News
UN marks November 29 'day of mourning'
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 30.11.09, 20:28
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
73 Talkbacks for this article
31. # 4
Birdi ,   Israel   (11.30.09)
We Israelis have been saying this for years. Thanks Hen.
32. 3
Rosie   (11.30.09)
Wonderful!!!!!!
33. 7
Rosie   (11.30.09)
Thanks for the information.
34. PLEASE ISRAEL DONT SEND ANYBODY TO THESE DEBATES
zionist forever   (11.30.09)
Its going to be like a show trial where everybody is going to be sitting away condemning Israel for its very existence Send somebody and he will be sitting there trying vainly to get everybody else to take into consideration what he says which nobody is interested in .. judgement has been passed before the debate began. The General Assembly has no power its a place where everybody who doesn't like Israel goes to have a rant and rave and pass a few non binding resolutions which are nothing more than proposals for Israel to choose to accept or reject Sending a representative is playing into their hands and making these debates look legitimate issues which are being discussed in a fair and reasonable manner.
35. #13 - anti-occupation..
mati ,   yerushalayim   (11.30.09)
Exactly what land are the Jews occupying? Judea? It's a shame some commentators have never read a history book.
36. chava@15 The Romans called it ..
Benny ,   NYC   (12.01.09)
They did not call it Palestina,but to humiliate the Jews at the time for not obeying the Roman dictums disobaying changed it to: Syria- Palestina. Thought I'd correct you.Hope you don't mind. One way or another we have had a presense in our Holy Land since,because not all Jews left.Many stayed and that is why we have had a presense here to today
37. And the joke is ----------
Rozz   (12.01.09)
the UN idiots are actually getting paid for their tripe! Wow, I think I'll become a member too.
38. # 18
Birdi ,   Israel   (11.30.09)
Gary, its close to 7 million jews in Israel now.
39. To#13Anti-occupation of Ireland the Malvinas perhaps
Dani ,   Amsterdam NL   (11.30.09)
I do not compare Ireland to Israel I just would like to remember that British soldiers are in Ireland as invaders and that there is a fence that keep separate Christian Irish from Protestant Brits. Malvinas if I am not wrong is Argentina sovereignty violated be British settlers supported by their army.
40. #23 - facts
mati ,   yerushalayim   (12.01.09)
Accusation: Use of white phosphorus on hospitals/schools Fact: phosphorus was used but in a completely legal context and not near people. Accusation: Use of Human shields Fact: No evidence unless you consider shooting at officers arresting someone and hitting the wrong person. King David Hotel bombing -- that was a long, long time ago by an underground group against the british and was even timed to minimize casualties (a handful). Collective punishment and "collateral" damage --going through checkpoints to reduce number of israeli casualties is not collective punishment. even if it were it is well-deserved. Targeted assassinations --unlike Arabs who blow up civilians Indiscriminate bombings of civillian centers. --is it precise targeting of illegal weapons cashes and militants. Most militants however, are counted as civilians and hide in schools. Uncontrolled settler and radical right wing violence in occupied territories. --The fact that they are Jews offends you and they are peaceful except when they are hunted at night like animals by surrounding Arabs. You think if a Jew wants to live in Judea he is a right-wing radical. THAT is offensive!
41. Turn it into Housing
Shimon ,   Cincinnati, USA   (12.01.09)
Turn the UN into housing for the homeless. Throw their useless "diplomats" out, but not before they pay their parking tickets and serve jail time for all their offenses. Worthless, pointless and hopeless are the only words that fit that collection of fools and tools.
42. #13
mark ,   ca   (12.01.09)
Person with an IQ above 90 would NEVER make such a statement:-)
43. Birdi, Israel's own High Court agrees with me...
BBSNews ,   Charlotte, NC   (12.01.09)
...The West Bank is held under belligerent occupation. Surely you believe in the rule of law eh Birdi? How do you expect to be taken seriously if you don't even know your own laws? You might also note UN res's 194, 242 and 338 to name those at the beginning in the long line of others that also show you to be incorrect. P. S. Gaza is and has also been occupied by Israel since 1967. See both the draft and the final Gaza Disengagement Plan as well as the Goldstone Report for a more thorough discussion of the facts. I do hope whatever it is in the Aloni thread you want answered is less nonsensical than your claim here.
44. zionist forever, what about UNGA 181?
BBSNews ,   Charlotte, NC   (12.01.09)
Explain that.
45. Israel's persecution complex stunting growth...
BBSNews ,   Charlotte, NC   (12.01.09)
Seriously, it's time to grow up. I mean here's Benny, talking about how the Romans only called Palestina that to "humiliate the Jews" - from outside it seems that every facet of Israeli life is measured against "the world hates us, the world has always hated us'. Israelis bash Europe, Russia, the US, various South American states, the Scandinavian countries, the entire Middle East, Australia (although not so much East/SouthEast Asia) etc - pretty much Israel gives the back of the hand to much of the entire planet and then they cry "they hate us"... Well duh! Between the damnable occupations and the repeated insults to diplomats, heads of state, and plain old citizens of nearly every other state on the planet what do you expect? Simply end the arrogance, the occupations, the animosity to the world and make a fair and just peace. I promise, you'll feel better about yourselves by ending the real existential threat - the illegal colonies.
46. Mati, about that White Phosphorous claim...
BBSNews ,   Charlotte, NC   (12.01.09)
From the Goldstone Report: Page 14, paragraph 38: "The Mission also examined the precautions taken by Israeli forces in the context of three specific attacks they launched. On 15 January 2009, the UNRWA field office compound in Gaza City came under shelling with high explosive and white phosphorous munitions. The Mission notes that the attack was extremely dangerous, as the compound offered shelter to between 600 and 700 civilians and contained a huge fuel depot. The Israeli forces continued the attack over several hours in spite of having been fully alerted to the risks they created. The Mission concludes that Israeli armed forces violated the customary international law requirement to take all feasible precautions in the choice of means and method of attack with a view to avoiding and in any event minimizing incidental loss of civilian life, injury to civilians and damage to civilian objects. 39. The Mission also finds that, on the same day, the Israeli forces directly and intentionally attacked the Al Quds Hospital in Gaza City and the adjacent ambulance depot with white phosphorous shells. The attack caused fires which took a whole day to extinguish and caused panic among the sick and wounded who had to be evacuated. The Mission finds that no warning was given at any point of an imminent strike. On the basis of its investigation, the Mission rejects the allegation that fire was directed at Israeli forces from within the hospital."
47. Mati, about that Human Shields claim...
BBSNews ,   Charlotte, NC   (12.01.09)
From the Goldstone Report. Page 19, paragraph 55: "The Mission investigated four incidents in which Israeli forces coerced Palestinian civilian men at gun point to take part in house searches during the military operations (Chapter XIV). The Palestinian men were blindfolded and handcuffed as they were forced to enter houses ahead of the Israeli soldiers. In one of the incidents, Israeli forces repeatedly forced a man to enter a house in which Palestinian combatants were hiding. Published testimonies of Israeli soldiers who took part in the military operations confirm the continued use of this practice, in spite of clear orders from Israel’s High Court to the armed forces to put an end to it and repeated public assurances from the armed forces that the practice had been discontinued. The Mission concludes that this practice amounts to the use of Palestinian civilians as human shields and is therefore prohibited by international humanitarian law. It puts the right to life of the civilians at risk in an arbitrary and unlawful manner and constitutes cruel and inhuman treatment. The use of human shields also is a war crime."
48. Mati, about that King David Hotel claim...
BBSNews ,   Charlotte, NC   (12.01.09)
Irgun terrorists killed 92 that day. From the Times: http://www.timesonline.co.uk /tol/news/world/middle_east /article690085.ece "Decades later, Irgun veterans are unrepentant. Sarah Agassi, 80, remembers spying in the King David Hotel. She and a fellow agent posed as a couple. They danced tangos and waltzes, sipped whisky and wine while they cased out the hotel. On the day her brother and his fellow fighters posed as Arabs delivering milk and brought seven milk churns, each containing 50kg of explosives, into the building. Ms Agassi waited across the street until her brother rushed out. She said that she then made the warning call to the British command in the hotel. Sitting in the luxurious hotel lobby, she expressed no regret. “We fought for our independence. We thought it was the right way . . . If I had to fight for Israel, I swear even now I would do anything.” Bibi himself has hailed this act of terrorism. The Palestinians had role models to work from...
49. # 40
Birdi ,   Israel   (12.01.09)
Good post, Mati.
50. How many relatively new countries that are truly imploding
Global Citizen ,   Israel & USA   (12.01.09)
under their crime and misery and exploding with terrorists and refugees has the UN railed against? None, you say? Of course - they provide nothing to be insanely jealous about.
51. #40 The REAL facts.
Addle ,   Toronto   (12.01.09)
-Fact: phosphorus was used but in a completely legal context and not near people. Real fact: Tell that to the innocent women and children who were burned alive severely by the phosphorus bombs. And it's not legal. Fact: No evidence unless you consider shooting at officers arresting someone and hitting the wrong person. Real Fact: Goldstone report makes note of the IDF using human shields in Gaza. Not only that but the IDF also ties up Palestinians youths to vehicles to act as shields. http://i41.tinypic.com/ege3uu.jpg Disgusting -- that was a long, long time ago by an underground group against the british and was even timed to minimize casualties (a handful) Real Fact: Timed or no timed, it was still a terrorist attack committed by people who would later form Israel. -going through checkpoints to reduce number of israeli casualties is not collective punishment. even if it were it is well-deserved. Real Fact: Too much abuse goes on during the checkpoints. It's simply inhumane and severely chokes off Palestinian transportation in the occupied West Bank. --unlike Arabs who blow up civilians Real fact: Civillians also get targeted in the assassinations. --is it precise targeting of illegal weapons cashes and militants. Most militants however, are counted as civilians and hide in schools. Real Fact: Precise? Tell that to the dead children of Lebanon and Gaza. You never target civillian centers when they're populated with civilians. To many unnecessary casualties will result from it. --The fact that they are Jews offends you and they are peaceful except when they are hunted at night like animals by surrounding Arabs. You think if a Jew wants to live in Judea he is a right-wing radical. THAT is offensive! Real Fact: Peaceful? What's so peaceful about Settler raids on Palestinian olive trees, cutting them down and taking away profit the Palestinians need to live day to day? What's peaceful about young settler kids hurling stones at Palestinian children trying to make their way to school? And it's not 'Jews' that offend me. There are many Jews who protest the unfair policies of Israel to which I admire.
52. #13..B.S.NEWS... DEBATE CHINA AND TIBET
ABRAHAM ben JACOB ,   CANADA   (12.01.09)
#13. B.S. NEWS SAYS NOT ANTI-ISRAEL, JUST ANTI-OCCUPATION. CHINA FORCIBLY OCCUPIES TIBET. DEBATE CHINA AND TIBET TO SHOW HOW NEUTRAL THE B.BS.NEWS AND THE U.N. ARE AGAINST THE REAL OCCUPIERS.
53. UN 181 didn't call to establish a "Palestinian state", nor
Eitan ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (12.01.09)
did UN 242!!! Neither in 1947 nor in 1967, the years in which respectively these UN fundamental resolution were reached, the Arabs of Eretz Israel (Land of Israel) did not perceive themselves to belong to a unique people, to a "Palestinian" people. Only in the late 1960s did members of this group, for purely political reasons, began to perceive themselves as a people. UN resolution 181 called for the establishment of an "Arab state", to coexist in peace alongside a "Jewish state" in Eretz Israel. UN resolution 242 corrected 181 in that it did not mention even once the setting up of yet another state between the River and the Sea!!! Indeed, it does not mention at all concepts such as "Palestine", "Palestinians" or a "Palestinian state". It is this wisdom that should be a guide to peace loving people around the world: Let the Arabs of the Land be part of the neighboring Arab states, as they were until 1967. They need not move in doing that. Their citizenship and center of social and political life however should be directed towards Amman and Cairo.
54. re: 13 "not anti-Israel"
Zak Meyers ,   New York   (12.01.09)
So, if the UN is solely "anti-occupations," you should be able to site the litany of resolutions passed against China's occupation of Tibet, right?
55. The Irgun and the King David
Elihu Stone ,   Efrat, Israel   (12.01.09)
Notice at least two key differences between Palestinian terrorism and the the activity of the Irgun: As #48 BBSNews, Charlotte NC states:" Ms Agassi waited across the street until her brother rushed out. She said that she then made the warning call to the British command in the hotel." The British Command ( military body) was quartered in the hotel and the Irgun called in a _warning_ - so that the hotel could be evacuated. Palestinian terror is distinguished by its targeting of civilians (commuter busses, Pesach seders at hotels, tennagers studying in talmudica academies, with the clear intent of maim ingand mutilating as many people as possible. No warnings are given. The message intended is entirely different. 'Subtle' differences like these are telling.
56. BBs 48
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (12.01.09)
The King David hotel was a military target . The Irgun had send a message to the French News Agency that The Hotel will be blown up in 30 minutes and that the hotel should be evacuated , the British commander was immediately told this , but he said : i give the orders here , not those terrorists . The british could not imagine or believe that those Jews would be able to enter this heavily guarded place . There were , sad to say , also Jewish victims there .
57. hgl27@aol.com
Herbert Glaser ,   Vail, Colorado   (12.01.09)
UN=Useless Nonsense
58. Charles@ 56 ...When they run out of ideas
Kate ,   ISRAEL   (12.01.09)
When they run out of ideas up comes the various erroneous stories. This time(not the first either)is the King David Hotel incident. That was the headquarters of the Brits'. They were warned them to vacate the premises,but coming from Jews the arrogant Brits ignored it. Thus the conswqences. i had neither read,or hear there were Jews working there.hadley likely ubder the prevaling circumstances.Arab workers?Yes So,what you say comes as a surprise and do not believe it sorry.
59. To @47 Twisted and misrepresented incidents
James ,   Israel   (12.01.09)
The IDF had at times resorted to ask the accomaniment of some in Gaza,unless you haveseen what the place loks like youhave zilch knowledge.Why? Because it is notonly to apprehend terrorists,but because the whole of Gaza is full of "wired up" tunnels where by,the only ones who know where they are situated are the residents even in who's homes they are in place to detonate te BOMBS. You are realy naive to think Hamas is not prepared for every eventuality. Sorry go elsewhere to get the true information in saying they were BLIND FOLDED.How can it help the IDF if they are blind folded,it is ludicrous.And don't quote Goodstons report that it has BEEN DISQUALIFIED for his erroneousness by every one who knows best. and I am not talking the result of his so-called findings were presented by OUR COURTS,or Israel but by the foreign bodies.. If you do I suggest otherwise just BITE YOUR TONGUE.
60. bbs news getting his nicker in a twist
James ,   Israel   (12.01.09)
With his usual exaggerations trying to maximize what had not happened.. Getting fed up with your ususl meandering we have read when you were at ....you know.You are just regurgitating the usual BS. Remember this awar we are fighting and not a game of "tiddly winks". I sugest you give it a rest,we have read all of this at Haaretz from you ad-nauseum. You don't like the truth?Tough.You want to accuse unnecessarily the IDF then better shut up,for it is okay to write from the comfort of your chair never having faught in any WARS. It would behove you to remember Vietnam,Kosovo, Afghanistan, iraq GITMO? The Russians and the allies fighting wars most certainly did notuse VELVET gloves to achieve information by it. Wars are like that and Israel has had to do it,not once,twice,three times,but ever since 1922+1924,26,27, 28,30,40,42,44,45,46,47,48,49,50,53 shall I go on? Until today. Stop lecturing Israel and the IDF/IAF.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article