News
Gaza doctor loses 3 daughters
Meital Yasur-Beit Or
Published: 17.01.09, 08:46
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
55 Talkbacks for this article
31. We have to stop this
C   (01.17.09)
I am an Israeli citizen. I don't trust Palestinian intentions or even the propeganda from Hamas on the numbers killed. I personally know innocent people who were killed in Gaza. We are creating more hate. This will not destroy Hamas but create new groups who hate us. I don't see the point.
32. What's that girl doing there? She and her family
Maria ,   MD   (01.17.09)
should be in their bombshelters,sorry, Palestinians don't have bombshelters only bunkers for their leaders and tunnels for their weapons.I've seen that picture before, I don't know where and when.
33. # 25 Stephen
Maria ,   MD   (01.17.09)
Satan is thinking, if he wipes Israel off the map,using these Arabs that includes Iranian president to do it for him,Jesus won't be able to come back. He did the same thing when he was behind the crucifixion of Christ, he thought that he really won the victory when Jesus died.But Jesus had risen from the dead.Satan: If I only knew, I should not have crucified him.
34. SHAME ON THE HAMAS
Maria ,   MD   (01.17.09)
The Hamas leaders don't want to surrender. And you people supporting these terrorists,you're just encouraging them to go on with their evil acts.The world doesn't help these Palestinians,by condemning Israel and not the Hamas,that's an encouragement for the Hamas.Read their charter, to find out more about this terrorist group.
35. Shimon Z. Klein , Bat Hefer, Israel
Maria ,   MD   (01.17.09)
Don't be modest now like Amira and Gideon.You know that it was Hamas fault.If the Hamas won't surrender, more killings to go for sure. http://www.conceptwizard.com/info.html
36. Hamas may have taken advantage of his home?
Maria ,   MD   (01.17.09)
WHO'S TO BLAME! for this.Blame Hamas.Hamas don't care about their people.
37. #19 Well, you're a bit far from the truth "Gazan"
The Doc ,   Haifa, Israel   (01.17.09)
Interesting. You claim you're from Gaza and Hamas moans and claims that Gaza is without electricity and communications, yet you have internet access... somebody is lying here - you? Hamas? Both of you? But I digress. Israel is not committing any "horrible crimes". This is how YOU label them. But from where I stand, I see only Hamas using you and others who do not support them, as Human Shields - that makes THEM War Criminals committing "horrible crimes". They shoot from schools, mosques, hospitals and private homes - they transform these building into military targets (Geneva Convention) while civilians try to find shelter there, or by forcing non-Hamas supporters to stay as Human Shields. Hamas using civilians as human shields is not a "pretext" - it is a documented FACT you cannot deny, and I have news for you - it is believed and acknowledged worldwide, although all we can hear is the mass hysteria of Hamas supporters and Muslims and Anarchists. We are not looking for 'pretexts" to shoot at you. If we were, Israel would have shot A LONG TIME AGO. Hamas has been firing rockets into Israel for 8 years AFTER we left Gaza for good, and we didn't do a thing! Don't you think that 8 years of shelling us is "pretext" enough? I hope that someday you wake up and realize that this violent policy of terror against the people of Israel is not going to be good at all for the future of the Palestinians in the long run. As a matter of fact, you can see that 60 years of terrorizing Israel has only brought your people more sorrow, poverty and despair. Your time to wake up and realize what your leaders have been doing to you, is NOW! Beware what you vote for, or whom you support (Hamas or other terrorists) and what you wish for (the destruction of Israel) . And don't make the mistake of underestimating the Israeli public support for what IDF does in Gaza today (not the unfortunate but unavoidable deaths of the Human Shields). Even if/when our politicians hesitate, today all the responsible and patriot Israelis support operation "Cast Lead" with words and deeds! Moreover, most of the Arab world supports it - they all hate Hamas and the palestinians for creating so much trouble. Today, more Palestinians want Hamas to disappear then when they voted for them several years ago. More and more Gazan Palestinians know that with all the bravado, lies and disinformation, Hamas and their leaders are simple and pathetic cowards, hiding in holes under hospitals, schools, and private homes and behind children and women. Hezbollah, Iran and Syria are your (or Hamas') only allies and we all know what the world thinks about them! So if you want us to eat Hummus together in Gaza City, use those BILLIONS you'll undoubtedly receive after Hamas is destroyed, to build a future for yourself instead of planning a Utopian genocide of Israel.
38. The only people who can end this war is
Maria ,   MD   (01.17.09)
the Palestinians themselves,the UN, the Arab world, and ordinary people like you.Stop encouraging the HAMAS to go on.I've never heard the UN condemning the Hamas.They always see Israel ,as the aggressor.If the Palestinians won't bother Israel, Israel won't bother them either.Stop shooting rockets at Israel, stop suicide bombing if you want Israel open borders.
39. WE ARE SORRY INNOCENT PEOPLE ARE HURT, ESPECIALLY FRIENDS
R.F.   (01.17.09)
IF WAR COULD BE FAUGHT ON PAPER, HAMAS WOULD LOOSE THE ARGUMENT VERY QUICKLY AND UNEQUIVOCALLY. UNFORTUNATELY, IT'S A BLOODY STATE OF AFFAIRS, THERE ARE INNOCENT CASUALTIES. 18 YEAR OLD SOLDIERS CARE VERY LITTLE ABOUT POLITICS, THEIR DRIVE IS THE IDIOLOGY TO CATCH THE HAMAS TERRORISTS, NOT THE WOMEN OR THE CHILDREN CAUGHT IN CROSSFIRES. THROUGHOUT THE WAR ISRAEL STATED THAT THE GAZAN PEOPLE ARE NOT THE ENEMY, HAMAS IS. OUR REGRETS AND THOUGHTS CAN DO VERY LITTLE FOR THEIR FAMILIES, BUT WE ARE SINCERE IN MAKING THEM. I ALSO WANT TO KNOW WHAT WENT SO WRONG, AFTER ALL IT IS SAID WE ARE EQUIPPED WITH THE BEST TECHNOLOGY TO AVOID THESE MISTAKES. MAY G-D REST THEIR SOULS
40. #19 U R THE FIRS ARAB PERSON WHO SAID SOMETHING AGAINST
F.R. IN ISRAEL   (01.17.09)
FIRING ROCKETS AT SDEROT ALBEIT BECAUSE ISRAEL FIRES BACK NOW. BY THE WAY, AREN'T U AN ISRAELI ARAB? AS A RESPONSE TO THIS TERRIBLE NEWS ABOUT OUR FRIEND AND HIS FAMILY, THERE IS NOTHING THAT CAN POSSIBLY JUSTIFY HURTING THEM
41. #19 who started this war?
Maria ,   MD   (01.17.09)
Why don't you have bombshelters,but why do you have bunkers for the Hamas and tunnels for their weapons. If your people stop shooting rockets at Israel, these Israel forces won't bother you.If you stop your suicide bombing, I'm sure the Gaza border will be opened for them/you.The only people who can stop this is you and your people, drive out all the terrorists from your land.They're not freedom fighters, they're rebellious.
42. you helped deliver my baby
pamela ,   israel   (01.17.09)
My condolences and sadness for you fine doctor, I remember you at soroka at the birth of my now 10 and a half year old daughter. Peace is possible as is coexistence, you are a man who proves this. I wish you peace and the strebgth to carry on
43. To the Israelis again
Gazan ,   Gaza city,Palestine   (01.18.09)
Many thanks for responding to my message. Well actually I am a Gazan who is writing from Gaza. These days in my area we get electricity for few hours a day. The Palestinian Telecommunication company built the DSL Internet infrastructure so long ago and I simply superscribed. You need to realize that people in Gaza are not generally uneducated or underdeveloped as you think. Although I lived most of my life in Gaza and have been exposed to the Israeli psychological as well as military violence, Iam very convinced that us as Palestinians shouldn't fight Israel. To me one life of a Palestinian child is worth than the whole Middle East conflict. However, the stupid Israeli policies with the Palestinians brought a lot of hate and radicalism in the Palestinian territories. The Palestinians have not been treated fairly for decades..well since the establishment of Israel. As a Gazan who did nothing to harm Israel I suffered almost my entire life because of the occupation. Israel/s policy of collective harsh punishment against every single living in Palestine wont work for Israel by any means. We suffered from occupation,blockade,humiliation,jails,killing,buildings and farms destruction,oppression, the use of internationally banned weapons, and more to come so. As a human being, Im not for the killing of civilians in Israel, but one thing you guys need to add to your national security system, which is, as long as your neighbor suffers cuz of you, you are not going to live well. Thats how God created the world. It has to be balanced. No one lives happily at the expense of others. I hope you people wake up and realize this. The other point Id like to talk about is: There is no doubt there are lots of friends of Israel, especially in the west. However, Gaza war showed another new reality of Israel. The massive human crimes that happened against helpless civilians were very shocking to your friends. Again there is no doubt that Hamas bears some responsibility. However, in a lot of cases such as the UN buildings, the houses in Beit Lahia, as well as the some other hospitals, there weren't any sign of Hamas militants presence there. Just as I listen to others, you need to do so as well so there can be a chance of co existence. Peace to the children in everywhere including the children of Gaza as well as Israel.
44. Gazan
Mirel ,   israel   (01.18.09)
Gazan,my friend, your answer gave me hope that one day it will peace between our nation. I'm sorry for your tragedy. I know Gaza strip well; there I spent most of my army reserve duty periods; I know the poverty of your people.I saw your daily life . I feel the pain for the killings of innocents. I think that people like you, of your cultural and moral level, has to become the leaders of your nation in an effort to save in this generation the children of Gaza and Israel. take care and good luck. Mirel
45. Pamela Israel
Karl ,   Australia   (01.18.09)
It is very nice to hear a human side coming out of Israel not just One ton Phosphor chemical Bombs! This is what the World wants to see. Sure If the Radicals of Both sides can be overpowered by the good hearted people like yourself and us, the world will be a much better place to live in and terrorism will die like a flame at the end of a candle!! It is perhaps our strength and conviction which can push aside those who advocate violence like Bush, Sadam, Olmert, Hitler, Idi Amin, Sharon, Bin Laden, Stalin,and so many more!!! All these pests who unfortunately crawl around our planet causing misery to the powerless and defenceless innocent beings. Wishing you love , True Peace. and harmony
46. Milwaukee re Gazan Doctor
Karl ,   Australia   (01.18.09)
I am no Arab and no Israeli .. but the whole world knows who dispossesed who, who occupied who and who was suffocating the Palestinians for years, letting them swim in their sewage in Gaza, flying F16s over their heads at night, depriving them from fuel and medicine, and all the bare neccesities, their fishing restricted, while catches are confiscated and boats possesed, Bombed families on the beaches or homes and whole families like the one of beit Hanoun .. these people are in a prison, struggling to survive, work and earn a living, export their produce unless Israel lets them .. you get that ..unless Israel LETS them .. they fire rockets, to remind you that there is a tragedy happening behind a wall you built around them .. to leave them there like rats and forget about them till they die slowly slowly!!!!!
47. Jjay3
Karl ,   Australia   (01.18.09)
I am no Jew and no Arab and no Palestinain,so I call myself none of these .. I am an Aussie! The doctor calls himself Palestinain, because he is one .... .. dummy!!
48. Dr. Abu al-Aish
Phin ,   Geneva, Switzerland   (01.19.09)
No the good doctor was not at home. He was on an interview on Israeli TV and saw the death of his three daughters LIVE... He hurled out in pain... my daughters please someone help.... When is enough enough?
49. shame.
Brown Bear ,   Detroit, usa   (01.20.09)
Yes there s much shame. There is shame for Hamas, who fights a war that they have no hope of winning, who endangers their own people, who target innocents. There is shame for Israel who maintains an apartheid state, and responds with disproportionate violence with the KNOWLEDGE that they will murder innocents. Shame to the US and Israel's neighbors for giving money and arms that allow this to continue. There is shame for those who write here, particularly Jewish people, who ask why he didn't leave when it seemed something horrible could happen. There is no shame in this man asking for answers, however there are no good ones. Just shame, for all involved Hamas and Israel.
50. outrage?
Darina ,   New Orleans, LA   (01.20.09)
what is your point? That because the media didn't catch on to that story, it's ok that this doctor lost three of his children? Israel is as much in the wrong as that suicide bomber. Your attitude is exactly why your entire region is getting no closer to peace. An eye for an eye makes the whole world blind...
51. Empty Pride
Darina ,   New Orleans, LA   (01.20.09)
How many Israeli's have been killed by Hamas rockets and suicide bombers? How many palestinians have been killed by Israeli tanks and airstrikes? For a people who have suffered being thought less than equal for millenia, Israel has certainly become adept at metting out just that kind of treatment to others.
52. To 11 from Norway
pesah ,   usa   (01.21.09)
After your finance minister attended demostration where they were screaming "kill jews" , your arian behind should talk.
53. # 15
hank ,   Oklahoma city   (01.23.09)
how many children have been killed by "khamasssss rockets" my dear ? ... i would add : "idiot" IDF is a criminal army, israel is a criminal country and israelis are criminals for supporting that kinda mess
54. gaza bombing
georg ,   santa cruz, usa   (01.28.09)
Mehmet from iran, Hamas was duly. freely and under the watch full eye of the world elected. Give the Palastiniens their land back and you will have peace. Right about now Israel made itself at least 1300 enemies. There is no other place for hamas to hide except in overcrowded Gaza. Maybe the american taxpayer should give Hamas the same weapons they give the IDF, you sure would think twice about killing innocent civilians. G
55. IDF now says no firing from house Dr. Abu al-Aish
Philippe ,   London   (02.11.09)
see last interview on bbc
Previous talkbacks
Back to article