News
Beilin calls Hebron Jews ‘deluded’
Tal Rabinovsky
Published: 17.04.07, 20:43
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
87 Talkbacks for this article
1. “Go home crazies!”
(04.17.07)
they are at home
2. evacuate Beillin
moish ,   Jerusalem   (04.17.07)
I would support a bill calling for evacuation of Beillin and the rest of the oslo criminals. Beiilin should join Bishara in some arab country and take his mentor senile old Persky too,
3. evacuate the gerbil from beillin's tochas
willy ,   Israel   (04.17.07)
4. Beilin- another malignant tumor in the Israeli body.
LEE ,   NY, USA   (04.17.07)
5. The third riech would have love to have him.
Jew from Israel ,   Jerusalem Israel   (04.17.07)
6. Beilin's hatred knows no bounds. Shame!
(04.17.07)
7. PEACE'S FIGHTER
abeer fakhri ,   jordan   (04.17.07)
DR.BEILIN YOU ARE A HERO, ALL RESPECT
8. I'm reading "The Seventh Million"
Student   (04.17.07)
and I'm sick at learning how Leftist Jews in Israel acted with such lack of compassion towards their fellow Jews during the Holocaust years. I recommend this book to wipe out all illusions about the Jewish Left. I know I'm going to receive replies to the contrary. That's fair. They were not 100% bad. Still, there is no excuse, no excuse whatsoever, for their lack of compassion during those years. Please read that book and weep.
9. "Come home Brothers"
avramele   (04.17.07)
Beilin never gets it that the true left zionist understands that even the residents of Hebron deserve to be free citizens in their own land (west of the green line). the rocks of Judea and Samaria may be part of all our collective memory but our future together is a Jewish and democratic state with a stable Jewish majority. v'shavu banim l'gvulam returning our sons to their borders can be interpreted lovingly in more than one way. Shame on Beilin and other arrogant leftists for uttering hate not realism.
10. Thanx Yossie - we appreciate your efforts
A Bethlehemite   (04.17.07)
Thanks for having the cojones to expose these wackos..
11. Evacuate bellin NOW!
Israel   (04.17.07)
12. The only "deluded" one is you Beilin!
Effi ,   Ramat Gan, Israel   (04.17.07)
13. Beilin came to make war
Amir ,   Beer Sheva   (04.17.07)
Remember how Beilin, Bishara, Peace Now and Hadash were trying to get some bloodshed a few week ago by telling Arabs that this is "their house". When there was no attacks on Jews, Beilin-Meretz-Hadash-Peace now were desperate for Jewish blood and sent Beilin to ask Arabs for actions against Jews.
14. Is Beilin Jewish? Was his mother a Jew?
David E. ,   Jerusalem   (04.17.07)
This self-hating Jew - if he indeed is - wouldn't mind evacuating all Jews from all of Israel and give it away to the arabs. Would he, like his friends, also want the Jews thrown into the sea?
15. Beilin has no problem stealing property
Steve ,   USA   (04.17.07)
B"H He figures that if he can offer legislation to steal homes that this is somehow moral. It is not any more moral if a State commits a crime verus an individual. The State faces collective punishment for its crimes as we plainly see in Sderot today. Beilin is a firm supporter of stealing Jewish property without due compensation. If he were honest, he would call for those currently not compensated according to the law to receive due compensation first instead of using the legislation method to steal, whereby the State does not follow its own laws but instead sets false expections for those it lords over. He further calls Hebron a new settlement when it has been established for Jews longer than Israel as a State has. As for interviews with those claiming ill-treatment, I think Beilin has some very ill treatment to offer that is far greater than any of the so-called suffering claims mentioned. Bear in mind that these claims mentioned are part of a highly-coordinated public relations stunt, where Beilin is provided state security to facilitate his stealing. For instance of the ill-treatment Beilin issues, if a Jew called out to expell the entire Arab population of Hebron, would not that be considered a greater suffering than a tough day at the grocery store? And yet Beilin is not somehow seen in the same light, as someone who is calling for the purge of an entire population. But he is just that bad in my eyes for his recent actions and words. His funding comes from foreign countries in Europe even though he is simultaneously on the public dole and there is no investigation at public levels of this corruption. But I have looked into it and it is quite deep. How could Israel permit such a traitor to proceed without facing dark consequences? Quote: “Spy, foreign agent! You’re pals with Bishara!” Marzel shouted, in an attempt to disrupt Beilin’s visit.
16. Beilin is my new hero
sharon ,   Raanana   (04.17.07)
What a great man!
17. Beilin - You Are Finished
Reuven Brauner ,   Raanana, Israel   (04.17.07)
Hours ago we read that Mr. Beilin had come out against giving the Arabs guns - and we praised him for finally coming to his senses or so we thought. The sun has barely set and we now read of this evil man's sinister designs and his slander against the residents of Hebron. Our Sages once said that a person delegitimizes his fellow with that very blemish he himself has (Kol Haposel B'Mumo Posel). Mr. Beilin calls a Jew "crazy", then it just that which is what he is. (It takes one to know one.) But more than that is his fervently anti-Jewish attitude. He blames the Jews for everything. We need him among us? If I had the authority, I would disqualify Mr. Beilin from the ranks of the Jewish people. He is a living example of the evil Rasha in our recently read Hagada. I am fed up with him. Yossi - you are OUT.
18. no need to evacuate jews from hebron
papa jay   (04.17.07)
pull the israeli army out and see how many last unprotected. whats the ratio again, 400 settlers in the middle of 150,000 palestinians. occupying one more house wont do a damn thing. i'd say the jews in that city have 150,000 problems to deal with.
19. Beilin, You Haven't Got A Chance Nor A Clue
Adina Kutnicki   (04.17.07)
The ONLY deluded one here is Beilin who STILL believes that Oslo was a good idea. I wonder how many in his family died at the murderous hands of his 'peaceful' Pals? He should be aware that the days of listening to anti Jewish Jews in Israel is over. Anyone who had doubts before about 'peace' are mostly seeing the light and are essentially cured after Gazastan emerged and Hizbullah rocketed the north. Beilin is one of the few holdouts. My bet is on Marzel and his 'Jews'.
20. #14 - David - Jewish mother
Fifty Percent   (04.17.07)
Being Jewish is ultimately a matter of what you believe in and what you feel rather than your percentage of Jewish blood. Personally, I'm only 50% Jewish and on my father's side, but I feel more Jewish and love Israel more than many of those who claim full ancestry. There are many examples of those who are 100% Jewish but who don't hesitate to betray other Jews and to work against Israel's best interests.
21. #15 Steve - Why is he permitted such conduct?
Jake   (04.17.07)
Because he does the dirty work for a lot of other MKs and the PM, both he and the other traitors in Peace Now. That's why he is tolerated. Just like some banana republics have squads to do the government's dirty work, Israel has Peace Now.
22. Dr. Beilin chooses hate
mordechai ,   jerusalem   (04.17.07)
Instead of coming to Hebron to communicate with fellow Israelis in regard to a great difference of opinion, Dr. Beilin , again, chooses to incite violence against fellow jews.
23. Beilin
Nachum ,   Jerusalem   (04.17.07)
This little fragile Beilin and his ilk are more dangerous to the Jewish people and Pharo+Haman+Chmelnitsky+Hitler+Stalin+Arafat+Akhmadejad. I would add: May his name be blotted out, but he is still a Jew and deserves repentance.
24. When we get a Jewish gov't,ball less bailin
jason white ,   afula,israel   (04.17.07)
will be jailed for supporting the enemy.
25. One sane Jew
Ossanassa ,   Nigeria   (04.17.07)
What ever you may say about Israel, there are some sane people. "Go home crazies", they should listen and start packing, they will have to leave sooner or later anyhow. How can the state just allow for this to happen, isn't there a legal body in Israel and if then how come they allow for these crazies to make life terrible for the population?
26. Beilin
Avraham ,   NYC   (04.17.07)
Beilin is such a hypocrite. To Arabs, he's the same settler as the rest of 5.3 mln Jews residing in Israel. There is no difference between Hebron and Tel Aviv in that respect. Moreover, while King David reigned in Hebron for the first seven years of his kingdom, do you know that the site of Ramat Aviv, a home to much of Israeli leftist elite was built on the site of an Arab village (Sheikh Munis, I believe). Were Beilin to be honest, he'd pack up and leave Israel and leave the nation-building to those Jews who know the Land of Israel is theirs by right.
27. enough with the attacks on beilin
Peter ,   Toronto Canada   (04.17.07)
The viciousness of the Israeli rights attacks on Beilin speak to a real problem in Israeli society. The fact is that agree with him or not, Beilin has done more for the survival of the Jewish state than almost anyone in Israel. It is not a state of Historic Israel, but he seeks a stable, defineable, legitimate and self perpetuating state that can be achieved and accepted by a broader community than just Israelis. Though I do not always agree with him, you are dillusional if you think Israel will ever no peace without something akin to the geneva accord as the solution.
28. Beilin is a racist
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (04.17.07)
Isn't that what you would call a politician who demanded the removal of all Arabs from Tel Aviv?
29. Go Yossi Go
Nachman   (04.17.07)
Yes go to Gaza to your Pal friends. Leave the Jews and the Jewish land alone. Hevron by all accounts belongs to the Jews. If Hevron is in question then Tel Aviv is in question. Go to the Gaza and take Peretz and Olmert with you and be traded for Shalit.
30. I Smell Stalinism!
David ,   Israel   (04.17.07)
Referring to people whose politics differ from yours as "deluded" is a quick two-step towards medicating political dissidents. Welcome to the Soviet Russia of Beilin's dreams.
Next talkbacks
Back to article