News
'I was put in a gas chamber,' says Israeli doctor
Itamar Eichner
Published: 03.06.07, 09:48
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
127 Talkbacks for this article
61. so what?
sunshine ,   germany   (06.03.07)
62. so what?
sunshine   (06.03.07)
quote:where I was asked to take off my shoes, my hand bag was taken from me and my belongings were taken out one by one and scanned along with my shoes in special paper for tracing dangerous substances. - unquote Now she knows how a lot of tourists feel when they undergo a similar security check at TLV airport. It's frightening and dissapointing!
63. JPS Efrat
NK   (06.03.07)
I don't quite agree with you. A simple example is the seperation fence, which was originally intended (as declared by Israelis) at preventing attacks on Israelis. It later became clear to everybody that its' main purpose is to rob more Palestinian lands, as well as satisfy the Israeli Physcho of living behind walls. By now, you should have learned the lesson that no checkpoints/walls in the world can bring you security.
64. Get over it!
Bek ,   Tel Aviv   (06.03.07)
# 11 - couldn't have said it better myself! & this woman really needs to get over her persecution complex. Much of the western world really dont care one what your religion is!! honestly! And - the way many Israelis act at airports is disgusting - pushing, shoving and shouting. & that's just the parents!...rude rude rude. You always know where the El Al queue is in any airport - just follow the noise. One you get shoved and have your feet ran over with a trolly, you know you are there.
65. To # 57 dovdevan - sure that's ur name?
Marian ,   Israel   (06.03.07)
You honestly compare Israeli security checks to the U.S.? Yes, Arabs or Muslims are being treated as hostile for a good reason, non Jews in general are treated with caution for a good reason - we can afford to do that for a good reason!!!! And as far as getting nude ? Hogwash, and you know it! Stripping down to underwear, yes, but that's as far as it goes. The woman was checked purely due to random checks of any age, gender or race - THAT is stupid and will never bring any results - For no Good Reason.
66. Yep! have to agree with #11
Talula ,   Israel   (06.03.07)
67. This Greg of LA
charles ,   petach tikva   (06.03.07)
is an antisemite , who tells the best lies seen in the world and around . Ok , the USA does what Israel says ? Sad to say for us , NO . They did'nt allow some of Israel's exports . They , the USA , ordered the 56 sinai campaign to stop , but of course , says this greg , this were Israeli orders . And those are only two samples . In other tb's he is also telling untrue facts , but do'nt answers embarrassing questions . A nice guy , indeed .
68. to #11
Marian ,   Israel   (06.03.07)
There is no excuse for rude checks anywhere, also not at Ben Gurion. This is an area that truly needs repair! However, the reason why anyone gets checked as detailed as they do in Israel or on flights to Israel is a totally different issue. The doctor was chosen for a stupid and ineffective random check, the minimum one could ask for is proper behaviour, or not?
69. I STOPPED FLYING.
JEWISH LADY ,   USA   (06.03.07)
BECAUSE I COULD NOT STAND TO BE PUSHED AROUND LIKE THIS ISRAELI DOCTOR WAS. THE RUDENESS OF THE INSPECTORS, THE LOSS MY OF PRIVACY AND DIGNITY, THE FEAR OF BEING DETAINED BY MISTAKE--MADE AIR TRAVEL TOO HARSH FOR ME. SO NO MORE AIR TRAVEL FOR ME. I LIKE TO BE TREATED LIKE A HUMAN BEING NOT A CRIMINAL.
70. Emotional and pathetic
Alan ,   USA   (06.03.07)
Give me a f***ing break and stop being that emotional. A doctor? How pathetic... just follow the rules and do what you are told like everyone else in that situation, or stay at home!
71. it's underestimation and humbling of the gas chamber
observer   (06.03.07)
it is Not overrecation, at all. It is a conspiracy between Israeli lady doctor and American sceurity, that's what it is all about !
72. #25 Name last Israeli suicide bomber
Ricky ,   USA   (06.03.07)
Please name the last Israeli that blew themselves up in a crowd. That is the difference. Wise up!!
73. Nothing to do with an Israeli Passport
joel ,   Israel   (06.03.07)
As someone who is on over 100 flights a year I can say that Yediot doesn't know what they are reporting and the respectable Dr. is a bit off. She was examined by a GE machine that sprays air for 20 seconds to detect explosive particles, she was selected most likely do to her ticket (might have had a stop over in NY), one in 30 people are selected, more or less and it isn't do to her passport. Her description sounds hysterical, I have gone through the same process despite flying on an American passport, it isn't fun but it isn't demeaning, she wasn't the only one to go through the process, it wasn't done upon seeing her Israeli passport (it is marked on the boarding pass) and she should get over it and go back to treating her patients
74. #67 aim of random check
(06.03.07)
logically, if it is for deterrence and intimidation, then a suitable subject is a respectable doctor.
75. THE SAME EAXCT THING WAS DONE TO ME AT JFK AIRPORT
..............DACON9   (06.03.07)
AND I THOUGHT IT WAS BECAUSE I AM A SO GOOD LOOKING BORN IN AMERICA MALE. PS. i didnt feel a thing. the security did their thing i didnt oppose , it went smooth i was surprised,,,,,but so what.... THEY ARE PROTECING ME, ITS WHAT I DEMAND ... TO BE PROTECTED.... BUT THEN THEY LET MOHAMED WALK RIGHT THROUGH...... AND HE HAD A BULKY VEST WITH DUCT TAPE KEEPING IT CLOSED.... SO I ASK... WHATS THE CRITERIA? I DIDNT CARE... BUT WHY ME AND NOT MOHAMED AFTER ALL MOHAMED STARTED THIS AND CONTINUES THIS PROBLEM OH WELL C'EST LA VIE...............or is it? .
76. i mus add to my post..IT DIDNT BOTHER ME TO ME CHECKED
SAME AS THE WOMAN ,   DOCTOR........DACON9   (06.03.07)
WHO WILL CHECK YNET? LOLOLOL WELL THIS WAS GOOD BATHROOM READING ANYWAY
77. The Orwellian society has arrived in US
Eddie J ,   Samson, Al   (06.03.07)
It is deeply disturbing the overwhelming responses to this article that reflect clear anti-Jewish sentiments. I know of no Jewish suicide bombers but you have an ever growing list of Arab-Palestinian suicide bombers. They have clearly earned this level of scrutiny, not grey haired grannys and professionals as are clearly the ones checked the most. I pray I never have to fly again and that my Exodus from Orwellian land is by the mighty hand, outstretched arm and poured out fury of YHVH....not thru any airport security!
78. to marian in the name of security all kind of methods can be
dovdevan ,   ashdod , israel   (06.03.07)
used and we can arrive to extreme situation ! guantanamo where we found innocent people among terrorist ! even in israel there are a lot measures in the name of security that are not justified the goal of those measures is to supervised people and not only ennemies so you should look at the big picture !
79. how many talkbackers has not blamed the victim ?
(06.03.07)
80. To #25..
miorn ,   ny,usa   (06.03.07)
If you not like live in ISRAEL you can GO to Saude or Jordan or Iran and leave nise.Why not.
81. #6
mark ,   ca   (06.03.07)
I wouldn't call them neonazis.Simply disfanctional "white trush".
82. #7
mark ,   ca   (06.03.07)
I have dual citizenship (US and Israeli). Had more trouble in Ben-Gurion with my Israeli passport than traveling in US. I travel once a month and US customs know where I'm going. The US security sometimes strip search members of US congress. Years ago I was undergoing strip search on different ocasions in Frankfurt airport on the way to TLV.Not a big deal.
83. Same thing happened to me
Chris   (06.03.07)
I think it was because I am a white practicing Christian. I should not have been subjected to this because my country is fighting alongside the United States in both Afghanistan and Iraq. When Israeli soldiers can strip seach fully accredited diplomats, then Israelis can be treated the same. Persobnally I would subject every Israeli to strip searches when entering the UK. I would also destroy their laptops, like what happens at Ben Gurion airport.
84. CRAZY JEWISH OLD LADY
(06.03.07)
givce me a frickin BREAK- you will whine if we DONT check everyone to I suppose. gas chamber. what is she going to SUE know for USA be cautious? DONT VIIST USA. THE!!!
85. no special treatment
(06.03.07)
for anyone now that this era is upon us. check everyone. and for the 'isrtaeli' what makes you so special? in fact- that particular AREA IS the AREA that has caused all this terroroism so I say check people from that area of the world the MOST!!! semities look aloke- arabs and jews- so you never know.
86. #57
mark ,   ca   (06.03.07)
My 15 years old child was harrased in BG. The security asked if my child speaks Hebrew and member of the temple. What it have to do with security??? I had Israeli passport. And it was 3 hours before the flight out of Israel. Not a single ? on the entry to Israel.
87. charles, cut the crap.
Andre ,   TLV   (06.03.07)
I had a christian dutch friend having a cavity check at the B. Gurion... don't blame the pals for our crazy security measures...
88. Same "Gas Chambers" at Statue of Liberty
Aliza ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (06.03.07)
If you go to the Statue of Liberty on Ellis Island, regardless of nationality, you too will have to go into the "gas chambers". Are israeli's getting put through tighter security. yes. is the doctor somewhat hysterical. yes. get a grip lady.
89. 'I was put in a gas chamber,' says Israeli doctor
Michael Collins ,   Calgary, Canada   (06.03.07)
The lady should undergo a thorough EL AL security check if she thinks the American one was too strict!!! Why is it that each time some Jewish person gets stopped, they cry prejudice?? I have been subjected to these same checks on several occasions and appreciate their justification: the blocking of terrorists. She should leave her ego at home and join the rest of the human race.
90. Boo Hoo Hoo
C'est Mio ,   Canada   (06.03.07)
Unreal...I mean whining is part of the zionist cause...gas chambers..antisemitism...what freakin hell are we in. Its a security measure whether she likes it or not...A colonialist complaining LOL
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article