News
Al-Dura's father: Israel's claims ridiculous
Ali Waked
Published: 02.10.07, 01:24
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
87 Talkbacks for this article
61. #12 who believes anything coming from Pallywood?
rachel ,   usa   (10.02.07)
62. #56, I have absolutely no idea
Danny   (10.02.07)
That the french channel seems so desparate to hide the footage seems to me to be more of a "smoking gun".
63. #57, you must have seen the rest of the tape!!!
Danny   (10.02.07)
I didn't realise bulldozers, tanks and F-15s(it is apaches and F-16 who carry out the targeted assasinations but never mind) got in on the act! Really exactly how many pictures of dead Palestinians "kids" have you seen?
64. #59
Richard ,   London UK   (10.02.07)
yes you may confirm that I am outraged by the kidnapping and killing of foreigners by Palestinians. Rachel Corrie was wearing a hi -viz and carrying a loud speaker. I Guess all the other people who are bulldozed to death in Gaza and the West Bank were just unlucky cos the driver didn't see them. Doh. Just a 'Pallie' anyway. I did read the post about the Romans which is why i responded. The Romans were most likely Etruscans - a group who preceded Rome and were based in what is now Umbria and Toscana. I think there were already many europeans (gauls, angles, goths, franks etc) already in Europe. Of course there was movement between tribes and groups. That was the glory of Rome then and the glory of Europe now.
65. #63
east ,   europe   (10.02.07)
sorry i don't know my insturments of death as well as you (F-16 Whatever)- but then we aren't occupying and killing an entire people. I have seen plenty of pictures of dead Palestinain kids. But according to you lot they are all faked or the dastardly fabrication of the French.
66. #40 they are not low lifes
rachel ,   usa   (10.02.07)
67. #54 ha! yes the "Buzz" word : "collective punishment" ...
rachel ,   usa   (10.02.07)
Its getting boring .......
68. #55 Dam you are pompously good!!!!!
rachel ,   usa   (10.02.07)
69. #64, you ever seen an armoured tractor?
Danny   (10.02.07)
a) The speed it goes at? She would have had to stand still for a few minutes right in front of the tractor. It wasn't like it chased her down. b) also the noise the tractor makes and the position of the driver make it highly possible he never heard or saw a thing. c) In case you think this can NEVER happen and MUST be murder, here's a case that happened around the same time: http://www.guardian.co.uk/israel/Story/0,2763,651203,00.html Wierdly I must have missed the Alan Rickman play about Lt Col Wiess....
70. #65, really?
Danny   (10.02.07)
I don't believe you
71. #57 yes indeed you did Silly you ......you fell for it....
rachel ,   usa   (10.02.07)
but , your apology is taken....it takes a real man (or woman) to admit the truth
72. RACHEL #71
David ,   Richmond va usa   (10.02.07)
Why are all of pallywoods useful idots so busy today. They sound even moore out of touch with reality than usual.
73. 57#
Leah   (10.02.07)
I am not saying the death of the child was fake or a hoax but other's have and that's why I was asking if there was a photo of the child's dead body that would be proof he was deceased. The Palestinians have lied before to garner sympathy it has been proven on camera remember the funeral of the person who was supposedly dead yet leaped out of his coffin and ran away? Yes,I have also seen photos of the dead Palestinian kids too and it is very sad. Of course,the pictures of the dead Israeli baby Shalehevet Pass shot and killed while playing on a playground in a sandbox broke my heart just as much.
74. road to jenin part 4:
rachel ,   usa   (10.02.07)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uAYeKATWji8
75. Ynet how come I don't see road to jenin part 1,2,3,?
rachel ,   usa   (10.02.07)
76. #65 east europe
Barry ,   Tokyo   (10.02.07)
hey East, you forgot to mention the whole Muslim world of 1.5 billion people plus their BBC lackeys who will soon be converting your daughters in Europe. Mohammed si already the no2 most popular name in the UK and number 6 in Sweden.... This would never happen in Japan thankfully.
77. Danny, and Richard
israeli ,   israel   (10.02.07)
Thank you, Danny, for coming to the rescue. Yes, that's exactly what I meant, that Jews were imported into Europe by the Roman Empire after the destruction of Jerusalem and fall of Judea. This is something else our detractors never stop to think (freely) about - Judea capta, not Arabia capta, not Palestina capta. Judea capta, and the coins depicting a Jewish woman weeping under a palm tree: http://www.bible-history.com/sketches/ancient/judea-capta-medal.html. However, there are claims that Jews had been living in Spain around the time of the destruction of the First Temple. The Franks were first identified in the 3rd century. The Visigoths are mostly known for the sack of Rome in 410. The Franks were Germanic tribes, the Gauls Celtic, but this is irrelevant, because unlike the Jews, none of the above can be identified with their ancestors' ways and traditions. And their languages?What is Jerusalem for us? What is Alesia for the French? And when did the Hungarians/Magyars find their way into Europe? And yes, legend has it (check out the Aeneid by Virgil) that the Trojan Aeneas escaped the burning city and made it eventually to what would become Rome, the new Troy. Is anyone still lamenting the fall of Troy? Does anyone still care about Priam and Hecuba and their slain sons and daughters? Does anyone read the Iliad on the Trojan Tisha be Av? And while we are at it: did anyone ever think of rebuilding Troy where it had once stood? Nope, they fled and rebuilt it elsewhere, under a new name. Think freely, Richard! Thanks again, Danny!
78. Palestinians and their lies
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (10.02.07)
At least the Jerusalem Post admitted that one of their reporters was hoaxed by a fake story. I'm not holding my breath waiting for YNet to admit to all their lies.
79. Ynet , Where have you put all my" ROAD TO JENIN" parts?
rachel ,   usa   (10.03.07)
I sent all 6 episodes from "Youtube"for the second time , What is going on here ?You don't think its important to see the truth ?EVERYONE ELSE JUST GO TO Youtube ....
80. To 18 from New Zealand
M.S. ,   Brussels   (10.03.07)
If you bother to look on a map you may see that the Gaza stip has a common border with a quite friendly country, Egypt and therefore have as many crossings they like, of course pending Egypts interests and good will. Not a great advertisement for the arab "brothers"
81. the Trojan Horse
israeli ,   israel   (10.03.07)
dear people, when you have seen the Road to Jenin, please take a few more minutes and watch the Trojan Horse. In fact all of Pierre Rehov's productions are absolute gems.
82. #81YES PIERRE REHOV NEEDS SOME RECOGNITION FOR
rachel ,   usa   (10.03.07)
THE GOOD WORK HE HAS DONE.....
83. Palestinians have no credibility left.
DR ,   Florida, USA   (10.03.07)
They have lied so much and staged so many "incidents" that one cannot take what they say at face value. If you accept their stories without any skepticism, then you are a fool. Plain and simple. We saw this with Hizbullah as well.
84. ~#77
richard ,   london UK   (10.03.07)
But what is your point? Everyone knows that The Romans colonised Palestine and that Jewish people were around in Roman times. So? Europe is made up from many tribes and religions. What has that to do with thinking freely? YOu should try and get beyond the notion that palestinians are all terrorists and that they might also have rights and dignity. Think about that for a while.
85. Richard
israeli ,   israel   (10.03.07)
See, that's where you are wrong. In their attempt to deny us our very right to exist, the Palestinians claim Jews have no history here, that we all came from Poland, that we converted, that oriental Jews are in fact Arabs. They claim Palestine has always been Arab, that there was never a kingdom of Judea or Israel, that king Herod was Arab. They claim that there never was a Jewish temple in Jerusalem, that is has always been a mosque, that's why the Wakf feels free to bulldoze the area of the Temple Mount, our holiest site, and dump the excavated soil with all the archeological evidence as if it was nothing but trash. Not to mention that among other artifacts a piece of pottery has been found dating back from the First Temple. bearing the name of a family mentioned in Jeremiah's lament. How's that for Jews have no history here?
86. Palestinians view themselves as the people described in the
jack ,   richmond, va, us   (10.04.07)
Bible (Jewish and Christian). Of course they are but that does not mean that the Jewish Diaspora is not also. The fact that Palestinians are descendants of the ancient Israelites and that the Jewish Diaspora is as well is writen in their collective genome. 50% of Palestinian Muslim Males and 70% of Jewish Diaspora Males have the same y-chromosomes (descendants of the same male ancestors) with a population separation right at 2000 years. An additional 30% of Palestinian Muslim Males have a y-chromosome whose separation from the 70% Jewish Diaspora Male population is right at 2500 years ago. (Perhaps they are the genetic remnant of the lost tribes which remained in Israel, or perhaps they returned at some time in the past.) Google"y-chromosome Jew Palestinian", the resultant studies which include Hebrew University researhers have this information in the raw data and one article by Ariel Oppenheim discribes this relationship in detail. Ironically both Palestinians and Jews are descendants of the ancient Israelites and their very own genetic markers prove the other's claims.
87. Mohammed al Dura and so on
Anne Lion ,   France   (05.30.08)
Well, the footage has been shown. And it has put Charles Enderlin and his Palestinian cameraman to shame. Nobody dies or is dying in that footage. As a matter of fact, at the end the child lifts his arm zo he can peer under it.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article