Opinion
Your opinion is irrelevant
Hanoch Daum
Published: 04.01.09, 14:03
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
130 Talkbacks for this article
31. KOL HAKAVOD Hanoch!
Proud Israeli! ,   Haifa, Israel   (01.04.09)
32. True words
Alon K. ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (01.04.09)
The fifth column and self-haters need to keep quiet. Arrest all traitors and release them into Gaza when this is over.
33. to #3 Maria
Susan ,   Kfar Saba   (01.04.09)
Next time tell them not to pick a fight with us. This is a good example of meglomaniac leaders bringing destruction down on their own people.
34. Response to Maria (#4)
Moshe Z. Matitya ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (01.04.09)
You're absolutely right. The deaths of a few Jews is no big deal. Who cares?
35. Sorry, I meant #3
Moshe Z. Matitya ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (01.04.09)
36. The hypocrisy of the left.
Robert Bernier ,   Tel Aviv   (01.04.09)
The hypocrisy of the left is astounding. They shout, “End the occupation now!” but when Israel did end the occupation of Gaza, they accused Israel of unilateralism. They cry out against racism, but they treat the Palestinians with a paternalistic racism that considers them so primitive they cannot be held responsible for what they do. After all, I have been told, you can’t expect the Palestinians to change, they grew up with an anti-Israel narrative. Israelis are expected to change. Israelis who have lived for years under the threat of Arab aggression and Palestinian terrorism are expected to change and to forgive and to apologize. But Palestinians are not expected to change. They are not expected to stop broadcasting children’s TV programs that fill their children’s minds with racist hatred. No wonder the Palestinians keep calling themselves victims. More about correctness at : http://israelagainstterror.blogspot.com/2008/02/collapse-of-political-correctnesswhere.html
37. To Andrew "Silly Article"
Robert ,   Brooklyn   (01.04.09)
Andrew, on the contrary the world is getting fed up with islamists and their pushy inhuman behavior. They are nothing but bullies unable to co-exist with any other people or religion anywhere. Proof of it is everywhere, - Kashmir, Kosovo, Dearborn, etc etc. These "protests" used to mean something when Arabs had power due to oil prices, but it's done and all over with my friend, Islamists and their goverments no longer have much leverage to manipulate and blackmail israel and free world into submission. Their "commodity" is no longer in high demand. Russia knows this, EU knows this. Notice how silent Russia has been on this whole thing?? World is heading into an economic crisis and Israel will be much much needed. So this time "the propaganda" will just remain what it is, propaganda. This just war is not just actions of Israeli government , but the entire Israeli population is solidly behind it, do you have a problem with them Andrew??
38. Notice how silent Russia is??
robert ,   Brooklyn   (01.04.09)
Notice, no reaction whatsover from Rossiaya ?:) There are few good reasons for that. Times of arabs and islamists blackmailing everyone with their well know high prized commodity are pretty much over. Russia and EU have advanced economical pacts with Israel, and in these horrible economic times, when both Russia and EU are goign broke, they simply do not wish to annoy a friend they need. Change is coming to Iran as well very soon, you will see.
39. # 3
Gersh ,   Usa   (01.04.09)
To #3 - did you read the title of the article - we don't care what you say. With that being said -if London was being bombed on a daily basis what would you expect your gov't to do , sit there a pick there nose as their people die
40. #3 - you idiot...
Idan ,   Hod Hasharon   (01.04.09)
Do you think London would have sat by in a restrained manner over several YEARS, like Jerusalem has, if rockets were falling on British cities from a neighboring territory. The answer is no you big fat moron - so STFU. And yes, by the way, anybody who wants to go around killing Israelis, targeting our civilian areas should learn to expect an overwhelmingly deadly response. Israel will destroy the Hamas now as well we should. We regret that Hamas hides behind civilians and we do what we can to avoid civilian deaths. But we will destroy the Hamas.
41. Maria, UK
m ,   Ashkelon, Israel   (01.04.09)
Maria - I will repeat once again : 8 years of rockets over the heads of our communities & parents who care enough to make sure that their children are protected in bunkers. If you don't know the famous quote by Golda Meir about loving our children - then go look it up - that's the difference - we don't put our innocent population in danger, and we defend them when they are. Live and Learn - ignorance is nothing to be proud of dear.
42. That's it.
Yakov   (01.04.09)
This article puts it very clearly the choice that Israel has to make when it starts this operation. By necessity, it must first secure the lives and lot of Israelis living in the South. It's only the duty. The Gaza pullout was a big mistake that we have been paying for the last few years since. We continue to pay for it because here we are going back into Gaza to clean it up. The leadership should ask itself when doing anything requiring "evacuation": Will we need to return there in a few years because things got out of hand?
43. GOOD JOB ISRAEL!
Petra ,   usa   (01.04.09)
44. GOOD!!!
Jacob   (01.04.09)
But we have a enemy within.
45. #12 The world gets fed up with terrorists and the UN
Siro ,   Rome   (01.04.09)
I have to tell you, that 1.) Gaza was occupied in the first place through wars against Arabs which where instigated by the latter. And it is a known fact, that most countries who conquer land in wars actually keep it! 2.) The civilized world is fed up with Islamic terrorists and their intimidation by the Arabs for others speaking out. 3.) The UN is exactly what it stands for : United Nothing@! 4.) No country on this earth would tolerate the indiscriminate shellings of its own population centers. 5.) Where in the hell is "Chester"?
46. To the Arabs
USA   (01.04.09)
You have a better shot at creating a "Palestine" in France or Greece than you do in Israel. They are practically all Palestinians over there anyway. Believe me they will not withstand one suicide attack in on one of their busses or subways.
47. #10
mark ,   ca   (01.04.09)
Avi,be nice. I don't know about Kev, but many of us who is living abroad, served in IDF before you was born.Take it easy,eled :-))
48. Israeli democracy summed up in four words
GUH   (01.04.09)
If you do not conform to the Zionist Regime's onslaught in Gaza, you are irrelevant. Quite simple, really.
49. Gaza before and after withdrawal.
Friend of Israel ,   UK   (01.04.09)
When did Israel get more rockets from Gaza, before or after leaving the place? Have you learnt anything? Truely the opinions of the anti-war demonstrators is of no consequences. Hamas charter calls for the destruction of israel. This is the only reason why Hamas was created. God will deliver Israel in the end.
50. Spouting Drivel....
Moose ,   Israel   (01.04.09)
If you must spout such drivel at least use spell check. Badly written drivel is so much more painful to read.
51. Silly response andrew
Daniel ,   Formerly Israel   (01.04.09)
We did take Gaza 40 years ago, but you have forgotten the following facts: We suffered terror attacks from Gaza for eight years (from 1948 to 1956) before we ever set foot in it. We conquered it in 1967 after the Egyptians forced the UN (which had been stationed in Gaza since 1956, to withdraw and prepared to attack us. We then spent the next forty years trying to exchange the land we conquered for peace, but for thirty years the Palestinians refused to make treaties with us and for ten more broke every treaty they made. We finally withdrew from Gaza without making any treaties just as a show of good-will, which has since been answered with five thousand rockets. The only gesture of good-will the Palestinians ever made toward us is to temporarily stop trying to kill us. They sure have been nice neighbors.
52. josh@xrayjeans.com
josh kameo ,   United States   (01.04.09)
I think this is one of the best written articales that i have read in a while. It is true Israel not only has a right but also has a duty to portect its citizins before having to portect the citzins of Gaza. it is unfortunate that there will be civilian casualtys in the middle and no one wants that exept i think hamas because they are the ones that are putting them in this danger. The Arabs can live a great life with the Jews side by side if there wasnt this hatred that hamas and every terror group puts into there citzins to hate Israel . I live with Arabs side by side and i work with them and we live a normal life as civilzed people and we have no problems with each other the only diffrince is they do not listen to hamas.
53. All guilty.
Logan ,   Brazil   (01.04.09)
In this war there are no innocents, all are guilty. The arabs because they don't care about their own people that are suffering at Gaza Strip and West Bank. And the Israelis because they use desproportional force to strike terror targets, with no care with the arab civilians.
54. #3 and #12 - Read This and Learn Something You Ignorant Fool
Eran ,   Edgewater, NJ   (01.04.09)
http://www.spectator.co.uk/melaniephillips/3204131/the-moral-battleground.thtml Particularly striking in its malice is the way in which the treatment of wounded Palestinians in Israeli hospitals is ignored – while news of the barbaric behaviour of Hamas in Gaza’s hospitals is airbrushed out of the picture. At WSJ’s Opinion Journal, James Taranto noted that a report of this scene in a Gaza hospital briefly appeared in the New York Times a couple of days ago: Armed Hamas militants in civilian clothes roamed the halls. Asked their function, they said it was to provide security. But there was internal bloodletting under way. In the fourth-floor orthopaedic section, a woman in her late 20s asked a militant to let her see Saleh Hajoj, her 32-year-old husband. She was turned away and left the hospital. Fifteen minutes later, Mr. Hajoj was carried out by young men pretending to transfer him to another ward. As he lay on the stretcher, he was shot in the left side of the head. Mr. Hajoj, like five others killed at the hospital this way in 24 hours, [my emphasis] was accused of collaboration with Israel. He had been in the central prison awaiting trial by Hamas judges; when Israel destroyed the prison on Sunday he and the others were transferred to the hospital. But their trials were short-circuited...
55. #3, this is going on for 8 years and Enogh is ENOUGH.
Asher ,   NY,USA   (01.04.09)
56. #26 Blind to Palestinian Terror
Cynthia ,   USA   (01.04.09)
You missed the thousands of kassams bashing Israel and Hamas "fighters" dressed in pitiful disguises posing next to their kassam launchers. Crime doesn't pay because the crime they sowed has now buried them. Perhaps you should welcome the fleeing Palestinians into Egypt instead of using them for your propaganda campaign.
57. Isis in Cairo
Sam ,   Canada   (01.04.09)
While the world accepted Israel as a legitimate Jewish-majority country the Arab world never did and certainly the Palestinians never did. Consequently,Arabs have never stopped attacking Israel (occupied territories or not) The only successful way to get Arab countries to stop attacking has been with a LARGE bombardment. This includes Hezbollah and Lebanon. The small retaliations are just brushed off by the Palestinians. I assure you that Jews are not interested in having any Arab casualties whatsoever but I also assure you that Israelis will not give up their country or change their demography because of Arab threats or attacks.
58. what I want from those who hate Israel
what is "occupation" ,   Settler, Columbus OH   (01.04.09)
TO those who hate israel... I do not care if you accept me, call me sons of pigs and apes... I do not care if you boycott me or exclude me from your clubs or universities... I do not care if you LIKE me, respect my faith or even hate me... But there is only on thing i wish... That you fear me... Screw with me? We will hurt you, your kids, your grandkids.... Is that clear yet? the days of legally expressing yourselves to us with rockets, knives and guns are over...
59. #3
jewish girl ,   israel   (01.04.09)
4 or 5 ISRAELI'S deaths is a big deal and the THOUSANDS WHO DIED BY BOMBERS. Who do you think you are?? What country are you from? You are a low life. NEWS FOR YOU JEWISH LIVES ARE WORTH MORE THE PALIS LIVES. GO BACK UNDER YOUR ROCK.
60. #10 DO NOT BE SO HARD ON SOME
JEWISH GIRL ,   ISRAEL   (01.04.09)
ONE WHO AGRESS WITH US. IT IS NICE TO HEAR FROM PEOPLE LIKE HIM. PEOPLE LIKE HIM WILL GO OUT INTO THE WORLD AND TELL OTHERS THAT ISRAEL IS RIGHT. WE DO NEED THEM ........... SO DO NOT BE SO HARD ON OUR FRIENDS.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article