G-d said said he would lengthen your days in the land that He swore to give to you, but you would deny the children entry there. If non-Jews are received get it straight about who a Jew is. Whether or not they abolish the Law of Return, every Jew has an unalienable right to enter and live in the land that G-d gave his fathers.

I have been addressing this with Charles from PT on the "Ederly " T/B. Law of return definition of a Jew added; who is not a member of another religion (political religious) Of course Israel can determine for themselves who or how they want to allow into their country. But if defines who is a Jew, then these = Israel.

I'm suspicious. Derfner and London sound equally idiotic. That can't be a coincidence.

You was one of the writers whom articles I always read .Now because of your completely incometent analyse of the real situation I don't rely on your knowledge in any other field.Shame.I made alia from Russia in 1991 with all members all my family except 2 brothers of my grandmother who were murdered in pogroms and 44members of family who were killed by nazis ,most of them in concentration camps,mostly in Treblinca.my grandmother in hers 20th was activist of zionist movement which brouth her to soviet union prison for a short time ,but obvioslly so terrible that she stopped talking about this period untill end of her life.My parients tried to make alia in 1974,but weren't permitted to live Soviet Union untill Gorbachev came to power,my family typical secular jews ,only me married to non jew who is much more patriot of the State that many Israelis,my douther did army service,working now as nurse and studing in university.I 'm midwife and inspite of very difficult period of adaptation always felt proud Israeli.Among my friends many mixed families and I admire non jewish members of these families even more than jews desided to make alia for making this hard decision to leave everything in they country, in they life... and to come to this country and to share not simple life with jews.All children of my friends made army service in spite of that their pariends didn't convert because to fill Israeli ,to be Israeli it is note same with being religios(don't forget that this country beild secular jews ,many of them have been Russians from same zionist movement of my grandma) stop alia of mixed famylies and country after a while won't have army,We'll have predominant population grouth from religios and arab sectors,majority of both of them don't serve in army with all my respect to to these sectors this is a fact,so after a while the State will fall down without any help of Islamic fanatics.Having so clever ministers we don't need enemy. And having many native Israelis voices like yours helps to destroy Zionism and future of our country. sophia , israel (02.24.09) Recommend

please,don't fool yourself.The fact that you read Ynet proves That Israel is not foreing country to you and with all pain to be jew you fill that Israelis your people