News
EU lawmakers lambast Israel over Gaza
Reuters
Published: 21.02.08, 20:40
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
44 Talkbacks for this article
1. Screw the EU.
Mark ,   Kibbutz Elrom   (02.21.08)
2. EU? Peee ewwwwe
moriah ,   sacramento,USA   (02.21.08)
When was the last time EU was happy with anything Israel did? Yes, they were ecstatic about the Disengagement but other than that it's been .. well, NEVER!! So much judgment from the moral relativists eating head cheese and blood pudding -- who needs them??
3. Israel doesn't realised that the time changed
(02.21.08)
The old good time is over Israel and if you will not change your policy life will get harder and harder with time for the Israelians .... the world can not be cheated again .
4. Typical European Logic
Jordan ,   Washington, DC   (02.21.08)
Blame the people being attacked... Perhaps the Europeans should adopt a very common American phrase... "It's the THOUGHT that counts". Meaning, the intent is what matters most. Hamas' intent is to destroy Israel, bring terror, and kill Jews... Israel's intent is to prevent that. If anyone disagrees with this, you're insane and know nothing about the situation.
5. Whiskey, Tango, Foxtrot
(02.21.08)
6. Al-Qaeda's doing that.
Ypip ,   Canada   (02.21.08)
7. The EU has not been able to stop Hamas firing daily rockets.
Robert Renders ,   Belgium   (02.21.08)
8. EU morons dont get it:NOTHING reasonable works with the Pals
Scott   (02.21.08)
Simply stupid people. More interested (solely) in testing Israels actions and approach rather than focusing on the cause. They simply dont care about what the Pals do, ""the poor, oppressed civilians" who overwhelmingly voted for Hamas whose purpose is to destroy Israel.
9. Thsnkfully Isnt a member of the EU
zionist forever   (02.21.08)
Its so easy for the Europeans in ther SAFE and comfortable homes who know they can walk out the door not have a rocket land on their head or get on a bus knowing another passenger isnt going to blow himself up to kill you. I dont see security gaurds at the doors of European buildings checking your bags there you walk straight in. I dont see any European millitary bases being tunneld into and then soilders are murdered or kidnapped. Hamas run Gaza and Hamas are trying to kill Israelis so either this is allowed to happen or Israel takes actton. The terrorist organistions operate out of civilian areas even school yards so if they are going to operate out the civilian areas then there is no way to try and protect Israelis from the terrorists without harming the civilians being used as human shields. If Hamas want to take their fighting out of civilian areas operate out of open fields then no civilians are going to be affected by any attacks Israel carries out against Hamas. This is not conventional warfare its urban warfare and in this type of war if there is one thing that can be garunteed its that civilians are going to be affected. The civilians wont be sitting at home watching on tv about their brave soilders doing all the fighting elsehwere while they get on with their everyday lives like the Europeans have the luxury of doing. If Europe wants to do some condeming how about blaming ALL of it on the terrorists try and undersrtand Israel is not fighting an ordinary enemy in an old fashioned war where soilders fight other soilders far away from civilian areas. For the EU its not only about playing the one with all the morrals its about trying to make the EU competing with the US to because the EU politicians dream about them having the same influence in word affairs as the US does difference so they make morrality speeches.
10. Love the stats
Danny   (02.21.08)
Let me see, out of 466 only 158 were not "actively involved in hostilies when killed" - a category that includes Hamas "militants" not actually firing at the time of death etc but is the closest proxity to "civilian" - and 100% of the Israeli casualties are civilian. It also means that a Palestinian "civilian" was roughly four times more likely to be killed by a Palestinian as an Israeli and that last year Palestinians killed more Palestinians that Israel did.
11. where's the lambasting of the palestinians over israel
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (02.21.08)
what about gaza's collective punishment on israel? where's the outrage? where's the condemnation? instead, we get foolish moral equivalence. we should consider the source.
12. Why not condemn Egypt, too?
Wendy in Chicago   (02.21.08)
The have a fence against the barbarians and promised to "break the legs" of anyone crossing it.
13. relocate Gaza to Brussels
YA ,   UK   (02.21.08)
..that will end "isolation". Just don't forget to ask Gazans to take Kassam factories with them, as a part of national culture and tradition. Palestinians have legitimate rights to fight racist occupation, wherever they go.
14. Didn't they applaud for disengagement?
Andras Bereny ,   Kfar Tapuah, Ephraim   (02.21.08)
15. I just sent this to the EU!!
Chaya ,   Bat Yam, Israel   (02.21.08)
I also included photos!! I just read on ynet (http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3509774,00.html) That EU lawmakers are telling Israel not to inflict 'collective punishment' on the citizens of Gaza. What about the collective punishment of the people of Sderot??? (see photo) It is part of international law that a country has the right - no - the obligation to defend itself by whatever means possible. That 'blackout' of a few weeks ago was a hoax set up by Hamas!(see photo) We left Gaza and what did they do?? They continued to attack us with Qassam rockets!! And the hothouses that were left for their use??? They destroyed them!! (see photo) We have continually provided them with electricity!! And when we allowed shipments of food to go in, we discovered that material used for bomb making was being smuggled together with food!! And recently, a shipment intended to be given to needy people was commandeered by Hamas to be given to Hamas fighters!!! Please, mind your own business!! You're having your own Muslim problems at the moment. Don't tell us how to deal with ours! ==================== You can also write to them: http://www.ombudsman.europa.eu/form/en/form2.htm
16. #3 reality check
Michael   (02.21.08)
Since when has situations ever been easy?! Besides, the day of reckoning for the arabs is approaching. There is an old american saying "what goes around comes around".
17. livne
sas ,   israel   (02.21.08)
IS GOOD FOR NOTHING. GET RID OF HER. SHE CANNOT CARRY ANY MESSAGE.
18. mike #11- you are right! and cute 2.
mira ,   israel   (02.21.08)
19. #7 neither could the EU make sun to rise from the west
(02.21.08)
20. When the EU screams that a good sign
Mark ,   England   (02.21.08)
When the EU starts to bark and bash Israel that means that the IDF is doing it's job in hunting down the rats in gaza.....
21. The EU has chosen dhimitude
Bill Ross ,   Alabama, USA   (02.21.08)
The EU has demonstrated that it has no plan for the current Islamic invasion of Europe other than concessions so it is not surprising that they should recommend the same. The *civilians* are the ones who voted in Hamas, and presumably did so *because* they were a terrorist organization, not *despite* the fact. They *should* be punished. In fact, truth be told, they will have to be destroyed in order to get the evil root of Islam out of their corrupted hearts. There will be no peace while Islamic ideology controls the populace of the "Palestinians." Only fools believe otherwise - fools like the EU Parliament, who are well on their way to being Islamicized. At any rate, their criticism can be safely ignored.
22. Did Israel asked for EU analisis?
Inyaki Bilbao ,   Bilbao Basque   (02.21.08)
I didn't know Israeli govr. has asked the EU for help. So it didn't work, so what? Who knows what works. Time is needed.
23. #13 Gaza in Brussels
Bernd ,   Germany   (02.21.08)
Actually parts of Brussels already look like Gaza... Bernd, Germany, Old Europe
24. They want you wiped out
wal   (02.21.08)
It doesn't take a rocket scientist. Rockets.. maybe the Middle East is used to this, but there are rockets -- weapons with the purpose to kill... being blasted into your country, and they're crying about electricity. What happened to all the intelligent Israelis I always hear about? You're going to sit there and let Europe do it again? It will be ashame to lose such an accomplished Western country.
25. EU policy on terrorism
Bernd ,   Germany   (02.21.08)
Please note that not all Europeans are represented by this disgusting politics. Many Europeans will not tolerate their governments making deals with racist terrorists such as Hamas. Supporting terrorism is against the law in my country and every MP in Berlin or Brussels should know that. BO
26. EU condemns Israel over Gaza
khader herzallah ,   Dhahran-Saudi Arabia   (02.21.08)
Livni is angry on the EU because they condemn Israel over Gaza politically and humanitariily and feels that will weaken Abbas and co. who are interested in reaching an agreement with Israel. It is you who weakens Abbas not the EU.How many road blocks you removed?how many prisoners you freed? how many night visits your IDF made to activists homes?how many tons of export goods you allowed to leave the occupied territories?etc..etc...The road map says you must allow the opening of service offices in east Jerusalem,did you fulfil that?1.5 million people are suffering for long time,do you think the world is dry of good people who care about humanity regardless of race and religion?and you still wonder why people worldwide hate you?think of your deeds then you will find the answer.
27. EU: a collection of countries that had us Jews Purged
David P. ,   Santa Cruz, USA   (02.21.08)
from their lands less then 70 yrs ago. they didn't care about our survival then and they care even less about it now. At the same time Israel takes drastic steps which place its citizens in grave danger in order to appease these same European countries. its time Israel stood up for itself and told the EU where they can stick their declaration.
28. BY THE WAY,HOW MANY E'U.PATRONS READ Y-NET?
(02.21.08)
EU CAN SAY WHAT IT LIKES.AS LONG AS ANY OF MY FAMILY, CAN BE MAIMED OR KILLED,I INCLUDE THE WHOLE HOUSE OF ISRAEL AS MY FAMILY,WHATEVER THEIR RELIGIOUS ASPIRATIONS,I WILL DO MY BEST TO OBVIATE THE CAUSES THAT AFFECT THEM AND CAUSE THE MAXIMUM AMOUNT OF DISCOMFORT FOR THOSE THAT PERPETRAY THESE ACTS.UNLESS THE EU CAN COME UP WITH THE SOLUTION OF HOW TO TURN THE ENEMY FROM HATE TO CORDIAL RELATIONSHIP,IT'S WORDS ARE ONLY HOT AIR EMMANATING FROM THE MOUTH AND ACCOMLISHES NOTHING THAN ALLOWING ITS MEMBERS TO CONTINUALLY DRAW THEIR WAGE PACKETS . MY FAMILY COMES FIRSTI HAVE YET TO SEE THE E.U EFFECTIVENESS,ISRAEL IS TAKING TREMEANDOUS RISKS BY ABIDING WITH THE PRINCIPLES OF THE ROAD MAP WHILST S'DEROT SUFFERS A DAILY BOMBARDMENT, OF ROCKET ATTACKS. E.U. FIND A WAY TO DISARM THESE WEAPON CARRIERS CARRIERS AND THEN YOU WILL CERTAINLY HAVE SOME JUSTIFICSATION IN YOUR ARGUMENTS.
29. EUROPE
DANIEL RIMOKH ,   LOS ANGELES   (02.21.08)
I SEE THAT EUROPE IS FOLLOWING WHAT JESUS SAID...IF YOU GET HURT FROM SOMEBODY,TELL HIM TO HURT YOU AT THE OTHER SIDE TOO...WHEN BRUXELLES IS GOING TO INDERSTAND THAT THEIR POLICY OF APPAISEMENT WILL NEVER WORK...EUROPE IS FOLLOWING WHAT THE ARABES TELL THEM WHAT TO DO....THE EUROPEANS ARE SO SCARE OF THE ARABES...THAT THEY BECOME BLIND...PLEASE EUROPE STOP YOUR HYPOCRESY...WAKE UP AND OPEN YOUR EYES BEFORE IT IS TO LATE.....YOU WILL NEVER SUCCED TO DICTATE YOUR STUPIDE POLICY TO ISRAEL...WE ARE NOT A BANANNA REPUBLIC....AND WE NEVER FORGET YOUR POLICY DURING WORLD WAR TWO....SO EUROPE GET LOST....AND TAKE CARE OF YOUR PROLEMES.....THANKS GOD THAT KOSOVO WILL KEEP YOU BUSY FOR WELL.......MUCHO GRACIAS...MR BRUXELLES......THANK YOU...DANIEL RIMOKH
30. How many "EU law makers" are secret muslims? time2check!
KMR ,   Overseas   (02.22.08)
Next talkbacks
Back to article