News
Report: Bush offers swift Golan withdrawal
Roee Nahmias
Published: 17.10.08, 10:22
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
101 Talkbacks for this article
91. I think news sites need a FWIW section
Raymond in DC ,   Washington, DC USA   (10.17.08)
The vast majority of these "reports" are next to worthless - they're idle speculation, propaganda intended to drive events, trial balloons, etc. (How many times has the Times of London, for example, reported an imminent strike on Iran?) A proper first response might be "consider the source". If the news editor can't get confirmation, such reports belong in a special "For what it's worth..." section. But people, especially on a site like this, respond to such reports because they "ring true". They see Olmert, Livni and their ilk ready to adopt the narrative and claims of the enemy. They see Bush and Rice desperate for *something* positive to balance their troubled foreign policy legacies. So a quick sell-out of Israel for any kind of deal isn't beyond credibility.
92. Can you believe idiot Bush?
Moshe ,   telaviv   (10.17.08)
Can you believe the stupidity of this man? Who is he to make decisions on behalf of our nation? Just because he is the least popular president ever and wants to achieve something that he would be remembered for, he is willing to sacrifice Israel. What a real idiot.
93. Ungrateful Jews.
Brad Boehm ,   USA   (10.17.08)
With all the aid that we provide Israel, you would expect you people to be a little grateful. If you dont go for the principle of land for peace, then dont come to us crying when your ass is kicked in the next war.
94. Post#24 Sayid your facts about Dayan are not true.
Ken Jurist   (10.18.08)
Your probably talking about the supposed interview he did with Rami Tal in 1976. In the interview, Tal claims that Dayan told him, Israel instigated the attacks on Syria in the Golan. This is a blatant lie which i can prove. First, why did Tal come out with this interview he did 19 years later. He did the interview in 1976 and came out with what he said Dayan told him in 1995. 14 years after Dayan died in 81. 2nd, if Tal is right and Dayan told him this. Then obviously their would be soldiers who were under Dayan's command from 48 to 67 who would verify that Israel instigated Syria. That fact not one soldier under Dayan's command has corraberated what Tal said Dayan told him. This is the real reason why Tal waited till Dayan died to come out with the interview. Tal made up this fact, cause he's a really a peace now supporter who believes in land for terror camps.
95. To #93 People w/out Knowledge
Oswald Machorro ,   greensboro, nc   (10.18.08)
Gets Me upset to see the millions of people like this one (stupid). First: All of that land belongs to Israel given by G-d. Second:- The U.S. doesnt have to give any money to Israel, G-d will provide victory - If the U.S. keeps pushing on this matter to give away Her land - The Lord will deal with the U.S. very hard.
96. #47 the little problem of the people
(10.18.08)
Israel expelled 120,000 Arab residents of Golan, for what reason? to replace them with Jewish people to full-fill a Jewish prophecy? the International Court wouldn't accept prophecy claim, either. Neither was it righting the wrong by claiming the inheritance of the land by evacuating its inhabitants for thousands of years. If Israel had had the right to the land, Israel would have presented its claim to the International court. Annexing land by force didn't need a court of law. Israel, in the process of creation, never resorted to the International court, why? because of assured failure if it had done so.
97. #47 Neither was Palesdtine identified separate from Syria
(10.18.08)
98. house demolition in Golan
(10.18.08)
>>approximately 120,000 Druze and Arabs were expelled from the Syria Golan Heights in 1967 and their villages (134 in number) were completely demolished, that makes about 20,000 additional demolished homes, assuming six people per family unit. >>1967-2006 number of house demolitions = 18,147
99. 96: The land flourishes when the Jews are there, but not
Rivkah   (10.18.08)
when the Arabs were there. That is true of the Golan and Gaza and all the disputed areas. God's promise that the land would flourish for the rightful inhabitants is another indication of the territory God wants for the Jews. You should read the prophecies of Zechariah even if the courts do not consider prophesies. They should consider what Zechariah has to say since all the prophesies of the Bible that have so far come to pass are 100% accurate. When the Jewish Messiah who is the son of God comes at Armageddon to deliver his people with angels who gather them from the four corners of the earth, and he stops the inhabitants of the earth from destroying the earth, he will do something else...he will judge the nations (races) for how they treated the Jews. Doesn't bode too well for Arabs and Islamics who persecute Israel.
100. #99 Zechariah, Messiah prophesied much more for Muslims
(10.18.08)
but Jews do not recognize them. Don't pretend to be Jewish, Jews never recognize a convert. God is the Ultimate Judge.
101. When Did the CONQUEST of ISRAEL by Global Jihad Supporter US
Linda Rivera ,   New York   (10.19.08)
When did the CONQUEST of ISRAEL by Global Jihad Supporter US/Bush Take Place... enabling the Powerful Ally of Jihad, the U.S., to offer HUGE chunks of little Israel to her worst enemies? In Islam, ALL countries that are not Muslim are regarded as dar al-harb - the House of War - to be conquered for Islam. Conquered and subjugated under Islamic sharia law, defenseless non-Muslims have NO human rights. On the frontlines of global jihad, Israel fights for all of the world's non-Muslims. US/Bush wickedly seek to render Israel powerless and defenseless in the cruel global jihad war against Israel and the Free World. World wide street protests are urgently required to save Israel and the Free World. A Muslim terror state in Israel would reduce Israel at mid-section to 9 miles wide INDEFENSIBLE, Auschwitz borders. Take to the streets in mass strikes and protest Israel! Save your freedom and your lives! STOP the US/EU/Islam PLANNED Second HOLOCAUST
Previous talkbacks
Back to article