News
Erdogan: Palestine an open-air prison
Ynet
Published: 31.01.09, 11:24
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
89 Talkbacks for this article
61. To Doc From Haifa
George ,   Canada   (01.31.09)
I believe Palestinian want peace with Israel and willing to share land, but Israeli don’t Israel advertises its williness for peace and do all to make it impossible. Leave me alone from such crap Charter...etc. Where is the peace plan offered by Saudi where 22 Arab countries are ready for complete peace with Israel ( Hamas has accepted as well) in return for Israel withdrawal to 1967 border? It was trashed by Sharon and his follower PM .What do you need more concession for peace?!!!! All what I hear they want destroy us, destroy us… give me a break!!!
62. If so, Erdogan, it is one the Gaza folk built themselves
Cameron ,   USA   (01.31.09)
Always, when you cut through the verbage & various postures, it always comes down to the bedrock of the Muslim World simply not being able to abide the existence & reality of Israel being an established "done deal". At least credit these malevolent, poison organizations like Hizbollah and Hamas for bluntly speaking the desire & intent lurking in every Muslim heart and mind when it comes to Israel. They work every angle possible, from attacking with formal armies, trying to destabilize with constant small-time incidents, to trying to inspire some sort of collective, undermining guilt-trip, but the intent remains unchanging. Pure pathology, baby.
63. #47 don't you pay taxes in canada? there is no palestinian
israeli   (01.31.09)
state. israel does not occupy the gaza strip to collect tax there, hamas collect tax there. hamas are the authority in gaza, be it that they got their power thruogh fear of gazans they might loose their life if they oppose hamas. you do know what happened to fatah in gaza (they were executed) maybe in canada arabs are priviledged, here one needs a specific education to work at a specific job. there are rich arabs in isrtael, there are a lot of arab doctors and lawyers, because of israeli correcting discrimination, that even when israeli arabs have worse grades then jews, in faculties where space is limited and only top students enter, arabs have the priority even though their grades are not high as israeli jews who get rejected. that's another reason why i think system here is fu--d. there should have been a fair exchange, we got jews out of the gaza strip when we gave them independence to become terrorists without our supervision on the lethel arms they bring in. we should have got pro hamas arabs from israel to live there instead of the jews we evacuated, so that the whole gaza strip will be populated with arabs. if arabs were not racists, they would agree jews should live amingst them in the strip, and not be evacuated from their homes. but arabs think it's only ok when jews are being evacuated, when that happens to arabs they immediately become refugees. are you a refugee for living in canada? canada is an immigrants country, when was the last time you appologised to an innuite. the landmass arabs live on maybe smaller then america, but it is not as small as israel to argue over. arabs living in israel use the system , use all facilities, don't have to sacrifice their lives in the army like the rest of us, and become traitors aiding and abeting our enemies what would canada do with traitors to it's security? lets see how well informed you are on that one.
64. Who Created The Prison?
bllngsk@aol.com   (01.31.09)
Israel is not dictating to the Palestinians. Israel is a prosperous nation while Palestinians are not. That is the fault of Palestinian leaders not Israeli leaders.
65. Jamal Pasha
J.K. ,   Brooklyn USA   (01.31.09)
Jamal # 18 When Israel handed over Gaza to the Palestinians,instead of building a viable country,they attacked Israel With mortars and rackets,here is your answer,Jamal.Had the Palestinian behaved like Canada,France,Sweden,i can assure you,there would not be a need to blockate the borders,but anfortunately,the Palestinians choose war,so ,Israel has every right to defend it's people as it sees fit.
66. If you come with peace to us - peace you get
Good to know   (01.31.09)
if you harm us - you will be heavily beaten. Simple. Even Nasralla and his Iranian bosses understand it. Try to send your lyrics to Iranian clerics who are the root cause of disaster and don't forget to cry on Darfur 400,000 victims at least as loud as your cry here.
67. to 50
idil ,   istanbul / Turkey   (01.31.09)
yes but there is an analogy in 26th text and i answered it therefore i tried to say ; the situations are so different about kurds and palastiniens.i didnt say anything about why there re walls or how.i just said there are* . people actually the difference between us is we dont defend anything or we dont against anything we are here for our countries relationship. this guy 'erdoğan' he is just welcoming his votes.we also say nothing about him because we dont care him. but you thought that we defend something against israel for this reason you ask some questions about our country's mistakes or problems but they have no answers in this virtual area. we dont need any negative atmosphere in our social communication . i personally respect your exercions about saving your own country you have got your own rights and im sure that everybody knows what is going on in middleeast area. civilians losts , the rights of kurds, hamas or so-called armenian genocide. we all know about them , right? so we dont need making criticisms about them to each other.we know the questions we know the answers .im not getting suprised when someone says something about 1.5 million armenians i'm just getting bored about the feeling of accountability for no result ! but i am not asking about the civilians deaths because its not etic to ask you !
68. Erdogan; a professional neuro-surgeon who hasn't left stage
Entebe   (01.31.09)
he has just resected the spine of Antisemitism charge to those criticizing Israel for its action. That has been in-public bloodless operation. Whether initiated by him or after receiving the green light from Obama, Erdogan hasn't left the stage; he has set the stage for the US approaching Hamas. An Entebe-like affair is urgently needed.
69. #61 - I will give you a hope
Another try   (01.31.09)
To come out of Pallywood propaganda. In brief - http://il.youtube.com/watch?v=i08L09V0_sg In depth - arabic to english translation for thousands of video and other materials - http://www.memri.org
70. ErdoClown is now competing with AhmadiWhacko for attention
Genuine Tosefta ,   Tveria   (01.31.09)
ErdoClown is now competing with AhmadiWhacko for Muslim World's childish attention. Like all power plays for hegemony in the Middle East this is a deadly game between two powerful Muslim countries sharing a border. It is inevitable that given a little bit of time Turkey and Iran are bound to clash and the result will be a horrendous carnage in the best Muslim tradition.
71. Why the heck does Israel not recognize Armenian genocide
Ken Jurist   (01.31.09)
There will never be justice for the 1.5 million Armenians massacred by the Turks unless the world recognizes this genocide. What did Hitler say. Who remembers the Armenians. Well i do and so should Israel.
72.  Erdogan -Islam
J.K. ,   Brooklyn USA   (01.31.09)
Erdogan's problem is not Israel But Islam,the problem with Islam,is,that it did not have a Martin Luter,(the Geman Martin Luter) Who would reform their Religion and challenge their religious and political leaders,and create what is called,the Protestant work ethics,instead the Muslims indulged themself with the Koran,which contains more opium,than the other faiths,so.the believer is always high,and can be easily manipulated by his leaders.As long the believer is provided with his daily dose,the enemy is always the infidel.Anfortunately,Erdogan is not Martin Luter.
73. #61 Shoddy Peace Plan
Cynthia ,   USA   (01.31.09)
George, the Saudi Peace plan offered Israel nothing. Israel has no conflict with the majority of Arab countries and does business with many of them. Long standing peace agreements exist with Jordan and Egypt. The problem is not Israel. The Palestinians refuse to stop terror as evidenced by their missile bombardment long before Israel activated a military response. As long as Iran uses Hamas and Hezbullah to attack Israel, the Palestinians have no country, there can be no peace and the entire region remains unstable. You'll find the head of the snake in Iran.
74. Every Turkish police station
Uzziel   (01.31.09)
in the occupied Kurdistan is a Fallujah style slaughterhouse for the Kurdish militants and often for the Kurdish civilians. Crocodile tears.
75. to 69 Do you have answer?
George ,   Canada   (01.31.09)
Leave me alone from Hamas ,I am not their advocate, they are extremist ,you have your own as well. Where is the Saudi peace plan?, Why Israel reject it and ignore it. Where is Annapolis with Abass ? What is the result of end less negotiation with the Palestinian Authority ? ZERO. What do you need more concessions .Do you have answer?
76. Venezuela & Turkey
TURKISH SWORD   (01.31.09)
Erdogan is a radical and hates Jews. Many times he has announced his Iran sympathy in 90's. He supports Hamas because he loves Iran. He always aiming to stop countdown of US attack against Iran. (Look at Caracas today) He is urgently wants to see a NUCLEAR IRAN. 01.31 Today Netanyahu announced that he will never accept a Nuclear Iran !! He has got the point. Iran will have A-bomb at the end of 2009 according to DEBKA. Iran can easily destabilize Iraq,Afghanistan,Pakista n and perhaps Turkey. Iran said "If Turkey opens airzone to US, we will hit Istanbul" and Erdogan without any reaction. Anti defamation League has given COURAGE MEDAL to him. After Erdogan has given courage to Iran for nuclear countdown. He has played a game.. We have warned many many times but nobody listened to us. Erdogan wants to win LAST political term to create Anti-Semitic REASON of economic collapse and an Iranian mushroom cloud. Israel will hit Tehran soon ALONE or next decade wont be available on the map.
77. "P" doesn't exist in arabic
Rob, USA   (01.31.09)
Yep, nobody of arabic speakers can say "P" - not a joke. Check it. The "Palestine" is an artificial new age creation
78. Said Erdogan"I'm Not Anti-semite"
Lawrence ,   Safed Israel   (01.31.09)
Not much.
79. #77
Ben ,   Gush Etzion   (01.31.09)
That's right , that's why the Arabs drink Bebsi and eat Bita on Besach in Balestine and they don't want Beace because they can't bronounce it, Wheareas Bresident Beres wants to continue as he calls it De Piss Process
80. Speaking of Love
Israeli ,   Wait a min   (01.31.09)
http://il.youtube.com/watch?v=opGlp1pE59s
81. 75 - I have an answer for you
I think   (01.31.09)
An interesting intersection here - The great man - Ataturk dismantled the caliphate in 1924 - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mustafa_Kemal_Atat%C3%BCrk What happens now is a huge project of its world-wide reviving driven primarily by Iran clerics and some other countries. Read this - http://www.ln.mid.ru/bl.nsf/900b2c3ac91734634325698f002d9dcf/700cb68392e7684c43256c71004b484e?OpenDocument So, don't be naive - arab initiative is just a red herring in this context. Israel is the only free country in the ocean of opressive regimes surrounding it - http://www.freedomhouse.org/template.cfm?page=363&year=2008&country=7416 You'd better support her, if you are able to deep and objective analysis
82. and here is my answer to 9
Mimi B ,   Panama Panama   (02.01.09)
palestinians throw rockets because thats what they are tought since they are born. And if you live in hell.. it is your own responsability. Why dont u force your leaders to provide better living instead of stealing the money they get every year or buy weapons to attack Israel. Now you cry? Israel DO NOT open the crossings for murdurers
83. After Turkish & Iran Peoples Vigour..
Bruno ,   Rome Italia   (02.01.09)
Turkish and Iran secret police, may leak to gazza to take revenge from israel.. they hatred about israel soldiers kill many innocent childrens... there is a lot of views about the childrens are afraid , see theirs familys blood.. and childrens was trembling... Who will care israel people !!
84. ATTILLA THE TURK - FREND OF ERDOGAN
AVRUM ,   CANADA   (02.01.09)
ATTILLA, OR ERDOGON, -- YOU SAY YOU WANT TO HELP BUILD A "NORMAL HOME FOR THE PEOPLE"-- THEN START IN YOUR OWN COUNTRY. BUT IT'S HARD TO HELP A MILLION OF ARMENIANS WHEN TURKEY ALREADY MURDERED THEM. TO ATTILA --TO TURKEY-- HELP THE KURDS BY NOT MURDERING THEM.
85. ERDOGAN--ATTILA--TURKEY -- ARMENIAN GENOCIDE !!
JACOB ,   CANADA   (02.01.09)
IS THIS THE PEACEFUL EXAMPLE THE TURKS HAVE FOR THE WORLD ?? ------ TO MURDER PEOPLE -- ARMENIANS, KURDS. PUT ERDOGON ON TRIAL --AND ALL TURKISH WAR CRIMINALS.
86. ERDOGAN -- I AM NOT ANTI-SEMITE !!
JACOB ,   CANADA   (02.01.09)
I JUST DON'T LIKE JEWS,- ALSO DON'T LIKE ARMENIANS, KURDS.
87. Erdogan: Palestine open-air prison- ERDOGON PREFERS CLOSED !
JACOB ,   CANADA   (02.01.09)
ERDOGAN MUCH PREFERS THE CLOSED IN PRISONS OF TURKEY--THEY ARE ARE HELL HOLES. TURKISH PRISONS, WHICH ARE INFAMOUS THE WORLD OVER. A TRUE STORY OF A TURKISH PRISONER CAME OUT IN BOOK FORM AND THEN THE MOVIE, CALLED "MIDNIGHT EXPRESS". WATCH THIS MOVIE YOU TURKEY, OR READ THE BOOK AND THEN YOU WILL KEEP QUIET AND TRY TO DISTRACT ANY ATTENTION AWAY FROM YOUR PRISON AND , JUDICIARY CORRUPT SYSTEM,
88. Erdogan, what you failed to look at?
Daniel ,   Israel   (02.01.09)
Open arms offered by Israel to Palestinians for progress and peace. Hamas: Political will of the people So; they suffer. What will you do Erdogan; if some one throws a stone at your house every day? How long will you tolarte and ignore that person?
89. Does Erdogan expects Israel accepts Hamas while Hamas does
Asher ,   NY,USA   (02.01.09)
not recognises Israel right to exist? I see he is talking only onsided and just calls on Hamas attacks against Israel only Mistakes while he speaks so harhly against Israel. This guy even doese not understand how much his religion belifs are taking over his mind and is only looking at the events if Israel was supposed to be silent for ever and accepts all the rockets hit it's land. He is only taking side and maybe getting closer to Tehran and taking distance from Israel only because of his Religion and sympathy he has toward moslems no matter who they are or what they do. This is a new Turkey under Erdogan.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article