you may laugh all you want. you may believe whatever you wish. however, your laughter or beliefs still do not change the historical facts on the ground, written by scholars of unsemountable knowledge and insight into the arab/israeli conflict and the origin of palestinians and jews. no, you are not educated. only educated as far as your belief system alows you to be. please listen to all talkbacks here. it's the best education as to the tgruth you'll ever get, asuming you know how to read, think, reason, and deduce. then, go on to major rspected universities around the world dealing with mid east studies (i am a professor in one very highly respected ivy league institution in the mid east department) and pick up a book or attend a lecture to find out how limited and abhoringly simplistic your logic and arguments are, in fact. i am not surprised that you, being a muslim and an israeli arab living in haifa, still live there, enjoying the wonderful country the jews have provided for you. haifa is gorgeous. and you are free. well, free enough to express your unfounded opinions as fact. if your reasoning wasn't pathetic and if you were one of my students, you'd get an f for general knowledge, never mind this knowledge you profess to have such expertise in. and no, i am not of jewish birth by any means. just an emeritus professor that knows the facts as they are on the ground and of which you have no clue, religiously nor biblically. our esteemed professor, dr. dershowitz would indeed have a great time holding a debate with you. then all of us at this wonderful institution can have the LOL you so insist you have on our account.

Ahmet atilla Karagözoğlu your written can bother even a corpse. For G'd sake, Keep your mouth closed!

I've asked you for permission to copy your written showed in Ynetnews. I got no answer. I'm saving them on my Hard-Disk. If you will not give me permission I'll delete them. Shalom

if you want to fight for the palestinian Arabs, go and live among them. The one thing that "ties them all" is their refusal to accept the reality of Israel and make permanent peace with their non-Muslim neighbors. This includes both Jews AND Christians.

oh, i read rashid khalidi many times. after all, i use his so called rhetoric and "historical explanations" text to make sure my students are in full comprehension of how arabs such as khalidi lied to the "so called arabs who call themselves palestinians" for many many years. but then again, one believes what one wishes to regardless of historical facts and broad doccumentation. i suggest you read other books that were written in response to your esteemed khalidi so that you can judge and review the present conflict in a more articulate and intellectual light. yes, i also live in israel some of the month where i teach at university there as well. and believe me, i am much more educated than yourself regarding these issues. unfortunatelly, to draw a good informed conclusion regarding any topic of conflict, one must examine both sides of the coin so that they can talk about it factually and intellectually, based on truth, not fiction, and definitly not on what your convoluted arab historians tell you.

Atilla, please examine your own gramar -"you written"........???

he is the BEST!!!

wish there were more like him on Ynet!

The way to hell is paved with good intentions

Take him to you

Sorry. It should be writings instead of written.

Jesus will prevail, I'm just sorry for all who spiritual blinded w/ HATE and will be lost.

"the way to hell." It's not only your grammar and grasp of idioms that need improvement, but also your negative attitude. Give it a rest, why don't you?

Israel should never have given up the spot for a mosque. It was a gesture of good faith as Israel was formed. It has been thrown back in the Israeli's faces. They should doze the mosque and build the Third Temple.

English isn't my mother language, so I'm forgiven for such mistakes. In my language much more rich than english, way is more abrangent than road. Unlike of you I'm not a coward, I have a name. Haven't you one? Say what you want, Attila has a bothering speech. See, I'm not saying he is bad I'm saying he is bothering.

Sefer Tehillim LaYahweh (Psalm) 122:1-9 1 We were glad when they said to us; Let us go into The House of Yahweh! 2 Our feet will stand within your gates, O Yerusalem. 3 Yerusalem is built as a city which is compact together; 4 Where the tribes go up, the tribes of Yahweh, as a testimony commanded for Israyl, to give thanks to the Name of Yahweh! 5 For thrones are set there for judgment, the thrones of the house of David. 6 Pray for the PEACE OF YERUSALEM! May they have peace who love you! 7 Peace be within your walls, and blessings be within your palaces! 8 For the sake of our brothers and our friends, we will now say; PEACE be within you! 9 For the sake of the House of Yahweh our Father, we PRAY FOR YOUR PEACE!

i have given you permission. i wrote to you before saying it is ok. i guess ynet didn't publish my talkback to you at that time. i hope it does so now. your english isn't that bad. good luck to you!

important except to criticize Atilla. Just what don't you like about what he says? At least he tried to make a point about peace. You just make a point excusing your bad your grammar. You can't even bother to capitalize "English," and that has NOTHING to do with language fluency. If you don't want to be bothered by Atilla, then don't read his comments, but please stop bothering everybody else with your empty remarks.

Kindly don't talk for everyone. Farias doesn't bother me. Don't they have free speech where you live? Take a bit of your own advice. If you don't like what Farias writes or the way he writes, don't read it.

Born Again, Spiritual believers in Jesus Christ , Are the living temple of Christ Jesus. Gal 2:20 Robert USA.

Nice try. Your ancestors tried to wipe us off of the map and you are still trying. They did not succeed and neither will you.