News
PM at Yad Vashem: Stop evil
Ronen Medzini
Published: 25.01.10, 14:07
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
46 Talkbacks for this article
1. we know that. Bibi act like a british and point
ghostq   (01.25.10)
the obvious, we know people look for reasons to hate jews, I know cause I talked to neo natzi british guy that claimed that the only 1,700,000 jews got killed in the holocaust, and that everything is jewish propeganda, yes it was a month ago. so in other words you don't have to go to Arab nations when they advertise cartoons still the so cal enlited west full of anti semetic BS.
2. What hypocracy
Avi ,   Israel   (01.25.10)
Coming from a family that lost family members in the holocaust. One of the many lessons we derived that it is wrong to persecute those who are different than yourself . Along with 6000,000 Jews there were also gypsies, political prisoners and thousands of gay men were murderd by the Nazis. Yet tin the year 2010 the Shas party here in Israel continues the Nazi propoganda and persecute gay people this time using religion as a means to promote the hatred and violence towards the gay community the results of which we are all aware. So please as a Jew who lost family I will not stand for such hypocracy
4. And there are new Jew-haters that seek to destroy Arabs
Brad ,   USA   (01.25.10)
Just read comments here, Netanyahu! Look around you! You seek peace for Jewish nation, while that same nation is explicit in its desires to expel their citizens to preserve "national identity" - the very blood of Jews! You speak of "evil that wants to destroy Jews", and yet you are silent about evil that lurks within your very nation that "deserves this land by its blood relation" (Talmud). Every day I read on this pages about oppression and maltreatment of non-Jews and Jews who think different! Every day I read here war-mongering slurs of "rightful Jews" who deniy other nation's rights to existence - there are no Palestinians, they say! And yet you take great offense when somebody says that Jews are not nation, but a religious group! And that Israelis are a nation - but that includes Arabs, Christians and others, all of them your fellow nation want to Kahane out (read: expel) of Israel. You want peace? You can't and do not want to give peace! Why would you deserve peace? Now start with your slurs about antisemitism - nobody pays attention to them anymore!
5. Stop the denial
Marcel ,   Florida   (01.25.10)
Everyone is afraid to admit the truth. From it's beginning to it's soon end, Islam is Evil,is a lie,is intolerant,is violent at it's core.
6. BBS says Israel is "evil and macabre".
Mike M. ,   Seattle WA.   (01.25.10)
What is that if not full-blown,straigtforward antisemitism. Of course he'll tell you his opinions apply only to the territories. But that is nothing but a bold-faced lie and cover for his own evil-heart.
7. #4 Brad,The Lord gave the land to the Jews
Vinny ,   Brooklyn N.Y.   (01.25.10)
and not the Palestinians and if you don't understand that ,then you're an idiot from jump street. There's a war going on Brad, so get over your self-rightous indignation and quit being a little anti-semitic mutt.
8. # 5 Fundamentalist blind the heart
Cat Stevens   (01.25.10)
9. Memorial Day
Chardon Bleu ,   Geneva Switzerland   (01.25.10)
One cannot but agree that the racist atrocities of extermination committed against 6 million Jews should never be forgotten. At the same time, let us not forget that another 5 million persons of other minorities suffered the same fate, and that at about the same time to the East of Germany dozens of millions were executed in the name of the Marxist class ideology as victims of the Stalinist purges: Where is their Memorial Museum, when is their International Memorial Day? It‘s tragical, but the words of the prime minister „There is still denial, and lies are still being spread in the world“ also apply to the Nakba, where the denial and the lies are Zionist. As long as this other evil, the Nakba denial, the denial of the ethnic cleansing of Palestine in the name of the Zionist ideology is not stopped, as long as the wrong of the unspeakable injustice done to the Palestinian Arabs is not made good, it will keep „threatening the security of the Jews"
10. We are trying but you are refusing to stop.
(01.25.10)
11. new reasons to destroy Jewish state?
no new ,   IL   (01.25.10)
No new reasons- no new hatred. Same same ol' story But that doesnt mean we have to tolerate it- like if as saying a little more pushing- anyway they're used to it? NO WAY NO MORE- Can we change? Can we mak it better for ourselves?
12. to #2 omg snap out of it, it's not about accepting
ghostq   (01.25.10)
someone who is different than your self that your personal conclution, damn holocaust got nothing to do with sexual preferences, you live in very narrow world, I should buy you a huge picture cause many got killed during the holocause because jews r th easiest scape goats, germany didn't had much choice after what the British and the franch did to her, if it wasn't for the jews they would have find other minority. see the Britsh outcome of action and the Israeli palestinian conflict is also and outcome of British policy and india Pakistan war. the british messed too many times and wasn't brought to trile it's about time someone will expose the truth about them, cause during many centuries jews were very liked in Germany only since the British put their foot there than the troubles began.
13. So far - 5,6 are a true proof of my words!
Brad ,   Europe   (01.25.10)
You ask why people hate you? Read 5 and 6, Vinny and Marcel. American Jews who are big supporters of Israel, but do not want to move there. An arm-chair Jews. Figures.
14. The Evil is still here...
Eli Freedman ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (01.25.10)
Like some of the talkbackers here, that pollute the pages of Ynet and other Israeli / Jewish sites.Their hatred of ALL things Israeli and Jewish, spreading their malicious hateful propaganda and lies. They have been taught well that, the more audacious and bold the lie, repeated often enough, "BECOMES THEIR TRUTH"... Am I right, B.S.News, Observer, Chardon Bleu, Matty Groves!!??..These repulsive individuals and their ilk are THE proof, that EVIL still lurks amongst us.........
15. those politicians attribute their failures to anti-Semitism
observer   (01.25.10)
16. yad vashem
avi ,   nyc   (01.25.10)
Time to recognize Hillel Kook
17. The gift that keeps on giving...
Mikesailor ,   Miami, FL   (01.25.10)
is what the Holocaust has become. All actions by Israel are automatically given license because of the Holocaust. Building settlements; given license. Bombing civilians: likewise. Using white phosphorus on UN facilities: applauded brecause it prevents another Holocaust. Demanding more reparations: approved even though the Holocaust happened over sixty years ago. I've always been amazed that every action, every theft, every humiliation of Arabs is somehow given license by the Holocaust. Bibi is only parroting the well-worn excuse, yet cannot understand that it is Israel's present and past policies that have brought Israel into its well-deserved disrepute, and that using the Holocaust as an excuse for every Israeli depredation doesn't have the same force as it previously did.
18. to #9 you r wromg the Britsh were
ghostq   (01.25.10)
the masters of it, zionizm exist since 1889. palestinians is British invention much like Syria and pakistan, and Jordan. go look at the dates, you will find it shocking when I tell you all of those countries were created by England and France and they r not even one race, their ethnicity is not existing, BTW pakistanies and Indian r the same people only in one point of history some converted to Islam, but the same people, yeah I see the ironic when British cause the same race to kill itself, and the British created the refugees camps they told palis that zionists started it but the truth is it was purly British descition to evacuate arabs and to kill them, have you ever heard on Ancor mission? no congra they managed to hide the fact they killed 3/4 of Jaffa arabs the rest run to Gaza of today. and what Russia did in Drezden was disgusting and they also should be send to court of law.
19. to Brad & Avi
Deb ,   USA   (01.25.10)
Gay people aren't being murdered or tortured by Israel for being gay. "Palestinians" aka Arabs who lived in British Mandate Palestine between 1919 and 1948, are not being murdered or tortured for being Arabs. Jews ARE being murdered and tortured for being Jews throughout the world. In France, in South America, in the USA!!!!!! Wake up! All over the world new stirrings of the same Nazi ideology that caused the deaths of at least 6 million Jews is being spoken, loudly and with world acceptance. Shame on you for not getting it!
20. :: Evil?
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (01.25.10)
The term ‘evil’ is used much too oft. Is it ‘evil’ to attack innocent civilians without provocation and destroy their homes and farmland? Settlers do. Is it ‘evil’ to spend years attacking young school children as they travel to and from school? Settlers do. Is it ‘evil’ to collectively punish an entire populace for the crimes of a few? Israel does. Is it ‘evil’ to use civilians as human shields? The IDF does. Perhaps before using the term ‘evil’ Bibi should first root out the ‘evil’ that exists within Israel.
21. # 6
Birdi ,   Israel   (01.25.10)
Mike we all know that BBS is a full-blown anti-semite.No matter how many times he tries to deny it.
22. #9 P.M.'s reference was for you.
Mike M. ,   Seattle Wa.   (01.25.10)
As long as you speak of "Ziomnist Ideology" you remain a flat out anti-semite and there is no dressing it up with care for others(which sounds oh so hollow anyway). But we have come to expect less than nothing from Mr. Chardon Bleu.
23. Shoah comparisons?
Chardon Bleu ,   Geneva Switerland   (01.25.10)
The first meaning of the Greek word ‘holocaust’ is ‘complete destruction by fire’ and refers to a biblical form of the Hebrew tradition of sacrifice. If it is used instead of ’shoah’ in reference to the abominable Nazi crimes of extermination committed against 6 million Jews and 5 million people of other minorities, the ‘nakba’ does not pertain to the same type of crime. The Zionist master plan just wanted to get rid in one way or another of as many as possible of the Arab inhabitants of the land it claimed to belong to the Jews. Nevertheless this ethnic cleansing is a crime against humanity, even though it is denied and hidden behind Zionist lies. The first meaning ot the word ‘shoah’ is ‘catastrophe’, natural or other. For the indigenous Arab inhabitants of Palestine the ‘nakba’ certainly was such a catastrophe. It meant the ethnic cleansing by intimidation, terror and land theft according to a Zionist master plan (cf. Ilan Pappe: ‘The ethnic cleansing of Palestine’), which definitely is a crime against humanity. As far as ‘ethnic cleansing’ in the meaning of ‘holocaust’ is concerned, the model for all other later repetitions can be found in the Jewish Bible, where ‘G-d’ ordered the King Saul through the Judge Samuel to completely annihilate the Amalekite tribe, i.e. to “slay both man and woman, infant and suckling” (1 Sam 15.3). I was shocked when I heard friends in Israel taking about the Palestinian Arabs by referring to them as ‘Amalekites’.
24. #5 the guy in denial
observer   (01.25.10)
Yad Vashem is Judaism-Christianity affair, Islam is not involved. Back from your denial to the realty on the planet earth!
25. # 14
Birdi ,   Israel   (01.25.10)
Well said Eli. I agree with you %100.
26. # 20
Birdi ,   Israel   (01.25.10)
Isnt it eveil when as terrorist enters a settlement & kills the inhabitants? Isnt evil to murder a pregnent mother of young kids, driving on an open road? Isnt it evil to hide behind women & children, & in hospitals ? Hamas did. Isnt it evil to bombard southern Israel for 8 years with daily rockets? Isnt it evil to stab border guards at checkpoints? Isnt it evil to kill policemen on the roads. Isnt it evil to hang 2 Israeli civilains who mistakely wandered into Palestinian territory? Isnt it evil to kidnapped an IDF soldier & keep him rotting for over 4 years? Isnt it evil to strap a suicide belt to your body & attempt to kill as many Jews as you can? There are 2 sides to every coin.
27. To 22, Mike M.
Chardon Bleu ,   Geneva Switzerland   (01.25.10)
Mike, if you just took a minute to look up the meaning of the word 'ideology' (political, religious, economical, ethnic, philophical, etc.), you would immediately realize that it perfectly fits to the Zionist ideas as a whole. Too blind? Too lazy?
28. Matty,what would you do if...
Vinny ,   Brooklyn N.Y.   (01.25.10)
you were surrounded by bloodthirsty enemies? You would probably pat them on the behind,kiss them,and God knows what else. But you know what, it's still no excuse for YOUR evil, you little anti-semetic mutt.
29. Anti Zionism = Anti Semitism it's simple as that.
USA   (01.25.10)
Don't give us the BS it's because of Israel's policies towards the Palestinians. The very Palestinians you speak of were invented to continue to harass, murder and terrorise Jews. Now Iran using these invented Palestinians to carry out Final Solution #2 while the nations are just standing around, waiting for the creation of yet more Halocaust museums. There never was a Palestnian movement for statehood prior to the establishment of a modern state of Israel. There never was a world outcry against terror towards Jews, against rockets, or an outcry against illegal evictions of Jews from their homes by the government of Israel, just like there never was a world outcry against the Halocaust. Those are facts. I just wish the government of Israel would tell the truth to it's own people for God's sake. The nations never needed a reason to hate Jews, they just do. You blame Jews from everything to killing your man-god to killing so called muslim profits, controling the media. If you recognize the Jewish people as a people you have to recognize the history of this people and of the country they belong to, the land of Israel. You can not recognize one without the other. If Hebron isn't Jewish and Jews don't have the right to it, than neither is Jerusalem or Tel Aviv or any other city in Israel, understand and we don't have a right to any of it.
30. good post birdie!
Ilana   (01.25.10)
However, these types (matty etc) only want to spew their jealousy and hatred for Israel and the Jews. They will curse their mother in order to get you mad- in order to annoy, and then they sit back all smug and happy and satisfied that they got a Jew mad based on twisted truths, lies and propoganda. They get enjoyment from it. It is their type that start genocides, and holocausts. We really should not give them answers, they do not deserve a split second of your thoughts or time. They whine, they lie, they spew again and again and again no matter what you say, prove, explain, show. There is evil in the world there really is and they are a part of it. Leave evil to fester.
Next talkbacks
Back to article