News
Hamas' Haniyeh declares 'victory' over Israel
Reuters
Published: 18.01.09, 23:17
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
123 Talkbacks for this article
61. Hamas sees victory in its defeat
Bill Freydberg ,   NYC USA   (01.19.09)
I wonder if Hitler thought the same thing as the Allied troops laid waste to Nazi Germany.
62. Hamas Did Win!
Richard ,   San Francisco, USA   (01.19.09)
The mere fact that 30 rockets fell on Israel, the Hamas Prime Minister appears on TV, the smuggling of weapons and retraining will begin probably tomorrow suggest that Israel's objective in the war were not met. To that add: the irreparable damage to Israeli reputation world-wide, the the awakening of the Arab peoples from a dormant decade and the exposure of those collaborating with Israel... as well as antagonizing erstwhile allies like Turkey... One wonders how and what did Israel win? Just because Prime Minister Olmert said so?
63. Only partial victory
Mendy ,   Jerusalem Israel   (01.19.09)
We did not totally destroy Hamas or even most of the missile launchers. We did not bring back Gilad Shalit. Soon Iran and other countries will rebuild Gaza and we will be back where we started from.
64. To Nick #7. Temporary Voyage On Planet Earth.
Maansingh ,   The Netherlands   (01.19.09)
You say :” This whole world is sick.” Nick, you tell me a century in which there was no war in the Middle East. In ALL centuries there were wars in the Middle East. In the First Century B.C. there were wars in the Middle East -- does it mean the world was not sick back than. THE lesson to be learned is that this world (i.e. planet Earth) is NOT our home -- we (i.e. you, me and everyone else) are on a temporary voyage on planet Earth.
65.  PARTIAL SUCCESS AT LEAST ? YES ?
ROLAND SEENER ,   LONDON ENGLAND   (01.19.09)
66. The Hamas fight against Israel : A fight to the death.
Robert Bernier ,   Tel Aviv   (01.19.09)
If we do not understand the present Palestinian violence for what it is - not an effort to end an occupation of some territories but a continuation of the real, original jihad and a fight to the death - then attempts to force an end to the conflict will only help make inevitable the catastrophic conclusion that all but the religious fanatics are dreading. International condemnation of Israel only gives it more power. More about the spirit of Jihad at : http://xrl.us/bebdoa
67. just wondering
naama   (01.19.09)
whole gaza is a mess, 1300 people died, and he still calls it a vicory??! crazy... im wondering how IDF didnt wipe him out as well
68. Monthy Python
Daniel ,   madrid, Spain   (01.19.09)
This reminds me of a Monthy Python scketch, the one where one of the stars leave a knight without arms or legs and the knight says "I win!"
69. isreal didnt win
yakof ,   paris   (01.19.09)
if isreal achive there goal where is kidnap sloder , and why hammas still fire rockets inside isreal so its not mean you get victory by number of peapole die the real victory tell the truth
70. #3 you fool
Leonard ,   LA usa   (01.19.09)
Don't you know all the world is allready against Israel. Israel has nothing to loose from the world. The world NEEDS Israel if you like it or not. You know nothing but you think you do like so many. In this war Israel has won for reasons I will not say. And there will be more wars to come, be patient oh ignorant one.
71. #10 lives another day
Leonard ,   lA usa   (01.19.09)
The head of the snake is left to live another day for another war. There will never be any peace till Shilow comes. And what 's this secede Texas form the union? Don't like socialism? Maybe we need a war? Home land security is watching you..
72. Comical ali speaking from Gaza
Kidon 77   (01.19.09)
Arabs always won the wars they loose. They are so full odf there own , taht they can't admit they were badly defeated. Whan one party looses 1300 and the other 10, when on ecity and nstallations sit in rubbles, and the other one was unhurt nobody normal on that earth woul say the firts won.. Hams loose a loose big. I would not bet atht a majority of Gazan would vot for them if there where election. Hope theyr got the lesson, otherwise we will have to come back and broke Hamas last leg
73. #3
Ezekiel36-40 ,   Yakima   (01.19.09)
Ezekiel 36 tru 40 says the same thing....But there is an interesting twist.... might want to read
74. HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Talula ,   israel   (01.19.09)
Victory? ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha - it's too stupid and pathetic for comment.
75. win the war?
pierre ,   usa   (01.19.09)
always declare victory this arab way anyway.hamas are nothing but terroristhidind behind women and kids they are not a warriors , their leader is hiding in syria what else could i say other then shame,during the war that's start in dec 27 they cry out loud to any one look up for them and help them for ceasefire now they call it victory that was a shame and cowardness
76. Obviously he wasn't watching the news
israel   (01.19.09)
The Palestinians were crying and begging Israel to stop. The crossings should remain closed. 'basic needs for our people"? They had the chance to give the Palestinians basics - but they chose to feed them rockets instead. We should hermically seal all the borders - and let them get on with it. And if one more rocket comes from Gaza, then really, we are left with the only choice of bulldozing Gaza into the sea. Israel, and every single country in the world has had enough of them.
77. Cowards always inter and withdraw
Helen ,   London   (01.19.09)
Why are you withdrawing Israels.. You were beaten to ......where? you should tell? I have suspected if you will publish this
78. Who won the war!?!?!?
Asem ,   ME   (01.19.09)
May the killed children wake up and tell Hamas and Israel who won the war !!!
79. The loser is........
Jeff ,   Eugene USA   (01.19.09)
The loser is the side that lets thier people die.... The winning side fights to save the lives of thier people..... The loser is the side that starts the killing...... The winner is the side that stops the killing.... The loser is the side that claims a victory..... The winner is Israel.......
80. Hamas claims victory
10/22/1953 ,   Augusta Georgia   (01.19.09)
Gaza is in ruins,death and fire,panic and fear abound the streets and the Hamas leaders call it a victory? Had it not been for the IDF being called off,this whole gaza situtation would be over. Israel was wrong to stop. It should have curtailed the reporting till the job was done and hamas was destroyed.
81. He hid in a rat hole
Leah ,   Israel   (01.19.09)
and he thinls he is victorious! He is a COWARD.
82. zionism will be defeated
rohit reddy ,   oakland, ca   (01.19.09)
Cheers to Hamas for standing up to the 800 lb gorilla. Israel is probably the most hated country in the world today and have squandered their entire goodwill. The courageous Palestinians will never be defeated as the will of the world is with them.
83. IDF put Hamas in Shame but lost because it quited too soon
Joubin Rabbani ,   Los Angeles, CA   (01.19.09)
IDF should have gone another week and broaden its stay on Philadelpha corridor 1 km Military Zone. and blow up any living thing getting there.
84. #55 said it best!
Albert W ,   Los Angeles, USA   (01.19.09)
#55, in spite of your difficulty with the English language, you are very eloquent. You gave a very accurate history of the Israel/Palestine region, and gave an eye-witness acount of what started this most recent fighting. I wish more people, on both sides, would read your comments. It could help put things in perspective.
85. #34 do your homework
Will ,   USA   (01.19.09)
Maria, two pieces of information you may find useful: 1) Buddha is not a god, he was a human who offered people a path to spiritual enlightenment. 2) the Arabic name for the God of Abraham, known also as the God of Israel, Yaweh, Dios, etc., is Allah.
86. Haniyeh, Gaza's fat slob.A worthless human.
jan   (01.19.09)
Dear Jews. Why are you so upset by this hamas "victory" claims. They are only following the pattern of world history (with the help of the world media).Incompetance,frenzy,stupidity,envy, poor or no education,are the weapons of choice to dictators, religion and madmen. Webster, Larousse,and other world dictionaries call it " Mob " In modern times, the "Mob" was whipped via hysteria by the nazis. When AIDS epidemic surfaced, the arab world accused Jews of "world Genocide". In the middle age, the black plague" was a jewish conspiracy for conquest. A more subdued (sometime) version of mob action - lasted about 2000 years - was the church. It accuses the Jews for killing another Jew. Well ,we all know that the church never killed anyone ( the inquisition was just a " misunderstanding "; the french never killed another frenchmen, the German another German, the Russian another Russian and so on.The only ones who do it joyfully, with gusto (and among themselves) are muslims. Allah blesses them for it, the koran orders them to do it, and the imams enforces this belief that every man, women,child must give their lives and become a martyr. It can be achieved only through killing. The "Big One " ,Sheikh Al Azhar, the " pope " of the sunnis, demands that martyrdom by ALL muslims, backed by islamic law, is a command against all Jews, including women an children.As you can see, aniyeh, together with the other Bums of our neighborhood like nasrallah, the Pygmy of Iran are just followers, and are putting their stamp on history. One thing I am not quite sure ; were they influenced by " Mein Kampf ", " Madame Bovary " or " J'accuse ". ??
87. # 53 I loved what you said!
sarah ,   manchester, UK   (01.19.09)
Israel is a big nothing without US.. and that's not very respectful..
88. Only in Gaza ...
Lee ,   Taipei, Taiwan   (01.19.09)
Only in Gaza, where Hamas fighters hide behind babies and diapers, and aprons and toothless men, and in mosques, hospitals, schools and U.N. compounds, and whine and cry about how ruthless soldiers are to root them out and kill them, and then beg the world to stop the onslaught, can a leader who hides in another country declare "victory". Hamas once again has proved it will willingly sacrifice the Palestinian people for its own selfish purposes -- power and politics. Hamas is disgusting. The Israelis should stay and kill every last one of the Hamas terrorists.
89. #52. When did Israel announce its goal was to destroy Hamas?
Jake   (01.19.09)
If you actually care to check the facts, you would see Israel was much more modest in its war aims than in 2006. It is a fact that Israel at no point announced it would topple or destroy Hamas in this war. Remember how this war was started. It started because Hamas decided NOT to extend the 6 month ceasefire, and instead to resume firing rockets on Israel. As a result of this war, Hamas has been forced to accept the ceasefire on terms that suit Israel. And the world's condemnation's of Israel do not translate into support for Hamas. So you are simply wrong. Hamas has been defeated, roundly.
90. Hamas was forced into a ceasefire it didn't want
Jake   (01.19.09)
This war broke out because Hamas declared the ceasefire with Israel finised and resumed firing on Israel. Now, it announces it will start a new ceasefire, having been clobbered by Israel. Hamas lost. QED.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article