News
Soldier killed in West Bank knife attack
Efrat Weiss
Published: 10.02.10, 17:12
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
99 Talkbacks for this article
31. Free Training for Palestinian Terrorist
Marcel ,   Florida   (02.10.10)
Something the Israeli media leave out of their reporting is the training this killer received at the hands of the US under US ARMY General Keith Dayton in Jericho. What other nation has such fools in government that allows a foreign army to train it's enemy to kill Jews better than they knew to do before ?
32. tapeh 110 missiles
marcel   (02.10.10)
syria has transferred these rockets 3 tons that can wipe out israeli cities. This what nasrollah was talking about when he said the world will change in the next war. he aims to destroy tel aviv, haifa, dimona , ashkelon, and eilat. syria should be reminded that if an israel city is destroyed, sryia as we know it wil be destroyed along with beirut and suburbs. Nasrollah can hide in the ground and israel can also seal his grave. Israel get your anitmissile systems ready and watch the northern border for hez operatives.
33. #19
(02.10.10)
there was no israel or zionism in the palestine before 1940's. yet, your arab haj amin al husseini went to germany to learn how to bring concentration camps to palestine to kill all the jews there. there was no israel before 1940's. yet, the arab mobs and killers murdered hundreds of jews living in jerusalem and hebron in 1929 and 1936. there was no israel in 1940's. yet haj amin al husseini created arab mobs that attacked jews in palestine and murdered them, killed them and slaughtered them. so, you say that arabs lived in peace with jews before zionism???? you are not right. arabs in palestine always killed jews there by order of the highest person that ruled them, haj amin al husseini that was best friends with hitler and aichman and himmler. best friends in germany!!!!! hameed aboughaze, iranian
34. #21
(02.10.10)
it was not a jew that was stabbed by the terrorist. IT WAS AN ISRAELI ARAB. ARAB. ARAB!!!!! he is palestinian, no???? with israeli citizenship. so, now you kill your own brothers too????? this arab victim was not russian, or polish or from queens. you moron! hameed aboughaze, iranian
35. Obama training PA policemen well
(02.10.10)
36. #19
(02.10.10)
salma, do you know that jews were THE MAJORITY IN BOTH JERUSALEM AND HEBRON BEFORE ZIONISM CAME TO PALESTINE????? yet, the haj amin al husseini hated jews, was an antisemite and was killing them all the time. the massacres by arabs, klling most jews in hebron and hundreds in jerusalme points to the fact that, IT WAS ARABS LIKE YOU THAT WERE KILLING THE JEWS IN PALESTINE. NOT THE OTHER WAY AROUND. IT WAS ARAB MOBS THAT WERE SLAUGHTERING JEWS IN PALESTINE IN 1929 AND IN 1936 RIOTS WHERE ARABS KILLED THOUSANDS OF JEWS LIVING IN BOTH JERUSALEM AND HEBRON WHERE THEY WERE THE MAJORITY. you arabs were not the majority in hebron and in jerusalem before 1940. you were the minority because the jews were the majority there and you arabs, with hate in your hearts, did everything to murder them and execute them. so, don't blame zionism in palestine for creating the hate and murder by you arabs against the jews. your hate started in the early 1920's...way way before zionism was brought to palestine. hameed aaboughaze, iranian
37. It sounds from the name of the
Robert Haymond ,   Ashdod, Israel   (02.10.10)
murdered soldier that he must have been a Druze. He would have been a young man. It must be a genuine loss to his family and village neighbours. Maybe he had a girlfriend or fiancee. I would just like to express my condolences to his people.
38. End this mess!
TK ,   USA   (02.10.10)
When is Israel going to destroy these fools? You guys need to quit playing games over there and get rid of them... It will make life better for Israel and the whole world!
39. #18 to Sarah
Eyal ,   USA   (02.10.10)
Sarah, your post was right on the button. Nour and the Palestinians are nothing but children that don't want to learn. She always believed in a 1 state solution, but this time she realizes she can't wipe the Jews to the sea, so she is compromising living with Jews. Sarah, I hate to be apocalyptic, but the only way to end the this conflict is war. My prediction is; something bad is going to happen to Israel before we either wipe the Palestinians completely or give them 1 choice, leave Israel or die. Obviously, Israel is going to attack Iran, Hezbollah and Syria will get involved. Syria will be completely destroyed until they shoot a biological weapon into Israel, which they have and will and a lot of Israelis/Jews will die. Israel will respond with a nuclear bomb and wipe Lebanon, Syria and Gaza out to dust. It is sad, but it well happen. Just imagine if the Palestinians had a biological weapon?
40. Will Netanyahu and Barak attend the funeral?
Miami, USA   (02.10.10)
Will the prime minster and defense minister go to the funeral of this dead soldier who was not killed in combat in Gaza or Lebanon but in his own country driving a car?
41. Nobody likes being occupied.
David ,   Canada   (02.10.10)
I live in Canada and if the USA invaded my country and control all access and checkpoints i would also stab a soldier if i had the chance. Nobody like to be occupied.
42. to #3 (u dirty camel-jockey)
opinhasi ,   NYC   (02.10.10)
may the holy ground you pretend belongs to you open up and swallow you whole...Amen
43. are soldiers & settlers fair targets in the occupied land?
observer   (02.10.10)
Palestinian civilians were massacred in by members of the Irgun and Stern Gang Jewish militias, supported by artillerymen of the Haganah, the future army of Israel. While many of the victims were women and children, 55 traumatized infants and youngsters were spared by being trucked to East Jerusalem and dumped on a street in the Arab quarter. There Hind Husseini, a member of a leading Muslim family in Jerusalem, found the terrified survivors huddling against a wall and gave them shelter inside her family mansion. Two weeks later, on her 32nd birthday, Husseini officially named her family home Dar El Tifl. For Dar El Tifl students in 1997, settlers had broken the gate of the school, entered the playground area and threatened children. Inasmuch as Orient House, across the street, was a target of the fanatical settlers, they had installed themselves in front of the school and raised wooden signs painted with a skull and crossbones on the school wall. As the day students approach the school, the racist settlers make them walk a gauntlet of insults and loud curses. There is a divine plan requiring the settlers to hold this land. With many of them armed and all of them furious over the 2005 withdrawal of Jews from Gaza and four West Bank settlements, they live by the slogan: “Never forget! Never forgive!” Hypothetical army's freez settlement construction is a lul in the path of protection of settlers' violence. Wasn't the soldiers in the military Jeep in the WB? what he was doing, driving his kids to the school? bet, he was armed to the teath and that's why he wasn't reluctant to leave "his" jeep's window open. If you dispute settlers' status, what about soldiers?, resistance it is, NO Zionism involved.
44. #4 international law does not prohibit armed resistance
observer   (02.10.10)
International law - and the matter was upheld by the Nuremberg Tribunal - outlaws any expropriation of property, houses and landed property included, in the occupied territories. Expropriations are only temporarily ones, and any such property has to be returned after the war, with any damages occurred to be compensated. Particularly, the law also forbids any form of collective punishment for resistance against the occupation, such as house demolitions, curfew upon whole populated locations and geographic areas (article 2 and 3 of the attached letters to the Hague Convention). Which of which does Israel abide by? a much easier solution is to throw he international law into the trash.
45. To: Eyal at No. 39
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (02.10.10)
I have come to the conclusion that hatred of Israel is little more than hatred of Jews, with a particularized focus now that the Jews have their own state back. I don't know why people hate Jews, and I don't particularly care why -- that is something they need to examine for themselves. What I do know is that Jews and the State of Israel are here to stay. No matter what.
46. Abbas provided the background 4 MURDER
sam ,   USA   (02.10.10)
47. ---AMERICAN TRAINED FATAH TERRORIST---
expel all arabs   (02.10.10)
AMERICAN TRAINED FATAH "POLICE OFFICER" TERRORIST!
48. Only in Palestine
SAM ,   ME   (02.10.10)
Both of them have the same family name ... Irony!
49. To Sarah B,,Versus the wishful thinking of Nour >
Kate ,   ISRAEL(forever)   (02.10.10)
Well siaid and written. The sooner we get rid of the destructers of our country the better. No wonder so many Israeli Arabs never countenance living in any Arab country for they will forfeit their freedom of expression and benefits. Nour keeps on wishing "a one state solution" ? Agreed one STATE ISRAEL without the degenerates called Arabs ALL.
50. #19 salma
(02.10.10)
Stop the lies Salma. YOU MUSLIMS CAN'T EVEN LIVE IN PEACE AMONG YOURSELVES. We can see the intolerance and evil deeds of Islam across the whole earth. Israel on on the front lines of this Satanic jihad.
51. #20 Nour
Eyal ,   USA   (02.10.10)
Not quite a Mandela. Mandela was not a terrorist and achieved peace. Barghouti in the other hand killed innocent women and children, so how do you even compare? Nour Nour, your excuses are dall and stupid. It would be better if you just shut your mouth, maybe then people will start respecting your posts.
52. killer and victim have same last name?
g ,   quebec, canada   (02.10.10)
ironic
53. #33 - Hameed - Exactly right!
Andy ,   ramat hasharon   (02.10.10)
54. #41 David
Eyal ,   USA   (02.10.10)
Who is occupying? Did you mean the Palestinians? Just for your information, the Jews lived in the what you call occupied land for the last 4.5 thousand of years, when did the Palestinians arrive dummy?
55. Tresspassers, KEEP OUT
Paula   (02.10.10)
Well, don`t drive in the West Bank. Then, there won`t be another time either. Palestinians aren`t allowed to drive in Israel, so why are Israelis in the West Bank?
56. #34 - Right again Hameed - it makes me wonder if...
Andy ,   ramat hasharon   (02.10.10)
Any body else really read the article. The muderer and the Israeli soldier HAD THE SAME FAMILY NAME - KHATIB! Idiots like Nour - with all that filthy hatred - think a KHATIB in the Israeli army is apartheid.
57. Palestinian State needed
Rami ,   Palestine   (02.10.10)
This attack is a continuation of the vicious violent cycle involving illegal colonists and Palestinians lured into violence to express desperately their plight following 20 years of useless negotiations. The Apartheid can`t be reinforced in the West Bank following this attack. This is a wake up call. The illegal settlements must be evacuated and a Palestinian state established. 500,000+ colonists can`t live freely on the expense of the indigenous population deprived of all forms of human rights.
58. to No 55
moshe ,   jerusalem   (02.10.10)
It turns out that a killed solider is Israel Aran , Ibah Khatib. By your standards he's a Palestinian, or at least that's what they call themselves. He's Arab, Palestinian, and Israeli solider, all into one. He's killed by a Palestinian Arab who lives in Pal autonomy. Arabs kill Arabs, is this ironic or tragic? Or the killer didn't know that he was killing an Arab, he wanted to kill a Jew, and now he'll have to live with a notion that he wasted his life with such a silly mistake. Ay-ay.
59. To: No. 55
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (02.10.10)
It is the Palestinians that are interlopers in the West Bank. Judea and Samaria belong to Israel.
60. # 39
Birdi ,   Israel   (02.10.10)
Eyal, dont you think that if Iran gets nucear weapons, she just may "give" some to The Palestinians??
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article