News
Report: Dozens dead in IDF strikes
Ali Waked
Published: 06.01.09, 17:20
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
172 Talkbacks for this article
61. To Citizen
Salvador ,   USA   (01.06.09)
Remember all Hamas want to go to hell with their boss satan.
62. School targeted deliberately
George ,   Canada   (01.06.09)
This Overwhelming and disproportion using of force is done deliberately and intentionally to terrify the populations and get them stand against Hamas from one side and build the lost IDF deterrent factor for Hamas from other side. It is well known Israeli approach. The Israeli generals have spoken about that openly many times. Again UN school was targeted because Hamas was lunching racket from within or by mistake, who believe in that, Israel who has air spy plans fly 24 hours and the most advanced precise weapon do this mistake. This school was targeted as exit policy to have excuse ending this operation, exactly like in Lebanon war when UN compound was targeted. One tank shall shut and hundred of civilian casualty. Good way to say to its citizen the world pressure on us is tremendous, we cannot continue. All the UN facility in Gaza are well coordinated and well known to the Israeli army and being used as refuge with hundred of civilian are being informed. This is the UN spokes man statement.
63. #12 Terrorist Supporter
NoPatienceForIdiots ,   LI, NY   (01.06.09)
I'm surprised you feel badly about the Holocaust. You otherwise sound like a dyed in the wool bigot. "The ability of Jewish people to rid themselves of any and all guilt since 1945 is astounding. " Guilt over what? Defending ourselves from terrorists and Jew haters? Our actions are justified. "You murder babies, slaughter thousands, and make millions suffer and still feel justified." I love it when liberals and anti semites make us out to sound like Nazis. Terry, I don't know what demented thought you have in your peanut-sized brain, but I assure you, your description is apropos of terrorist tactics rather than the actions of the IDF. When thousands of rockets start raining down onto Chicago, then you will gain the insight of what the Jews of Israel are faced with. Then you will see what "heartless beasts" really are. I hope you and your family are indiscriminately targeted 24 hours a day 7 days a week so that you may then be able to post more balanced comments.
64. we have crossed the line.
jos ,   israel   (01.06.09)
I initially supported this operation, but this is unacceptable. And everyone who can justify the deaths of civilians hiding from the bombings is just sick.
65. Can I add something else?
Terry ,   Eilat, Israel   (01.06.09)
When Hamas was sending suicide bombers into Israel during the intifada, deliberately targeting civilians, in cafes, buses, markets, night-clubs, etc. these incidents made a brief headline & were gone before the day was out. There was no outcry, no international outrage, no UN involvement, no diplomats flying around trying to prevent such attacks. The only real consequence was a lot of Jews sitting shiva for murdered loved ones, a lot of ruined lives while Palestinians passed out sweets, rejoicing in death. Yet somehow you feel more sympathy for those that perpetrated those horrors, for those that deliberately provoked a military response, & try to misplace the ultimate responsibility for the consequences. Your idea of morality is seriously perverted.
66. to17
Helena ,   Stockholm Sweden   (01.06.09)
good point Chaya, let's wait for more info from reliable sources - unfortunately such sources are very few indeed.
67. Israel had stated its position clearly and often
Ibrahim ,   S. Arabia   (01.06.09)
Israel had told the Palestinians many times that they would pay a heavy price if they continued the rocket attacks. Israel has been saying it for a long time. The time came, after seeing no change, to get into action. The Palestinians pay no attention to Israel's warnings. They obviously want as much killing of civilians and destruction of civilian targets as possible-it's their only way to garner sympathy and money. Strange how no one says anything about the Palestinians' lack of any action to protect their civilians-women, children, old men are right there in the streets next to gunmen. The prize for propaganda goes to the Palestinians once again. And the heads of state who have large Muslim populations in their countries, of course, speak up in defense of the Palestinians, to prevent riots in their own streets. It's way too much propaganda. Meanwhile, everyone blames Israel, for taking decisive action to stop rockets raining on its cities. As if accepting rockets on their heads makes good sense and they should accept it as part of life!
68. Israel is making every jew a target by it's actions!
IRAN#1   (01.06.09)
Jews around the world have to be very careful now. The backlash is going to be pretty severe.
69. As Tzipi Livni said: "No humanitarian crisis in Gaza"
oscar ,   buenos aires   (01.06.09)
70. wait the futur
rachid ,   morocco   (01.06.09)
if israel believes that their actual crime will be forgotten by the palestinian and also arabic people let me tell you israel is dreaming because future will show them that they miss a big opportinity for the peace .... we beleive to the future
71. If HAMAS cared about its people, the rockets would stop
meir elazar   (01.06.09)
Our responsibility is to protect our people at ALL COSTS. If HAMAS gave a damn about its people, it would: 1. NOT have sent suicide bombers to our cities which resulted in the SIEGE to stop them. 2. STOP the ROCKET ATTACKS on our people. The TERROR ATTACK on our people is their PRIMARY GOAL and they don't give a damn about the people. THEREFORE NEITHER DO I. I don't care if 1.5 million Gazans are permanently banished if it stops the rockets against our innocent civilians. I don't care how many Gazans are hurt or killed if the terrorist hide behind their civilians. THEIR CHARTER UNCOMPROMISINGLY CALLS FOR ISRAEL's DESTRUCTION AND THE DEATH OF ALL ISRAELIS AND JEWS. They are getting exactly what they wish on us and deservedly so. WE MUST CONTINUE UNTIL HAMAS UNCONDITIONALLY SURRENDERS. The current numbers of casualties are insignificant when compared to WWII or even Viet Nam. Furthermore, listen to the rhetoric of the terrorist threatening to be our graveyard. Right now it looks like it will be THEIR graveyard and THEY DUG THE GRAVES.
72. It's called rules of the game
chaimon ,   israel   (01.06.09)
Well, to all of you that cry about the dead arabs: You cannot change the rules at will. 1- you say they are humans, so theoretically, have human rights. 2- As part of their human rights, they have the right to choose their representatives. It's called democracy. 3- They choose wrong. Or right, as you prefer. Their leaders promised them to annihilate the neighbors They liked the idea and thus vote for them. 4- Just to be honest: israelis choose Kadima, and suffered rockets from Gaza a lot of years. Everyone choose what they want. 5- Gazans were saying to media before the IDF entered: If we knew before that Israel will bent under rockets, we would bomb them before. 6- War happens. Yes, war. People dies, if you can consider them people. You, "civilized person" reading and writing here, would be able to choose a representative as Hamas for yourself? 7-Conclusion: you cannot change the rules. Israel proceeds as the rules. You attack me, you will be held responsible. Think what you want , but rules are rules. Don't judge Israel before judging others and you.
73. You people are doing terrible crime, I am almost crrying:((
Andrei ,   Владивосток, Russia   (01.06.09)
74. It is war
sanna ,   sweden   (01.06.09)
Sad things and mistakes happens, otherwise the israeli soldiers also would be alive to day. But I´m not so sure it turn out to be Israels fault alone, when the investigation is complete. UN and UNWRA has long time collaborated with Hamas.
75. We support you
Tar Pit ,   USA   (01.06.09)
Keep up the good job. Israel we are with you ! don't let one Hamas terrorist escape alive their fate !
76. Bombing Schools and Mosques
Carlton ,   Dublin Ireland   (01.06.09)
Is it not time to stop this killing, you know that that rest of the world condems you (apart from your buddy Bush).
77. For This Operation To Be Successful...
Reuven Brauner ,   Raanana, Israel   (01.06.09)
Israel must clobber the Gazans. They simply do not understand any other language. You cannot talk with them. You cannot reason with them. You cannot threaten them. You cannot even hit them lightly as a warning. The only thing they understand is clobbering, and then only maybe.
78. the cycle well turn,
realistic   (01.06.09)
plant hatred, this killing well not be forgiven,
79. 40 dead at school in Gaza
John ,   Los Angeles Califor   (01.06.09)
If it is true that 40 civilians died due to shelling of UNRWA school then the campaign is effectively over. There will be outrage in the United States and all over the World that will force the U.S. to pressure Israel to stop the massacre. In other words, Hamas has won by not allowing Israel to achieve its objectives.
80. #29 Great analysis Vin
No PatienceForIdiots ,   LI, NY   (01.06.09)
The 3rd grade special education students I teach said the same thing.
81. UNRWA 'School'
Ros ,   London, UK   (01.06.09)
An article appearing today said that there would be a 'massacre' within the next few days because the Palestinians are losing the war but want to win the propaganda war. This will be the way that they do it. In the same way that they did in Lebanon. The world will buy it and press those Israeli 'butchers' to end their hostilities and the status quo will remain. Next time the rockets will go to Tel Aviv.
82. UNWRA "school" is a mortar and rockets launch site..
The Doc ,   Haifa, Israel   (01.06.09)
...and an ammunition cache. It is a legitimate target - especially when terrorists are in it!
83. retaliating against Hamas
Zuri ,   Sydney Australia   (01.06.09)
Like many Jews and Israelis and many people around the world I would have liked Israel to stop the incursion against Gaza and avoid civilian casualties. I agree with Yossi that we have the right to defend ourselves, however this seems an un-winnable war with dire consequences. I would like the Israeli government to avoid any civilians casualties and stop a collective punishment against the Palestinian people. We as Israelis and Jews around the world would like to see an end to this senseless violence. As a father myself I wouldn't like to see my little kids hurt, so understandingly even though Israel has the right to defend it's borders and against the rockets fired daily from Gaza I feel for Innocent people trapped there. We are facing a big problem, we want peace with the Palestinians who do not respect cease fire or any agreement. They tried to take over Jordan as you remember in 1970 and King Hussein eventually defeated them .then expelled to Lebanon and in Lebanon we already know the chaos they have caused in Lebanon We call terrorist Ismael Hania to stop being stupid and stop with rocket attack on Israel. and use all the millions of euros of aid from EU to use for Palestinian people, i.e. hospitals schools food and not steal the money for Hamas so they can bomb Israel The terrorist group Hamas is the cancer in Gaza preventing any progress for Palestinians, and as long they rule Gaza there will have a future Arabs and Jews should be able to live side by side as long as there a mutual respect, and positive negotiating, why the hell we gave them Gaza back???? We want real peace in return and not war.
84. Enough!! Is this Olmerts iron fist, killing children?
ben Avraham ,   הבלקן   (01.06.09)
Maurice Samuel writes: "In everything we are destroyers - even in the instruments of destruction to which we turn for relief. The very socialism and internationalism through which our choked spirit seeks utterance, which seem to threaten your way of life, are alien to our spirit's demands and needs. Your socialists and internationalists are not serious."
85. #29 HAMAS WILL NOT FIGHT ISRAEL FACE TO FACE
andy ,   orlando   (01.06.09)
Instead Hamas choose to attack Israel and hide amongst civilians.This is called PERFIDY and is contrary to the Geneva Convention.When Hamas fight in the open like a regular army,then there will be less civilian casualties!!!
86. This is report is not ballanced and dosen't show all facts.
Asher ,   NY,USA   (01.06.09)
IDF has lost it's own soldiers by friendly fire and in war many casualties happen specially when the coward Hamas militants change outfits into civilians and use the well-known cowardly tactics to put as many civilians into danger as human shields. When gazan civilians accept to have these cowards among themselves and let them hide behind women and children they signing to their own destruction. These casualties happen because of coward Hamas militants hiding among women and children. This the nature of cowardly militants that only learened how to stab in the back.
87. To Humanitarians;
George Weiss ,   Boston Ma   (01.06.09)
To all of the humanitiarians who decry the alleged attack on the UN school; Question for you; Are you willing to die, and have your wife and kids die, if a terrorist comes to blow you up and is hiding behind women and children (his family- who also wants you and your kids to die) and if the police shoot at him, they may kill his family? So, are you READY to sacrifice your kids and your wife? If not, don't criticize Israel for protecting their wifes and kids from this cuthroats.
88. Some questions
Brent ,   Lawrence, US   (01.06.09)
The deaths of noncombatants has never been the objective of western countries in the modern era. However, before the anti-Israel crowd jumps to conclusions, perhaps they should pause and take a breath. First, the claim the school was hit by Israelis comes from Hamas. Who would have the most to gain from such an incident? Hamas would. So, would they be tempted to "distort" or "create" such an incident for propaganda purposes? Does anyone remember the "dead" boy shown on French TV? Court investigations in France showed that the entire scene was faked and done so to illicit a sympathetic response from westerners. Lesson here? Don't get sucked in. Further, how does a single artillery shell collapse an entire school? I have some experience with explosives and their effects. It would have required a very large shell or some kind of special munition--Fuel Air--to have the power to even come close. Additionally, were there secondary explosions? If so, then this was no "school". Historically, various twisted goverenments have deliberately placed non-combatants in or on military targets. I give you Saddam Hussein as one example. Hamas has used similar tactics in the past. This may prove to be another example. In otherwords, if you have assumed this is an Israeli driven atrocity, then you are most likely either responding from bias or acting without all the facts.
89. I agree #65 & 67
A.M. ,   Muscat, Oman   (01.06.09)
Peoples' opinions become perverted when it comes to issues of Jewish self-defense. Hamas and the Palestinians who elected them brought this upon themselves.
90. What would we do
andy ,   Nottingham UK   (01.06.09)
I Live in Nottingham Uk 40km from Leicester. Nottingham has a good size jewish community Leicester is 75% mouslim. If Leicester who want the city to be an islamic state start to launch Rockets at Nottingham what would we do? I would do the same as Israel. I am not jewish and i dont even know any jews but the point is DEFENCE israel wants peace Hamas wants war with Israel. and if any idiot in france thinks that they will be safe well ha ha ha because HAMAS WANT TO KILL ANY WESTERN COMMUNITY uk usa france they hate us all GO ISRAEL DO WHAT NO OTHER COUNTRY HAS THE BALLS TO DO
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article