News
Neturei Karta meet with Haniyeh in Gaza
Ali Waked
Published: 16.07.09, 14:24
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
70 Talkbacks for this article
31. AND take ADAM with you. He's ugly like you
go creeps go   (07.16.09)
32. bad journalism
observer ,   JERUSALEM   (07.16.09)
The Lifeline 2 activists including the four Neturei Karta entered Gaza from Egypt by land and not by boat o ship.Big shame ynet.
33. to #30 kibutz???? lol you paranoied
ghostq   (07.16.09)
we get thos articles all the time. betzelem basterds. duh
34. "Jews, Arabs not enemies" - Haniyeh
William ,   Israel   (07.16.09)
"Now just remember that we're equal, but Muslims are more equal than others, and if you don't pay your tax, you'll be killed. We can be friends just like old times" - Hanyieh
35. #30 - Ask why Chardim commit such crimes
William ,   Israel   (07.16.09)
Why do some Chardim hate the seculars and the State so much? Why do they commit crimes and violence that hurt many just to oppose the State and its people? Certainly the NK doesn't represent all of you Chardim...or do they? I have good friends who are Orthodox and Chardim and they respect the State, so my guess is you like NK or support their beliefs. Why are there no specific articles on seculars visiting terrorists and supporting them? That's because it's not news! It's extremely common (and saddening) and could fill volumes of books.
36. Naturei Karta and Hugo Chavez
Spencer ,   Israel   (07.16.09)
Lets stop pussyfooting around. Don't allow these Naturei Karta back into Israel....and those that are hewre....if they riot show them no mercy. Beat them as they beat their own chldren , then try them and either gaol them or ewxpel them to Gaza or Venzuela. As for Chavez, don't allow his boat to enter out territorial waters and don't allow him into Gaza via any other way. These scumbags are polluting the free world.
37. haredim/neturi karta
michael ,   D.C USA   (07.16.09)
Israel should kick out anyone who does not recognizes the place as 'The state of Israel" ,Jews ,Arabs and others!!! I am sure the Arab countries,their friends, would welcome these jews!
38. The Living wtares of the Torah have been garbled by these
Ridiculous ,   Prosecutethem Israel   (07.16.09)
fringe idiots into waters of poison. They are a complete Hillul Hashem and remind me of Chelm, the legendary Jewish folklore about foolishness and fools. It would be better if these people's leaders were prosecuted for aiding the enemy.
39. #1
alan ,   Texas   (07.16.09)
My feelings too. Don't let them return to the Israel they don't recognize. They are traitors and Israel will do well to rid themselves of these soldiers for the enemy.
40. incitement?
michael ,   usa   (07.16.09)
The facts are there. and with the lefties too. but there are many differences. They do not believe in the state of Israel.and by this undermine Israel right to exist. They do not serve in the army. They "milk" the Israeli people by getting social services money for their existence. Therefore ,they should have no rights and should be escorted to the exit sign!
41. good work?
michael ,   usa   (07.16.09)
and who will save you in time of war? oh,you in Englad,my mistake.but not to worry ,there are enough arabs there too to take you to next world!! unless you are too Neturi Karta,then you will be served bread and salt.
42. To: No. 28
Sarah ,   New York City, USA   (07.16.09)
In Israel, treason is punishable by death.
43. mordechai . You suffer from paranoia
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (07.16.09)
They spoke only of "ultra orthodox - netoure karta" not about the Charidim . And as you say it , correctly , those netoure karta don't represent the whole charidi world . I would like to hear strong Charidi voices opposing those "people"
44. #2 Sarah
Marco ,   Spain   (07.16.09)
Well, well, well Sarah, what are we calling for here? The death penalty???? Amazing how short sighted you are! If any one should be tried for stupidity, its yourself and people like you. You never learn from the lessons of history. Neturei Karta is trying their best to save the Jewish people from another holocaust while idiots like you are doing their best to create enemies for the jewish people. Sarah what do you your children to inherit? Hatredness and despise of others? You already lost a child, how many more do you want to loose. Take my advise Sarah, if you leave nothing for your children after you are gone, you cannot afford to leave them vulnrable. No weapons of mass destruction can assure their safety. The only thing that would assure their safety is not to be viewed arrogant by others.
45. desert
michael ,   usa   (07.16.09)
why the desert, to Iran or Suria ,they treat jews well.and we should not forget to supply the ropes.
46. What Mr Chavez Doesn't Understand
Frankie Littlehammer ,   New Herstal, Tx, USA   (07.16.09)
What Mr Chavez doesn't seem tp understand is that Islam and Arab rule came to this part of the world much like Christianity and Spanish rule came to Latin America. The Arabs are the colonialists and settlers, and the Israelis are the indigenous people who shook of the occupation to rule their homeland again.
47. #2. Sarah. Absolutely...these miscreants are spineless, weak
Jae ,   lynn us   (07.16.09)
and deluded, wearing 16th century garb. Hey Jews if you want to be "AUTHENTIC" in your dress, through away the 18th century polish look, and put on the garments our ancestirs have worn for 4000 years in our land of Israel.
48. Question
Poppy   (07.16.09)
HOW ARE THESE PEOPLE ALLOWED TO LIVE IN ISRAEL???? WHAT PASSPORT DO THEY CARRY??
49. Marco , you are DISGUSTING
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (07.16.09)
Not only for your ideas . Those people have visited this Holocaust denier in Iran , now this guy who wants to annihilate the State of Israel [ and all her Jewish inhabitants ] And you call them people who want to save us from another Holocaust . By visiting our worse enemies ? by denying our right to exist ? Learn history Marco , and you will see how the Jews were treated by muslims , before and after 1948 . How Jews were expelled from their homes , only for being Jews , and not armed terrorists as those who fled Israel in 48 .
50. To: Marco at No. 44
Sarah ,   New York City, USA   (07.16.09)
Why, Marco, I never realized that you have been appointed publicist and chief spokesman of the Neturei Karta. The Neturei Karta are anti-Zionist because they take literally the injunction that the State of Israel must be brought about by divine intervention. I -- and most Jews -- are not strict fundamentalists, so we apply a more figurative approach to "divine intervention" -- for us, the Holocaust works as intervention -- G-d, after all, works in mysterious ways. But any anti-Zionist, anti-Israel port in a storm works for you, doesn't it? You ARE quite the hypocrite, do you realize that?
51. #16 steve where did you get your info from?
Wildmandxb ,   M.E.   (07.16.09)
where in the Quran does it say that god considered Jews to be apes and pigs? I dare you here amongst everyone viewing these talkbacks to show us some evidence! I know in advance that you won't be able to because this just doesn't exist, it is built-in your zionist mind, that we, muslims have a qoran that says hate jews! it is people like you, with brains that only function with incitement of hatred against others that come up with these stupid moronic issues, grow up man and read some educational books for gods sake, it'll save you from looking like an idiot, just like you've done here.
52. to 51 wildman...
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (07.16.09)
Read some History books about Jews in muslim countries . During most periods they were considered not as second , but third category persons [ if even considered as persons ] So even if your kuran don't says it explitely as you claim , the results were the same . Death , persecutions , expelling and so on .
53. Ynet - these are NOT Jews, ultra-orthodox or otherwise
Roscio ,   Rome, Italy   (07.16.09)
According to Torah, Talmud and virtually all mainstream Jewish authorities past and present, they are Rodephim, those who pursue the death and destruction of Am Yisrael. They have been cut off by Cherem by all mainstream Jewish bodies - however, even that action is redundant. The Neturei Karta, by aiding and supporting the bloodthirsty enemies of Israel and civilization, have long ago cut off their own souls from both the Jewish people and from humanity everywhere. According to Halacha, they are not Jews, and not to be referred to as Jews EVER. Any food they produce or cook is considered Treyf, and any so-called "synagogue" that they create or manage is rendered Tamei, ritually impure. Please set the proper editorial standard for accuracy and do not call these cheerleaders for genocide "Jews". Thank you.
54. Only Hareidim can make peace
Aaron ,   Baltimore, USA   (07.16.09)
The secular Jews want to give back land (especially houses owned by religious Jews), but could never live in peace with Muslims who demand a traditional middle eastern (and to secular eyes), medieval society. If you want peace in Israel, look to ultra-Orthodox.
55. Neturei Karta was on Arafats payroll
Ken Jurist   (07.16.09)
Rabbi Moshe Hirsch, Neturei Karta's self-proclaimed "Foreign Minister", who served in Yasser Arafat's cabinet as Minister for Jewish Affairs. Hirsch and his followers oppose Israel on religious grounds. Devoutly committed to their faith, they reject Jews who promote the agenda of Zionism and the State of Israel as heretics. They also maintain that an Orthodox community of Jews can and should be a viable minority in an Arab-dominated Palestinian state. Hirsch notes that there is a striking accord between the views of Neturei Karta and those of Fatah, which is the dominant party in the present Palestinian Authority: both seek to distinguish Judaism from Zionism, both favour a secular and nonsectarian government in Palestine. In 2002, during Israel's "Operation Defensive Shield", Israelis captured numerous documents from the headquarters of Arafat, which proved that Rabbi Moshe Hirsch was on Arafat's payroll.
56. Neturei Karta never visted any buses blown up by Arabs
David Stoler   (07.16.09)
Neturei Karta never visted any buses blown up by Arab terrorists. They want Jews to live under Sharia law. They are totally sick people.
57. #50 Sarah
Marco ,   Spain   (07.16.09)
So what you are saying is that they are the real Jews and that you are fake?
58. It's starting to look like a soup
Observer   (07.16.09)
No one knows who's with who anymore... It's like everyone is become confused ...
59. The first time I ever see in Haniyeh in a positive light
Jake   (07.16.09)
when he stands next to that perfidious, boot-licking gutter snipes that the cat just dragged in.
60. To: Marco at No. 57
Sarah ,   New York City, USA   (07.16.09)
No, Marco -- as usual, I can count on you for misinterpretation and hyperbole. The REAL Jews -- who never stopped turning towards Israel and praying for a return -- are Jews like me. Zionists, if you will. The fakes are the ones -- like the Neturei Karta and the Satmer -- who defer to fundamentalist belief. Religion, to be valid, must move forward. Those with feet of clay remain hidebound and unable to progress -- witness fundamentalist Islam, for example, and its jogging retreat to medieval mentality and practice. In sum, Marco -- you are wrong. I -- and those who are likeminded -- are the REAL Jews. We believe in progress. The Neturei Karta -- like those Islamists who believe in stoning women to death and public flogging and executions -- are so hidebound in their beliefs that they can do one of two things: remain fixed in place or move backwards. Civilization operates against them. Civilization exists because it can move forward. Trust this is responsive to your question (which was really rather a stupid one, you know?).
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article