because in my opinion those people can read what someone writes . Being Jewish is not only a religion , it's belonging to a people . Belonging with TRUE and not faraway connections , even proven by DNA . With this faraway "origin" , being cut off from everything Jewish for centuries , having lost everything Jewish , you can't have this Jewish background , we , true , even secular atheists as i am , Jews have . I can accept you as a person with faraway Jewish origin , i can accept you as a Zionist , but not as a Jew .

not a She .

Slicha I only read sousan I thought he was a she my apologies. Its true I am no scientist and sometimes i dont read correctly but on the other hand I see the results of dna in the news all the time. I don't believe everything I read of course but if a court says this child is yoiurs oir yoiu killed that person. Lifetime judgement calls. Also with the new stemcell research If it quacks like a duck walks like a duck it was be a duck. In my opinion I would like to see the original hebrews together but who knows at this point its still relativly new dna genealogy. I do on the other hand think that it has been proven that people have converted to other religions. So we must be carefull as to who we call jew for security reasons and multi religious view mixing messiancs and islamianics . How would we deal with that . We have enough problems in the middle east. Maybe only from prostelizing judaism to them and it wouldn't be guarenteed effective.