News
Settler kills Palestinian stone-thrower
Efrat Weiss
Published: 13.01.09, 22:09
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
90 Talkbacks for this article
31. Do they fire at Religious Jews stoning cars?
Tayfun_Turkey ,   Istanbul   (01.13.09)
I read many times religious Jews stoned cars in Israel Do they shoot at them? no? So lesson to drive from this event muslims should never throw stones at cars but use more effective Kalashnikoves Arab parties are banned, they kill Arabs stoning then it is time to rise!
32. re: this is what i call terror
American Jew ,   Los Angeles/Israel   (01.13.09)
first off: stones ARE deadly weapons. you are simply uneducated if you believe that a stone to the head will not kill you, or take your eye out at least- and that the throwers do not have similar intentions. Peace will not come with your solution of disarming and disengagement. why? for one, because we left Gaza. did we have peace with the gazans? no. "blockades" have been lifted in times of peace and enacted in times of palestinian aggression. move to 67 borders, remove impeding settlements? once again, camp david 2000: 97% of west bank and ALL of gaza, plus autonomy and police forces. what about the remaining 3%? that 3% would be taken out of israel proper to compensate. Arafat walked out: no peace. what else could they want?? Israel should announce its final goal? just take a look at hamas and fatah's final "goals." if you are not ignorant, they remind you of hitler's, stalin's, maybe even saddam's? their final goal is NO jews in ANY part of Israel/Palestine. with a goal like that, do you really see peace in the future? even coexistence? israel wants peace: we have offered to make sacrifices for it and have been rejected time and again. just as importantly, we have no partner for peace. when hamas and fatah want to rid the earth of jews and israelis- just refer to their charter and hamas' radical islamic ideaologies, you will see: Israel has no partner for peace. When that partner arises willingly, the peace progress will as well.
33. To Sheina @ 1 Indeed true and good for the man..
Miriam ,   T.A Israel   (01.13.09)
Some people seem to think hurling stones at passing cars is a mere bagatelle .What they forget is the unjuries/deaths incurred through this act.And the critics of Israel forget that Israeli Arabs too use those places and can be injured by the THUGS too.. Nuff said
34. Good on him!
John ,   TA, Israel   (01.13.09)
Thank you for being an example of a man with courage who is proud to be a Jew. I would hate to think what one of those self-hating peace freaks (Peace now and other such org's) would have done had the Palestinian thrown rocks at his car; maybe kissed the Arab while the Arab slit his neck.
35. #2 FYI Jews have the right to self-defense
Steven ,   San Francisco   (01.13.09)
As do you Irish.
36. The Man's A Hero.
Reuven Brauner ,   Raanana, Israel   (01.13.09)
37. how bout this #2, #13 &the rest who claim stones r harmless
Crikey ,   World   (01.13.09)
tell us where you live and we will do a little experiment. to see what happens when we drop a rock/boulder on your head. if you survive we shall see how civilly you react. I expect tay und Cake from Eric of DUMB-lin. Toodles twits
38. I doubt you would call the 15 year old gang members
rachel ,   usa   (01.13.09)
with guns in your neighborhood cute little boys defending themselves ...or do you live in the comfortable suburbs isolated in front of your computer .....
39. re: "Taliban Jews"
American Jew ,   Los Angeles/Israel   (01.13.09)
Occupation Occupation Occupation...Stolen from Arabs??? It was gained in a DEFENSIVE WAR and we have time and again offered to return it, and what settlement have take up the whole 2% of it, to take a chunk of Israel proper to make up for it. We want to end activities in the legally accepted DISPUTED territories. And for your "poor settler" statement, it seems as if most websites are siding with the Palestinian; this website included!
40. Outrageous for ynet to call an Israel citizen a "Settler"!
GET REAL ,   USA   (01.13.09)
The term "settler" and "west bank" is used by anti Semites and fools who are ignorant of the meaning! It is NO different then the arab term "occupiers" and "occupied territory"! All these terms were coined by arab propaganda, and to be used by a Jewish news service only caters to all those who favor an Israel Ghetto!
41. what about destroying his house ?
reiner ,   europe   (01.13.09)
throwing stones on driving cars is a crime against humanity! What the settler (feel the sound of humanity in the word settler) did is absolutly a typical selfdefense and the idf should now destroy the house in which the stone thrower was born!
42. eric in dublin
jo moor   (01.13.09)
so you boys are void of all guilt of self protective killing and maiming? what are knee caps for? target practice or what?
43. #4 ezzeldin
jo moor   (01.13.09)
hey! go home to where you came from and stop chirping such utter trash from across the pond
44. Tough Love. More Bullets, Fewer Stone Throwers
David H ,   Marietta USA   (01.13.09)
Should have started ages ago. Throw a stone at a cop in New York, expect to be shot dead, on the spot.
45. The police found the ROCKS
Dana ,   TA   (01.13.09)
that had been removed from the hill, to hurl down at cars, AND the hit marks on the car belonging to the RESIDENT of Emanuel. Please Bench Goimel in Shul, as their aim was MURDER. Ok, lefties? BTW the lefties were angry today that someone turned up at a meeting of the Irya WEARING HIS ARMY UNIFORM. He had raced to the meeting from miluim!!! Despicable leftie council members, move to where Aloni the yored lives. We here can't stand the sight of you.
46. Hey #4
That Guy ,   Planet Earth   (01.13.09)
Lot of "we"'s in your feedback when you're sitting in Chicago why's that?
47. Sticks and Stones may break my bones
That Guy ,   Planet Earth   (01.13.09)
There you have it!
48. Good shot!
Lednah ,   Europe   (01.13.09)
49. #15 jps
jo moor   (01.13.09)
Well said. Do you think eric will understand it?
50. Chazak U'Baruch
Shira ,   NYB"H YERUSHALAYIM   (01.13.09)
Three cheers for the individual who protected himself from a blood thirsty would be killer. Future stone throwers should learn not to do such as it will send them to hell faster.
51. Good, maybe the rest will learn.
TheAre ,   Brooklyn NYC USA   (01.13.09)
52. @ #2
Ehyen ,   New York, Usa   (01.13.09)
eric, you people will justify any negative action against the isreali's. Of course stones are deadly weapons, the iranians use stones to kill all the time stoning adultry cases. U are a dumbass of the worse kind.
53. Take em out.
Janet Keno ,   Baltimore   (01.13.09)
Stones hurt and cars are expensive. Try throwing a stone at MY car and see what happens to you... :)
54. Please, give him a medal.
GZ   (01.13.09)
55. Educate stone throwers
Salvador ,   USA   (01.13.09)
stupid boys they look like ashholes trowing rocks.
56. John #13 The Question Here Is
Zohan ,   Tel Aviv   (01.13.09)
Who is the one who provokes? Doesn't matter if it's stones, rockets or even rubbish. If not stopped, it will keep coming and coming and coming. And John #13, what happens if your neighbor keeps throwing stones @ your house. Don't tell me you do nothing. If you just admit you are anti-semitic we would have understood you better, instead of writing stupid rubbish here.
57. to ezzedlin in Chicago:Go stand on the South Side
Arie ,   BaGolan   (01.13.09)
And let's see how long before you get stoned. Then let's see how magnanimous YOU are. We don't care if hamass recognizes us. To have terrorists recognize you is not important. It is important to make them fear - that is the ONLY language they understand. You should be more concerned about the corruption that permeates your city and State, starting with your BELOVED terrorist incarnate louie farrakhan
58. So they did not settle on Palestinian land?
Mateen ,   Jersey city, USA   (01.13.09)
Are you saying that calling them settlers is incorrect? Aren't they settling on land that is occupied by Israel? If Arabs use words like settlers and occupiers and occupied territory, they're calling it how it is... now when Israelis call Arabs and 15 yr old kids who throw stones at ppl taking over their land terrorists - now thats a little bit extreme dont you think
59. Reiner you go a take the stones
Salvador ,   USA   (01.14.09)
60. He did the right thing
Avraham ,   NYC   (01.14.09)
Need I remind our dear contributors of Jewish victims badly beaten when they did nothing being afraid using their guns on rioters or not having such? Need I remind our dear contributors of Jews (men, women and children) being burned alive by Arabs throwing Molotov cocktails at cars and buses? Just look up a story of mother and her children burned alive by Arabs in a bus that was attacked years ago in the Jordan Valley.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article