Jewish Scene
Rabbi Eliyahu: I sent Mother Rachel to Gaza
Kobi Nahshoni
Published: 21.01.09, 08:27
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
96 Talkbacks for this article
61. Jake 55 , Arie did'nt say that
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (01.22.09)
He just responded to a vil attack of a Turk , don't say what Arie did'nt say .
62. Besalel ,
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (01.22.09)
I say also that it is a "nes" that nescafe is coffee . Lol You can't compare your examples with the belief that praying can have miracles as a result . But thinking that the rising sun is a miracle , that life is a miracle , and this in the 21century !
63. Jewish Girl #60
Another Jewish Girl   (01.22.09)
You are a blessing and I agree with you 1000%
64. CHARLES
BELEIVER IN HASHAM ,   ISRAEL   (01.22.09)
D0 NOT BLAME G-D FOR THE 6 MILLION THAT PERISHED. YOU NOR I KNOW WHAT G-D'S PLAN IS. WHEN JEWS HATE JEWS WE BRING DESTRUCTION TO OURSELVES. I DO NOT BLAME G-D FOR THE 6 MILLION.. I BLAME JEWS. YOU ONLY HAVE TO LOOK AT OUR HISTORY TO SEE THIS. WHY IS IT THAT JEWS LIKE YOU BLAME G-D WHEN THINGS GO WRONG. BUT YOU NEVER SEEM TO THANK G-D WHEN THINGS GO RIGHT. I DEEPLY FEEL SORRY FOR YOU AND JEWS LIKE YOU. SO LOST IN THE MALCHUT. YOU NEED TO LOOK WITHIN AND FIND THAT SPIRIT THAT WAS ONCE CALLED YOUR SOUL.
65. To 60 , poor girl !!! i pity you sincerely .
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (01.22.09)
66. #21 Tom and #49 Mark: You Misinterpreted
Brana Lobel ,   Israel   (01.22.09)
what Rabbi Eliyahu said and jumped to conclusions that are not accurate. He said he prayed. When you pray your prayers go to Shamayim (Heaven). If they are answered positively some physical event may happen. I think when he said did Rachel mention that he "sent" her it meant more that his prayers were influential in her appearance to the soldiers, not that he gave her directions as to what to do. Remember, he was not praying to her which is forbidden in Judaism, he was praying to Hashem. His request of her was to add her weight to his prayers.
67. To 65,poor boy!!! pity you sincerely. (END)
jewish girl ,   israel   (01.22.09)
68. Rabbi Eliyahu
wes ,   Brisbane, Australia   (01.23.09)
One would have thought that a Rabbi would have prayed to Hashem, rather than a dead woman.
69. Jewish [ ? ] girl
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (01.23.09)
I'm asking myself if you are Jewish , i have never seen such a backwards Jewish Girl in my life who believes that everything is a miracle .
70. Believer # 64
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (01.23.09)
I don't have to know the plans of hashem . I have seen the results , that's more than enough for me . When i see nazis crashing the heads of babies , i don't need to know the plans of hashem . I don't blame god , for me there is NO god , i'm not a believer . And please , don't think your capitals can impress me .
71. #60 Isn't it clear yet
Israel   (01.23.09)
that ALL here, pity you and we'll all PRAY for you, ho ho ho.
72. Sorry #60
#71 Israel   (01.23.09)
WE all know who my talkback refers to, I don't even need to quote name or t b number...certainly not to you. Shabbat Shalom to you #60, and again, apologies. Andrew you're great.
73. More advise from J Judah in London
Avi ,   RG   (01.23.09)
Thanks but i dont think we need advise from jewish traitors that live thier live in Dear old England yet dish out advise and tell others how to live their lives in Israel, Its us you know those jews that actually live in Israel that bare the consequences of such lunatics such as Rabbiu Eliahu not you.
74. charles, petach tikva
jewish girl ,   israel   (01.24.09)
frist off i am 100 per cent jewish and i do not think of myself as a backwards jew. second i had no idea you felt so much hatred for HaShem. If you are from the camps i am truly sorry. if you have experience something so awful - i am sorry. everyone is on their own journey when it comes to their feelings for g-d. i will not engage in a talkback war of words with you. but i do feel sorry for you. you sound like you are in a lot of pain. as a jew i feel for you. you are my brother. i hope and pray that someday your heart and soul will heal. i hope and pray that someday you and i will understand HaShem plans. i hope someday you will beleive in HaShem. Sincerely, Jewish Girl / Ilyse Feder Loven Israel/Shoam/LA/USA
75. Jewish Girl , no need for prayers
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (01.24.09)
Thanks . It's not hatred for hashem , since for me he does'nt exist . When someone talks about everything being a miracle , sorry , this is not a person living in this century . There are people who need a religion to hold on , something that tells them how to think , to behave and so on . I can't believe in a "god" who did allow , or want , such atrocities to happen . I was'nt in a camp , did'nt suffer physically myself . But SIX million of our brethren were murdered , and you dare to say that we don't know god's plans . That HORRIFIC .
76. charles
jewish girl ,   israel   (01.24.09)
yes charles i dare say 6 million died and i do not know why. only g-d know why. just like i do not know why my step son was born with so many medical problems, while my 2 children were born heatlhy. i see the mircles every day with him. we all have our own journey and we all have our own tikkiun. there are things you do not understand and it is not my job to explain them to you. if you do not live by any religious laws then how do you conduct your life. to you lie, steal, cheat, kill, harn children and aminals? etc? i think you live by jewish law and i think your love for our people and israel says you live like a jew. because the botton line is all HaShem wants us to do is love and support each other. charles i have been reading your post for a long time and most of them i enjoy, i can also read your personality, so go ahead and have the last word.
77. Jewish Girl
charles ,   Petach Tikva   (01.24.09)
Thanks for enjoying my TB's . You may say that you don't know why our six million brethren died , who knows it . But saying that you , or others , don't know the plans , מטרה , god had , makes me "boil" There were and are Shoa survivors who ask themselve why they survived , and others not . I do not need religion to conduct my life , I have'nt any right to harm others , the same that i don't want to be hurt myself . If you think that not murdering , stealing and so is living by Jewish laws , free to you . I'm 100 % Jewish , not only because of my Mother ZL , respect TRUE believers , who believe with heart , not only what is written , and who are tolerant to others . To love our people , to be proud to belong to this people , to love Israel , you don't need to be religious , being Jewish is more than enough . שבוע טוב
78.  The term Z"L contradicts atheism.
Israel   (01.25.09)
79. 78 Israel , stupidly WRONG
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (01.25.09)
It's used by Jews , not only religious ones . It means , for me , that i remember her .
80. #79 A jewish tzadika/tzadeket
Israel   (01.25.09)
rests in peace in a Jewish cemetery, not in an urn. Therefore,hopefully Kaddish is recited by a believing jewish relative. If not, and it would have been her wish, it can be arranged on the yahrzeit. Aleha Hashalom.
81. Israel , You again stupidly mix things
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (01.25.09)
An atheist does not believe in Kaddish or any other prayer . An atheist doe'snt need one specific day to remember a dear one .
82. #9 Thank you for reading Ynetnews ! ! !
ed ,   herzlia, il   (01.25.09)
83. charles and israel
jewish girl ,   israel   (01.25.09)
Please stop all of this...........
84. A question
Israel   (01.25.09)
What does an atheist do , if his or her parent was a believer, is buried in a jewish cemetery, and that parent would therefore assume that someone would say kaddish over them? The atheist's feelings dont interest me. The saying of kaddish is the question. Who says it in place of the atheist?
85. Re: Rachel showing up in Gaza, or not
Elisheva ,   New Jersey,USA   (01.26.09)
Only a jewish mother would show up in the middle of the battle and try to tell her son(s) where and how to shoot! :)
86. #84 maybe he feels guilty and has a
israel   (01.26.09)
rabbi do it and gives him a donation.
87. #83 Rachel Imaynu is the ancestress
chavera   (01.26.09)
of all of us, long before talk backs and long after them too. Calm down and get things in perspective. Ignore what doesn't please you. We all do.
88. One answer
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (01.26.09)
For me to know , for you to find out
89. Jewish Girl , you are right
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (01.26.09)
But i like to make fun of this guy
90. Who is this sicko from PT?
just read   (01.26.09)
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article