News
State to help same-sex couples adopt
David Regev
Published: 29.07.07, 08:40
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
121 Talkbacks for this article
31. gay adoption
Yorgos ,   Palm Beach, Fl   (07.29.07)
Homophobia is a reflexion of your own homosexual pulsions, a very common feeling amongst the ultra-orthodox jews. That being said, adopted children by gay parents can only be success stories as they are really "wanted". My partner have the happiest, healthiest child (egg donation+surrogacy, not adoption) in a traditional Jewish home and totally accepted our orthodox Jewish shul members
32. More solidly replicated research tells us...
Sheikh yer Bu'Tay   (07.29.07)
"When young boys have primary caretakes of BOTH SEXES, they are less likely as adults to engage in woman-devaluing activities and in self-aggrandizing, cruel or overly competitive male cults." 9 "We should disavow the notion that 'mommies can make good daddies,' just as we should disavow the popular notion of radical feminists that 'daddies can make good mommies.'... The two sexes are different to the core, and each is NECESSARY - culturally and biologically - for the optimal development of a human being." 10 9. Mary Stewart Van Leeuwen, My Brother's Keeper: What the Social Sciences Do (and Don't) Tell Us About Masculinity, (Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press, 2002), p. 121. See also Scott Coltrane, "Father-Child Relationships and the Status of Women: A Cross-Cultural Study," American Journal of Sociology 93 (1988): 1085. 10. David Popenoe, Life Without Father: Compelling New Evidence That Fatherhood and Marriage are Indispensable of the Good of Children and Society, (New York: The Free Press, 1996), p.197.
33. Married mothers who divorce and turn lesbian..
Sheikh yer Bu'Tay   (07.29.07)
do no favors for their children. The American Academy of Pediatrics, the same organization that tells us the same-sex family will work out just fine, now tells us that divorce "is a long, searing experience ... characterized by painful losses." 11 11. George J. Cohen, et al., "Helping Children and Families Deal With Divorce and Seperation," AAP Clinical Report, 110 (2002): 1019 - 1023.
34. To # 22 , 23 and 24
charles ,   petach tikva   (07.29.07)
Children need loving parents , be it dad and dad or mom and mom , or mom and dad . Do you truly think that those psychologists checking would be parents will give them to potential pedophiles ? Or do you think that gays are pedophiles ?
35. Great... what are we expecting from bad gov't???
Arad ,   Israel   (07.29.07)
36. Straight dad forget his baby in hot car for hrs. She died.
food for thought ,   USA   (07.29.07)
Ynet reported this past weekend that a dad forgot his baby in the car for almost two hours. It heated up and she basically broiled to death. Yikes! Perhaps we should just, in general, require licenses for parenting? You need to get a license to get a dog, but any sadist or idiot can have a child. And it's hard to enforce laws to ensure they take care of that child properly. It's far, far easier to take away someone's dog, if they abuse it... Something to think about
37. Why is it "discrimination"?
JPS ,   Efrat   (07.29.07)
Same sex partnerships by definition preclude children. To say that this is discriminatory is ludicrous. Those who procreate obtain children. Same-sex couples with children is an oxymoron. For gays and lesbians to be in relationships is fine. But for gays and lesbians are imposing their norm on the hetereo society, where couples procreate and have children. To say that gay and lesbian couples having children is "normal" is simply not a credible argument.
38. Proud to be an Israeli
Isragirl   (07.29.07)
To all the Jewish "Ayatollahs" here - lucky for all of us, you are not running this country. And you never will....
39. It's almost time for the "Woe to Israel" to start happening.
It's coming & we ,   tried to warn you.   (07.29.07)
40. #38 And just look what r leaders have truned r
country into-sad day ,   for us--Israel   (07.29.07)
41. Gays and children
Nemesis   (07.29.07)
They should not be allowed to adopt children.Let them live their lives as they see fit,but keep the little kids out of it. How would the child feel,when he brings a friend home to meet his Mom and Dad and they're both wearing a bra? That would be embarrassing,I think,and also damaging to the child. If they want to be gay..fine..leave kids out of the picture.
42. Great gays can adopt but older couples can't
ralphsrant1 ,   USA   (07.29.07)
Great gays can adopt but older straight couples can't. Really fair. http://ralphsrant1.blogspot.com/
43. WHAT CHILDREN NEED
charles ,   petach tikva   (07.29.07)
that are loving parents , not foster "parents" , who do it only for the money they receive . Not all of course , there are exeptions , foster parents , who later simply adopt this child . And when children are loved , they feel it , and return this love 1000 times . Love can be given by gay parents too , they are certainly as loving as hetero parents . It's certainly better for those children to be adopted , to have a home , than to stay in a strange family , or to change from one home to another .
44. God made...
L ,   Tel Aviv   (07.29.07)
God made Adam and Eve, not Adam and Steve.
45. To #33
M. Hartley ,   Atlanta, US   (07.29.07)
Oh, hogwash! My dad was hauled off, before I was 2. My mother reared three girls and a son by herself, under the worst of conditions, all of us turned out exceptionally well, and nobody's additcted to anything. Oh, my mom died, when I was 16, and by that time, she had taught me the wisdom to make it through life that I couldn't have bought in any university. Did you want her to go out there and haul some man into our house, because, according to some wimpy dingbats, we needed a mommy and a daddy? I don't think she could have found one man who would have survived the three of us women and her with his sanity intact. And guess what? There are two more generations, who will be able to stand on their own two feet, because Grandma has and is teaching them well. And do you know who appreciates that attitude more than anybody? The husbands. Just as my husband died knowing that I'd make it just fine without him, my daughter's husband and the husbands of my granddaughters don't need to sit around and worry themselves sick about what might become of their families, if something should happen. They know without a doubt that everybody will survive in good shape. Just in case you don't know it, but researchers tend to come up with exactly what the people, who pay for that research, want to hear. That's why one year, research says this, and two years later, some other research says the opposite. Besides, people who handle the viccisitudes of life without falling to pieces never see shrinks, and one has to wonder on whom all that research is based. Let's see: since I'm widowed, when should I expect to turn lesbian, or does that only happen, when you're divorced? Just in case, should I renovate my bedroom and make it more frilly or what? Oh, wait! Since I don't have a clue, yet, what role I'll play as that soon-to-be-revealed lesbian, maybe I need to make one bedroom over in "Barbie" and have another one redone in a cowboy motif. Geezus H. C......., is there any kind of garbage some people won't believe?
46. Sad for Israel
Baruch ,   Boston, USA   (07.29.07)
After 2000 years, HaShem gave us an opportunity to re-establish Israel. The Torah tells us that afterwards, we should remember that it was Him and not our own strength that made it happen. He hoped that we learned what we did wrong in the past. Ahmadinejad is right. Israel will be wiped off the map. Not by Iran or Hezbollah. It will be eliminated by HaShem, possibly using Iran as He used Babylonia, because too many of the Jews of Israel don't understand where they live and why. Acceptance of homosexuality is only one of the many violations that occur in Israel. Add prostitution, materialism, desecration of Shabbat, widespread eating of treyf, giving up to Arabs the Land of Israel that He promised us. What kind of a Jewish country is Israel, anyway?
47. To #44
M. Hartley ,   Atlanta, US   (07.29.07)
Steve showed up a little later, after that bitchy Lilith refused to feed him.
48. Thank God Israel supports all kinds of families....
Andy ,   ramat hasharon   (07.29.07)
Secular, religious, hetrosexual and gay. Good move!
49. #6 - Feiglin's candidacy is dead on arrival....
Andy ,   ramat hasharon   (07.29.07)
Israel is for ALL Israelis.
50. Poor? Sell your kids to gays!
Jack Garbuz ,   Queens, NY, US   (07.29.07)
If they can't produce kids of their own, they shouldn't be allowed to adopt! Unless the child is an orphan, adoption is the theft or sale of a child from, or by, his biological parent. Selling children to rich gays is just another nail in the coffin of the biological two parent family. What we need is families, not human commodities.
51. to the moron talkbackers!
gay dad ,   Israel   (07.29.07)
It is amazing how people make statements in a bubble without knowing any of us gay parents. stop quoting the bible and talk to us. The state has to grant us equality. There are many of us with amazing children who we love very much. It is time we had the same rights as you.
52. Gay Dad - Israel
L ,   Tel Aviv   (07.29.07)
Get outa here.
53. #51..gay dad
Nemesis   (07.29.07)
If you want kids,marry a woman..that's why males and females were put on this earth. You are not equal,simple as that. Do you see an annual "hetero parade"..no you don't. I couldn't care less what you badly bent people do in your own homes,I just don't think you deserve to raise children.
54. Did you suffer 9 months with "your child" inside?
Jack Garbuz ,   Queens, NY, US   (07.29.07)
If you want the "same rights" you should have to go through the same suffering. I'm a man and I only wish I could have given birth to my son. If that had been the case, then I and not his mother would have gotten custody. Women and gays today have WAY more rights in the courts than most regular heterosexual men.
55. To everyone who opposes this plan:
Mike ,   Atlanta, USA   (07.29.07)
Why not encourage the Haredi population to adopt ALL children in need? Not only will you enable these children to have a mother and father, but you will also guarantee them a childhood reared under the Yoke of Heaven and guided by Torah. If you really want to save these children - and I think NONE of you does - you would adopt them yourselves or encourage the Haredim to do so.
56. Jack Garbuz , you are ignorant
charles ,   petach tikva   (07.29.07)
Do you think that only orphans are adopted ? There are many other cases where children become adoptable . Do you think that people who adopt children , legally as we are talking about , have to pay ? If you think this garbage you are truly ignorant about adoption .
57. Gay Dad - congrats on the court decision
Isragirl   (07.29.07)
Ignore the Jewish ayatollahs, they besiege this website for some reason. Maybe b/c half of them are "Zionists" who have never been to Israel and they don't speak a word of Hebrew but they have to put in their 2 cents on our affairs. Reason doesn't work with them anyhow, it's all voices of god-fearing hate...
58. Mike , Atlanta
charles ,   petach tikva   (07.29.07)
Only people who can care for those children can adopt them . By care is also meant financially . If you do'nt have enough to raise your biological children , why should you receive one more ? Regarding guided by tora , not necessary . There are other , better people , who can take care of those children in need of love and stable home .
59. Nemesis
charles ,   petach tikva   (07.29.07)
or anonymous guy . You with your hatred towards people who have another life style as your 17th century one , you do'nt even deserve to have biological children .
60. # 54 , jack Garbuz
charles ,   petach tikva   (07.29.07)
With your ideas i understand it very well that your wife , and not you , has the custody of your son .
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article