Jewish Scene
To be Jewish, even without God
Efrat Shapira-Rosenberg
Published: 25.10.09, 07:49
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
65 Talkbacks for this article
61. 56 -your version of christianity is as wrong as your judaism
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (10.27.09)
i can find hundreds of thousands of jews who support chabad, but who will say the same about you (besides yourself)? that's been my question from the beginning. you still can't show the goods. you can't show ONE who says your teachings are legit. ONE!! clearly you have an overinflated opinion of yourself, equating yourself with the orthodox, chabad, judaism's 'pakeed', not to mention judaism itself (in light of your admission above). if it's so true, why don't jews agree with you? why doesn't ANYONE credible agree with you? and don't lecture me about your made up caricature you call 'ribi yehoshua'. i'm not into drinking kool aid. something's fishy in raanana. people know a stinker when they see one.
62. 58 You see? The slander doesn't stop after your appeal.
Paqid Yirmeyahu ,   Ra'anana, Israel   (10.27.09)
Surely you're not suggesting that I stop defending myself against slander? Do these two ever produce any evidence for their ad hominems? No, because all of the evidence proves they slander and they won't deal with it. Every reader can see that I try to address issues--Christianity, atheism, homosexuality, Islam, etc., not persons unless they attack me--while those who attack me, uh, attack ME--ad hominems. Any intelligent and educated reader knows that ad hominems are what need to be eliminated... and even more than that, slander. Certainly, you don't expect me to stop defending myself against slander directed at me? I can tell you that's never going to happen. If you live in Israel, come to Ra'anana and check out the facts and be part of exposing the slander. You can contact me through the Web Cafe blogback in our website. I can show you. Why do you think the Orthodox critics in Israel stopped slandering? Because they realize they need to provide evidence before making charges in order to avoid slander. Many have checked the evidence... but, oops, I'm right. Silence. I'm trying to find a slander lawyer I can afford. Nothing else is going to stop the Christians, atheists and homosexuals who have no reply other than ad hominem and slander. Paqid Yirmeyahu Paqid 16, The Netzarim, Ra'anana, Israel Israeli Torah-reverer (& Orthodox Jew) Advocate for Logic as Halakhic Authority Welcoming All Torah-reverers (Jewish & Goyim) www.netzarim.co.il
63. 62's threats are proof he's losing the argument
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (10.27.09)
he can't give answers to legitimate, reasonable questions, so he threatens legal action. sounds pretty desperate. -don't hide behind false accusations of ad hominem. -don't hide behind false accusations of slander. -don't hide behind false accusations of misojudaism. -don't hide behind threats of lawsuits. find a credible rabbi to back up your claims and shut me up. if you can.
64. 56 , increasingly the Rabbis agree....
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (10.27.09)
What kind of Rabbis ? Metzger ? Ovadia Yossef ? Or the kind of "rabbi" you call so ? What you wrote is this not the same truth as those "blessings" you claim the Head Rabbi send to you ?
65. rivkah, please
Yid ,   Eretz Yisrael   (10.27.09)
try Jews for Jesus website to post talkbacks. I'm OK when you spout something on kabbalah or weird halacha that no one knows in the world execpt for you or so it seems. But 'Rabbi Yeshua' is too much, thats annoying. Cut the missionary stuff. This is a news website not a church
Previous talkbacks
Back to article