News
UN: IDF shelled evacuated civilians
AFP
Published: 09.01.09, 13:15
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
92 Talkbacks for this article
61. would someone tell me why when muslims killed 200,000
amymarkell ,   usa   (01.09.09)
innocent people including kids and women in DARFUR and sub sahara no one said anything??????????????????????? tell me why we hould be held to any higher level of standard than they do themselves?>>>>>>>>>>
62. why doesnt anyone say anything about darfur and how
amymarkell ,   usa   (01.09.09)
these muslims barbarians kill and murder 200,000 people and take over but that is okay with the world right? bythe way, those were women and kids, and still no one objects to that, why is it only world looking at waht israel does to stay alive? some one of you ARABS tell me that please before you bash us for defending our only homeland. ARABS address this is you have any guts? 200,000 isa lot of men women and kiddies to kill for no reason other than you want their land and to convert them ARABS tell me, take responsibility for this question
63. why is black african blood cheaper than arab blood in darfur
amymarkell   (01.09.09)
someone tell me that. why is it ok for these lousy arabs to kill darfur people?
64. Jihadi was just executing Pedophile orders to kill Armenians
Genuine Tosefta ,   Tveria   (01.09.09)
and Kurds to purify their racist race 1.5 million Armenians genocided at the hands of Great Moral Lesson Givers and 35, 000 Kurds and still counting
65. Where are the 'Rights of the Child' UN outrage...
RR ,   Miami   (01.09.09)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eTGbP55HGi8&feature=related
66. Start the war crime tribunals and...
Persian CAT   (01.09.09)
put the IDF criminals on trail ASAP.
67. 2 Questions
Corinna ,   Netanya, Israel   (01.09.09)
1. Strange why the Palestinians dont demand that their women and children be evacuated to egypt. 2. Why do the Palestinians accept the world treating them like Barbarians. The world doesnt seem to expect them to have any morals - where as the the world seems to expect the Israelis to have very high morals. Personally if I was a Palestinian I would be offended by this.
68. I have to question the UN on this one.
Daniel ,   San Jose, CA USA   (01.09.09)
First off the dates given troop locations are off, then no hospitals seem to know anything. Wow a massacre with no injuries. The UN and Aid releafe is trying to bolster their position. Let's face it Hamas wanted a Jihad and now they got one. Suck it up you losers. I love my kids and the kids in Gaza they are the innocent but you let a terrorist organization run wild in your land. Fire and store rockets in your homes, schools and places of worship. You gave up your rights by bowing to the easy cause instead of standing up for peace and denouncing violence. Having parties and rallies each time someone blows up a bus does help you get sympathy either. You reap what you sow and now it is time to pay up.
69. I Love It
Lawrence ,   Safed Israel   (01.09.09)
70. I.D.F. SHELLED DOZENS OF EGGS
Lawrence ,   Safed Israel   (01.09.09)
71. easy way to resolve it
william #27   (01.09.09)
if they let independent reporters/observers and the red cross in, then there will be less ambiguity.
72. Much more likely that...
Michael ,   Toronto   (01.09.09)
Hamas figured that they could use fatah-supporters as political tools by gathering them together in the house that was set up with dynamite, and then blowing them up. After all, Hamas has already killed far more than 30 fatah-supporters. And, I would have thought that an Israeli strike on a house would have killed everyone in the house.
73. Simple logic reveals UN lies
epro ,   Finland   (01.09.09)
The last thing IDF wants are these stories of deliberately targeting civilians because they surely will quickly turn against IDF itself and its operations in Gaza. So some people here are suggesting that IDF is deliberately harming its own interests like some brainless creature. This UN story smells bad.
74. #44
(01.09.09)
this was war. on the other hand, none of the israeli soldiers captured in the 67 war ever came home alive. idf/iaf and paratroopers found their mutilated bodies on the battle field, their penises cut off and stuffed into their mouth. we lost almost 560 soldiers and found them in this way in 67. they mutilated them all. no prisoners talen. but then again, don't you know that arab animals do not take prisoners????
75. THE WORLD THINKS ISRAEL IS LYING ABOUT THIS
Arik Silverman ,   Milwaukee USA   (01.09.09)
In previous stories IDF was quoted as claiming that Palestinian militants were firing out of the building. Today IDF claims that its troops were nowhere near the building. So what is truth? Both of Israel's claims can't be true. These contradictory messages are extremely bad for Israel's credibility.
76. Why are Arab attricticies (Dafur) ignored. Arabs have OIL
John Phee ,   Sydney AUSTRALIA   (01.09.09)
Sorry to the poor black people of Dafur, but the Arabs have the OIL you don't. They also own the media you don't. They kill & rape & terrorise in other countries to cower the locals (look at Eurpoe & Australia) you don't. They domonstrate you dont.
77. #60
jb ,   Canada   (01.09.09)
Well said, William! C'est la verité trite mais trop trop vrai! Very sad but oh so true!
78. "put them on trail"
jb ,   Canada   (01.09.09)
Put your friend Ahmedinijad on "trail" On the trail to martyrdom! Persian DOG
79. Shades of Jenin! - more non-existent massacres
Raymond in DC ,   Washington, DC USA   (01.09.09)
Some of us remember the stories of those hundreds allegedly massacred in Jenin, bodies buried alive, etc. - all LIES, as eventually admitted by the UN itself. While I admit I wouldn't put it past Hamas itself to engineer such a massacre, there isn't a shred of real evidence that anything of the sort has taken place. But given the lies and hate they suckle with their mother's milk, they're quick to spread such libels.
80. Shortages
Marilyn ,   USA   (01.09.09)
With the shortage of love and truth perhaps the biggest problems in this region, everyone needs not to let their emotions get the best of them or to start jumping to all kinds of conclusions.
81. Arrest Allegra Pacheco
La Cumparsita ,   London UK   (01.09.09)
arrect the OCHA spokeswoman & charge her with malicious perjury & incitement. IDF have denied being anywhere in the vicinity. IDF soldiers never direct people to a specific house. This is a repeat of the "Jenin massacre" myth. I challenge the Israeli authorities to arrest this madwoman.
82. Yes, put the war criminals on trial - here's proof!
Joe Sittizen ,   Jerusalem   (01.09.09)
"The attacks against civilians by Palestinian armed groups are widespread, systematic and in pursuit of an explicit policy to attack civilians. They therefore constitute crimes against humanity under international law. They may also constitute war crimes" http://www.amnesty.org/en/library/info/MDE02/003/2002
83. #75, The two claims apply to 2 different incident altogether
Jake   (01.09.09)
So they need not agree.
84. #82: Thanks.
Global Citizen ,   Israel & USA   (01.09.09)
85. To 75; Ah? This is a seperate incident not the school
(01.09.09)
incident.
86. #5
Janea   (01.10.09)
If words fail you, why not shut up? You "know" only what is convenient to your agenda. Thousands upon thousands of rockets on Jews are of no concern to you, right John? You curse the result, but don't even address the cause. Words fail you because you cannot conjure up the bullshit fast enough.
87. Mikesailor
Jane   (01.10.09)
And yet another one. Where were you when the rockets were (and are still falling)? Where were you when Shalhevet Pass was shot in her father's arms and Koby Mandel had his skull crushed? Where were you then, Mikesailor?
88. #38
Jane   (01.10.09)
Genocide? Genocide? When did 800 become 6 million? When did Gaza become Cambodia or Rwanda or Darfur? Genocide? That's a disproportionate response.
89. Internatnl Observer, Australia
Jane   (01.10.09)
First, learn to spell. Then read history. Came from Europe? More than 50% of Israelis come from Arab lands from which they were cast out - without compensation or their property, I might add - after living there for millenia. Furthermore, there has been a constant Jewish presence in the land. Do not subject us to your ignorance.
90. Persian Cat
Jane   (01.10.09)
Ahmadinejad goes first.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article