News
Muslim clerics vs. female genital mutilation
Gil Yaron
Published: 25.11.06, 11:54
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
39 Talkbacks for this article
1. Loyal????
M. Hartley ,   Atlanta, US   (11.25.06)
How does genital mutilation make you loyal to a man? That's a crock. These guys don't want their women to find out which of the men are inept and don't have a clue what's what. They're afraid to come home one day and find their women, who've had nothing but long faces for years and years, sporting grins from ear to ear, especially after Ahab from down the camel path had stopped by the tent. A good roll in the hay will do that to a girl. Show me a guy who likes a "dead" woman in bed, and I'll show you a class A wimp. No wonder Muslims are such a miserable lot. They're missing all the fun, except, of course, for Ahab. He knows how to talk to a girl, hehehehe.
2. what courageous clerics
Concerned Israeli   (11.25.06)
Now when will top Muslim clerics gather to condemn terrorism as aggression against mankind?
3. Call it like it is :assault
Connie ,   VA, USA   (11.25.06)
Murder , adultery etc., begin in the heart anyway. Cutting away the female genitals have no effect there. How could you "love" someone who is a cruel,oppressive barbarian. They fear the idiots. If after seeing for himself(Nehberg) what is being done to these woman and he still has a 'positive view of Islam, he's sick too.
4. #1
(11.25.06)
Do you always shit from your mouth ?
5. No, only when it involves radical Muslims.
M. Harltey ,   Atlanta, US   (11.25.06)
6. Previous post was directed at #4
M. Hartley ,   Atlanta, US   (11.25.06)
7. mutilation
john doe ,   USA   (11.25.06)
I think involuntary male circucision is also mutilation. Most Russian jews are not circumcised. I think many jews in nazi Germany would have survived had they not been circumcised.
8. Genital Mutilation
Libneniyyeh ,   Lebanon   (11.25.06)
Same old bs. Islam does NOT call for genital mutilation. It calls for circumcision ONLY of boys. The reason why this tradition developed to grow to this ugly practice goes back to some societies' beliefs that a woman without a clitoris will be a "good" woman, as she will not be lustful and lecherous. This practice developed in some countries where the climate is particularly hot and girls reach puberty early and have rather prominently developed genitalia. Some sick people just love these sensationalist articles; they have a roman holiday over their misconceptions of Islam. And in the end, as always, you get disgusting racists and ignorant remarks from someone like 1. Ynet, I am sure you anticipate these reactions, and I also know that Jews practice circumcision, like us, for hygienic purposes. I respect what the Germans are doing, and I am aware that, because of poverty and illeteracy, a great many tribes know no better. But that is not the true face of Islam, nor are those incidents that you jump to expose reflective of it. I wish for once you'd post an article that says something nice, I am happy to draw your attention to many different sources and topics.
9. idiots: this is not muslim. Its an african tradition which
fadi ,   lebanon   (11.25.06)
is spread into certain muslim countries of north africa !!!
10. #5, 6
(11.25.06)
It show what kind of shit you are !
11. * 8 /YOU Are so disgustingly sick
free man ,   free all women   (11.25.06)
I bet males' genitalia doesn't develop as much in the climated does it ??? What's your problem if genitalia grows above average there? Do you also advocate mutilating some major part of men's genitalia too?? I bet you don't. Cause in Africa men's are far larger and larger than anyone else's. If you call mutilation, and in such mega scale, sensacionalism, well, close yourself behind bars. Normal people wouldn't even want to meet you
12. To #8
M. Hartley ,   Atlanta, US   (11.25.06)
My making fun of some things is not nearly as disgusting as going around, preaching and screaming, "death to....," blowing oneself up in the name of some god or for some political agenda with no goal in mind other than to kill or maim people whom one doesn't even know and brainwashing one's children into believing that it's a goal in life and that there is a reward in some paradise for that behavior. That is not just disgusting. It is SICK. Frankly, I'd rather make fun of something, including sometimes even myself. Laughing has never hurt anybody.
13. To no name, no town, no country, no guts #10
M. Hartley ,   Atlanta, US   (11.25.06)
Take my word for it, I've been called worse by much, much better people. Nevertheless, I'd be glad to help you expand your vocabulary past four-letter words, although you seem to have a real affinity for excrement.
14. To the red neck witch # 13
(11.25.06)
As long as my vocabulary can show how SHITTY person you are that's more than enough ! :)
15. Islamic Female Genetial Mutilation & #8
Lindon Richards ,   Milpitas, USA   (11.25.06)
The practice of female genetial mutilation is a very well known Islamic practise. It may not be one of the five pillars of Islam, but it is part of Islamic tradition. Yes, it is backward, uncivilised, disgusting and downright foolish, but it is still part and parcel of Islam in many parts of the world, including supposedly modern societies such as Egypt. # 8, your phraselogy and the manner of the way you respond, suggests that you have more than a resonable level of education, and the strenous effort that you invested in your vain attempts to convince us, that female genital mutilation is not the true face of Islam, truly rings hollow. These efforts suggests that you are indeed ashamed of the practise, and you should. There is a lot for you to be ashamed of. Your religion is not known anywhere as a purveyor of peace, and prosperity, especially since 1979. No body anywhere, can point any innovations in computer technology, agriculture, wealth creation, information technology, space exploration, the construction of earthquake resistance buildings, aerospace, world class medical research, etc, that redounds to the benefit of human kind. that have come out of the Islamic community. Instead, we can all point to the multiplicity of wars and acts of unspeakable violence and unending chants of death to America and Death to Isreal in the streets of some Islamic countries, especially in Iran, the main benefactor of Hezbollah, the same group that the Argeitines say attacked ther Isreali embassy andJewish Cultural Center in Buenos Aries some years back. The attacks of 9/11, the Madrid train bombings, the Beslan Massacre, the Bali bombings, the attacks on inocent tourists of Rome and Vienna in 1985, the activities of Hamas, Abusayev, the Chechen war, and the London bombings are only a few random examples that come to mind. The rest of us are also quite familiar with the technique that you use in your postiing. That is to say, others are always ignorant of the true face of Islam. Well, needless to say, it is not for the likes of you to tell the rest of us about what constitutes the 'true face ' of Islam. Perhaps your efforts would be better spent in trying to convince your violent and foolish clerics to present the rest of us with a more civiized, less violent face of your death laden religion! Here is an idea for you, it is only a matter of time before the world as a whole exact the proper price from your religion. The time for empire building has long past, There are far more benefical purposes for humainity, to purpose outside of reverting to the backwardness contained in Islam!
16. Number 10
Libneniyyeh ,   Lebanon   (11.25.06)
Please read what I wrote carefully before making your stupid remarks, which I find completely uncalled for and ignorant. Not only do you show ignorance at interpreting clear English, but I'll bet you have an automated built-in response with the same answer ready to pop up, no matter what the context. I did not at all advocate the practice, and no where in my response did I say I had a problem. What I said was: "This practice developed in some countries where the climate is , particularly hot and girls reach puberty early and have rather prominently developed genitalia. " This is a fact; in hot climates children reach puberty at early ages, and, usually, both male and female genitalia are more prominent than other peoples'. And unfortunately, some cultures see this as a sign of hypersexuality which they attempt to reduce, especially in the case of females. I clearly stated that these rites were a result of ignorance, illiteracy, and poverty, and I actually commended the efforts on the parts of the German and Muslim people who were attempting to ban these practices. And what I clearly meant by sensationalism is that some people find a certain horrified fascination at reading these stories, and my only criticism was that these stories do not reflect Islam. So, the way I see it is that it is you who has a problem and I think it is you who is very sick.
17. Hartley
Libneniyyeh ,   Lebanon   (11.25.06)
What you do, Sir or Madam (since I dont know what M stands for) is not "make fun". What you do is go around calling people scum, animals, low lifes, etc. If this in your definition means innocent making fun, Id hate to see what you look like when ur nasty. The fact is, when you or any one else says something along the lines of: "death to....," blowing oneself up in the name of some god or for some political agenda with no goal in mind other than to kill or maim people whom one doesn't even know and brainwashing one's children into believing that it's a goal in life and that there is a reward in some paradise for that behavior. That is not just disgusting. It is SICK. " then be sure to look closer to home, as you'd be surprised what you'd find swept under the carpet. I do not advocate terrorism or people blowing themselves up, but Ive made the point clear on many occasions: those people are not Muslims. Just like Jews who slaughter innocent people and say, "oh well, they will grow to be terrorists" are NOT Jews. Sure, everybody loves a laugh. I myself have a great sense of humor. But I can also identify venom when its spewed out. So if we are ever to have peace, then let us try to understand what motivates other people. And believe me, your pet phrase "70 virgins" is NOT what motivates them.
18. Number 15
Libneniyyeh ,   Lebanon   (11.25.06)
Please provide me with sufficient evidence to support your claims, and not some website that you chanced to come across in your browsing. I couldn't care less if you are convinced or not. You do not want to be convinced, and that is all that your own "strenuous efforts" show me. You are right only about one thing, and that is that some Muslim people and clerics do demonize the portrait of Islam to the world. But even if I am one in a hundred to speak up, at least I am doing something, and I do speak up, no matter where I am. Whoever chooses to listen or not, that is their concern. At least I am honest and brave to defend what I see is right. And if you have a problem (which you obviously do), dont read my posts.
19. Ethiopia
ali ,   detroit   (11.25.06)
Christians make up 61% of the country's population 80% of women experience genital mutlation. this goes to prove the retards that this has nothing to do with islam just with African tradition.
20.  Lebanese Dancer
DemocracyRules ,   Canada   (11.25.06)
Lebanese Girl: http://ikbis.com/beirut%20girl/shot/1300 OK -- THIS is what it's all about. Democracies have to be willing to die, so this person can do this anytime she wants, without interference or persecution. (It's not dirty, it's just FUN, and full of spirit, and hope, and JOY) No one will protedt her without us
21. #19 Ethiopian Jews do !
(11.25.06)
22. ali (19) on retards
sk ,   USA   (11.25.06)
"Christians make up 61% of the country's population 80% of women experience genital mutlation. this goes to prove the retards that this has nothing to do with islam just with African tradition." You are incorrect, Ali. The only thing this means is that some Christian women (if your numbers are correct) in Ethiopia are mutilated. One question is whether Muslim women are more likely to be mutilated than Christian women in Ethiopia. Are they? Then one could ask why Christians in Ethiopia are more likely to be mutilated than elsewhere. Could it be because Muslims will kill or enslave them if parents do not have their daughters mutilated? In other words, is this mutilation voluntary from the parents' perspective? Then you might analyze when this custom become active. Was it before or after Muslim domination? If you pool data from other countries, does it turn out that Islam is associated with mutilation after controlling for continent?
23. # 8, one man agaisnt nearly all of us and he is wrong too!
Lindon Richards ,   Milpitas CA, USA   (11.25.06)
So, you ask me for evidence if my claims that the Islamic community has not contributed to the development of any useful innovation that we currently enjoy. Well, why did you do that? How about this, why don't you try and point to even one single innivation yourself! Believe me , you would find it much more difficult to do so, than I would in listing the fact that the internet, the development of robotics, the internal combustion engine, the development of cures for various diseases, container shipping, air conditioning, trucking, education, building construction, reduction of air pollution, the development of solar and other forms of alternative power, safe mining techniques and another 100,000,000 such innivations have all come out of the non Islamic commuity, especially the West. How about this, where did Yahoo, Google Cisco Sysyems, Adobe, You Tube, Microsoft, Boeing, Lockheed Martin, Toyota, Honda, Mitsubishi, Yamaha, Mannesmahn, Vodaphone, Airbus, Hyudai, Dsiney, Ferrrari, BMW, Volkswagen MercedersBenz, Pfizer, SamSung, Hutchison Whampoa, AT&T, BBC, etc develop? Which of those companies developed in a Muslim country? Again, name just one useful world wide, world class innovation to have been produced by a Muslim country! Man, like I said, you do sound very well educated and please understand, i do support your effort to tell us that Islam is not all what most of the current portrayers apear to make it. Yes, I do iuderstand all of that, but you do need to be honest, and be less accuseatory of the genuine critics of yur religion. I does constitute a very serious thret to al of us. Herr in America, especially, since 9/11, there is widesppread fears of Muslims, and Islam. I for one, really to believe that Islam is way too concerned with use violence as a measns to impose its will on others. What with the utterances of the Iranian president vis- a vis Isreal, as well as the past conduct of Hezbollah, and other suchh groups. One more thing, female genetial mutilation is ONLY one of the many backward practices of Islam, so you do have your cut out for you in trying to revese the correct perception of the rest of us about the body of ideas of this religion. Ah, but there is more yet, you assert that climatological reasons might possibly have casued some people to have developed this most abhorrent practise. But, alas how come the very same practice did not develop among non muslim peoples with similar concerns of as you put it 'hypersexuality'. Again, I am happy that you are speaking out, but as you can see by the unusually high number of negative reactions to your initial posting, you are pretty much isolated and indeed wrong ion this one!
24. To #17.
M. Hartley ,   Atlanta, US   (11.25.06)
Sorry, but people who, intentionally, blow up buses full of children are animals, and I don't care what motivates them. If Islam has a bad reputation, then I suggest that you do something about your "preachers," who spew hate left and right, against anyone not Muslim and who are hardly ever challenged by the so-called decent Muslims. Would you prefer to be called "scum" or "uncovered meat?" That's a rhetorical, not personal, question. Yes, we have our David Koreshs and Jim Joneses, but they're not praised as "freedom fighters" or "liberators." They were muderous nutballs. I am, btw. neither Jewish nor Christian. But here are a few Sura quotations that don't instill the feeling that Islam is very peaceful. And those just scratch the surface. Regarding infidels, they are the Muslim’s “undoubted enemies” (Sura 4:101) Besiege them and lie in ambush everywhere” for them. (Sura 9:5) Seize them and slay them wherever you find them. (Sura 4:90). Strike off the head of the infidels. Cut off every finger tip (Sura 8:12) If a Muslim does not go to war, Allah will punish him (Sura 9:39). Believers, make war on the infidels who are your neighbors and let them find you rigorous. (Sura 9:123). Be ruthless to unbelievers (Sura 48:29). Kill any person you wish if it be a “just cause” (ANYONE! ) (Sura 6:152) Anyone who fights against Allah or renounces Islam in favor of another religion shall be put to death or crucified or have their hands and feet cut off alternative sides (Sura 5:34). Let not those who disbelieve suppose that they can overcome. They cannot escape. Make ready for them all you can by armed force Surah 8 (59-60). “Take not Jews and Christians for friends. They are friends to one another. He among you who takes them for friends is one of them.” Surah 5:51 The next link, too, is an interesting collection of information, . http://www.prophetofdoom.net/chapter.aspx?g=401&i=41003 http://www.faithfreedom.org/ Would you like for me to post some excerpts from "Obsession?" I'm sure, though, it's all just propaganda.
25. #9 Fadi - It is just one more symptom of Arab/Moslem Barbari
Fasulia Hudra   (11.26.06)
Fadi, This is just one more classic example of the barbarity of Arabs/Moslems. 1. Female Genital Mutilation is beyond criminal and THERE IS ABSOLUTELY NO DEFENSE OR JUSTIFICATION - PERIOD.!!!! Note that the article states 60% of women in north Iraq. 2. Look at Moslem traditions of assasinations and most recently in Lebanon. Assasinations and murders are considered and acceptable alternative to voting. 3. How about the lack of respect for holy places? The Arabs/Moslems destroyed the 3000 yr old Budha in Afghanistan, the Shiite Gold Dome Mosque, countless churches, and Jewish holy places. Today the WAQF in Jerusalem are digging clandestinely trying to destroy any Jewish taces from their area in the Moslem quarter. 4. How about Arab/Moslems murdering their sisters and daughter to restore "The Family Honor". Some honor that family has. 5. How about distributing toys in Gaza depicting the airplanes striking the WTC? 6. How about giving out candy to children after suicide bombings and terrorist attacks/ 7. How about the teaching of hatreds in the school text books and Madrassa? 8. One could write an encyclopedia and the crazinesses of Iran and Ahmadenejad's reign of terror. Denying the holocaust, purging all the people that don't agree with him, etc. 9. The terrorism that includes beheading, Afghani custom of cutting off of the right arm and left leg. 10. Public executions, etc. Fadi, Arabs and Moslems have adequately demonstrated their barbarism to the world and as such deserve no respect or consideration until they learn to first treat their women properly, treat others with dignity, and learn some semblance of humanity. Until then they are barbarians who are stuck in the 8th century and going full gas in reverse.
26. Libneniyyeh on who are not Muslims.
sk ,   USA   (11.26.06)
"those people are not Muslims. Just like Jews who slaughter innocent people and say, "oh well, they will grow to be terrorists" are NOT Jews." Sorry, Libneniyyeh, that won't do. First of all, I won't accept the parallelism that you suggest (comparing Jews with Muslims), as Jews are only rarely guilty of deliberately slaughtering innocents and certainly haven't created a culture and society dedicated to doing so. All countries throw off nutcases; that is not the issue. (There is a reason Baruch Goldstein can easily be cited here -- he is a rarity and thus stands out.) Second, Jews who are terrorists ARE Jews, and I don't know of any Jew who would deny this. And Muslims who are terrorists ARE Muslims. Let's leave aside all the support that the Koran and Hadith provide for terrorism. Who are you, Libneniyyeh, to decide on who is a Muslim? If you want to argue that certain interpretations of your texts are more valid, feel free. But don't expect anyone to buy that "Ahmed is not a Muslim" BS.
27. #24 - M. Hartley
Sabientje ,   Weston, Florida   (11.26.06)
WOW! If only more of these "Suras" could be read by the whole world, we would begin to understand the carnage and murderous mentality of Muslims! No wonder they aim to kill and destroy Christians, Jews and other people of various beliefs. These monstruos Muslims are taught the most heinous crimes and sadly for the world we see them each day carrying out those "Suras" even amongst themselves...i.e. Iraq with Shiias killing Sunnis and vice versa. Thank you M. Hartley sharing such in depth observation as to why Islam is considered and "evil" religion. It makes sense that the Pope would quote a Persian scholar about the savageness and evilness of Islam! May our G-d punish them with all the misery that they now enjoy and may their children's children continue to be cursed in the world as they are now. Amen!
28. 20
Libneniyyeh ,   Lebanon   (11.26.06)
In Lebanon Muslim women wont get persecuted for dancing.In Lebanon some of my best friends are Christians. In Lebanon we open our doors for each other, we eat from each others' food, we shelter each other. We have our quarrels but at the end of the day most of us look out for each other. I am far from being a saint, but still, I hate it when people misrepresent my religion, and it makes me so angry that so many people in the world are twisting its image. How quick people are to make conclusions. The point I wish to make is that all people should be willing to learn and to read and to see truth, before they jump to conclusions.
29. Number 24
Libneniyyeh ,   Lebanon   (11.26.06)
Ms Hartley, I opened these links and did not bother to stoop to read beyond the first few lines. And not because I am too righteous to read such writings, but because it is written by someone whose credibility, at first glance, is sorely lacking. I am sure you have been to school, and perhaps university, and I am sure the first thing ur profs warned u of was not to resort to online research unless ur sure its a credible source of info. I can defend each and every statement the idiot creator of the website u sent has made. And i am ready to do so. If you really have the desire to learn (which somehow I doubt you do, judging from where you look for ur info) then I can refer u to a number of credible and relaible sources, and a lot of them not only by Arab Muslims but western Muslims. Where I am studying here in the west I come across so many westerners who are converts to Islam, who see its truth and beauty. Ask urself why there are so many converts. You say u are neither jewish nor christian, that is fine. I did not ask what religion u were, only what to address u, as man or woman. Anyways, Im not trying to convert you, it would be a waste of my time. I am trying to make u see that u have to really understand something before u attempt to criticize it.
30. EVIDENCE YOU SAY?
LEE ,   NY, USA   (11.26.06)
Here's a clip from Kuwait. This will link you directly to evidence of your religion's practice. Your own people, your own language. Let me know if you need more. http://switch5.castup.net/frames/20041020_MemriTV_Popup/video_480x360.asp?ai=214&ar=1090wmv&ak=null#
Next talkbacks
Back to article