News
Steinitz: Israel can do without US economic aid
Roni Sofer
Published: 10.01.10, 11:09
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
120 Talkbacks for this article
31. Uncle Sam: Choose Wisely
Gabriel ,   Israel   (01.10.10)
Sometimes, an uncle can forget that there is a father and mother and of course the child's own self that comes before him. Uncle Sam, you are only that; a secondary support (or not). For those who think that Israel exists because of Uncle Sam, in addition to lacking common sense, also they lack an understanding of what powers the State of Israel. BTW, the British colonialists were attacked and their soldiers informed their superiors that they could not defeat the Zelotous Jews who could not care less if they were killed, as long as Isreal succeeded. They packed up and went home. If Uncle Sam is here to continue that tradition, Uncle Sam can (metaphorically) take a hike, and although the world would be worse off because of the slaughter that could follow, Israel will undoubtably prevail, and for sure, you could write off Uncle Sam as yesterday's fad. Can you say Iriquois, Seneca, Sioux? I think you might consider learning to.
32. Yees, 1 Madoff with 50B USD depositing in Israel is Enough!
Tayfun_Turkey ,   Istanbul   (01.10.10)
33. poem, dedicated to Mr. Mitchell
israeli poet ,   stupidgovernmentland   (01.10.10)
they call me Mr.Steinitz my famous worm's-eye view does fit my stupid government opinions of a few
34. Israel has no better ally than the US
anonymoUS ,   nyc   (01.10.10)
Israel: clean up your mess and get your house in order, and never forget who your friend is.
35. to #6 nice try but Israel don't control
ghostq   (01.10.10)
your inner issues you got the fatah to turn to, and the time for action you should read what Abu Mazen turned down mmm I get they didn't advertize olmert offer a year ago, too bad cause Abu Mazen turn it down with the advise of forign arab recomandation land swap and all, but as I see it you r your own worst enemy.
36. like until now Israel needed the help
ghostq   (01.10.10)
of the USA, until far reality showed that the only one Israel can count on is herself.
37. I wouldn't be THAT quick to call it quits with the US!
Heather Czerniak ,   Milwaukee, USA   (01.10.10)
To a point, Israel still relies on outside help with its defense. Israel has also shared much of its own military technology with the US, not to mention honoring its agreement to use the nearly $3 billion in US military aid to buy American weapons and thus keep American defense companies in business. But if Israel or the US decides that this relationship must end, Europe will gladly step in and offer Israel a better deal. Not that I'd easily trust Europe, but the US could very well be losing the one true ally it has left.
38. If obama tries it he will be living in Chicago in 2012
zionist forever   (01.10.10)
Israel already gets very little in economic aid thanks to a little deal worked out by Bibi as finance minister. When Bibi was finance minister under Arial Sharon he worked out a deal with the US where they no longer finve financial aid in exchange the military aid would gradually be increased over a certain number of years. They might provide loan guarantees sometimes and give military aid which helps the US more than Israel because of all the money it gives to the US arms industry through both a US government subsidy and the hard cash of its own Israel spends. There are also lots of strings attached like Israel must buy the buk of its weapons from the US and they have a veto over who Israel can sell domestically produced weapons to. How are Lockheed Martin & Boeing going to feel when they start loosing contracts worth billions and have to lay people off thanks to Obamas ego? Also no US government is going to try and place sanctions onto Israel. In November there are mid terms and the last thing the Democrats are going to do is let their man start putting sanctions on Israel and risking jewish votes. After that Obama will be slowly approaching an election year and if he wants the jewish vote in 2012 he better not try anything stupid. Bush senior tried this little trick and at he was a 1 term president and APAC were boasting about how they brought him down. Obama is already falling in the polls big time the last thing he needs is to risk upsetting the jews because although Obama hates Israel and loves the muslims its the jews who have all the muscle when it comes to lobbying which is where it really matters for a president wanting to get reelected. How will Americans feel about Obama choosing royalty, dictators, & people who were dancing in the streets on 9/11 over Israel as allies? Obama is playing with fire and if he is not careful he will get burned in 2012.
39. USA only talks w/ $$$ which is really only bribes.
Eli   (01.10.10)
40. Steinitz, you're correct.
Jim ,   Tokyo, Japan   (01.10.10)
Israel doesn't need American money. Refuse to take it. I applaud you for your courage.
41. Actually Steinitz is almost right
Bruno ,   Haifa   (01.10.10)
We can do without him ... not the US.
42. U.S. Aid
Joan Lichterman ,   Oakland, CA, USA   (01.10.10)
If Israel can do very well without US aid, I will press for its withdrawal. I believe Israel has received a disproportionate amount of US aid.
43. Israel can do without aid
jim l ,   macon, ga usa   (01.10.10)
I think its time to let them stand on their on 2 feet....They don't need us and they don't seem interested in peace...Neither do the Palastinians...They both seak world sympathy but yet neither wants peace...Leave them alone and let the best man stand..
44. Bush the First
Dorothy Friend ,   Tel Aviv   (01.10.10)
all over again!
45. Steinitz and his big "brave" colleagues
Michael ,   Haifa   (01.10.10)
What they don't understand is that this is only the tip of a very large global iceberg of various economic sanctions
46. Stalemate on Jerusalem,refugees,Israel as Jewish state
Sam ,   Canada   (01.10.10)
Rather than bringing up easier issues first, the US, Palestinians and Israel painted themselves into a corner on the core issue of Jerusalem.(freezing settlements there) Abbas is making his stand and Netanyahu is making his stand. This American administration will find that it can't bully Israel, as the Arabs would like, on the core issues. (Jerusalem, refugees etc)
47. Obama-Remember George Bush Sr.
Susan ,   Kfar Saba   (01.10.10)
George Bush Sr. did this. Israel needed loan guarantees to absorb a million immigrants from the ex-Soviet Union, a humanitarian task. He lost Jewish support. He was a one term president.I personally voted for him the first time, but not the second. Furthermore, loan guarantees don't cost the US anything. It is not an actual loan or foreign aid. US merely co-signs the loan so that Israel can get a better interest rate. Israel has never defaulted on a loan.
48. Mitchel is a Lebanese-He should advise Hezballah not the USA
Alan ,   SA   (01.10.10)
49. HA!
James ,   US   (01.10.10)
Stop all aid, stop ALL guarantees! Lets see how long israel lasts without them...
50. 47 - I think it was more the overall dissatisfaction...
Dorothy Friend ,   Tel Aviv   (01.10.10)
... in the USA over the economy in 1992 (remember the "Sadam still has his job. Do you? bumper sticker) that lost Bush Snr. the election, not some all powerful Jewish vote. The American economy is the first concern of American voters.
51. #43 I'm stunned -- another self-righteous American
Yaniv ,   Israel   (01.10.10)
You invade nations that are not neighbors launching rockets on you and then preach about peace? Israel happens to have more songs about peace than any other nation, a value we teach our kids regularly. But perhaps you think peace means dead Jews, because to survive in this tough neighborhood called middle east, you can't put your guard down and expect love in return. A final showdown, I would love it, so get your American fingers out of our business and our of our way and stop holding us back in our short wars, while you linger in Afghanistan for a decade.
52. The peace trap
Marcel ,   Florida   (01.10.10)
The enemy could not defeat Israel by war and so by peace Israel is slowly taken down piece by peace. Welcome to the New World Order where the top agenda is for Israel to disappear. Amoral,godless China will gladly sacrifice Israel faster than the US did for good relations with their lslamic partner$. Lest this fact be lost on the naive I remind all that the UN was created by the US globalists for one reason, world government which is very,very bad for Israel. The evil Babel 2 UN has grown into manhood and no longer tries to hide it's Satanic,Anti-God,Nazi agenda. One thing the secular,degreed,intellectual Hellenized Jew suffers from is spiritual blindness which causes him to chase after lies and delusions and not seek the Holy One of Israel. He is trapped in his material world box and cannot get out to grasp the spiritual dimensions of the growing threats to Israel related to the international rebel's UNited against the God of Israel. Pressure and threats against Israel from 'friends' only grow as it is non existent against the front line Islamic army (fatah&hamas) arrayed against Israel. China is just one of the newer rather large delusions as America was for vertically challenged Jews.There is only 1 Friend,1 Ally and this is the 1 secular Israel ignores. What the secular Jew must now come face to face with is the truth. The nations now look back to the creation of Israel in 1948 as a mistake to be corrected and that is what the peace process is really all about.Not even extremist Hamas in control of Gaza slows down the farce process. Israel's slow removal with a George Mitchell smile while Iran's is much quicker.These are the only two choices the world offers Israel and why Israel is foolish to ignore God at this very late hour. Again Jews are made the scapegoat to be sacrificed to the demon god of Islam to appease their global jihad.This plan has already backfired on the nations of the world especially the chief betrayer of Israel ,the US which will soon pay a hugh price for it's treachery against Israel.God is in control of this global drama and it ends real bad for all of Israel's enemies. Thou shalt arise, and have mercy upon Zion: for the time to favour her, yea, the set time, is come. For thy servants take pleasure in her stones, and favour the dust thereof. So the heathen shall fear the name of the LORD, and all the kings of the earth thy glory. When the LORD shall build up Zion, he shall appear in his glory. Psalm102
53. ahaaaaaa!!!!!!!
Yafa ,   Palestine   (01.10.10)
Are you sure Mr. Steinitz?! Personally, I hope so,, from the depths of my heart, Israel must depend on it self, it is today about 60 years old!!!!!and itis the time to stop arequest for support from Mama America, but unfortunately I do not think that this will happen
54. We'll be here for you when all those missiles launch, Israel
Cameron ,   USA   (01.10.10)
55. PARASHA SHEMOT: I FEAR GD NOT YOU
....DACON9   (01.10.10)
56. No. 49. acording to economics
Anon ,   Johannesburg RSA   (01.10.10)
and free markets, if Israel is free to do business with whoever they want they will be doing better then they are now. Today we live in a global village! China and India are waiting to accept Israel with open arms. trust me, this is fact. The USA, can become just another business partner, not the CEO by calling the shots. The Aid is hurting Israel. It helped in the 70's and 80's - but now its just hurting. Israel MUST NOT lose its friendship with the USA, but does not need or want a handout in any way. Handouts is for the Palestinians, Not Israel
57. #5: EXCELLENT FACT YOU OFFER THE IDIOTS !!!
.......DACON9   (01.10.10)
I DONT UNDERSTAND WHY THEY EVEN READ JEWISH NEWS unless they are hoping to see GDS FAVORITE CHILDREN BEGGING. AND THAT AINT GONNA HAPPEN ONLY BEGGING WILL BE TO THE ''ONE GD OF ISRAEL'' AND NONE OTHER
58. as expected from an unfreindly administration!
OZ   (01.10.10)
mitchell, obama's puppet, has no toher way to leverge his boss, only by threatening to cut loan gurenntteea. we all remeber what happened to bush sr., when used that tactic. obama , you ain't our mama! gfy!
59. Re:Israel Needs America
Mohamud ,   USA   (01.10.10)
Israel is sorrounded by hostile neighbors who cant really be blamed for being hostile, However America has always been at the forefront from the presidency of Harry Truman to the present and guess when the whole world condemned Israel massacres against palestinian women and children America has been the one ally that used its veto power time after time... Time for hate should be over..either allow the palestinians to have their own country and state or absorb them as citizens of Israel and give them the rights of citizens. We are in 2010 for goodnes sake you guys should end this drama for once and reconcile your differences. It is a shame that this has dragged on forever!
60. The misnomer known as "aid"
Christopher ,   Boston, MASS   (01.10.10)
Mitvhell admitted on a show run by a vaunted Jew hater like Rose that what is euphemistically called "aid" are actually loans that Israel must repay. A little historical data for the Antisemitic ignorant sourced from Barron's Magazine and Time Magazine in the late 90s when Clinton started the same BS: Israel is the ONLY country in the world ever to take a US loan and not default. That included ALL our Eurabian allies, Japan, Egypt, Jordan, Saudis, Kuwait, every Latin State, China, Russia, and yes even the UK and Germany! The CBO estimates that for every dollar loaned Israel, the US gets back a profit of $1 to $7 . HOW? In interest! And in the fact that 90% of all the loans must be spent in the US. So, before the Anti-Jew crowd starts dancing, think of the garment factories in Alabama making IDF uniforms; think of Boeing Lockheed and Martin getting billions in orders and maintaining thousands of jobs. Literally tens of thousands of US jobs are dependant on Israel spending money here. Without the LOANS, Israel has no reason to spend here, but would be better off shopping out for bidders for the lowest prices. Remeber that the next time a Jew hater spews his venom like Charlie Rose does nightly and ask why the unemployment rate jumped again after Israel begins spending money in more friendly environments - perhaps move the garment factories back to Sderot ...I'm sure they would love the jobs!
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article