News
Amnesty International: Israel destroying hope of Palestinians
Yaakov Lappin
Published: 04.06.07, 01:59
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
61 Talkbacks for this article
1. Why hasn't this organization been sued yet?
Tracy W   (06.04.07)
Peace Now just got fined for slander. A Jerusalem judge ruled Wednesday that Peace Now must pay 58,000 shekels ($14,336) to Aryeh King after slandering him on the left-wing Peace Now website. The group had claimed that King, a well-known activist for Jewish settlement in eastern Jerusalem, had announced that he planned to break the law by bringing 40 Jewish families to live in an area that lacked building approvals. The site called King a racist and a fascist, and accused him of threatening the peace of Jerusalem and leading to its “Hevronization.” The judge found that Peace Now’s allegations were false and slanderous, and ordered the group to pay the full penalty required by law. (As reported by INN) Amnesty international admits its bias, although it attempts to disguise it by stating that they expect more from states (Israel) than militants. This would not stand in a court of law. Just because someone acts beyond the law does not excuse him from equal treatment in sentencing.
2. AI
M. Hartley ,   Atlanta, US   (06.04.07)
Well, those people have to justify their existence by writing reports. Maybe they'll write a report on Sderot next month. Yeah, right!
3. AMNESTYand their REPORT !
ben ,   singapore   (06.04.07)
NO CREDIBILITY, FLUSH AMNESTY and their REPORT down the SEWERAGE. NO OBLIGATION ON ISRAEL TO LISTEN TO AMNESTY INTERNATIONAL- ANTI- SEMETIC ORGANISATION ! AMNESTY also may OSTRACISE well SUCH THING DOSENT WORK ANYMORE. WE ISRALI GOT USE TO the UNFOUNDED ACCUSATION. TELL AMNESTY NOT TO INTERFERE WITH THE NATIONAL SECURITY OF ISRAEL. ENOUGH GRACE AND MERCY WERE GIVEN TO THE PALESTINIANS, BUT THEY HAVE BEEN TERRORISING THE ISRAELI PEOPLE. THAT ALL ! ISRAEL SUE AMNESTY ! DEPORT ALL THE SO CALLED ACTIVIST AND ARREST THEM for being SEDICIOUS in ISRAEL ! THE MINISTY OF FOREIGN AFFAIR AND INTERNAL AFFAIR SHOULD REVOKE ALL THEIR ENTRY INTO ISRAEL- MOSSAD THIS IS AN ESPIONAGE- COUNTER ESPIONAGE ! ben singapore : - O
4. Give Them a Good Caning
Dave Levy ,   Burbank. CA USA   (06.04.07)
What a farce this Amnesty (not so) International. I personally know a few members of this group in the States, they diehard leftists, and some long term socialists and communists at heart. They are against corps, and for big govt. As far as Israel, this entire report is a joke. They condemn the US at times for our racial bigotry...and we just ignore them. If I were Olmert, I would give them 24hrs to leave the country or face a firing squad. These people don't care about why the wall, or the check points. Maybe Israel should show them the graves of people killed by suicide (children) bombers, or take them to the Erez Crossing, which just saw mortar attacks, injuring a few soldiers. I would not dignify them by reporting in any Israeli newspaper. What army are they members of? How many legions does the Pope have applies to them. Send them packing Israel, to Darfur, where they will be treated appropriately. What they need is a good caning, like they do in the Orient.
5. questions concerning bias are biased
izzy d ,   jerusalem   (06.04.07)
The questions alleging to the perceived bias in the reports are fair and hard, however the follow up is nil. in other words when asked as to why 7 demands of Israel while only 1 of the Palestinian authority constitutes as bias is brushed off with an innocuous "Israel is a state while the PA is a militant organization". Intelligent question (i would like to think): When asked why the expectations of a state are higher then expected of the militants conducting systematic attacks with the declared aim of destroying and obliterating said state the answer is alwayes the same; "We condemn but do not expect." Ma'am, isn't it fair to expect a complete destruction of a subversive element of a destructive society especially as it holds back the obvious mobility of said society into a democratic and productive entity? simply; If the PA is to be a state why would you treat it otherwise? and if you were to agree that Israel is fighting MILITANTS then why would you disagree as to the methods undertaken to protect its citizens from a clearly violent organization?? BIAS!!!!!
6. Amnesty Biased and Bigoted. Miss facts
Semsem ,   New York, USA   (06.04.07)
For these bigots at Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch, killing Jews is really acceptable. They look at the micro picture at the poor Palestinians and ignore why these poor Palestinians are in such a terrible State. It's their own doing.
7. a.i.'s only message to Israel: surrender to terror
dante ,   uk   (06.04.07)
8. Amnesty hates Israel and Jews
Laurence ,   Santa Ana, CA USA   (06.04.07)
Anything that impedes the destruction of Israel or Jews in particular is upsetting to Amnesty and the Arabs. Here's to their ongoing lower intestinal aggravation.
9. wall of death
Boris ,   Toronto   (06.04.07)
This "wall of death" should really be called the "wall of prevention of death"
10. Brave IDF soldiers solve jihad problem
Negru Voda ,   Transilvania   (06.04.07)
Ynet's stern grilling of the AI spokesperson raises some good points. Why doesn't AI ask the Palestinians "to stop indoctrinating children for jihad, or using child-combatants, for example?" Why doesn't AI report "what the IDF was doing, such as responding to intelligence of imminent attacks and threats to Israel's security?"
11. Palestinian amnesty
I. Barr ,   Bloomfield, Mi, USA   (06.04.07)
Amnesty International is a UK organization who works together with British academics , journalists, architects, trade unionists who gang on Israel to appease the growing Muslim population in UK. We in Belfast have a 25 Km fence separating Catholics and Protestants and cross communities no less than those in Israel. There are gates that close at sunset. Amnesty International may not know about that, about the fences in Arizona, Kashmir etc. As we say in Belfast "good fences make good neighbors". I invite AI reps to come to Crown pub which is a mile away from the fence. I have permission from the Sinn Fein.
12. Next, Amnesty will call for all Isrelis to take cyanide
Phil ,   US   (06.04.07)
Like the BBC, the British academic unions that are so hostile to Israel (and want to economically strangle Israel), the author of this report is nothing but a liar and a Jew hater. The matra of these bigots is to deny the obvious and claim to have nothing against Jews while doing everything possible to make sure that Jews are murdered. They just don't want Israelis to defend themselves in any way. It is interesting that Amnesty wants the "inconveniences" at Israeli checkpoints ended but doesn't give a rat's ass about the reason that the checkpoints are there. While they are protesting checkpoints, why don't they criticize airports for security checks that have resulted in long lines and wasted time? Oh, Amnesty would reply that airport checkpoints are necessary because of terrorism and the hijacking of 9-11, but Israeli checkpoints only protect Jewish lives which are far less important than inconveniencing Palestinians. It's time for Israel to stand up to these lying monsters and make life so miserable for them that they'll go live with their Hamas and Hezzbollah friends.
13. These people have no moral legitimacy. Sue them.
Joyce   (06.04.07)
14. Palestinian's "hope" is to destroy Israel
(06.04.07)
A.I. just wants somebody to blame. The PA ignores them so they take it out on Israel. What a joke. Get a real job.
15. IF Palistinians ,hamas &hezbelah were really...
Psalm 83 ,   selah washington USA   (06.04.07)
interested in being serious about living peacfuly with israel they would find most israelis willing to help make it happen ...but palistians ,hezbelah hamas want the whole land of israel under thier control....thier charter says that is thier goal..they have no intention of living peacfuly side by side with israel .....
16. IF Palistinians ,hamas &hezbelah were really...
Psalm 83 ,   selah washington USA   (06.04.07)
interested in being serious about living peacfuly with israel they would find most israelis willing to help make it happen ...but palistians ,hezbelah hamas want the whole land of israel under thier control....thier charter says that is thier goal..they have no intention of living peacfuly side by side with israel .....
17. Carter is certainly Right, but with no enough Might
(06.04.07)
18. pals are to make israel's life hell BY Nagative Means
(06.04.07)
19. The UN's DEGENERATE MUST BE STOPPED
(06.04.07)
The UN needs to be taken out of any politics. The UN needs some people, who have objective and pozitive looking over world. Atilla Liman Karagözoğlu
20. how many deaths? can we get a number here?
aaron ,   ra'anana   (06.04.07)
before the wall existed, from 2000-2003 about 1000 israelis died in terror attacks eminating from the west bank and gaza. since the wall has been built, the rate of deaths by terrorist attacks has slowed considerably this WALL OF LIFE saves lives.
21. Amnesty, This Is a Shame!
nell ,   switzerland   (06.04.07)
Switzerland is also on their black list. How more biased and left people can get???
22. Who cares what those hippies say...
Talula ,   Israel   (06.04.07)
They've never said anything nice about Israel, why start now? They don't have to live with constant threats of Looney suicide bombers. If our country listens to the opinions of other countries, we'd cease to exist. Sod them all. They need to turn their attention to Darfur - they need help more than the whinging Palestinians.
23. The bug stops @ the helm of AI
john ,   nz   (06.04.07)
Irene Khan who makes human rights looks wrong. All her years @ Harvard has taught her nothing. Being a Muslim, she deliberately sees only one side of a story and turn a blind eye on the other which makes her biased. She is a woman with no substance with bad judgement, short-sighted and bad breadth. She avoids the real abuse of Muslim women, namely, honor killings and pick on the Jews which she hates. As a conclusion, she's a hypocrite and has no place in this organisation. Get rid of her
24. Why don't the 'palestinians' build
gm ,   south africa   (06.04.07)
their own hospitals?? Why do they have to go to Israel?? Don't they want independance? If the 'palestinians' want a Palestine, surely they would have to go through border posts to get to Israel. Is Israel not preparing them for that? Also why don't they turn around and go to Egypt or Jordan for help. Where are there 'brothers' to help them. Why to these ungrateful people go to Israel for help when they want to destroy her? This must be one of the most illogical, two-faced, double-standard people I have ever come across.
25. It is none of their business what we do to defend ourselves!
jason white ,   afula,israel   (06.04.07)
They should not be allowed into Israel. Anyone who helps them should be jailed for aiding the enemy.
26. AMNESTY, SHUT UP!!!
(06.04.07)
GET OUT OF THE COUNTRY!!
27. to # 24 and to others
(06.04.07)
You are very far from this land and this must be the reason behind your ignorance or because you watch a lot the pro-israeli propaganda. here we are talking about check points in the heart of the west banks and far away from israel. pals want to reach their own hospitals and are not let whitout any reason. so think before you open your mouth. If you want to see more come and check by yourself. people are waiting for hours to move from one palestinian city and another. This is not for security it is only called HATERED.
28. Amnesty Get OUT of Israel !
ben ,   singapore   (06.04.07)
29. A I mishekar
Norm   (06.04.07)
30. biased reporting from AI
Shai ,   Israel   (06.04.07)
Imagine a baseball game with a sports reporter saying, "and he punished the Red Sox pitch due to his consummate skill, over the wall for a home run - and WE won." That's like AI. They are clearly taking sides, not just reporting what they see. They ignore what doesn't suit them, and exaggerate what does.
Next talkbacks
Back to article