Jewish Scene
British Jews: Don't celebrate Israel's 60th
Hagit Klaiman
Published: 30.04.08, 20:11
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
171 Talkbacks for this article
91. Birds of a feather self hating Jews and the Guardian
A proud Israeli ,   Jerusalem   (05.01.08)
Just how sick are these people,we should ignore them,and forget that they exist or are Jews.After all they are English. The enemy within is far more dangerous than the enemy without. We will enjoy our 60th and they can stew in their own juices
92. Happy 60th to all Israel and all Israeli's
Salim Nouri ,   Rome Italy   (05.01.08)
As a non Jew I wish you a very happy 60th,Israel is a miracle in the true sense of the word. You have worked hard and done in 60 years more than your neighbours have done in 600.May God be with you.
93. They are horrible people and will fade away
Shame on them ,   USA   (05.01.08)
Long Live Israel!
94. Who breeds such dirt?
Gail ,   USA   (05.01.08)
Ohh...well, unfortunately we have them too.
95. Disgusted
j jasie ,   Baltimore,usa   (05.01.08)
This article shows how quickly we forget what happened 65 years ago. It is a sin for any Jew to denounce what they don't live for or understand. The signators seem to have forgotten the Holocaust. I think some of German Jewery felt the same before Hitler came to power. It could never happen to us. They were wrong and these British Elitists are wrong. We should never forget.
96. Very strange information!
Dr. Weinberger. ,   Tel-aviv   (05.01.08)
Professor of what? where did he get his education? Where did he get this weird information from? This person has a serious mental problem, and I guess the rest of the group too. What they say is not only groundless, but takes a real sick mind to invent, and to compare to the holocaust. No nation ever treated their enemy so well as we do. The Arabs are lucky that they fight us and not the English or German or Americans or the Iraqis !!!
97. #1
mark ,   ca   (05.01.08)
100%!
98. Only A Fool Would Believe This Crap
GillyRo ,   NYC USA   (05.01.08)
Yeah!
99. these morons live in a country that once expelled all Jews.
leo ,   NY   (05.01.08)
Shame on them!
100. British Jews: Don't celebrate Israel's 60th
Bill ,   Colorado Springs   (05.01.08)
Almost unbelievable.
101. Do any of the 100 write for Haartetz?
David ,   Houston   (05.01.08)
If not, they are missing out on the foremost publisher of anti-Semitic propaganda, would be just their cup of tea!
102. Israel
Michael ,   Boca Raton Florida U   (05.01.08)
Those who do not truly understand the ultimate goal of Israel and the goal of the Jewish people do not understand the real importance of Israel. Those who do not wish to celebrate need to consider why they are living freely in their respective country outside of Israel. If Israel does not exist then neither will each of us. Think before you say such things. Sorry if this offends anyone as this is not the intension.
103. IT is fabriacted
Roshan Rahim ,   UK   (05.01.08)
UK Jews are far away from reality. They are doing it under pressure or are like Camels with heads buried in sand.
104. well known intellectuals??
eliezer ,   jerusalem   (05.01.08)
wow they got 100 self hating Jews in Merry England to sign a petition against Israel. Well, they are probably run aways from the Meretz party.
105. Them and Barbara Streisand
(05.01.08)
Let them party together, the great minds without roots and identity, the peace loving hypocretical whores of Europe. Who wants you to celebrate with us? Don't even think about it, you are not invited! You can rot in your rat holes.
106. Look, I obviously don't want anything bad to happen to the
Yuvi ,   Haifa   (05.01.08)
European Jewry, but... If a right-wing fascist ever gain control of Britain or Europe, I'll be the first one to protest against letting these fools in to my country. I would gladly support them remaining in Europe, trying to save their own skin. That's how much I despise you, racist cunts.
107. British Jews
drjohn ,   Rechovot Israel   (05.01.08)
Thank G-d I left these deluded idiots behind, when I emigrated. Take it as written that there will come a day that they will beg for Israel to allow them in. ( Not that we need this kind of rubbish here!!!)
108. Final solution for them!!
zosh   (05.01.08)
109. British Jews v Israel
I.Kemp ,   Nahariya   (05.01.08)
Here we go again - Academics ! This lot in the UK are no different than terrorists. They should feel perfectly at home in the UK amongst the sponsors of terror against Israel
110. God save the queen...
Paul HT ,   Jer. Israel   (05.01.08)
Fascist Regime!!! IDIOTS!
111. self-hating morons
Roni   (05.01.08)
112. to yaron 65 and the camel
ayda ,   jerusalem   (05.01.08)
in our holy book god say ,think about the camel how god create it ] do you think if this same god would sent a new religion to canada or to usa he would say .. think about an earoplane how did you do . . . i want a reply
113. british Jews
bareven   (05.01.08)
Rabbi Melamed , are those guys also on your list of "Jews" whom you would give the Israeli citizenship ?
114. Who needs them.
David ,   Australia   (05.01.08)
Why dont they denounce there own faith and go and join the other side. We certainly dont need them. I am proud to be a jew and proud of what Israel has achieved. Um yisrael chai
115. Do you know...?
Gimpel the Fool ,   Jhb, S.A.   (05.01.08)
Can anyone who knows about the above 100 self haters, enlighten me about their marital status. Is Steven Fry married to a jew etc? Usually self hating Jews have married out, and as a result have this need to attack their religion due to issues they have in their unconscious minds (all the guilt). Just my theory, but I would be interested to know,
116. A very bad case of brown-nosed toadies
James McNamara ,   Broken Hill OZ   (05.01.08)
Ignore them,every country has it's quislings. If Israel's next 60 years are as good as the first 60th. Then Israel will be soaring to great heights.Cheers from true blue
117. No.53 would you like to know where Egypt is?
YSL ,   Jerusalem Israel   (05.01.08)
Egypt is in that place where there are food riots at the moment,there are riots because the government can't feed it's citizens.Where a nurse earns only a few dollar a day,that is if she is lucky enough to have a job.it is over populated,crowed,dirty and it stinks.It would take Egypt 6000 years to achieve what Israel has achieved in 60 years.
118. Bet they didn't stand side by side for 2 minutes
Israel   (05.01.08)
to remember the holocaust - it was business as usual in the UK - and the 6 million jews that died - a faded mark in human history. The Brits don't feel the way we feel about it. British Jews are arrogant assholes - ignore them.
119. kol hakavod, well said
(05.01.08)
finaly somebody is telling the truth, when the israelis wil wake up. Answer NEVER
120. #117 It would take Egypt much more than 6000 years
observer   (05.01.08)
to achieve what Israel has achieved in 60 years. Egypt will never be able to achieve even half of it !
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article