Culture  The Buzz
Oprah coming to Israel for solidarity visit
Itamar Eichner
Published: 22.05.07, 12:03
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
119 Talkbacks for this article
91. Opera's visit to Israel
dara taher ,   Amman _Jordan   (05.29.07)
I was really shocked when I read that Opera is going to Israel for solidarity.We in the Middle East think highly of her and we hope she would think more about it.We know that the Israeli influence is very strong in the united states but this should not fool someone like Opera.She always stood for opressed people and I am sure if she investigates more she would realize that the palestinians are not the terrorists they are merely defending themselves against death every single day of their lives.we have faith in you Opara and have always admired your courage.Please learn more about the situation in Palestine but make sure you do that from people who are not baiesed.
92. #64
Butterfly! ,   Jordan   (05.30.07)
Your comment really made me laugh! Your comment is simply irrelevant to the whole topic! "You should really encourage those of you who actually have a good command of English to comment here", hahahaha... Well I think we should encourage those who can actually stand for Peace & Justice. A good command of English is absolutely irrelevant to this! I would really love that Oprah comes to visit Israel but she also has to visit the Palestinian territories. She is a courageous woman who stands firmly towards Peace & Justice, against all types of oppression. Salam...
93. Oprah
Vardit ,   Toronto, Canada   (05.31.07)
When Oprah had women who supported the suicide bombers on her show, I had lost a tremendous amount of respect for her and I emailed her telling her same. It is a free world as far as opinions go, but she never had a follow-up giving the Israeli position which I thought rather "strange" for lack of a better word. I am glad Oprah is coming to Israel, but I would also want Oprah to interview the women and children of Sderot to be aired for their opinion of what is happening to them perpetrated by the terror group of Hamas.
94. You should not come
Rania ,   Palestine   (06.01.07)
You should not accept this invitation, you should say you would come when the Israelies will end their occupation. You are a black women who suffered from White and you know what is suffering.
95. Your Plan to visit Isreal
Wes & Jane Hare ,   Chapel Hill NC 27517   (06.02.07)
Please include the suffering of hte Palestinians in your visit as Jimmy Carter and Desmond Tutu refer to their Apartheid reality
96. Why the paranoia?
Mirror ,   Earth   (06.02.07)
After reading a couple of pages of readers' comments I feel depressed. There are many comments that seem to come from people who are not constructive in their words and attitudes. If a person decides to visit a place, let that person visit the place. Why all the fear and paranoia? And if there is worry that the problem in that area will not be understood by the visitor, why not the visitor visit all sides invovled in the problem? Isn't that the best way for someone to make up their minds? The better decision is usually one made with a wider background. All the best and may you have peace before you die
97. Human Rights and Palestinians
Dr. Fred R. Guenther ,   Newtown PA USA   (06.07.07)
Dear Oprah: Please take time to visit the other side of the wall and talk to the Palestinian people, skip officialdom and visit plain citizens. I was there in 97 and visited Gaza Gallilea and East Jerusalem. The view of the wall is great from the Israeli side, but please crossover and see the rest of the story. Dr. Fred
98. Palestine too
Eyad ,   Palestine   (06.10.07)
Dear Oprah, We ask you as Palestinians to visit the west bank and Gaza too.
99. oprah's visiting
faten ,   Montreal   (06.10.07)
Dear oprah i am a palestinian women, I admire you , i watch your show regularly, concerning your visit to the region, it seems that some Isrealian are afraid of the impact of this visit, and many Palestinian are looking for your visit to be the voice for the voiceless. you know, there is always two sides to every story, so pleas do your best to see the story from different sides
100. No 1 is No 1 in ignorance
Rachel ,   Jerusalem   (06.12.07)
I would describe at least 60% of Israel as non white Jews so what are you chatting about, you are so ignorant .
101. Good effort, we must support Israel
Jeff ,   Kenya   (06.15.07)
It is absolutely right to support Israel. Take me with you.
102. When is she coming??!!
Yaron Farzan ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (06.17.07)
I love Oprah. Will it be possible to meet her personally?
103. #1
Leon ,   Houston   (06.19.07)
husseinali , canada Take some English lessons, you moron. Do you really live in Canada?
104. #83
Leon ,   Houston   (06.19.07)
Religion of peace? it is more a religion of death, you retarded MORON.
105. why not?
Deema ,   Palestine   (06.20.07)
Why would you not invite Oprah to your land??? We should welcome Oprah with open arms to come and see the truth and see exactly what is happening in Palestine and Israel. And this is not an Islamic land Rashid. This is a land for all holy religions.... always was and always will be..... that is why it's so precious and cannot be a country which is based on one religion only as Israel is formed!
106. 91 - "defending themselves"?... Excuse me???
Tahl ,   Israel   (06.26.07)
"Defending themselves" by shooting kassam rockets at Sderot, without any provocation? After Israel pulled out of Gaza, giving them full control over it? "Defending themselves" by detonating themselves in countless buses and restaurants, with the full intent of murdering in cold blood, many innocent civillians, including many children? "Defending themselves" by blowing up a nightclub in Tel Aviv, murdering over 20 teenagers? "Defending themselves" by shooting point-blank and murdering, in her car, a pregnant mother, Tali Hatuel, along with her four girls? "Defending themselves" by invading a house and shooting a 5 year old girl, Danielle Shefi, in her bed? And these so many other examples! Trust me - if Palestinians did not "defend themselves" so fiercely - then there is a very good chance Israel would have retreated completely and we would all be living in peace. You have no one to blame for this violence than your leaders, and your militant thugs! Besides, where is your criticism of Hamas? Did you know that in recent weeks, more Palestinians have been killed by themselves, than in many months, by Israel? Where is your criticism of Hamas, genious?
107. #64 and "Palestinians"
Mike ,   Pittsburgh, US   (06.27.07)
Yeah, several of the "Palestinians" posting, such as #7, probably aren't Palestinians. And you're a racist douche. Just throwing that out there.
108. How can you?
Rasha Hassan ,   Qatar   (07.02.07)
i do not suppose oprah knows that there are currently 4 million palestinians classified as refugees- do not hold passports and are not citzens of any country..they are so because israel decided to get their land back after 3000 years... lets all go back to where we came from 3000 years ago.. how about that? shuffle the whole world around! so much for her enlighitened vision.. i used to watch her show and listen to her, take it all at face value not anymore anything she says should be questioned!
109. make time to visit gaza to see there sufferstoo
cvarla   (08.03.10)
i wish she will make time to visit gaza & west bank see how pple there live & then judge who is really suffering
110. God forbidden holy land on jewish 40years god time ever
suzy   (08.03.10)
the jewish refused to move to the holly land with musa they told him go fight with ur god the pple there we cant fight strenght pple so god puished them not to enter the holly land &would be forbidden on them 40years god tiem mean forever
111. OPRAH, OPEN YOUR BLINDED EYES & GO TO VISIT REFUGEE CAMPS
PALESTINIAN ,   The Globe   (08.03.10)
112. wow and why is mandela not a friend of israel??
kat ,   jerusalem israel   (08.03.10)
because israel has supported apartheid in South Africa where the whites occupied African land?? because it shares history of the white occupier? or because it copied the system into a weirder more criminal one in Palestine and are against symbols of human freedom?? it's quite low of Oprah to humiliate herself helping the PR of a terrorist state with a shameful history just coz some israeli institution gave her a trophey. and for the ignorant's information; in Palestine the war is on occupation of land (you would think that it's trivial to know), not about terrorism. This is just ridiculous.
113. it's a matter of business
bam ,   free land   (08.03.10)
she can announce what ever she wants who cares, our real enemy is usa not small (israel) for sure somebody there paid her or threatin here with suspende her program, it's loby business known everywhere
114. Oprah
Bort ,   Oslo, Norway   (08.03.10)
c'mon oprah i thought you were for the oppressed and the poor of the world israel is starving 1.5 million gazans while bulldozing and demolishing homes in the west bank they are one of the few entities to not give refugees the right of return but of course they cant because they wouldnt have a country if they did that!!! oprah you are just another ignorant american bought and paid for by aipac money
115. Israel's problem is what to do wth bodies of their victims
Jarret Herrmann ,   Luray USA   (08.04.10)
Is that the situation she will show sympathy for? That it is a bother to dig mass graves and to bulldoze the homes of the ORIGINAL AND RIGHTFUL OCCUPANTS OF THE LAND? I have no sympathy for Israeli land thieves. If Hamas and Hizbullah want to launch rockets, they're within their rights because they're firing on their own lands that were robbed from them in Al Naqba!
116. Oprah showing solidarity with Israel
Jeanie Toth ,   Clearwater, USA   (08.04.10)
She's come a long way! Building schools for oppressed girls to showing solidarity with the worlds biggest oppresors!...It's a class thing ya know!
117. Huh, that would be like saying slave owner's suffering!!!
Charlie ,   San Francisco, CA   (08.05.10)
Come on Oprah, I just lost all respect for you!!! Saying that your going for solidarity to for Israeli suffering??? I agree that they suffer but the suffering is more of self created suffering that needs to be humbled by letting Israeli policy makers understand their policies are WRONG AND INHUMANE AND CRIMINAL! Comparing it to Palestinian suffering would be on a scale of 1-1000 with 1 being the lowest, Israeli's are suffering at level 1 while Palestinians are suffering at a level of one million!!! If you don't show the Palestinian suffering, you will be just seen a dirty evil talking head for Israel and you know it!!! Just ask Israel to treat all people equally no matter their color or religion and see the response you get!!!
118. Oprah and Israel
Katie ,   SF, CA   (08.06.10)
Way to be UNBIASED to the cause of human rights OPRAH! Responsible journalism is dead. Open your eyes to the pain on both sides of the WALL!
119. Seek the truth
Oprah Fan ,   Santa Monica CA   (08.12.10)
Oprah, if you must visit Israel, I urge you to also visit the occupied territories and go through the check points which Palestinians have to go through everyday. Speak to the Natives and speak the truth.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article