Opinion  Nahum Barnea
We’re losing them
Nahum Barnea
Published: 17.03.10, 18:06
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
69 Talkbacks for this article
61. #60 Not when the bank...
Donald ,   New York, NY   (03.18.10)
...holds your mortgage and your value is far below the loan. You are correct. China, with its large Jewish and Evangical population I'm sure would welcome Israel with open arms. Is that why they support Iran? What do you think China would do if you sent Pollard over there; or disrespected their leaders like you do ours? Israel is the definition of arrogance.
62. 60 - you're not exactly anything to be proud of
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (03.18.10)
spewing bile doesn't exactly endear you to much of anyone, except the hateful. but that may be what you're going for.
63. 62 Xn Crusader not proud of Torah-keepers? Excellent!!!
Paqid Yirmeyahu ,   Ra'anana, Israel   (03.19.10)
64. 63 - hmm, so lying is ok for teh paqid? not surprising
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (03.19.10)
interesting how he gets his little panties in a wad when someone supposedly speaks "lies" about him (in his world, lies = facts he doesn't like), yet doesn't hesitate to call me a "crusader". i'm pretty sure my age disqualifies me from that accusation, but then again those pesky facts don't concern teh "honorable" one much.
65. Just be glad he (#63) wasn't born in Gaza
Donald ,   New York, NY   (03.19.10)
He'd be strapping on bombs and babbling about the Koran instead of tefillon and the Torah. Nothing to be proud of indeed.
66. 65 - just remember: he's not the real deal
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (03.19.10)
he's a convert (with reservations, but that's another story), so that explains his extreme irrational rants. he wants so badly to be accepted as a jew that he goes overboard to prove it by hating/slandering everything not jewish. it's just another religious hater as you described, showing us all the value of his religion.
67. srael increasingly losing support of America’s liberal Jewis
George   (03.21.10)
68. srael increasingly losing support of America’s liberal Jewis
George Weiss ,   Teaneck, USA   (03.21.10)
Barnea is making the error that people's political views remain stagnant. That is grave error. He is lso forgetting that i another generation these American Jews will be gone and their children will mostly not be Jewish at all. One has to do what is right, not always what is politically expedient.
69. #68 - agree; but
Barry ,   Long Island, NY   (03.21.10)
I think the term "liberal", and the "UK Guardian/Chomsky" type implication of the liberal mindset, is misleading for the vast majority of American Jews who find them anathema. Most American Jews are moderate/centrists and want what's in America's and Israel's best interests (which generally also believe, is a 2 state solution). Our goal is stability and prosperity for each country; not some biblical BS. Israel's government arrogantly insists it is going to do what it (ie: the right wing) perceives is in its best interest, and then criticizes America for doing what is in our strategic interest. That the assimilation/intermarriage are an issue is true. Israel's hard right thinks the Evangical's are a more loyal base (according to Bibi's brotherinlaw). Notwithstanding the Evangelical agenda (Armageddon - not exactly encouraging for those looking for long term peace), their ranks are shrinking also. Israeli's need to consider: the demographics of the region; the mentality of your enemies that love death more than life while Israel is willing to trade hundreds of prisoners for a single soldier. And consider Iran. Israel cannot afford to alienate the US or their biggest long term (ie: Jews) base of supporters therein. It is time to wake up and smell the coffee.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article