News
Obama advisor: US Jews hinder peace
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 26.03.08, 01:24
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
119 Talkbacks for this article
61. #15: Because The Republican's Core Is . . .
emanon ,   USA   (03.26.08)
The majority of the Republican party firmly believes the US was founded as a Christian Nation. It's that simple. Look not at the causes they back, but the reasons they back them. All their reasoning is based on what they claim is said in the Christian version of what they call the Bible. If their were a shred of logic, and not just religious reasons, I might consider the Republican opinion on of their position, but there is nothing to argue against. They believe in a Christian Manifest Destiny and, just like the Taliban, they believe we should all fall in line with their beliefs. My beliefs, and my Jewish beliefs, do not preclude their choices. Under the Democrats, at least the current incarnation of that party, I feel I have more of a chance of maintaining my individual identity and not becoming some clone of W, of Limbaugh, of Huckabee or any of their other overly vocal mouthpieces. All else failing, I go Independent and owe allegiance to no party. In that case, I'll write myself in wherever possible.
62. And he's right ...
ari ,   never never land   (03.26.08)
So what? Where is it written you cannot be critical of Israel? I'd love to see that. Do you, as Jews, deny that you fund American politicians of all stripes n order to control their voting how Israel wants them to vote? This hypocrisy will be the Jews' undoing, Despite your hollow screams of 'anti-semitism', Americans are slowly realizing that Israel's view is not America's view, and supporting Israel unilaterally has done the United States much, much harm in the world. If Israel was interested in any kind of peace, settlement-building would halt. Until it does, Israel lies about seeking a lasting peace. Love ya.
63. Maybe he's right ...
ari ,   never ever land   (03.26.08)
So what? Where is it written you cannot be critical of Israel? I'd love to see that. Do you, as Jews, deny that you fund American politicians of all stripes n order to control their voting how Israel wants them to vote? This hypocrisy will be the Jews' undoing, Despite your hollow screams of 'anti-semitism', Americans are slowly realizing that Israel's view is not America's view, and supporting Israel unilaterally has done the United States much, much harm in the world. If Israel was interested in any kind of peace, settlement-building would halt. Until it does, Israel lies about seeking a lasting peace. Love ya.
64. Maybe he's right?
ari ,   never ever land   (03.26.08)
So what? Where is it written you cannot be critical of Israel? I'd love to see that. Do you, as Jews, deny that you fund American politicians of all stripes n order to control their voting how Israel wants them to vote? This hypocrisy will be the Jews' undoing, Despite your hollow screams of 'anti-semitism', Americans are slowly realizing that Israel's view is not America's view, and supporting Israel unilaterally has done the United States much, much harm in the world. If Israel was interested in any kind of peace, settlement-building would halt. Until it does, Israel lies about seeking a lasting peace. Love ya.
65. I AGREE WITH YOU ARI- 62
USA ,   USA   (03.26.08)
It is LONG overdue the USA critisizes Israel and the problems it causes the USA. LONG LONG OVERDUE. and, for you jewish Americans 'freaking' out... Where does your LOYALTY LIE? ARE YOU LIKE POLLARD a dualie that puts the safety of a foreign nation above the USA?
66. Progressive Jews love Obama
Tomas   (03.26.08)
Progressive/ liberal Jews love Obama and will sell Israel and there own family just to be liked by progressive movements. Progressive/ liberal Jews are cancer within Jewish sociaty.
67. Supporters of Obama and McPeak
Phil ,   US   (03.26.08)
One of the commenters on this article, Abe Froman is convinced that anybody who doesn't vote for Obama is a racist. In Abe's world, nothing that Obama does will lessen his suppoprt for the Illinois Senator. To Abe, it doesn't matter who OBAMA HAS SELECTED as his advisers or spiritual mentors or what views that they have. Anyone who doesn't vote for or expresses concern about Obama's lack of exerience or judgement is a racist. Then there are those who love to accuse Jews of dual loyalty. Evidently, in these pathetic people's minds, American Jews do not have the rights guaranteed under the Constitution for free speech and expressing their opinions because they are Jews. This is serious stuff and is antisemitism, not just animus towards Israel. To McPeak, the all-powerful Jewish cabal controls the entire country because there are a lot of Jews in New York and Miami. Those who agree with him are the enlightened or good Jews. How can Obama have such a person as one of his key advisers and one of his campaign directers?
68. To # 7, We support Obama for 2008
USA ,   New York   (03.26.08)
Only Obama can bring change for USA and save USA. The money USA donate to Israel is more than money donates to all African country.
69. Obama advisor: US Jews hinder peace
Linguini ,   Usrael   (03.26.08)
Telling the truth has been a fear for those very ones that call out wolf for everthing. I support the comments of McPeak , Jews have infiltrated this (usa) country and have managed to manipulate it into complete self destruction w/ the policies that are being implemented worldwide & NO to the having McPeak removed , why because Israel says so!? Well lets see where Obamas allegiance are w/ his next step .
70. WHAT HAPPENS IF OBAMA WINS ?
Arik Silverman ,   Mmilwaukee USA   (03.26.08)
What happens if Obama wins? What happens if Obama loses? That the Weekly Standard, product of ardent Zionists Rupert Murdoch and William Kristol, should write in this way about Obama and his advisor is no surprise -- it actually tends to give validity to what McPeak has said. From what I've seen of Mr. Kristol on many television shows, his intellect seems as dull and lifeless as his face. Nobody should rely on his advice, and his "help" might be a poisoned pill. What happens if Obama wins after all this bashing by right-wing Zionists? Unfortunately Israel might suffer from a backlash. What happens if Obama loses? If African Americans think that he was torpedoed by Jews such as Kristol, it will surely be a setback for Jewish-Black relations. In addition, Israel will lose support from upset Obama voters. These attacks are ill-advised. Kristol, Murdoch, and the others should stop digging up dirt and throwing it around. Most Americans don't care anyway about Obama's views on Israel, and most of those who do care are voting for McCain. This mudslinging only builds resentment against Jews and Israel..
71. To Dovy #19, two words come to mind
Jake   (03.26.08)
One of them is "you", and the other one isn't "thank".
72. Wolfram, #18, come again?
Jake   (03.26.08)
"a fair, just and humane US position toward Israel and Palestine. " Sorry, Wolfram, but I know of no country called 'Palestine', I thought that the existence of such an entity was supposed to be the outcome of negociations, and not a prerequisite. Oh, and when you say "fair, just, and humane", I sincerely hope that this would be better than that shown toward Queen Liliuokalani, who once ruled a sovereign nation, unlike "Palestine". What do you know? We are not all unsuspecting dupes.
73. No we can't!
Jake   (03.26.08)
74. anti-israel
dave page ,   voorhees, nj   (03.26.08)
It does seem that american politicians put israels interests before their own peoples. While agree we need to look out for each other. No country should put another peoples interests first. Especially when israel has been less than honest with spying and black ops against the usa.
75. Obama needs to put America 1st, 2nd and 3rd!
Makeshift Patriot ,   USofA   (03.26.08)
Let's face it Carter, Walt, Mearsheimer, and now McPeak all raise good points, which are hard to argue against- logically that is. So the shmear campaign continues. Not one of thems says that we should not support Israel, but that we need to put American interests first. Bush and his oil buddies get to control more petrol, the military-industrial complex gets more money (and uses more petrol) while the taxpayer is left paying the loan interest while our economy crumbles. I would vote for any candidate who weens Israel off the American teet. Israelis can't vote in our elections, so why so much interest in our politics?
76. Idiot Jewish Liberals Will STILL Vote For The Biggot!
David ,   Marietta USA   (03.26.08)
And I though Hillary was a disaster! It is amazing how how Hill and Bill and Hussein can make even John McCain, RINO (Republican In Name Only) to his core, look viable and even worth electing. With 8 months to go, we are in for one hell of a lot more fun and games. I can't wait till Hussein gets the MoveOn.Org Party nomination.
77. #75, Walt and Mearsheimer shot themselves in the foot
Jake   (03.26.08)
when one of their chief sources damning the "Israel lobby", Lawrence Wilkerson, chief of staff for Security of State Colin Powell, revealed that Israeli officials had warned the Bush administration AGAINST going to war in Iraq. This refutes one of the chief lies touted by the anti-Israel fetishists. How many times did that lie travel around the world before the truth got its boots on, eh? http://ipsnews.net/news.asp?idnews=39051
78. Ah yes the global Jewspiracy
Steve from Raleigh   (03.26.08)
We control the banks and yet have our hands out to the US. We control the media and yet the media is completely against us. We control the US government and yet the Arabs own this country and all the politicians. We're at the heart of a 1000 year old secret plot for world domination - - that everyone knows about.
79. #70, Arik Silverman from Milwaukee
Ignatious Mucklefutz ,   Fargo ND   (03.26.08)
Arik, you just don't know what you are talking about and sound just like a scared ghetto Jew. Oh me, oh my, if Obama loses the black-Jewish alliance may be damaged. Exactly what black-Jewish alliance are you talking about? African Americans have their concerns and American Jews have their concerns. Where they merge, there is an alliance. Where they differ, there is disagreement and discord. In congress, Jewish Democrats and the black caucus are often allies and that is good usually . However, to imply that Jews are not free to vote their interests because of black retaliation is despicable and cowardly. Sort of like the Sulzberger like Jews who were afraid to demand action to save Jews during the Holocaust because of their fear of non-Jews. The bottom line is that there are troubling issues surrounding Obama that have not gone away. His inexperience, his association with an anti-American and paranoid minister, his association with a church that is clearly anti-Israel, and his willingness to expose his little gitrls to bigoted sermons are deeply disturbing. In addition, his team of advisers is loaded with people who at best are unsympathetic to Israel and at worst are hostile to the existence of Israel also continues to be a redlight. My feeling is that Obama, if elected, will be another Jimmy Carter. We don't need that.
80. Did all anti-Semitic cooks have moved from Haaretz to ynet?
AK   (03.26.08)
81. Obama advisor right on this
Paulbe ,   Cairns Australia   (03.26.08)
He's absolutely right on this and you people know it. Lets have a quick roll call shall we? Pearle, Ledeen, Libby, Feith, Hadley, Kristol,....Does one really need go on? I suppose its "anti-Semitic" to point out the obvious though.
82. What if tis true?
Daniel ,   St. Johns, Canada   (03.27.08)
So, if someone thinks that jewish lobby groups in the us have to much power over their foreign policy, then that person is anti-jew? All blame should be placed on the Palestinians? Your failure to accept responsibility for any of your actions is not what I would expect from the people who were chosen to be gods people. you sound like a bunch of winy victims. not a strong people who can mold heir own destiny. You sound weak.
83. #81, Paulbe, a quick roll?
Jake   (03.26.08)
I found no evidence to substanciate your intimation that Stephen Hadley is a Jew. I also found nothing directly linking any of the other names you mentioned to the main topic of the article, namely Israel and the Mideast peace process. I suppose you simply things upside down.
84. Military Photos of the Twin Towers. - NEVER FORGET the 3,000
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (03.26.08)
and never forget the thousands of Jews maimed and murdered in Israel in the cruel world war against all of innocent humanity. Click on the bottom left side of screen to very quickly see 58 photos: http://www.scribd.com/doc/282415/Awesome-Military-photos-of-the-Twin-Towers Please G-D, protect the world's innocents.
85. 8. us people want to know if you are representative of
truth strikes again   (03.27.08)
Australia or are they mostly bright?
86. Bottom line: Obama is unelectable...
PK ,   Hong Kong   (03.27.08)
...and it has nothing to do with Israel or the Jews!
87. 26. Gee jonathan I didn't now that a Jew with an opinion
truth strikes again   (03.27.08)
different than yours was, "circumventing the democratic process." How long have you suffered from these delusions of our granduer? Just like the rest of the world, we too get to say what we think and we think General McWacky is a lying anti semite...and birds of a feather flock together....
88. 49...your oink is showing! Ew! Pull DOWN ur Shirt!
truth strikes again   (03.27.08)
89. 52 ur spelling and writing style sucks and you repeat urself
(03.27.08)
and over again....stop writing talkbacks as if we can't tell you're the same person giving the same negative type responses...and get a life
90. 61...the U.S. was founded as a Christian nation with the
(03.27.08)
sense and humanity to see the value of all people and not impose their religion on them. Read the founding fathers, they were amazing , visionery and Christian. The U.S. has continued to evolve from those early days to become even more accepting and inclusive. It is not a sin to be a Christian; it is only a sin not to allow others to practice their religion freely without fear. Speaking as a Jew...it's okay that America is Christian, it's not okay if they try to make me convert or damaged because I'm not. Please think it over some more. Is it possible that you are being unfairly critical?
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article