News
Israel: 980 prisoners to be freed for Shalit
Aviad Glickman
Published: 29.11.09, 18:08
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
67 Talkbacks for this article
31. If one Israeli is killed by one of these freed
jason white ,   afula,israel   (11.29.09)
terrorists, then the ministers who voted for this release, the high court judges, the government lawyers, the media and the members of the security forces that allowed this should be hung in public. I figured out Bibi, should be spelled B.B. for blee baitzim! And ehub barak is as good for Israel as barak hussein. We are a nation led by cowards. And unfortunately we will pay in blood for their cowardice. No nation was ever led by such a treacherous government as we have since 1948. They should have destroyed gaza to get Gilad back! Gilad's parents should be forced to attend every funeral of the future victims of this release of terrorism.
32. you make me laugh !!!!!
(11.29.09)
the government is saying that 530 prisoners will be freed as a good gesture to the palestinian people . the palestinian people know very well that this is not true , and that this is a huge defeat to israel ... who are you trying to fool ??????
33. to families of released palistinians
Galut ,   Selah -pause&reflect   (11.29.09)
many of those being reased with blood on thier hands - make sure you concider the price israel is paying for your undeservred release...many countries would have allowed you to rot in jail...but because israel valued the life of one of her citizens it was willing to risk future attacks.... consider it could be if you were an upstanding citizen in israel ...you would have the same status as that one prisoner. in hamas or fatah if you stray from political goals you have to look over your shoulder for fear there is a bullet with your name on it...
34. # 21
Israel Forever ,   Israel   (11.29.09)
Very very bad luck for you to be jumping the gun Keep your negative vibes & jabs to yourself.
35. # 23
Birdi ,   Israel   (11.29.09)
YAY meet you at the airport so we can wave bye bye to them.....
36. There is no deal Bibi is refusuing to release murderers
jason ,   haifa israel   (11.29.09)
Bibi has stood his ground and has refused to release murderers. Bibi didn't lose two wars and didn't leave iranistan in gaza by leaving. Yet israelis pound him every day. I can't take it anymore. First time Israel took down bibi we ran from lebanon and then ran from gaza and lost two wars. Remember shalit was kidnapped because olmert wouldn't allow soldiers to check tunnels on the other side of the border. Remember ehud olmert wouldn't even for a time let soldiers fire at rocket launchers even if they were in the process of firing rockets. Israelis love to pound and pound Bibi. Reports are he is refusing to release terrorists with blood on their hands yet you pound and pound him. If bibi is taken down you will have PM mofaz or PM livni. Mofaz wants to release every prisoner with blood on their hands which bibi is refusing. Bibi is refusing to release barghouti and saadat. The 980 released was back from the olmert era. These reports are false flags for years.
37. There is no shalit deal as bibi refuses to release killers
jason ,   haifa israel   (11.29.09)
Bibi is refusing to release terrorists with blood on their hands. That is why no deal has happened. Mofaz of Kadima wants to release every hard core terrorist. Bibi is refusing to release terrorists like saadat and barghoutti.
38. Shalit kidnapped because olmert said no to troops in gaza
jason ,   haifa israel   (11.29.09)
IDF knew there were tunnels on the other side of the fence and wanted to go take them out but Olmert refused to allow them. The same Olmert who gave orders to the IDF not to shoot at rocket launchers even if they see them firing rockets at sderot. Yet it is Bibi who people are calling the worst PM. Israelis need to wake the hell up and get a clue.
39. #18, I hate the occupation and the injustice.
Noor ,   Palestine   (11.29.09)
Not ordinary people like you. I wish the best for you and for all of our people. Opposing the policies of a country doesn't make me a hater of a people.
40. "Anti-Semitic?"
Laura ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (11.29.09)
I keep reading comments about how "this or that" is "anti-Semitic." It's understandable that one does not appreciate profiling or discrimination based solely on race or religion. So why is it that I find comments, from the same people who are constantly denouncing things as "anti-Semitic" or "racism against the Jews," discussing how Arabs are all terrible people/terrorists who need to be deported. Please, for the benefit of your own credibility, reflect on this next time you call something "anti-Semitic" and think before follow that post with an equally discriminatory comment about Arabs. It makes you look very, very bad.
41. #14 When was the first victory?
Cynthia ,   USA   (11.29.09)
The Palestinians have made no progress. You sit comfortably in Canada after your family ran away from Israel in '48 cheering the Palestinians as they march backwards. The kidnapping and abuse of Gilad Shalit is no victory.
42. Would you people get off bibi's back with this false report
jason ,   haifa israel   (11.29.09)
Bibi didn't lose wars. Olmert and kadima humiliated israel by losing wars so they can please UNIFIL. Bibi is not giving Ghajar back to UNIFIL. That was falsely reported. Bibi isn't releasing terrorists with blood on their hand like mofaz and livni voted for to release all of them. Mofaz has said release all of them. Bibi is refusing to release barghoutti and Saadat. The 980 prisoners was from olmert's court petition. All these stories taken out of context. Bibi let 3,000 homes that olmert allowed to go forward and yet these builder fanatics go nuts. Bibi didn't lose the war to hezbollah humiliating israel because olmert woundn't allow full force and had soldiers hide in homes and wouldn't let them go forward. Bibi didn't leave gaza for iran and hamas. Yet you people pound and pound bibi. The same people that were quiet when olmert was in power just want to take down bibi. These people took him down the first time and we got sharon and kadima to destroy israel. Enough already bibi risked his life as a soldier for israel being shot. National Union doesn't care about Israel they care about taking Bibi down. They even praised olmert for taking shots at bibi. They were silent when olmert was losing wars and not allowing troops to fire at rocket launchers firing rockets at sderot. I hope you get what you deserve and take bibi down and get PM Mofaz who will release barghoutti and saadat and every prisoner with blood on their hands. You people have no idea how much better bibi is. You forget that Kadima released hard core hamas terrorists for a good gesture. I give up with israeli politics as they are taking down a good man in Bibi. GET OFF HIS BACK HE GETS POUNDED AND POUNDED WHEN SHALIT WAS KIDNAPPED ON OLMERT'S WATCH BECAUSE OLMERT GAVE ORDERS NOT TO GO AFTER TUNNELS ON THE OTHER SIDE. YOU SLAM BIBI WHO RISKED HIS LIFE FOR ISRAEL WHILE OLMERT THE LAWYER WHO NEVER SERVED DIDN'T GET NEARLY THE POUNDING.
43. To: No. 14
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (11.29.09)
Oh, yes, just another Palestinian "victory." You've had SOOOO many in sixty-one years. Yep. We sure have played into your hands. Forty percent unemployment in your autonomous regions. Rampant inflation. Closed hospitals. No foreign investment capital. Crumbling infrastructure. Climbing infant mortality rates. A "leadership" that puts their luxurious lifestyles ahead of Palestinian interests, using money intended to benefit the Palestinian people, not their bank accounts and homes in Europe. Tee hee. Boy, have we played right into your hands! Noor -- I used to think you were merely hopeful. Now I know you are delusional. You just keep snapping up all those "victories." If you are really, really good little terrorists, Israel will give you more such "victories" than you can possibly dream of. That's the operative word for you, Noor. Dream. Dream on, dear. Reality is just too gosh-darned harsh for you to stand. I wonder what "victory" Israel has planned for you tomorrow and the day after. Hmm. We'll see. We'll see.
44. # 42
Birdi ,   Israel   (11.29.09)
BRAVO to you Jason. Good TRUTHFUL post. All the Bibi bashers need to allow him to do his job.He isnt as dumb as you all make him to be.
45. # 41
Birdi ,   Israel   (11.29.09)
Noor is in Canada ??? Ah thats news to me. Noor do enlighten us as to where you live....please.
46. To: No. 29
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (11.29.09)
I admire your creative and most articulate post, but you should realize that it works much, much better if you kick your feet and pound the floor with your fists while you say it. Come to think of it -- you probably did!
47. u r wrong
david cohen ,   china   (11.29.09)
there is nothing comforting about "one Jew is worth 980 murderers" this is a joyful day for a few Shalit family memebr. THIS IS A SAD DAY FOR ISRAEL. THE BEGINNING OF ITS SECURITY UNFOLDING. GONE ARE THE DAYS OF OUR SUPREMACY. GONE ARE THE DAYS WHEN WE STOOD FIRM AGAINST BLACKMAIL. WE ARE GETTING SCREWED AND WE ARE RELASEING 500 MURDERERS BEFORE WE EVEN HAVE ACCESS TO SHALIT THROUGH ANY INTERNATIONAL ORGANISATION. i am mourning for you Israel.
48. To: No. 39
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (11.29.09)
Oh, look, the "kinder and gentler" Noor. Or the obsequious and pithy Noor, at any rate. Do you think you have anyone fooled? Do you think some of us haven't read your posts in which you spew venomous anti-Semitism and anti-Israel vomit? Didn't you post just a day or two ago on another thread that Palestinian violence is justified, and that Palestinians are proud to be terrorists? Yes, you did. Okay, I guess it is schizophrenic or multiple-personality Noor in the house today.
49. Lose The Collective Guilt Or Perish
Dan ,   USA   (11.30.09)
No country can survive releasing the number of captured terrorist that Israell releases every year. Those released will only hate Israel even more than before their capture and return to do damage to Israel. It pains me to think Israel will not survive, but it will not. Not unless it loses it's feeling of collective guilt as a people and gets strong leadership. Neither is on the horizon.
50. Sarah #43
Noor ,   Palestine   (11.30.09)
For all intents and purposes on this current discussion, I will dismiss the first half of your post as it is irrelevant in this case. The bottom line is that when it comes to receiving the prisoners we demand, we the Palestinians and other Arabs are very successful at doing so. And we always get Israel to do so. "You just keep snapping up all those "victories." What irony! I believe it is you who has the audacity to regurgitate the "fact" that Israel "won" all 6 wars ad nauseum without failing to take into account the implications of the two most recent wars proven to be utter failures for Israel.You have regurgitated this concept in almost every single one of your posts, failing to realize that Israel's military power has eroded since the past 20 years. Point the dirty finger at yourself, first. "Reality is just too gosh-darned harsh for you to stand. " You are just mad at the fact that I am right. Those that we demand Israel to free are those that we get in the end. That ticks you off.
51. Sarah #39
Noor ,   Palestine   (11.30.09)
"Oh, look, the "kinder and gentler" Noor. Or the obsequious and pithy Noor, at any rate." You fail at life. Stop conflating those who are opposed to Israel's policies with those who hate Jews altogether. "Do you think you have anyone fooled? Do you think some of us haven't read your posts in which you spew venomous anti-Semitism and anti-Israel vomit? " I am a Semite, you fool. As far as I'm concerned, I never posted a single statement that attacked the religion of Judaism or the Jewish people. Those who are opposed to Israeli policy are not anti-Semite. Criticizing Israel's policies, on the other hand, is justified. "Didn't you post just a day or two ago on another thread that Palestinian violence is justified, and that Palestinians are proud to be terrorists? Yes, you did. " No, I didnt. In fact, this is a fabrication created by you meant to demonize me. I do support popular resistance, however, because to resist is to exist and vice versa. "Okay, I guess it is schizophrenic or multiple-personality Noor in the house today. " You seem confused.
52. Cynthia, you re just as confused as Sarah.
Noor ,   Palestine   (11.30.09)
What part of, "Every time the Palestinians demand a particular prisoner, they succeed at getting Israel to hand he/she over every single time," don't you understand? "The Palestinians have made no progress." We are still in the land of Palestine, arent we? We still exist, dont we?
53. Noor
Yaron ,   USA   (11.30.09)
If the Palestinians have one more grand victory....Israel may become the number one destination for venture capital as opposed to the third in the world. Your claim is pathetic and baseless. The fact is the Palestinians continue to digress further while the whole world moves forward....sounds grand to me.
54. current exchange rate
dani   (11.30.09)
1 israeli = 980 palestinians for comparison: 1 Euro = 1.5 U.S. dollars Just for clarity - Euros are more valuable than dollars.
55. To: No. 50
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (11.30.09)
Noor, if you consider it a "victory" to have blown three opportunities for a Palestinian state, lost six wars and incurred the revulsion of millions throughout the world with your vile acts of terror, then fine, you are victorious! Okay? I wish you hundreds more such "victories," even thousands! Reality is really not your strong suit, is it?
56. To: No. 51
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (11.30.09)
LOL! Keep it up, sweetie. You have wonderful entertainment value. Still, it is a purpose in life -- however meager. Keep those posts coming. I enjoy a rollicking good laugh.
57. # 43
Birdi ,   Israel   (11.30.09)
1) "And we always get Israel to do so" Noor you are going to eat those words as you will see that the 2 killers you want released from our prisons, WONT BE RELEASED. 2) calm down, your anger is really not healthy for you.
58. 50
zionist forever   (11.30.09)
Noor The reasons that Israel hasn't had any overwhelming victories in recent years are mainly the left wing members of the government who are peace process obsessed will intentionally not let the IDF take the gloves off and as a result we only get jobs that are half done which is worse than doing nothing at all. Lebanon 2006 was a disaster because of the people at the top and a decade of budget cuts because the peace process was going to be our saviour. The bafoon Olmert Amir Peretz whose defenition of pre emptive strike had more to do with unions demanding a pay rise rather than anything to do with the military. Dan Halutz the chief of staff a former air force general that was convinced the whole operation could be won with air power and refused to listen to the officers in the field who wanted more men and were saying we need more infantry to win this not jets. Also thanks to budget cuts the IDF might buy a tank but to save money they may not spend that little bit extra on a system to protect that tank from anti tank rockets. As a result some tanks were damaged & I believe 2 destroyed. Also again to save money some reserves hadn't been called up for training for years at a time and so skills were forgoton After Lebanon lessons were learned The IDF started spending money and reserves started getting more training. Cast Lead was very successful until Olmert decided to once again refuse to listen to the IDF officers who were calling for about an extra week. Olmert though unilaterally pulled out before the job was done & Hamas started working again. If an Israeli government said to the IDF commanders you run this your way, and we will not hold you back in anyway at all then the Hamas & Hizbollah would be smashed beyond recognition. Israel has the firepower all it needs is a will to use it and if its pushed to far then it will throw everything its got at you. Next time Southern Lebanon & Gaza might just get flattened.
59. Noor -anti semitism -resistance
galut ,   selah   (11.30.09)
if the resistanc e ,was direcrted at government or military that would be one thing ... most of hamas, hezbulah and fatah rocket attacks have been at civilian populations ,sucide bombs exploded in public market and malls...and buses ,,,definatly not military targets....as long as that continues I will call it terrorism and designed to kill jews...you say you don't hate the people yet you support this kind of hateful activity
60. #52 Noor, Sarah and I see the reality
Cynthia ,   USA   (11.30.09)
How pathetic that a prisoner release of terrorists in exchange for one kidnapped and abused Israeli soldier who should have been released long ago, is a major accomplishment. The stateless Palestinians now have less land than was offered them in '47. No economy, no infrastructure, insufficient medical facilities while dependent on foreign aid, donations and Israeli transfer of goods, medical care/supplies and funds. The Palestinians exist but perpetuate a state of failure to garner world sympathy. I honestly would like to see the Palestinians succeed but no matter what any country, group or individual does for them, they never progress. And please don't start barking about how it's Israel's fault. Take responsibility for once!
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article