no it dosent fit well in my mind...just thinking ? many quetion ! help pls explain ............who exactly are this group of Rabbis ? Are they from the college of Ort Rabbinate or not ?

They should start their book with a list of every Knesset Member that voted for Disengagement. It will make it easier to try them later.

He brings awareness to the failed expulsions to the nadir state we have gotten into just because of the fire sale of Israel. We are considered puppets with no determination We are dictated to as to what we have to do. The lucky thing is that the arabs are not accepting our appeasment. Kol Hakovod to Rabbi Volpo and Chabad.

And they should not forget to include the rabbis who supported the expulsions. Many soldiers consulted with them and they were told to go ahead. And as #32 Edgar says, start with the Knesset. Make the list as complete as possible. The evacuations were a shameful act and some talkbackers seem too particular about the religious nuances of this faction, and not outraged enough about the evacuations themselves. If they don't like this group, why don't they start a movement to create a record of what happened during the expulsions and by whom. Future generations will demand to know why a pogrom was allowed to take place in Israel.

I assume this extremists view it OK for the JEW who killed Rabin, right? Pathetic.

The IDF has been facing terrorist from the Front now these Rabbi want to terrorise the IDF Soldiers ? Now listen the IDF soldiers were also BROKEN in THIER HEARTS executing the disengagement PLan. Go get that OLMERT, PERETZ and the BUnch of Kadima's, those are the real culprits ! The Current IDF Generals and the former Chief Of STAFF. Wait till the Winogret come out, you will know the culprits : (

You are walking on a very thin line! If you'll hurt even one Zahal soldier - you'll feel the rage of the secular majority.

But wait, we live in Israel...who knows what democratic means? I think I saw it on TV once.

Ynetnews.com looks like a sect for "soldiers who follow orders according to the law". You did not heard this before, did you?

is talking

There was no greater Chillul Hashem in the history of Israel, than the expulsion of these 10,000 Jews from their Jewish homes in the Jewish homeland. This will be forever be remembered for its cruelty just like the expulsion of the Jews in 1492. People from chutz le'aretz were telling me that TEARS were flowing FROM GOYIM watching it on TV. What a chillul Hashem!

Just to set the record straight, Mr Volpo does not represent anything from Chabad or its associates, he has been asked many times to stop his extreme behavior (even at times the idea he is doing is correct at times) he himself is a disqluafied person, the idea and the movement he has started is a just cause and it’s a good idea, but should that be coming from Chabad? Chabad official’s will tell you loud and clear, he has NO connection with us. Apparently the Lubavitcher Rebbe ZT”L many times as well gave him some stern responses to questions or actions he did during the Rebbi’s lifetime (u can confirm that) , and now after 1994 after the passing, he is no longer on a leash, the animal has gone wild. Someone needs to contain him, he has a few friends that help him, and they as well should be contained. Let him call it something else, but please Press, please stop mentioning its Chabad, just say “some new group has arisen from nowhere”…or think of something else, Chabad does not want its work of the holy Rebbe in the trash because of a few people like him and his henchman mainly from Tzfat!

so why they have such a strong opinion about all this? If they want settlements to not be evacuated then they should join army and help to guard them with their lives like we have to do Its very easy to talk. To do action is more difficult. Let them help first, with action, to guard the places with their lives, then they can talk as much they want. שלום

who do nothing for the construction of our country , who have their friends going to kiss the iranian president , who tell the people that the reform Judaism was the cause of the Shoa , again all those hate filled faces we've seen in our capital's streets , they , all those extreme black headed people want to go against the law . And others who support them , sad . How can they then ask that we , seculars have to support them , that we have to be tolerant ? Shame on all of them .

By writing "seculars" you imply that you want to attack us Chareidim for what this idiot is doing. Please be aware that Chabad in general and Wolpe's group in particular has been vomited out from the Chareidi world. This guys are total drop-outs, rejected from nearly the entire Chareidi world. That applies to most of Chabad-Lubavitch but to these guys even more so.

AND they serve in the army too as the Rabbi demanded

Who gave you the authority to authorize or reject Rabbi Volpo. I have read many of Rabbi Volpos sefarim (that incidentlly have the Hascomas of great Talidai Chachomim across the spectrum) I find him very knoledegable in Torah in general and specially in shlaimus Haaretz. Rabbi Volpo has a lot of fans in Chabad Just look at the events he arranges so stop your nonesense about Rabbi Volpo.

just ask anyone from the chabad headquaters in Israel or the US. no one has the authroity to talk in the name of Chabad other than the people up the top and they said he is no good. call them yourself. dont put false news online! he may have written good books, but so did many people in germany know how to sing and write and then kill jews. im not comparing, but please dont write that because he knows how to write nicley and he has some signatures of some "Rabbis" he is Kosher. he is NOT and Chabad does NOT accept him, he is an outcast!!!

I know it very well , but it were also the same black wearing people . And to 51 : you are probably ashamed of your writing , for not giving your name , you are right , you have to be ashamed , not me

What is his swinish activity if not public shameless lashon ha'ra against other Jews. He's not a rabbi.

those -pretend jews- hari krishna fools dressed in black are becoming quite a bundle to handle. their lunatic religious beliefs are a sore and blasphemy. those among them who disown this judeo nazi bearded goggle eyes idiot do so only to try to salvage the flow of money from jewish fools that keeps those parasites alive. they are not any better. messianists among them, conceal their elokimist beliefs. non messianists, are messianists elokimists who conceal their messianisms elokimism that could affect their shnorr business. finally the elokimists are the lucky few lunatics among them that are free to practice idolatry in the open and do not have to adopt another personality. expose them for who they are!

I have now seen this circular and it is appalling. Those responsible for its publication and distribution must be brought to justice.