News
Solution to Baghdad violence: pressure on J'lem
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 30.11.06, 02:19
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
82 Talkbacks for this article
61. To american corrupt advisers
gil ,   ashkelon   (11.30.06)
Take your GI's back to yr country and let us alone.
62. You can't feel Jewish??That's a new one for me!
Steven Wilson ,   Anchorage, Alaska   (11.30.06)
I asked one of my Jewish female friends how she got to Israel if she didn't know where Australia was on a map. She told me,"I got on the plane...and I landed here!" She told me,"I don't believe in God." So I asked, "How can you be a Jew, if you don't believe in God? I mean, God said that you were a Jew. If there isn't a God, then he could never have said you were a Jew in the first place." Her answer was," It's just a feeling!" This is the honest truth. Rabbi Mark S. Diamond might have to explain this to all of my non religious Jewish friends. It's not a feeling? That's funny. What can a non religious Jew fall back on?
63. # 24
Milo Perez ,   Tijeras, USA   (11.30.06)
I agree w/you totally, Israel must not give in to pressure from the USA and must keep all buffer-zones intact. Look how the so-called peace-maker Egypt has let arms smuggling go unnoticed through Rafah. Bush, should realize how dangerous giving up more territory to Syria is not the answerl.
64. NO CONSESSIONS!
Mark ,   Carlsbad, USA   (11.30.06)
Please ISRAEL DO NOT LISTEN TO A WORD THE USA SAYS. YOU DO NOT HAVE TO GIVE UP ANYTHING! WHY WOULD YOU EVEN ENTERTAIN THE THOUGHT OF LISTENING TO A COUNTRY WHO CANT EVEN RUN THEIR OWN WAR & COUNTRY? YOU SAW WHAT HAPPENED WHEN YOU LET THE USA GOVERN YOUR WAR WITH LEBANON. TELL CODELISA RICE TO TAKE HER INEPT & INANE RHETORIC AND SPEW IT ELSE WHERE. YOU DONT OWE THE USA OR ANYONE ELSE A THING! STAY STRONG AND MORAL. FIGHT LIKE ONLY YOU KNOW HOW. GOD IS WITH YOU . YOU CAN NOT BE BEAT! KEEP WHAT YOU HAVE SO BRAVELY WON!
65. Hani 55, 56, 57 You live in the past. Join reality.
Marwan Khoury ,   Montreal   (11.30.06)
From your comments it is clear that you do not even recognize Israel's right to exist, just like many of the so-called Arab nationalists who continue to blame all of the Arab world's problems on Israel and the Jews. Israel is a reality whether you like it or not. It's a viable state, the only democracy in the Middle East with respect for all of its citizens, unlike most of Arab countries. I am an Arab realist. I know that the Arabs will never destroy Israel and will do much better by making peace, RECOGNIZING its right to exist in peace and learn from its success in economy and culture. I want the Palestinians to prosper, as I do want my native Lebanon to succeed. Useless wars, non-stop violence in their name will lead to nothing but more suffering. Only offer of a true peace will lead to a prosperous Middle East. Look at Jordan and the benefits it reaped since signing peace with Israel. Maybe you've been spending way too much time at coffee houses debating with guilt-ridden Canadians or watching Al-Jazeera. I, on the other hand, have been to Lebanon and my opinion is shared by many, many Lebanese (Christians, Druze, Sunni and Shia). They want to co-exist with Israel, not be the battleground for the insane leadership of Iran and Syria.
66. Hani. Recognize that your hate will lead you nowhere
Marwan Khoury مسيحي ,   Montreal   (11.30.06)
Read what Walid Shoebat (former member of PLO) says. He argues that parallels exist between radical Islam and Nazism. He says, "Secular dogma like Nazism is less dangerous than Islamofascism that we see today ... because Islamofascism has a religious twist to it; it says 'God the Almighty ordered you to do this'.... It is trying to grow itself in fifty-five Muslim states. So potentially, you could have a success rate of several Nazi Germany's, if these people get their way." He also says, "No one (Arab or Jew) has a 'right of return'. Jews who fled Arab persecution from 1948 to 1956 should have no right of return to Arab lands, and Arabs who ran away in 1948 and 1967 should have no right of return either. This should end all argument. Yet the Jews accept this judgment, while the Arabs reject EVERYTHING." By the way I am a Lebanese from a long line of Khoury (priests) in the northern and central Lebanon. If you know anything about Lebanon, sounds like you don't, you would recognize that its a Christian Lebanese name. صلى الله عليه وسلم
67. To Pres G W Bush. Iranian Regime Is Becoming More DARING.
Maansingh ,   The Netherlands   (11.30.06)
Pressure "Israel to .. (improve) the situation in Iraq"? It has been proven NOW that the Iranian Regime has trained and armed Shia-militia's of Iraq. President Bush, you are trying to establish democracy in Iraq - while the Iranian Regime is trying to undermine the Iraqi civil society by encouraging sectarian violence. Due to the impending development of Nuclear Bombs - the Iranian Regime is becoming more and more DARING. This Iranian behaviour has to be STOPPED - by taking away those nuclear facilities capable of developing nuclear bombs. Conclusion: the USA has now the RIGHT to bomb those above delineated facilities. WHY USA has the right ?? Because USA is trying to establish democracy in Iraq - and the Iranian Regime is going against that. BTW the above delineated facilities should be BOMBED as soon as possible. The sooner the better. BTW if the above delineated facilities ARE taken out - Iran will NO longer feel invincible - and thus Iran WILL back down from Iraq. So, President Bush, there is NO need to pressure Israel. By dealing with Iran in the abovementioned way - you WILL get assistance of Arab countries "in improving the situation in Iraq".
68. Middle East needs a comprehensive solution
expert   (11.30.06)
It may be difficult for a Westerner to understand but the reality is this: PARTIAL solutions are WORTHLESS. That's also why the Gaza withdrawal was worthless. It could have been a good beginning, but standing alone, it was like hopping on a bicycle and then stopping pedalling. There must be a comprehensive solution. Or the region will be totally destroyed in the near future. To Israel and Palestinians: at the core of your solution must lie the trading of East Jerusalem for the right of return. You don't seem to see it, but most of the world understands this. Think about it.
69. Another lost left winger... Too bad..
freedom ,   canada   (11.30.06)
Open your eyes and see this for what it is.. Israels sacrifice. Do you give squatters legal possession of land.. Would you let a squatter take control of your house. Now think about that.
70. 25 Now you are p@@@@@@ me off.
freedom ,   canada   (11.30.06)
Grow up and move to Hamastan. Kind sounds like their rhetoric..
71. 29 Media critic do the arabs and christians exist in peace.
Freedom ,   canada   (11.30.06)
Or was I imagining the burning of five christian churches in the west bank.. Need a compass. Ive got one for you.
72. 30 Sounds kind of two faced to me. Are you
freedom ,   canada   (11.30.06)
saying squatting on land actually legitimizes possession.. Interesting theory you have. But wrong.. of course..
73. 54 Actually youre wrong from a legal standpoint.
freedom ,   canada   (11.30.06)
But then again when has Hamas ever cared about legalities. Hey Hani, what did you think about the five christian churches being burned in the west bank.. Dont you think Bethlehem should be returned to its rightful owner. The christians, surely you can see the logic can you not????
74. Hani. You have to stop blindly following every Arab cause
Marwan Khoury ,   Montreal   (11.30.06)
We can only prosper as Arab nations when we realize that the path of nationalism will lead us nowhere. When we stop fooling ourselves by thinking that if only Israel ceased to exist it would make everyone's lives better. That's a failed ideology and will lead to continous recrimination, self-victimization and unrealized potential. Learn from Israel. The Jews survived the biggest injustice in the history of human kind and instead of continuing to be hateful and feel like a constant victim they built a country from scratch. Don't tell me that what the Arabs had in the pre-Israel time was a country. There were a few villages and towns with nothing by agricultural economy and depended on the British for everything. The Arabs who stayed in Israel are more part of Israel's society than their brotheren who fled and still live in squalor in Lebanon, Jordan and other places. I wish my Palestinian brotheren a better luck than be stuck in the 50-year-old past that very few actually remember. Finally, just because I don't share your self-destructive hate, does not make me any less of an Arab or Lebanese. Its those, arabs, which I presume you are, who have lived outside of the Middle East for a long time who don't understand the reality on the ground and prefer to grab on a nationalist cause without any real knowledge, only so they can still have their identity. How sad that the only way you can define yourself is by being a hateful, facts-denying racist. Comment triste que la seule voie vous puissiez vous définir est étant un raciste détestable.
75. #64 2-VIABLE States solution only way out...
Hani   (11.30.06)
...for now
76. #65 Leik Habibi
Hani ,   Montreal, Canada   (11.30.06)
I was in Lebanon in July prior to the events, and I've visited Lebanon many times since 2000. I am not a typical Palestinian, I befriend Christians, druze (my best friend), and Shi'ite muslims alike. My hang-out is Jounieh. I've spoken to many Lebanese about the whole situation. Sure they resent the PLO, Iran, Syria, and America for making Lebanon the battlefield it is today. That's unfortunate. HOwever the vast majority of them knew that the common ennemy is Israel - the Middle East's prime destablizing bully, stockpiler of nuclear weapons, and founded on illegal immigration and expulsion of the native Palestinians. Otherwise, would there have been a PLO and the refugees today in Lebanon? Let's be honest here, neither Jordan or Egypt have peace with Israel. Those agreements are nothing more but cold documents stashed away in some safe box. Even Israelis recognize that today. I think rather than bashing Arabs for not accepting "reality" (Mind you we Arabs have our share of shortcomings), you should see also address the injustices which linger on....Perhaps addressing the human angle of all this would result in peace. PS. How many MOSSAD agents operate in Lebanon today?
77. Give the Iraqi terrorists nothing
MichaelF ,   Silver Spring MD USA   (11.30.06)
When it comes to Israel, the only thing of interest to any Iraqi is Israel's destruction. This goes for our enemies and our "friends." The Iraqi government is made up of Iranian puppets and agent. The PM, President and Minister of State all have Hazbollah connections. To hell with them!
78. Decline of Israel
Yellowbirdwoman ,   Rapid City USA   (11.30.06)
Israel will self-destruct. Time is on the side of the indigenous of the lands.
79. 71 Freedom!!!! you are being misguided
Media Critic ,   USA   (11.30.06)
Reconciliation is a noble idea. The Palestinians have been either displaced or under occupation, oppression and depression for almost 60 years. Retaliation is the only method they know how to relief there mental depression, they cannot blame them selves for this because they do not see it that way. The problem is that they are not the only group in the conflict that are blinded by the dust that surrounds them but the Israelis are also blinded because of lack of trust of the people that surrounds them, it is a viscous cycle that will never ends until and external force comes in to the rescue. http://www.threefaithsonegod.com/
80. When US returns NY to Indians, Alaska to Russia
Umm El Kul Naqba   (12.01.06)
Sure, Right after USA returns Manhattan to the Indians, Alaska to Russia, California to Mexico, and the Louisiana purchase to France
81. #74
Wes ,   Canada   (12.01.06)
why are you and hani here in canada if you love your arab world so much,please explain,why is any arab or muslim here,it just does not make sense?
82. 80-
(12.05.06)
het moron- that was centuries ago- and that didnt make it right anyway- its just too bad for you jews that you cant make that your excuse for stealing land- you dumb dumb thing.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article