News
'Saudi king says Israel, Iran don't deserve to exist'
Ynet
Published: 03.07.10, 08:44
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
69 Talkbacks for this article
31. Response to #1 and 11
MKL ,   USA   (07.03.10)
Maybe you can translate this to them; Isaiah 34:8, Ezekiel 38, Psalms 83, and Micah 5, etc. To keep it short, if Muslim fanatical leaders keep insisting on the destruction of Israel, they will soon be stomped on by the YHWH himself.
32. Well Said The Persia
Ken Coppal ,   Canada   (07.03.10)
I like your anology. You need to dispose of your Mullas and Dictators in order for the True Persia to stand up to the Suadies and show them that they are nothing mearly then sub humans. Iran has the wealth in the fields to do this they just need to be more democratic and humane. Both, Israel and Iran could reshape the whole ME but they must be democratic entities that plays by the EU and the West to get away with it.
33. Turn Mecca Into Glass
Ed G. ,   Labrador, Canada   (07.03.10)
1400 year old problem SOLVED.
34. :: THERE IS AN IRONIC OUTCOME OUT OF ALL THIS
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (07.03.10)
Iran and Israel, both armed with nuclear weapons, will become allies again and Arabs will be the losers again, and be at the mercy of both countries.
35. Remember 9/11? The US should have take Mecca out!
Frank ,   USA   (07.03.10)
36. ARAB PEACE PLAN, HE WANTS PEACE IN THE REGION.
A ,   Belgium   (07.03.10)
He wants peace in his own repressive, oppressive, selfish, greedy regime. He could give a rats ass about the ishmaelians in gazastan. All he wants is to sell his oil to the fools of the world and make himself and his close family wealthier
37.  to # 19
A ,   Belgium   (07.03.10)
Dont forget Shai Agassi! He's going to invent a car that runs on mouse droppings, just wait and see. Faisal and the rest of his diaper head buddies are going to end up drinking their worthless "black gold".
38.  to 18. No state deserves to exist.
A ,   Belgium   (07.03.10)
Neither should yours, which never did and hopefully never will.
39. I agree with matty
Genuine Tosefta ,   Tveria   (07.03.10)
Both iran and israel should be armed with nukes to stop the arabs, it makes perfect sense
40. Why nbot all exsist in peace?
David Israel ,   New York, USA   (07.03.10)
Wouldn't it be better to have a culturally divers world living in peace? Shouldn't we aim to achieve such a peaceful world? Why do so many people posting here are talking about why one or the other should not exist? Is this the solution that you can figure out? Stop your hateful feelings and try to find a way for all nations to live in peace instead of obliterating another nation.
41. A world without Iran and Saudi Arabi would be a better world
David ,   EU   (07.03.10)
Such a world would be much more modern, much more secure and much more peacefull and less violations of human rights would occur!
42. @17/ The Persian
Bernie ,   France   (07.03.10)
Some interesting points to be discussed on a broader scale...once Shia-theocracy quits ruling Iran the way it's been doing it for over 30 years! Rgds
43. The scoop comes exclusively from Georges Malbrunot
observer   (07.03.10)
Al Jazeera aims to be “friends with all”, which includes Americans, Iranians, Israelis, Hamas, Western and Islamic people. Saudia Arabia banned the cooperation with the liberal Al Jazeera. Le Figaro reporter Georges Malbrunot, said that a French-speaking radio station is is to be on the point of being launched soon in Doha. George Malbrunot along with Christian Chesnot and their Syrian driver Muhammed al-Jundi, was taken hostage on August 20, 2004, by the Islamic Army in Iraq. This group gave the French government a 48-hour deadline to repeal its law against girls wearing the Muslim veil in school. The ultimatum was delivered by means of video broadcast on the Arab TV channel Al Jazeera at 6.30 p.m. GMT on August 26. Muhammed al-Jundi was freed by U.S. Marines in November 2004 in Fallujah, Both French hostages were released on December 21, 2004, spent 124 days as hostages. The scoop of King Abdullah's saying comes exclusively from Georges Malbrunot, a Al-Jazeera-Le Figaro agent. Why would have the Saudi King specifically chosen Al-Jazeera reporter? is he credible? KSA has already denied the report.
44. Arabs don't deny right of Israel to exist
observer   (07.03.10)
but deny the right of its existence to wipe Arab Palestinians off the map.
45. because
observer   (07.03.10)
Saudi Arabia is asking major powers involved in Middle East peace-making for "clarifications about Israel's arrogant policy and its insistence on defying international will." and Saudi Arabia Opens Up Its Airspace So Israel Can Attack Iran.
46.  17. The Persian
A ,   Belgium   (07.03.10)
"but you can not, and can not show one instance of a Jew, a synagogue, a Jewish cemetery ever attacked, desecrated in Iran. " Maybe not, but... At least 13 Jews have been executed in Iran since the Islamic revolution, most of them for either religious reasons or their connection to Israel. Saturday is no longer officially recognized as the Jewish sabbath, and Jewish pupils are compelled to attend school on that day. Throughout the 19th century, Jews were persecuted and discriminated against. Despite the official distinction between "Jews," "Zionists," and "Israel," the most common accusation the Jews encounter is that of maintaining contacts with Zionists. The Jewish community does enjoy a measure of religious freedom but is faced with constant suspicion of cooperating with the Zionist state and with "imperialistic America" — both such activities are punishable by death. Jews who apply for a passport to travel abroad must do so in a special bureau and are immediately put under surveillance. The government does not generally allow all members of a family to travel abroad at the same time to prevent Jewish emigration. Again, the Jews live under the status of dhimmi, with the restrictions im posed on religious minorities. Jewish leaders fear government reprisals if they draw attention to official mistreatment of their community. Well, Persian, if thats what you call love, I can understand why Iran is the biggest arms supplier to Hizbollah, Hamas, Syria and the rest of your "friends".
47. EQUATING SAUDIS & ISRAEL IS ABSURD.
BUTSeriously ,   SYDNEY   (07.03.10)
One of those countries has no historical merit, being one of numerous fictional Arab states created between 60 and 120 years ago. Israel has 100% factual historical rights to her land. Further, S. Arabia was created in secret without a UN Motion where all states voted - unlike Israel. The advocation of genocide on a 4000 year nation from a new kid on the block is absurd.
48. # 44
Birdi ,   Israel   (07.03.10)
Nice twister, as usual.
49. You are another idiot, who has to accuse me of others crimes
Persian ,   Iran   (07.03.10)
What you have never understood and are incapable of even digesting is this. I don't know what "Dhimmi" is. That is the first. If you get your information, from the recycled Iranian idiots, the exiles sitting in Paris, good luck to you. I never, ever said, Iran is the Heaven, nor did I say it is Democracy. Although, with Israel and USA being the democracies, I think we have had enough of them. A new idea is required. I never praised Zionism either, it is not part of us, it has not been and it will never be. It is a European idiea, that came out of Europe for all the reason we know. I did not even talk about Jews. I only talked about "Our Jews". I don't care about what Europeans or Arabs did to Jews in 19 century, or during Spanish inquest or even during Venetian inquest. Read my posting again. For all I care you can own the whole of Germany, even Europe for that matter. You talk about 18 Jewish leader ....I don't know where you get your information, but let us suppose it is correct. For 0.03% of population having suffered so much is nothing. I have lost my nephew, a friend and many more. There has been suffering, no doubt. But the question is, have my Jews suffered more than Muslims. I would say no. That is the distinction you can not understand. We have all suffered, Muslim, Shia, Suni, Jew, Asserian, Catholic, Kurd etc. etc. to almost to the same measure. That is what makes a us a nation, that is why they are not Ashkenazy, but Persian Jews. As I said, Iran is not heaven, yet you can not understand with your European mentality. And of course, American Evangelists would not want either, and if you read and listen to them, you will see why. They want their Jesus to return, at the cost of all Jews. For them Jews are noting but the sacrificial Lamb. Iran has always been a safe heaven for Jews, and believe me or not, it will be once again when the Western Jesus returns.
50. Saudi King
J.K. ,   Brooklyn USA   (07.03.10)
Statements are confirmed,only when denied.
51. King Abdullah
Iranian Jew ,   LA   (07.04.10)
I do not see any purpose Suadi Arabia serves in the world. What was the latest invention coming out of your lizard eating country beside Bin Laden?
52. #18 Noor
Iranian Jew ,   LA   (07.04.10)
I agree. Let's blow up the earth and join allah as soon as possible. .... what a fabulous idea. .. I say stop the donation form Saudi Arabia now and in fact return all the money they have given you today. After all they are partly reliable for whatever is happening to the Palestinians.
53. #17 and Iranian love offering
Iranian Jew ,   LA   (07.04.10)
Good morning! I'm not leaving in Iran because of this so much love you claim you have for me. If I cannot be a Jew in Iran then who give a crap for your love? You love us as long as we obey your stupid rules. Once we get stronger then you hate us. Drop the BS act of love. Are you practicing typing here? Persia is gone, dude and so is our culture. You love the diaper heads and you keep following them. You love us so much then respect our views and Israel. Don't tell us to join you. We are stronger than you. Maybe you should join us instead following another moron like Mousavi and the rest.
54. #44 your dementia is getting worse by the second
better observer   (07.04.10)
55. Figaro report
Xena   (07.04.10)
Every time I read that a report is ‘denied”, I wonder if in fact it is true. The same goes for 'Saudi king says Israel, Iran don't deserve to exist'. Why would the Figaro newspaper make up such a thing? Note that "military and diplomatic elements" confirmed that king did in fact make the comment? Lost in translation? I don’t think so, notwithstanding some of the ‘experts’ commenting here.
56. S. ARABIA IS A FCTICIOUS STATE
BUTSeriously ,   SYDNEY   (07.04.10)
It never existed 120 years ago, was installed in secret for 30 barrels of oil and none voted for her establishment at the UN. Israel marks the reverse of this genocide inspired Saudi declaration. But Osama - oops, I mean Obama - will bow graciously here.
57. #8 - if you can find the original recording, i'll translate
lara ,   Australia   (07.04.10)
You seem to be far from an expert on my religion and your assumption of the religion i follow is incorrect.
58. In 30 years, Saudi Arabia will be gone: Israel HERE
iObserver and News ,   Israel   (07.04.10)
Once their oil begins to drain, Saudi Arabia Nd Islam will become insignifant pestilence, nothing more. Same holds true for any oil rich nation, aside from the US and Russia, who've been using so little of their own. Then they'll starve and die off. Such is nature. Saudi Arabia gave birth to terrorism and the most despised cult in history. People R just too afraid to say it outright. Their days R numbered: a noosehanging around their neck. Only, in the future when survival trumps oil, the west WONT b so kind. SA should enjoy their last days: we'll see it's demise in our lifetimes, along with their wretched kind.
59. Oil Tick
(07.04.10)
60. The Persin @ 17 Oh what a wonderful thought!(ynet for Sunday
Stephen ,   USA   (07.04.10)
Dear Persian how wonderful and true your words,description of the whole story which in reality bears thinking about.Indeed you are correct.Ahmedi may curse and rant,about Zionism/Israel,bottom line (as far as I'm aware) Have not heard any dissent from Jews living in Persia.I maybe wrong,BUT! since presumably you may live there you know more than it is published in the media. Don't despair at sometime or other we can relight the flames of the times during Xerces King of Persia and his Queen Esther.And live happily ever after.Well,I can dream can't I? Good post,much appreciated. The Saudis are a bunch of dictators and crooks .Better say no kore,yiou have put your finger on the PULSE!
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article