News
Hebron: IDF kills Palestinian youth holding fake gun
Efrat Weiss
Published: 03.07.07, 19:56
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
78 Talkbacks for this article
61. #41 - God! you're stupid!
(07.04.07)
62. #4 u r the idiot-and probably nerer served
sigalit morano   (07.04.07)
http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/122960 go to the link and see u can tell the real gun apart from fake. YNET-start doing yo job-why didnt u post the picture of comparison that every other site did!!!!
63. And besides being the soldiers hassled by arabs
Keren ,   SP-Israel   (07.04.07)
They are hassled too by a group of "special observators for Hevron" ,which I do not recall the name, who are a kind of UN ,and their job is to wander around all the time,up and down ,with an air of superiority ,posing as the protectors of the law among those "children"-Jews and arabs. It is indeed enerving their presence there.
64. Kid should have
Stan ,   JHB RSA   (07.04.07)
Any decent kid would have been home watching Mickey Mouse. Ooops - Mickey told him to run in the street and point guns at IDF Guess he was just doing what Mickey Mouse says
65. Keren is a crazy woman
Shir ,   Finland   (07.04.07)
Keren means beam, ray or something like that. This woman really doesn´t do justice to her name. There is nothing sunny or bright about this woman. I wonder why the most fanatical zealots in Israel are always women? They really don´t stand out as being very feminine. What happened, is obviously a tragedy. And it shouldn´t have happened. I hope Israeli army will be able to improve security measures and prevent incidents like these from happening in the future. More successful and lethal attacks on terrorists, and less unnecessary civilian victims.
66. Misunderstanding...
Jo ,   Egypt   (07.04.07)
The boy was not running in the direction of the IDF soldiers anyway!! Why on Earth did they shoot him then??because he was playing with a gun, running round his house? Since the boy was not moving anywhere near the direction of the soldiers...then it poses NO THREAT..which goes back to again unnecessary killing..which is in the genes of every Israeli
67. Toy gun
leon ,   Grand Rapids USA   (07.04.07)
When I was 16, my mommy used to tell me "go out and play with your toy gun". HAH !
68. Shir
Keren ,   SP-Israel   (07.04.07)
I am not a "fanatical zealot" ,not at all. I just think that these lands belong to Jews for all reasons in this world,being maybe one of the most important ones, in this moment of the history, that they were WON in wars Israel didn't want and was always pushed to . The blood and the life of some member of every Jewish family in that place was lost in those wars. Arabs don't want peace.They provoque all the time. I was in Hevron,and I can tell FOR SURE ,that no one would wander about with an arm if not for provocation. Arabs don't care for life;they are pleased to die if that death will cause trouble to Jews,and that was exactly what they did. The soldier could and should not risk his life.It was or him or the other. And,just for a matter of information,I can tell you that those people living in Hevron are a very beautiful and kind people and they live a much(MUCH!)more significant life than we all in the actual extremely materiliastic world. It is this significance that made me wish to live among them. I believe that ,even with great risks,this meaning really makes life worth living.
69. #68 Keren, you are absolutely right in your statements
Glenn ,   Canada   (07.04.07)
70. "Apartheid" nice dodging of the issues!
please do shut up ,   usa   (07.04.07)
You did not answer even ONE of the questions I posed to you. Your response is completely disingenuous because of that. By blaming the so-called "Jewish lobby" for all our problems in the ME instead of our deceitful, self-interested and arrogant gov't, your response proves that your bottom line is just fear and hatred of al things Israeli (and/or Jewish,) Hiding behind a political ideology does not mask your prejudice; it exposes it.
71. hey apartheid: if there had been no holocaust, there'd be
(07.04.07)
no Israel. It is the anti-semites like you who created the problem for the arabs. anti-semetism created the problem for the arabs, don't you agree with pres. ahmadinejad, --of course you do!
72. do you mean that Israeli boys do not play with fake guns?
(07.04.07)
73. #70
Margret   (07.04.07)
Your right Apartheid, is just another in a long line of antiJewish people who use's his antiIsraeli sentiment as a smokescreen to mask his true feelings of hatred towards the Jews. Infact in one tb I asked him that flat out if he hated Jews and he didn't respond at all,by his silence he answered though.
74. To Jack #27. They ARE Our Protectors.
Maansingh ,   The Netherlands   (07.05.07)
You write :"... because he is a Muslim ...". NO, you are wrong. Because he aimed his plastic assault rifle at the Israeli soldiers. You write :"... it is a great evil when your soldiers are harmed." YES. Our Police and Army personnel NEED to be protected -- because they protect our citizens and our borders. WE, the citizens, SHOULD take good care of our Police and Army personnel. Because they ARE our protectors. You write :".., if not to become murderers themselves". NO, you are wrong. When the Army, during war time, kills belligerent men -- it is NOT called murder -- it is called acting out of duty. THE karmic reaction of killings during war doesn't go towards the soldiers. ALL the karmic reaction goes to the Head of State -- under whose order the soldiers are acting.
75. To Apartheid#56. Originally a Christian Church.
Maansingh ,   The Netherlands   (07.05.07)
You write :"Who built all the old Mosques?" You mean the Al-Aqsa Mosque in Jerusalem ? The Al-Aqsa Mosque was originally a Christian Church built by the Roman Emperor Justinian in the 530s A.D., and named the Church of Our Lady. IT was later coverted into a Mosque by the Muslims after 638 A.D. BTW Jerusalem came under Muslim control in 638 A.D. SO, what old Mosques are you speaking about ?? IT seems to me that due to too much hatred against the Jews -- your brain has been stolen. WITHOUT brain -- not much sensible words can come out from you !!!!
76. #74 that's why Israel is after elderly Nazis
(07.05.07)
ALL the karmic reaction goes to the Head of State -- under whose order the soldiers are acting.
77. "Anti-semitic" now means "opposed to Israeli gov policies."
Apartheid ,   Boston USA   (07.05.07)
78. "apartheid"" anit-semetic still means wnat it has always
apartheid EXPOSED ,   usa   (07.05.07)
meant, only now it has a new face that attempts to legitimize it, namely that it's okay to be "anti-Zionist" or "anti-Israel" or "anti-Jewish lobby." Israeli statehood has been a fact for 60+ years. Like it or not, It is time that the Arab world and anti-semites like you get used to it. If you persist in your arguments that Jews do not have a right to live in their ancestral homeland as a national entity because Arabs cannot tolerate their being a majority, then you are just a plain, garden-variety anti-semite. People who are not anti-semities and who are merely "opposed to Israeli gov policies" do not make statements like you made linking the "jewish lobby" with the Iraq war and blaming US support of israel as the reason for Islamic terrorism. Only a true anti-semite would scapegoat world Jewry for all the problems America faces in the ME and refuse to acknowledge the responsibilty of our reps. in governement with gentile names like Cheney, Rumsfeld and Bush. (But of course these gentiles could never make political mistakes without some Jew egging them on, right?---the very defintion of anti-semitism!!) You also fail to implicate Arab gov'ts (Syria, Iran, Saudi Arabia etc.) for being complicit in supporting Islamic terrorism and, by that omission, seem to imply that it is "Israeli gov policies" that are causing Arabs to perpetrate murder and mayhem on themselves and others throughout the ME. It is high time you admit to yourself that your prejudice stems less from pure virtue than from a distilled form of atavistic fear and dislike. .Your comments on this forum expose your insidious hypocritical bigotry and psedo-righteousness and do not fool anyone except you.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article