or conscience. Several years ago, they even admitted that they behaved inexcusably during the Holocaust but their mea culpa was obviously not sincere. Thus, Erlanger is an appropriate mouthpiece for such a despicable organization. As a matter of fact, he is both stupid and despicable. Basically, what he is saying is that since Israel refused to embed his reporters, he didn't know what was going on so he based his stories on the Hezbollah version of what happened and reported obvious lies as the truth. He shows how cold-hearted he is towards Israel by actually criticizing a country that was taking thousands of missile hits(all directed against Israeli civilians) of not caring about Lebanese civilians even though Israel dropped leaflets warning civilians to leave. Is Erlanger a self-hater, a delusional leftist, an antisemite or just a garden variety psychopath?
62. Who cares how they feel anymore?
Howard ,   Toronto, Canada   (08.30.06)
I really don't care anymore how they feel about us. Israel has to do what it has to do to defend itself...and damn what the rest of the world thinks. I only wish Mr. Olmert and his cronies felt the same way instead of running to Mr. Bush and Condaleeza to get the ok to do what Israel NEEDS to do. No way we're going to allow the second coming of the "Third Reich".
63. Journalism and Wars
Larry ,   Toronto, Canada   (08.30.06)
Do these idiots from the "real world" press think that war is a television reality game that can be manipulated to their liking?? Do they think that they are entitled to have their lives endangered at the expense of the IDF so they can bring more bang for their buck to their viewers??? Why don't they complain about being embedded with the U.S. in Iraq where what they report dictates whether they will remain embedded. As for casualty counts it is irrelevant whether it is 500, 600, 1000. Israel is allowed to defend its citizens against missiles launched by terrorists that don't reflect Lebanese government policy. In the absence of the Lebanese restraining Hizbollah Israel dealt with the situation as any other country in the world would do.
64. Journalism in Lebanon
Mahmoud Ibn Bargoni ,   Jakarta, Indonesia   (08.30.06)
Laughable at best. Nic Robertson, CNN's signature reporter in Lebanon was completely fooled by his manipulation at the hands of Hizballah during his famous report in Lebanon. Even his colleague the more credible Anderson Cooper spoke about how journalists were manipulated by HIzballah. It seems that many are too stupid to realize that Hizballah has a superb spin machine recycling dead babies and desecrating graves in the name of Allah and world pity.
65. Journalism
Yanki Goh Ohm ,   Beijing, China   (08.30.06)
What a flap Lebanon coverage of news were. Reading about Reuters photgraphist shooting picturs and doctoring with Photo Shop!!! Where is coverage of Hizbolah bunkers hidden under houses, rockets, missiles?? Where is reality about what the threat of Hizbalh is too Israel?? Journalist bad artists painting picture of things not true but what makes their people watch and read. Sometime truth is need to show world what problem coming from crazy in Islamic JIhad world.
66. Yup... Just as George Galloway told Ya
Geronimo   (08.30.06)
67. Think Again!
Dory ,   Anfeh-Lebanon   (08.30.06)
Do u really think that ur civilized and victims? open some pages, visit some websites about lebanon and see for urselves how wrong u are but i dont blame you ! i blame ur poor media!
68. Journalism
shari ,   Golan, Israel   (08.30.06)
Steve Erlanger shouldn't be surprised that Israelis don't see the war the way the world did -- we actually have access to real facts. Journalists who present unsubstantiated estimates as fact and "hearsay" as if it were verified are lying. Journalists are as despised as lawyers, and for the same reason: lack of integrity.
69. Feed up with your lies
Bill marlonie ,   Canada   (08.30.06)
You wanna tell that CNN is bios to arab too right?this is a tupical jew ideology .whoever critisize Israel is antisimit.The jew are the perfect people in the world nobody should have the right to blame them for anything except the jew of course. The worl opinoin is going to know the truth sooner or later what ever you lies
70. #46 - See: www.littlegreenfootballs.com
(08.30.06)
It's the oil $$$ stupid
71. Zero journalistic integrity Thank God for websites & blogs!
(08.30.06)
72. Sure, israel is to blame for fake photos...
AK   (08.30.06)
Okay, they admitthat they have always faked photos? Well, now we all know that those "journalists" are really propagandists, and nobody will be stupid enough to rely on anything they print or show.
73. To Steven Erlanger
AK   (08.30.06)
You may find it surprising, but despite your pernicious reports very few Americans actually shared your view of the war.
74. Fox did an outstanding job & was embedded with the soldiers.
Miriam ,   Netivot   (08.30.06)
Guess, this is because they tell the truth...................
75. to #69
jason white ,   afula,israel   (08.30.06)
We are fed up with your bull and your spelling errors. Is your name really walid and not william?
76. Journalists
Meir ,   USA   (08.30.06)
The talkback responses are amazing. Particularly the venom against NYTimes's Erlanger. There was nothing what he was quoted as saying that is even remotely "anti-Israel." Why can't Israel's advocates accept that not everything is perceived as they see it and that someone can disagree without being an anti-Semite? I attended the program in question and I did not hear any overt anti-Israel comments. Disagreements, but nothing that is anti-Israel.
77. Insist of truth.
Truth ,   USA   (08.30.06)
THE INTERNET ON: PALLYWOOD & CORRUPT JOURNALISM Media is coming around to the humiliating discrediting of Pallywood Islamofacist and biased media reporting thanks to countless blogs, group postings, websites, talkbacks, video, etc. Their “spin masters” never envisioned the power of the Internet. The truth is out. No matter how much "Pallywood" blogging, internet posting, photos, video, or oil billions goes into biased media, Islamofacist claims of "oppressed" peoples engaged in a "righteous" cause is now contemptible. Pallywood and biased media’s reporting strength is lies. Pro-Israel's, indeed, pro-decency‘s, strength is in uncompromising substantiable truth. Keep repeating truth; the whole truth, historic and factual truths; keep substantiating it, keep posting it, spreading it, and demanding it. Pallywood, BBC, Guardian and Reuters media types cannot hold biased media agendas under the onslaught of blatant truths. Their Pallywood media agenda is clear for all the world to see and rebuke, we have and we do. THE TIDE IS TURNING - DO NOT QUIT Oliver Stone’s 9/11 is now playing in movie theaters across USA. Honest Reporting's "Obsession the Movie" (www.obsessionthemovie.com) is readily available, promoted across the internet, and widely screened by various groups. CNN's has: Know your Enemy (Osama - Islamofacism) and 9/11 (cnn.com). 1) BOYCOTT biased media! Cancel subscriptions and encourage all others to do so as well. Email them and let them know why! NOTE: “Tell it like it is.” Ghandi and Martin Luther King were exactly these types; an empire and the most corrupt ideological deceptions fell with a colossal crash in the face of uncompromising truth persistently applied. Islamofacist Pallywood and corrupt media, rebuke them with truth! a) Islamonazism http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0U2n-RxUh48&NR b) Tounge Slayers: http://tongue-slayers.blogspot.com/ c) Little Green Footballs: www.littlegreenfootballs.com (See: Green Helmet, BBC, Reuters, et. al. in action) Insist on truth.
78. #69
Yaha   (08.30.06)
On the contrary, the world is starting to realize the MSM's blatant pampering to Hezzy propoganda. Thank you blogosphere! MSM = ownt
79. Erlanger surprised
Alex ,   Bat-Yam   (08.30.06)
What a d***head! Maybe the news looked different because your arab-fed-journalists were doctoring photos and promoting Hezbo-propaganda? Erlanger, no worries, your dinosaur media is dying. Bloggers won't leave a piece of crap from NYT lies. Lies of BBC/AP/Al-Reuters won't go unnoticed anymore! Enough is enough.
80. Erlanger on Arafat's "Heroic History"
CW ,   New Jersey   (08.31.06)
Remember that Erlanger is the same reporter who referred to terrorist Yasir Arafat's "heroic history" of resistance: http://www.timeswatch.org/twarticles/2005/20050106.asp#2
81. Blatant anti-Israel prejudice
Roberta E. Dzubow ,   Fort Washington, PA   (09.01.06)
I am constantly amazed at the inferiority of your reporting. The media's blatant and hostile anti-Israel stance reveals the most vile prejudice against Israel. 5,000 Israelis were wounded, 4,000 rockets fell on Israeli cities, 750.000 trees were destroyed, over 150 Israelis died. Meanwhile, in Iraq, 3.000 are killed monthly yet Israel 's " civilized war" claimed less than 1.000 in a month -with 500 being Hezb'Allah fighters. You reported none of this. Islam causes the world unending pain. You whitewash their actions and abet their murderous deeds. Shame on each and every one of you.
82. Speilburg and Nasrallah !
lisa ,   london   (09.02.06)
to hear suggestions by from people of the civilised world that Lebanon was digging out Previously dead bodeis of people , is like asking a native from the the Brazilian jungles why are Cannibals . So even the western media PRO and Against Hizbollah are in it . why then get angry when people deny the extent of the holocaust , you jump in to a fit . When the Passion of christ was showing exactly what and who was behind his murder , Rabbi Shumuley boteach in a heated debate broke and called out for the Jewish Hollywood / Media to rescue him and protest against the TRUTH. Spoiled Brats .
83. INFO sites :
lisa ,   london   (09.02.06)
Concerning Jewish Idiology look at ; www.youtube.com then look up " what the world should know " Next look up Race and religion ?! as a separet site , if can`t get hold of it ( rather than don`t want to get hold of it ) just noted on your comment page
84. 25: Half of Lebanon wasn't flattened
Ehud ,   Karmiel, Israel   (09.02.06)
Hardly half of Lebanon was flattened. The media mostly showed the same area in Beirut, while 99.9% of the city was unharmed. If the IDF didn't try to minimize civilians deaths, would you really expect, after a month, as many Lebanese casualties as there were? (And I wonder how many of them are Hizballah in civilian clothing?)
85. 46: Why the press is biased? Well,
Ehud ,   Karmiel, Israel   (09.02.06)
Partly because their prespective is their happy, threat-less, abode. From afar it's easy to be sure diplomacy is the way to pacify everyone. (Also see Iran.) And they assume, for that reason or another, that the underdog is the one that should be sympathized, regardless of the rest. I guess that's good for dramatic effect. And of course, more sensational death and destruction sells better.
86. Re: Simon McGregor-Wood
Lance ,   Montreal, Canada   (09.03.06)
This Simon McGregor-Wood clown is an anti-Israel bigot. See his rediculous comments about the IDF at: http://blogs.abcnews.com/thejerusalemfile/2006/08/when_will_i_go_.html
Previous talkbacks
Back to article